The Case for Restraint

At The National Interest Dave Majumdar makes a plea for restraint on the U. S.’s part with respect to Syria:

Thus, while it is easy to start a conflict with Russia and Syria, a shooting war could easily escalate out of control. It might be prudent to exercise restraint before launching a new war—against a nuclear-armed power—that the American people don’t necessarily want to fight. That’s especially true in a conflict where the lines are blurry and there are no clear-cut good guys—where even so-called “moderate” rebels backed by the U.S. government are beheading children. Under such circumstances, the best policy for the United States might simply be to leave well enough alone—there is simply no need to stick our fingers into yet another hornet’s nest.

“Don’t necessarily” is an understatement. Only about a third of Americans think we should intervene more forcefully in Syria. The issue is almost a perfect epitome of the disconnect between elites and ordinary Americans. If our leaders were heeding ordinary Americans, Syria would hardly be on the radar at all let alone an issue of vital importance.

And ordinary Americans are right. We just aren’t that interested in Syria. However, Europe’s interest is much more proximate. If the Europeans aren’t rushing to intervene in Syria, we probably shouldn’t, either.

0 comments

Sorting Out the Teacher Pension Issue

Speaking of things that are combinations of fact, gossip, hearsay, and myth, at Brookings Dick Startz makes a noble attempt at shedding some light on the issue of teacher pensions:

Teacher pensions are a mess. Understanding what’s going on with teacher pensions is messy as heck. However, some progress can be made if we divide the topic into two pieces: Are teacher pensions really high? (Not so much.) Are teacher pensions really expensive? (Not only expensive, they’re even more expensive than it appears on the surface.)

One piece of advice. Never, ever use averages in your analysis or at the very least try to avoid them. Ranges or medians are much better but averages are like the a fan dancer’s fan. They’re intended to conceal while appearing to reveal. The pensions of a very small number of very highly compensated individuals in the private sector can skew the results beyond all recognition.

So, for example, the median private pension benefit in 2014 was $9,227. The median private sector total retirement income including pensions, annuities, and Social Security benefits was around $24,000.

One thing in the article caught my eye:

Teachers, like most of us, make contributions to their pension as does their employer.

In Illinois that’s not entirely true. Although in theory teachers make contributions to their pensions, in practice many if not most districts put in the employee contribution as well as the employer contribution. That’s the case in Chicago, for example.

He also fails to mention that most teaching positions are nine or ten month positions.

I think that case studies would be a much better way of explicating the thorny issue of teacher pensions than the from 50,000 feet, national averages approach Mr. Startz is taking. A $30,000 pension in Mattoon and a $30,000 pension in Chicago just don’t belong in the same category.

Just for the record I don’t begrudge teachers their pensions. At least here in Illinois and in Chicago the issue is one of political malfeasance, misfeasance, and nonfeasance. Our elected officials failed to contribute to the public employee pension funds from the mid 90s to the early 2010s, digging a hole from which it is now impossible to escape. They preferred to use the money for other purposes so they shortchanged the public employee pension funds rather than raising taxes.

The politicians responsible for the mess? They were overwhelmingly supported by the public employees’ unions. If you can figure out some exculpatory reason for that you’re a better man than I am.

0 comments

Historical Note

μολὼν λαβέ (molṑn labé), literally “having come, take” or more colloquially “come and take them” was Leonidas of Sparta’s response when the Persians demanded that the Greeks surrender their arms at the Battle of Thermopylae. It has become a classic expression of defiance.

To the best of my knowledge our sole source for this is Herodotus. Herodotus also reported that Babylon had 100 gates (archaeologists have only discovered 8), that Persia had ants the size of foxes, and that lion cubs clawed their way out of the womb. It’s pretty clear that Herodotus freely intermingled facts and myths.

No complete contemporaneous manuscript of Herodotus’s Histories, purportedly written around 440 BC, has come down to us. The earliest extant manuscript is from the 10th century AD, some 1,400 years later, and it is undoubtedly some combination of fact, gossip, hearsay, fiction, and scribal interpolation.

But it’s a nice story.

6 comments

The 90%

As I read this passage in Jeffrey Sachs’s Boston Globe op-ed on income inequality:

Consider technology. Throughout modern history, ingenious machines have been invented to replace heavy physical labor. This has been hugely beneficial: Most (though not all) American workers have been lucky to escape the hard toil, drudgery, dangers, and diseases of heavy farm work, mining, and heavy industry. Farm jobs have been lost, but with some exceptions, their backbreaking drudgery has been transformed into office jobs. Farm workers and miners combined now account for less than 1 percent of the labor force.

In the 1900 federal census 90% of men listed their occupations as “farmer” and in 1935 there were 8 million farms in the United States. Technology has changed that. Although U. S. agricultural production is considerably greater than it was a century ago, the total number of farms and farmers has dwindled. Only about 1% of American workers are farmers.

We do not have 89% unemployment among men. It isn’t 49% or even 29%. It’s closer to 5%. How can that be?

What has happened is that other jobs, including jobs that couldn’t even be imagined in 1900, have taken the place of all of those jobs as farmers. Although fewer workers are involved in primary production enormously more workers are involved in secondary production. Jobs like information technology, healthcare, education, and UPS delivery.

