The editors of the Washington Post pose an interesting question. So, a joint U. S.-Iraqi government force dislodges DAESH from Mosul, Iraq’s second-largest city. What then?
In short, the Mosul offensive is setting the stage for a potentially catastrophic Day After problem. Though the United States has painfully experienced what such poor preparation can lead to, in Baghdad in 2003 and Libya a decade later, it is pushing the Abadi government to move still faster.
Military experts are more concerned about the aftermath than the fight itself. Brig. Gen. William F. Mullen, who was deputy commander for U.S. operations in Iraq until June, predicted last week that Islamic State defenses in Mosul could collapse quickly. “And then what?†he asked at a forum at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy. The Iraqi government’s plan, he said, amounts to “chips will fall and we’ll sort it out when we get to that.â€
“That’s not a good plan,†Mr. Mullen said. “This is going to be ugly.â€
They go on to suggest failing to plan is likely to result in a repeat of the same abuses that led to the rise of DAESH to begin with.
They conclude:
Though the absence of such political solutions facilitated the rise of the Islamic State, the Obama administration is not pushing for them. It is not using its considerable leverage — U.S. air support will be vital to liberating Mosul — to insist on better political preparations or the exclusion of Shiite militias. Instead, eager for the operation to begin before President Obama leaves office, it has been encouraging Mr. Abadi to speed up the Mosul offensive, while leaving the Day After problem to the Iraqis. That is a highly risky course.
But, hey, it won’t be risky to the president. He’ll have left office by that point.
It’s too bad the editors couldn’t have started asking questions like that long, long ago. Say, fifteen years ago.
In his New York Times column Paul Krugman explores what seems to me a remarkably implausible theory of why Hillary Clinton hasn’t dispatched Donald Trump’s candidacy summarily. The press is just too darned unfriendly to her:
As I’ve written before, she got Gored. That is, like Al Gore in 2000, she ran into a buzz saw of adversarial reporting from the mainstream media, which treated relatively minor missteps as major scandals, and invented additional scandals out of thin air.
In other words even the most tepid of negative reporting is enough to deflate her. My recollection is somewhat different. I think the mainstream media has been fawningly obsequious to Sec. Clinton and, when it has reported a negative story about her, only did so because it was forced to by events.
I do think that the media is partially to blame but not because of “adversarial reporting”. They’ve consistently given far too much free advertising to Donald Trump, part and parcel of the culture of celebrity they’ve cultivated.
An analysis of the August toll shows more clearly than ever who’s dying in the Chicago slaughter and what’s behind it: surging violence in a handful of the city’s most impoverished neighborhoods, which are riven by loosely organized street gangs.
Young African-American men are the chief victims. In a city that’s one-third black, the overwhelming majority of those murdered in August — 71 — were, like Malik, African American. Another 11 had Hispanic surnames. Almost half were in their teens or early 20s.
And more than 70 percent of those shot to death appeared on the Chicago police’s “Strategic Subject List,” which includes 1,400 people considered likely targets of violence based on gang involvement or criminal record.
There is one credible explanation: gangs. Another possible explanation: that gangs are consistently portrayed as exciting and glamorous. There is one slightly less plausible explanation: guns. There is one implicit explanation in the article: drugs.
The article also included one incredible claim—that larger, better organized gangs would result in fewer murders:
According to community activists, the eagerness to kill wasn’t as great years ago when these neighborhoods were dominated by larger, more organized gangs that concentrated on carving out and defending drug turf.
Now, “I don’t hear much about Gangster Disciples against the Vice Lords,” said Marshall Hatch, a minister in the East Garfield Park neighborhood where Causey lived. “I hear block against block.”
Unmentioned is whether the “community activists” quoted are present or former gang members
The article fails to mention any number of other prospective explanations including inadequate economic opportunity, social dysfunction, self-serving politicians, and decades of nonexistent, incompetent, or even malevolent police work.
I’m honestly not sure what Anthony Cordesman’s point is in his post at RealClearWorld on the terrible conditions in four Middle Eastern and West Asian countries that we’ve either invaded or intervened in—Iraq, Libya, Yemen, and Syria. That we should invade at will and let the chips fall where they may?
I found the post most useful in the catalogue of horrors Mr. Cordesman provides for each country. Those countries were horrible long before we invaded or intervened in them and they’re even more horrible after our meddling. How much responsibility should we bear?
Far from lowering our expectations for the results that can be achieved via military intervention, I’d suggest raising our standards for intervening. We should only use military force when there is no other alternative and when our national interests, narrowly construed, are threatened. If we can’t bring ourselves to use the level of military force required to achieve our objectives or don’t have the sitzfleisch necessary to deal with the consequences, maybe the interests weren’t that compelling to begin with.
