The Healthcare Reform That We Need

In his op-ed in the New York Times, Robert Pear has lurched uncontrollably towards the observation I made back in 2009:

WASHINGTON — The fierce struggle to enact and carry out the Affordable Care Act was supposed to put an end to 75 years of fighting for a health care system to insure all Americans. Instead, the law’s troubles could make it just a way station on the road to another, more stable health care system, the shape of which could be determined on Election Day.

My complaints at the time were that the PPACA didn’t do much about the most pressing problem with our healthcare system and that the way it was enacted poisoned the well. Even though it manifestly would require additional reforms, it made such reforms less likely rather than more likely.

The most pressing problem then as now was the increasing cost of healthcare. In 2014 for example the general rate at which prices were increasing was essentially flat while the rate at which healthcare prices were increasing was about 3%. In other words, we were actually experiencing deflation which was masked by healthcare price increases proceeding rapidly. That is not the direction for greater affordability but because the PPACA subsidizes the healthcare insurance of most of those not covered by employer-based plans, Medicare, or Medicaid, that’s hidden behind a curtain.

My interpretation of that is that healthcare spending is in a positive feedback loop. Spending by government at all levels on healthcare represents the majority of healthcare spending (something between 50% and 70% when everything is taken into account) and establishes a floor for healthcare spending. As that ratchets up, private healthcare spending must continue to exceed it. If my interpretation is correct then the method of reforming the PPACA preferred by many Democrats:

The departing president, the woman who seeks to replace him and nearly one-third of the Senate have endorsed a new government-sponsored health plan, the so-called public option, to give consumers an additional choice. A significant number of Democrats, for whom Senator Bernie Sanders spoke in the primaries, favor a single-payer arrangement, which could take the form of Medicare for all.

will have perverse consequences.

A number of years ago the then-head of the Mayo Clinic characterized the reason for the high costs of U. S. healthcare as “too many people making too much money”. The problem of increasing costs cannot be addressed unless one or both of those issues is addressed.

0 comments

How to Lie With Statistics

One of the late President Reagan’s famous wisecracks was that when your neighbor is out of a job, it’s a recession and when you’re out of a job, it’s a depression. I think that something similar can be said about crime waves. That’s what occurred to me when I read Arthur Rizer’s claim at R Street:

Is the increase of a few violent crime categories in a few neighborhoods of a few cities tragic? Yes. Is it a crime wave? No.

My researches tell me that Mr. Rizer lives in suburban Washington, DC. I have little doubt that in his in all likelihood lily-white neighborhood there is little crime. However, in my more diverse neighborhood on the Northwest side of Chicago, people are being robbed at gunpoint within blocks of where I’m sitting for the first time in living memory. Houses in my neighborhood are being broken into in broad daylight. And the city of Chicago’s homicide rate is the highest it’s been in a generation.

I think the FBI’s annual crime report tells a different story than the one that Mr. Rizer sees. I think the story is that the long drop in urban crime rates has ended, that urban crime rates are now rising, and that, rather than just rising in a few cities, the rate of violent crime is rising in most large cities. What Mr. Rizer is seeing is that an increasing percentage of Americans are living in the suburbs (and even more want to).

The variant of Reagan’s wisecrack with respect to crime might be that, when there’s more crime in the city where you live, there’s a crime wave and when it’s in your neighborhood, it’s a crisis.

1 comment

What Have They Been Doing? (Updated)

My reaction to the revelations about Donald Trump’s carrying forward a $1 billion loss on his federal income tax returns were about the same as Brent Arends’s at MarketWatch:

Donald Trump has done nothing wrong if he has legally used the tax code to minimize his taxes. All private citizens do that. I suspect most politicians do as well.

I take every legal tax deduction I can. So do you. So do your friends. So do reporters at the New York Times. So, I bet, does Times publisher Arthur “Punch” Sulzberger.

A rich guy takes big deductions, where you and I take smaller ones. But that’s because he’s rich.

The real “scandal” of Trump’s tax avoidance isn’t that he did it, but that it’s legal — that loopholes exist that allow very rich people to pay little or no tax. That is really the fault of Congress, not the citizens who use the loopholes.

The emphasis is mine.

So, Mr. and Ms. Perennial Incumbent, what the heck have you been doing about our mystifying, byzantine, and corrupt tax code? Why are we arguing about comprehensive immigration reform when comprehensive tax reform could make the lives of ordinary Americans better by eliminating the deadweight loss of inefficient taxation?

The highest marginal tax rate is a red herring. The real issue is how you determine income.

