Dave Schuler
October 8, 2016
It’s easy to see why Matthew Fay, writing at RealClearPolicy, objects to the idea of running the government like a business. His idea of business ends with McNamara and he thinks that the Pentagon is being run like a business.
Organizations like people tend to look back to whatever brought them their greatest successes. For the federal government the period of greatest success was World War II and the present operations of the federal government hearken back to the organizational frameworks and strategies of the 1950s and 1960s.
Perhaps the word “business” in the sense of a for-profit business is off-putting. The federal government is an organization and is in desperate need of being run the way successful modern organizations are run.
Stop thinking GM and U. S. Steel and start thinking of Google or Apple.
Dave Schuler
October 8, 2016
I’ve finished the class I was taking (I start another, different class on Monday). It was tremendous fun and I hope I get a chance to apply some of the things I learned.
The instructor was a pioneer in the area of agile management, one of the big names. Very impressive CV. He is, as you might expect, very enthusiastic about his subject matter, always a good quality for an instructor.
In response to a question by a regular reader, to the best of the knowledge of my instructor (who goes all over the world teaching) no major medical center is in the process of implementing or even experimenting with any framework of agile management. You could be the first!
Dave Schuler
October 7, 2016
You know, I think the two major political parties have pretty severe problems with cognitive dissonance. Cognitive dissonance is the mind’s struggle to maintain contradictory beliefs.
In the Republicans’ case for the last three decades they’ve been preaching small government while doing almost nothing to reduce the size and reach of government. The resolution of their conflict seems to be the quasi-religious but empirically unfounded belief that tax cuts always pay for themselves.
The Democrats for their part struggle to be the party of the little guy while deriving most of their strength from the very biggest guys. Their resolution appears to be the equally dubious belief that if you just pay the top quintile of income earners enough it will solve the problems of the poor.
For the Republicans their long-overdue chickens have come home to roost and the name of the rooster is “Donald Trump”. I think he’s the candidate of “throw the bums out”. It hasn’t dawned on Trump supporters yet that even if he wins the bums will still be left in.
The Democrats have yet to receive their comeuppance but I believe it’s inevitable that they will. When they do it will be, as somebody might say, yuge.
Dave Schuler
October 7, 2016
Paul Scharre has a very interesting post at War On the Rocks in which he asserts that the Pentagon’s approach to planning and operations is at odds with the national security challenges we’re facing today:
The U.S. military’s dominant paradigm for operations is a six-phase planning construct, consisting of phase 0 (shape), phase I (deter), phase II (seize initiative), phase III (dominate), phase IV (stabilize), and finally, phase V (enable civil authority). This implies a linear progression of conflict through a culminating phase (phase III) of major combat operations, and then a “post-conflict†period of stabilization and transition. Within this paradigm, the central decisive point is assumed to be phase III, and the bulk of the U.S. military’s attention for resourcing, modernizing, training, and allocating risk is found there. While the United States is getting ready for the big fight, however, its adversaries are working to accomplish their objectives short of open conflict.
analogizing the generals’ approach to the Kübler-Ross stages of grief, only with six stages rather than five.
Read the whole thing.
Dave Schuler
October 7, 2016
At Forbes Thomas Del Beccaro has a set of predictions for the outcome of the 2016 election that you might want to take a look at. In essence he predicts that the Congress will remain in Republican control whoever wins the presidency, hedges by presenting predictions in the event of each presidential candidate ultimately prevailing, and then, in my opinion stumbling, issues an opinion that that might be either a prediction or an expression of preference:
Trump has a long history of delegating authority to those best able to do certain tasks. Hillary does not. Hillary will not be able to court Congress because it is her way or the highway. Trump has Pence. Donald therefore trumps Hillary.
He also predicts something I think is likely to be true: a Hillary Clinton presidency will much more closely resemble the Obama presidency than it does the presidency of Bill Clinton.
Dave Schuler
October 6, 2016
I’m going to be a bit scarce and posting will be light for the next couple of days. I’m attending a two-day class on a specific methodology of agile management, quite a bit different from the old Sloan functional management model.
I’m finding it quite a bit fun. Basically, it’s how I’ve been operating for the last 30 years or so. As is typical for affairs of this sort I’m older than anyone else in the class by decades. The attendance at the class is about 20 people, about half of them shy Millennials. I suspect that a great deal of what’s being said doesn’t mean much to anyone with less than 20 years of experience.
At any rate the class continues tomorrow, I’ll be tied up all day, and exhausted tomorrow evening. I may be able to sneak in a post or two but I might not have the time or energy until the weekend.
Bis später.
Dave Schuler
October 5, 2016
In assessing the big city real estate markets, at CNBC Claudio Saputelli observes:
In a world in which more than a third of all government bonds offer negative yields, investing in tangible assets remains popular. So it is hardly any wonder that major urban housing markets are again overheating, just a few years after the last major wave of global correction. We see a significant overvaluation of housing in some key financial centers, with six markets in bubble risk territory.
Although cities at risk of a bubble may not experience a crash, investors should still bear in mind the significant chance of a correction over the medium term.
You will be relieved to hear that Mr. Saputelli does not list any U. S. city among the six most at risk of a bubble. Those would be Vancouver, London, Stockholm, Sydney, Munich, and Hong Kong.
What about Chicago? He attributes Chicago’s tepid real estate appreciation to the fiscal incompetence of Chicago and Illinois politicians and its “comparatively weak local economy”, which is basically another way of saying the same thing.
Dave Schuler
October 5, 2016
Over the period of the last several decades we’ve seen the computer industry disrupted by Microsoft and Apple, retail disrupted by Amazon, the taxi industry disrupted by Lyft and Uber, and the hospitality industry disrupted by Airbnb. Disruption as a business model has become so routine that Silicon Valley venture capitalists are now searching for the next big disruption.
That’s what I thought of when I read these remarks at Bloomberg by former Federal Reserve Governor Narayana Kocherlakota:
The Fed has played a big role in the poor performance of the latest decade as well. It has actually been tightening monetary policy for most of the past four years, even though inflation has been below its 2 percent target. In other words, the central bank is not pursuing a pro-growth agenda.
If there is one institution crying out for disruption, it’s got to be the Federal Reserve.
Dave Schuler
October 5, 2016
At MarketWatch Brent Arends asks a question that I presume he knows is rhetorical:
Americans, when are we going to get our heads back where the sun shines and implement a wealth tax?
The answer is easy: never. Why do think the Congress has so many rich people in it? It’s not for wealth or power. They could promote their own wealth and power more effectively outside the Congress than in it. Public service? It is to laugh. The Congress stopped being public servants decades (or generations) ago.
It’s to ensure that the Congress does not impose a wealth tax.
Dave Schuler
October 5, 2016
I watched a half hour or so of the vice presidential candidates’ debate. I’d rather vote for either of them than the two at the tops of their respective tickets. In a way I guess that’s reassuring.
I predict that last night will turn out to have been Trump’s best debate.