California isn’t spending its money on trains, just as the Federal Highway Administration does not spend its money on highways, and the Department of Defense does not spend its money on aircraft carriers, military bases, and tanks.
California’s government, like the federal government and most other state and local governments, spends its money on salaries, benefits, pensions, and other forms of employee compensation. The numbers are contentious — for obvious political reasons — but it is estimated that something between half and 80 percent of California’s state and local spending ultimately goes to employee compensation. (Interesting analysis here.) That is where the money goes.
I don’t have a problem with teachers, police officers, and firefighters being paid one or even two standard deviations above median. However, when their pay puts them into the top 1% of income earners, I don’t know how we’ll be able to afford it, especially when their pensions, a substantial fraction of their ending wage, will be paid for decades after they’ve stopped working. And when their pay catapults them into the top .1% of income earners, as is the case with many university presidents and sports coaches, that skepticism is even stronger.
Here’s what Illinois’s state spending looks like:
The 20% of the state’s budget that goes to Medicaid goes to pay salaries, too—the salaries of healthcare providers that provide services to the poor. That might be acceptable if the spending is effective but there are reasons to believe that’s not the case.
I was asked how Germany manages to keep its manufacturing employment and its manufacturing wages both up and this post is my response. Consider the graph above. The Germans have an export-driven system. They maintain a positive balance of trade, exporting more than they import. Indeed, much of what the Germans import is oil and gas which they use to power their factories. Until quite recently the Germans maintained a trade surplus with China, one of relatively few countries to do so.
Without going too much into the mechanisms by which this operates, in effect the Germans export goods and import employment.
Now consider the U. S. balance of trade:
We import a lot more than we export. We import oil (although slightly less than we used to) and we import consumer goods. We do the opposite of the Germans, importing goods and exporting employment.
Although we could and IMO should import less, we can’t implement an export-driven strategy. The rest of the world isn’t rich enough to buy enough U. S. exports for that to happen.
One of my commenters took substantial umbrage at my claim that the idea that saying that U. S. manufacturing jobs could be “brought back” from China, Japan, South Korea, etc. was poorly informed enough as to constitute a lie so I thought I’d explain my reasoning. What I’m presenting in this post is widely known among economists and businessmen. It’s not particularly controversial.
Let’s start by defining our terms. First, let’s talk about what a job in manufacturing in the U. S. was like in the past. A half century ago someone with a high school education only (or even less) could get a job working on a factory floor that would pay wages high enough to support a large family in a middle class lifestyle, paid all of their healthcare expenses, and, after they’d worked their entire lives at that company, paid for a graceful retirement.
Millions of those jobs no longer exist. As the graph at the top of this page illustrates, manufacturing employment in the United States peaked in the 1970s and now nearly 8 million fewer Americans are employed in manufacturing than were 40 years ago. But manufacturing output has continued to grow and is higher today than ever. The manufacturing jobs of the 1970s are gone, they aren’t coming back, and there’s nothing that anyone can do to bring them back.
BTW, it isn’t just in the United States that manufacturing jobs have peaked. Manufacturing jobs in China peaked a number of years ago.
To understand why let’s consider one example: what we used to call the “Big 3” U. S. automobile companies—GM, Ford, and Chrysler. Those three companies alone employ 300,000 fewer hourly manufacturing employees than they did in the 70s.
Prior to the automobile industry’s near-death experience in 2007, the hourly labor cost in those three companies (wages plus the cost of benefits) was around $75/hour. Today those companies have tiered payment systems. New employees are paid closer to $15/hour. Let’s talk about the old jobs rather than the new ones which clearly don’t fit the description of the “good, manufacturing jobs” I outlined above.
300,000 X $75/hour X 2,000 hours per man-year = $45 billion. That’s three times the Big 3’s combined net income. The numbers just aren’t there. You could cut their CEOs’ incomes to zero. The numbers still wouldn’t be there. You could impose tariffs on Chinese manufactured goods high enough to start a trade war. The numbers still wouldn’t be there.
Today’s good, manufacturing jobs still pay well but their numbers are not growing rapidly and their requirements are greater than they used to be. They require greater skills, those skills aren’t taught in our high schools and, importantly, they change over time.
The present state of affairs could be improved if we took some substantial steps. First, we should stop tolerating currency manipulation by our trading partners. That isn’t limited to China but includes Japan, Germany, South Korea, and many, many others.
Second, the federal government should stop subsidizing the off-shoring of jobs.