Is it possible that today is different? That today’s jobs that become obsolete through technology won’t be replaced by anything? Why, yes it is. But the evidence for that is scanty and there are much more compelling explanations for what’s happening including the rise in occupational licensing requirements and other barriers to entry, deadweight loss, and immigration.

However unlikely, how you would go about mitigating the risk of widespread, massive technological unemployment is a reasonable question. The strategy I’d propose is to deal with the factors mentioned above which would reasonably be expected to produce the results we’re seeing before taking any sort of strenuous measures to deal with widespread, massive technological unemployment that may never occur.

3 comments

Are Journalists Exempt?

If I receive goods that I know or have reason to believe have been stolen, I’ve broken the law. My crime may be a felony or a misdemeanor depending on various factors but I’ve broken the law. I live in Illinois and the governing Illinois statute is here. Note that it does not contain an exemption for journalists, my reading of Illinois’s “shield law” suggests that it does not extend to receiving stolen goods, and there is no generally accepted common law right of journalists in this area.

Does anyone know what the New York state law is regarding receiving stolen property and any relevant exemptions for journalists?

7 comments

Gong Show Re-boot in the Works

ABC is reviving the Gong Show:

After successfully rebooting several retro game shows, ABC is bringing back another classic shiny-floor competition series. The network has given a 10-episode order to The Gong Show, a new version of the irreverent talent show competition, which is being executive produced by Will Arnett.

Every episode will feature non-traditionally talented performers plucked from the internet and put in front of a revolving panel of Hollywood judges. Sony Pictures TV, which owns the rights to the original series, is the studio.

I thought they showed the pilot for that last Monday.

5 comments

Lies, Damned Lies, and Chinese Statistics

Here’s a story that should make anyone uncomfortable. A study by the Chinese government has found that 80% of the data in Chinese clinical trials are just made up. From Science Alert:

A Chinese government investigation has revealed that more than 80 percent of the data used in clinical trials of new pharmaceutical drugs have been “fabricated”.

The report uncovered fraudulent behaviour at almost every level, and showed that some pharmaceutical companies had hidden or deleted records of potentially adverse side effects, and tampered with data that didn’t meet their desired outcomes.

This sounds to me like a modern version of Lysenkoism. It’s the kind of thing you would expect when good (rather than true) results are rewarded and bad results punished.

In fairness most published research results here are bogus, too. Still, 80% is darned impressive. I’m sure that with a little effort the CCP can boost that to 90% or greater.

6 comments

Miscalculation

The way in which you calculate things can distort what’s actually happening in surprising ways. For example, as employer-provided or -supported healthcare insurance became an increasing proportion of total compensation, that inevitably affected wages.

Now I wonder how increasing deductibles are affecting total compensation. I’m guessing that it’s been quietly declining for a while but that’s just intuition.

0 comments

Something Wicked This Way Comes

I dislike a lot of the way that George Friedman phrases things in his most recent post at RealClearWorld. For example, the use of the word “generational” here:

The year 2008 is appearing to be a defining moment in history, like 1991, 1945, and 1929. It is a generational shift in the way the world works.

The intervals between the four different years are 16, 46, and 17. Either there’s something missing or “generational” is just a misnomer. And this:

An economic boom creates vast inefficiencies, as huge amounts of surplus cash flow into the hands of people who don’t spend that money on food, clothing, and shelter, but rather invest it to make more money. Most of the time this works, as the investment, with decisions made by individuals rather than the state, generates wealth and jobs.

simply reflects a misunderstanding of the business cycle and economic booms. That’s just not how they work.

However, I think the general thrust of the article is right and he’s saying something worthy of consideration. Something serious is happening and it’s happening worldwide. It hasn’t completely unfolded yet. It might be the end of this most recent round of globalization. It’s hard to say.

Here’s his conclusion:

The world after 1929 changed and was never the same. That is true today. All regimes have shifted the way they operate, most democratic elites have been stunned by the changes, and their contempt for the incivility of their challengers is not enough to maintain the status quo.

0 comments

The Peasants Are Revolting

In what will certainly be a consequential decision for Colombia if not its neighbors and the rest of the world, Colombians have rejected a peace accord with the FARC, the rebel group which has been in a state of armed conflict with the government of Colombia for over 50 years, longer than most Colombians have been alive and probably so long that both sides have forgotten what the conflict was about. At The Guardian Isabel Hilton reflects on the reasons for the “No” vote:

Colombia’s long history of violence and its tortured politics offer many possible explanations: Santos is not personally popular and by putting himself and the Farc commander in chief Timochenko front and centre of the agreement, and the lavish signing ceremony organised a week before the referendum, he alienated as many voters as he attracted. “If he had had the grace to step back and let the victims speak,” complained one Colombian commentator before the vote, “it would have been completely different. He would have held the moral high ground and people could have voted for peace without feeling they were being invited to support Santos.”

Repeated hints from supporters of the president that he and Timochenko were in line for a Nobel peace prize did not help. Why should a guerrilla leader with so much blood on his hands, people complained, be honoured with such a prize?

Read the whole thing. Like Brexit, the changing tide of German politics, and the rise of Donald Trump, the Colombian vote is an illustration of how disconnected the elite are from many of the people they’re trying to rule. I have no idea of how this trend which is so apparent in so many places will play out but it does not have a good feel to it.

1 comment