After making this observation at the Wall Street Journal:
Why did Americans turn so hard against the president? They felt he wasn’t focused on rising prices and the economy. This impression was compounded by what they considered mishandling of immigration enforcement and Iran and anger at his self-enrichment schemes.
Karl Rove offers some interesting statistics:
The bipartisan political analyst Bruce Mehlman estimates 142 of the House Democrats are “New Dems,” a category he describes as “pro-growth, more moderate.” They overlap with the 23 “Blue Dogs,” defined as “centrist, fiscally conservative Democrats.” On the other side are 105 “left-leaning lawmakers,” who share some common ground with the eight self-described Democratic Socialists.
My recommendation is to pay close attention to the committee appointments in the incoming Congress. Fifty years ago a “moderate Democrat” was a moderate and a “moderate Republican” was a moderate. Today not so much. The party infighting about whether Hakeem Jeffries will become Speaker of the House is a case in point.
Rep. Jeffries is not a moderate. He’s a former member of the House Progressive Caucus. But he’s a “moderate Democrat” by today’s standards. Just as an example, Rep. Jeffries has deputized New York Rep. Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez to formulate the Democratic House healthcare policy. She’s hardly a moderate by any reasonable reckoning. What this suggests to me is that Rep. Jeffries isn’t triangulating between the political left and right but between the left and right wings of the Democratic Party. By appointing Rep. Ocasio-Cortez and the more moderate Rep. Terri Sewell to lead the Democrats’ healthcare working group, he’s effectively defining the boundaries of the debate. A compromise between the progressive and moderate wings of the Democratic Party isn’t necessarily a moderate position. It’s just a compromise within the Democratic Party. I think that’s highly unlikely to produce moderate results, regardless of how many members of the Democratic caucus describe themselves as moderates.
I don’t know which way the next Congress will jump. Will they be more moderate than the last Democratic Caucus or will they “overreach” as Ruy Teixeira, William Galston, and Karl Rove have worried about? One good indication will be the committee appointments of the incoming Congress. They are are consequential because much of the House’s substantive legislative work takes place in committees. Chairs influence hearings, oversight priorities, and the development of legislation.
If leadership places progressives in the positions that shape legislation, the 142 “New Dems” won’t make a lot of difference.
Magic 8-Ball says…