Third, we need to re-balance the emphasis in our schools away from college prep towards vocational training and to do that we’ll need to accept that some people will not go to college and that’s okay.
Fourth, American workers need to realize that learning doesn’t end in high school, college, or, indeed, ever. They will need to continue to improve their skills over their entire working lives.
Fifth, a better division of the costs of improving workers’ skills needs to be struck between the workers and their employers with government playing some role. I’m not prepared to say what that division should be or how it should be decided but I do believe that the present division with most of the onus falling on the workers isn’t working.
Among my regular commenters some have substantially more first-hand knowledge of these matters than I do and I hope they’ll join in the discussion.
This TPP sets the gold standard in trade agreements to open free, transparent, fair trade, the kind of environment that has the rule of law and a level playing field.
She did not say that she hoped it would as she claimed. She said that it did.
Donald Trump lied, too, when he said that he will bring good-paying manufacturing jobs back to the United States. That horse has already left the barn. It is beyond his or anyone else’s power. Our efforts would be better directed to mitigating the effects that our poorly-constructed trade agreements of the past have wrought on ordinary Americans.
The plain truth is that today’s trade agreements are less about free trade than about picking winners and losers. Too long have a privileged, connected handful been anointed the winners while most Americans were made the losers. That has to stop. Economic winners must start bearing more of the costs for remediating the harm done to those who have been who lose due to our trade agreements. Too long have our trading partners become prosperous by manipulating their currencies, exploiting the openness of our markets, and imposing backdoor tariffs on our goods and services. That has to stop. Too long have our trading partners allowed unhealthy and unsafe conditions for their own workers to prevail and polluted the environment in the interest of exporting their manufactured goods to the United States at low prices, undermining American manufacturing. That has to stop.
I am grateful to President Obama for his efforts in negotiating the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement and I am committed to expanding our relationship with our neighbors on the Pacific Rim. I believe, however, that the agreement is flawed and will return to the bargaining table to renegotiate the agreement along the lines I’ve suggested.
The “fast track authority” that some have sought to approve the TPP is nothing more than letting the president go over the heads of the American people to adopt trade agreements they don’t like. There’s another alternative to that: adopt trade agreements they do like.
The issues of trade and immigration are inextricably intertwined. No country is more accepting of new immigrants than the United States, a quality we have had for our entire history. Today there are six times as many immigrants in the United States as there were when our immigration policy was liberalized in the 1960s and as many as a percentage of total population as at any time in our history. Frankly, the American people need some time to adapt. We need to strike a better balance among restricting immigration, enforcing our laws, getting the workers that American industry needs, and providing a haven for those fleeing persecution. To that end we will fully implement and enforce a program of workplace enforcement. It will be fully funded by a surtax on companies that employ immigrants and foreign workers. The surtax will be borne by the federal government in the case of refugees, who will receive thorough screening prior to their admission into the United States.
As Lord Palmerston said more than a century and a half ago, we have no eternal allies…our interests are eternal and perpetual. Conditions change over time and it makes sense to revisit the alliances we have contracted from time to time.
NATO was formed when the greatest challenge to the free nations of Europe was an external one and those countries, still reeling from the lasting effects of the Second World War, could not meet that challenge without our help which we provided. The greatest challenge for those nations today is an internal one. What kind of countries will they be? That is not a debate in which we should interfere.
The United States remains committed to Europe and is prepared to render aid to the countries of Europe as we have in the past. We are grateful for the aid that our NATO allies have rendered to us. That commitment to Europe cannot be greater than the commitment that the countries of Europe themselves have. If our NATO allies decide that the alliance no longer matches their needs and they have other priorities, who are we to disagree?
Neither candidate accomplished all their major goals.
Clinton probably shored up her minority constituencies by her direct attacks on Trump, especially on the birther issue, where he is vulnerable.
Her ability to press home her attacks while still seeming likable could well reverse her recent downward slide in the polls. But it is not enough to weaken Trump badly.
He lives to fight another day. He will continue to fight like the Donald Trump of the Republican primaries. He is not backing away from his stance as a full-throated, often abrasive nationalist, an outsider who touts his successful businesses as proof enough that he can get things done.
He may have learned that a little formal debate prep is not such a bad thing. He left a lot of his opponent’s vulnerabilities unexploited. She hit all of his. The question now is whether Clinton accomplished enough to stop her slide.
The overnight polls will probably give us a better picture. Voters just don’t see things the way that pundits do and it’s hard if not impossible for a writer who covers politics day in and day out to put her- or himself in the voter’s shoes.