Update

I see that Ann Althouse basically agrees with me:

The real issue is the tax code. Does it need to be reformed or not? If Trump took deductions, it was because the tax code provided for them. Once the deductions are there in the tax code, he pretty much has to take them and would be a fool not to take them. If it looks wrong, what’s really wrong is the tax code. So, is Hillary proposing to take away this deduction? Is Trump? Presumably, the deduction is there because it’s good policy. Will either candidate defend the policy and, if not, promise to change it?

If politicians complain about something, I assume that they think some change is required. Maybe they just like to complain.

6 comments

Aleppo’s End Game

I strongly recommend French military man Patrick Bahzad’s analysis of the situation in Aleppo at Pat Lang’s place, if only for this frank commentary:

What is the empathy for Aleppo worth, when you are not even willing to mention Saudi airstrikes over Yemen in a similar fashion?

Besides, it may be dangerous to cry “war crimes” and “atrocities” at this point in time, when the US lead Coalition in Iraq is about to launch a major offensive against the so called Islamic State and its capital. The Jihadis in the Middle-East and other places will make sure to remind us of the strong wording used for Aleppo once the onslaught on Mosul will have started. And they will definitely try to point to the bias and double standard of Western media outlets if we do not display the same sense of outrage at the casualties that the offensive on Mosul might cause among the civilians there. Don’t throw with stones when you live in a glass house …

There is a strong parallel between Aleppo and Mosul. Each is the second-largest city in their respective countries. Both have fallen under the control of Islamist terrorists. Both countries, Syria and Iraq, have invited the aid of powerful patrons who are providing it largely in the form of air support and special forces.

Will the parallels end there? Russia is rather clearly following the urban combat playbook they followed in Grozny. First, try to drive civilians out; then apply the level of force necessary to take the city. Urban warfare is ugly. Look up the Battle of Stalingrad, the Siege of Budapest, and the Battle in Berlin for World War II parallels. Or the Battles of Battle of Huế or Fallujah for urban combat involving Americans.

There is suspicion that the assault on Mosul is being rushed so that it takes place and is completed within President Obama’s term of office. I hope it does not begin until it can be effective.

4 comments

Not As Advertised

As I’ve been trying to explain for years, researchers have figured out that hydroelectric power isn’t carbon neutral, reports the Seattle Times:

Think hydropower is carbon neutral? You have another think coming, Washington State University researchers have learned.

In their paper to be published next week in BioScience, the researchers reported that reservoirs of all sorts are important sources of the potent greenhouse-gas methane. The gas is produced by decomposing organic material underwater.

While much attention has been paid to the effects of dams on fisheries and the natural form and function of rivers, little notice has been taken of the emissions they cause. Usually thought of as carbon-neutral sources of energy, hydropower dams, while far cleaner than fossil fuel for generating power, nonetheless are sources of carbon pollution.

Reservoirs not only produce methane, but they generate more greenhouse gases than natural lakes, found research associate Bridget Deemer and John Harrison, associate professor of biogeochemistry at WSU Vancouver.

Next thing they’ll be telling us that wind and solar have carbon emissions, too. Just as a for instance when the solar panel you install was made in China (90% of them are) or when the polysilicon used to make your solar panel in China was produced in the U. S. and shipped to China (as much of it is) it drastically increases the carbon footprint of your solar power.

2 comments

I Saw the Signs

If there’s one good indication of a phlegmatic U. S. economy and also, possibly, a global economic decline, it’s got to be the collapse of one of the ten largest global shipping companies, South Korean Hanjin Shipping. It’s a lot easier to maintain high levels of debt amidst competition when the volume of shipping is rising than when it is falling.

2 comments

Asleep at the Switch

In his post about the tension between trade and immigration on the one hand and our two party system on the other, Mark Aspinwall provides this accurate and helpful history lesson at The Conversation:

The U.S. has had “big tent” or “catch-all” political parties for much of its existence. They are two broad mainstream parties, each capturing a wide variety of opinion on all kinds of issues. Big tent parties had an easier time consolidating views among their members and producing unified platforms during the 20th century, when the focus was on domestic questions of social welfare and redistribution versus deregulation and market freedoms.

I think he runs astray when he characterizes the two parties’ views on trade and immigration:

However, when the issues shift to drawbridge topics like immigration and trade, the parties are less stable. Like a sticky weathervane, they are buffeted by crosswinds in which party members who are poles apart cannot unite behind a single policy. Within the Democratic Party, the left of the party is opposed to free trade because of the effect on workers. Within the Republican Party, the right is opposed to immigration because of the effect on national security, jobs and public services. For different reasons, both of these groups want the drawbridge up.

If Democrats object to free trade, I haven’t seen it. They object to what we have which is managed trade that works to the benefit of the few rather than the many. And the polls overwhelmingly suggest that not merely Republicans but Americans more generally object to our present immigration laws being enforced selectively or not at all. Characterizing those positions as opposition to trade or immigration is a bald-faced lie.

The framing of these issues as “drawbridge topics” is clever (he attributes it to The Economist—never take your advice on immigration and trade from a publication that operates from an island separated from the mainland by a distance of no less than 20 miles) but inaccurate. It would be better to characterize them as “asleep at the switch” issues. Or maybe “robber baron” ones.

IMO we have a problem but not the one to which Dr. Aspinwall calls our attention. Our problem is that both of our political parties are so insulated from democratic discipline that they have adopted policies that benefit wealthy patrons rather than their rank-and-file members.

3 comments

Tribune Endorses Johnson

The Chicago Tribune has endorsed Gary Johnson for president. On Donald Trump they write:

The Republicans have nominated Donald Trump, a man not fit to be president of the United States. We first wrote on March 10 that we would not, could not, endorse him. And in the intervening six-plus months he has splendidly reinforced our verdict: Trump has gone out of his way to anger world leaders, giant swaths of the American public, and people of other lands who aspire to immigrate here legally. He has neither the character nor the prudent disposition for the job.

while on Hillary Clinton they write:

The Democrats have nominated Hillary Clinton, who, by contrast, is undeniably capable of leading the United States. Electing her the first woman president would break a barrier that has no reason to be. We see no rough equivalence between Trump and Clinton. Any American who lists their respective shortcomings should be more apoplectic about the litany under his name than the one under hers. He couldn’t do this job. She could.

But for reasons we’ll explain — her intent to greatly increase federal spending and taxation, and serious questions about honesty and trust — we cannot endorse her.

But with respect to Gary Johnson they note:

Libertarians Gary Johnson of New Mexico and running mate William Weld of Massachusetts are agile, practical and, unlike the major-party candidates, experienced at managing governments. They offer an agenda that appeals not only to the Tribune’s principles but to those of the many Americans who say they are socially tolerant but fiscally responsible.

On the inevitable topic of squandering a vote:

We reject the cliche that a citizen who chooses a principled third-party candidate is squandering his or her vote. Look at the number of fed-up Americans telling pollsters they clamor for alternatives to Trump and Clinton. What we’re recommending will appeal less to people who think tactically than to conscientious Americans so infuriated that they want to send a message about the failings of the major parties and their candidates. Put short:

We offer this endorsement to encourage voters who want to feel comfortable with their choice. Who want to vote for someone they can admire.

and in conclusion:

This year neither major party presents a good option. So the Chicago Tribune today endorses Libertarian Gary Johnson for president of the United States. Every American who casts a vote for him is standing for principles — and can be proud of that vote. Yes, proud of a candidate in 2016.

Read the whole thing.

12 comments

Which Direction Is Progress?

At The National Interest Leon Hadar weaves together the Whig theory of history, politics, and present immigration to ask an interesting question:

We are told to remember that the granddaughters of the families who emigrated from highly stratified, patriarchal and religiously oppressive Italy’s south now wear a bikini when they go to the beach. As do the granddaughters of the ultra-Orthodox Jews who immigrated to America from the shtetl in eastern Europe. Why shouldn’t that happen to the granddaughters of the Muslim immigrants from Egypt?

But wait a minute. Why do things seem to be happening in reverse in the case of many young Muslim immigrants in Europe and the United States? Their grandmothers, growing up in the 1950s in, say, Alexandria, actually looked “like us,” wearing the latest European fashion and a spiffy swimsuit on the beach. It’s their granddaughters who are now wearing veils, the hijab and the burkini to make sure that they don’t look “like us.”

What if becoming increasingly secular isn’t seen as progress?

9 comments

The First Override

I only have one remark to make about the Congress’s overriding of President Obama’s veto of the JASTA bill, the bill that would allow civil suits against Saudi Arabia to proceed for the attacks on September 11, 2001. I think it reflects the president’s characteristic distaste for retail politics. If the White House had gotten in there and lobbied the Congress for changes with the president making direct, one-on-one personal appeals to individual senators, it probably wouldn’t have turned out so embarrassingly and it might have resulted in a better outcome.

1 comment