You Can’t Go Home Again

At Bloomberg Adam Minter is skeptical about the prospects for Apple’s bringing the production of iPhones to the United States:

Low labor costs and minimal regulation were certainly part of China’s appeal. But the most important factor was its huge and nimble workforce. The main iPhone facility in Zhengzhou now employs 110,000 workers, with other factories employing hundreds of thousands more. China’s 270 million migrant laborers — most of them ambitious and opportunistic — have proven indispensable to a business that prizes flexibility. Last summer, Apple contractors reportedly hired 100,000 workers to ramp up production of the iPhone 6s in advance of its fall release.

Nothing comparable could ever happen in the U.S., no matter what the president wants. A mass mobilization on that scale, and at that speed, likely hasn’t been attempted since World War II. And there’s little reason to think it would be successful or desirable today, even if Apple was willing to try.

Finding enough skilled labor wouldn’t be much easier. Apple CEO Tim Cook told “60 Minutes” last year that, thanks to better vocational education, China now has a more skillful workforce than the U.S. Apple’s executives estimate that they’d need 8,700 industrial engineers to oversee 200,000 assembly line workers, yet only 7,000 students completed university-level industrial-engineering programs in the U.S. in 2014. Shenzhen, by contrast, is home to 240,000 Foxconn employees — and millions of additional engineers and laborers.

He may be overstating the problem a little. I don’t know that anybody is suggesting that all iPhones be made in the U. S. and last year more iPhones were sold in China than in the U. S.

However, if I were in Tim Cook’s shoes I’d be looking around for second sources for iPhone manufacturers, if only for leverage against the Chinese, their notoriously predatory attitude towards intellectual property, and their obvious desire to have Chinese people buy Chinese branded products.

2 comments

The Bias Towards Higher Education

Something else I’ve mentioned frequently is the bipartisan bias in federal policy towards higher education. This article at City Journal documented that bias:

In 1990, more than 53 percent of the federal investment on education went to a combination of elementary, secondary, and vocational schooling. The Clinton-Bush years shifted the balance toward higher education. By 2008, only 38.5 percent of all federal education dollars went to elementary, secondary, and vocational schooling. The early Obama years slowed this trend somewhat, though not in a way that helped vocational training efforts. Obama’s 2009 stimulus package shifted monies back to elementary and secondary schools, in part to protect the jobs of public school teachers. The pro-college bias reasserted itself more recently, and higher education’s spending share has increased steadily. The 2017 budget approaches 2008’s relative high, allocating 57 percent of all such spending to higher education and leaving only 43 percent to be shared among primary, secondary, and vocational efforts.

Note that, since the incomes of the parents of college students are significantly above the median, support for higher education is a middle class subsidy or even subsidizing the rich, not aid to the poor.

0 comments

Normal Distribution

I mention things like normal distributions and standard deviations pretty frequently around here so I thought it was about time that I elaborated on it a bit. The graph above illustrates what is known as a “normal distribution”. In a normal distribution the mean, median, and mode are all the same. “Mean” is the average, i.e. the sum of values divided by the number of values. One half of all values are above the “median”, one half below. And the “mode” is the most frequently occurring value.

In a normal distribution 68% of all values are within what’s called a “standard deviation” from the mean. The standard deviation is sometimes represented by the Greek letter sigma (sort of an “o” with a squiggle at the top, “σ”). 95% are within two standard deviations and 99.7% are within three standard deviations.

There are all sort of things that are believed to occur in an approximately normal distribution, e.g. wages, intelligence as measured by IQ scores, the logarithm of stock market indices, measurement errors in the physical sciences, and so on.

The IQs of people in the professions, i.e. doctors, lawyers, etc. tend to be between one standard deviation and two standard deviations above the mean. In general, people with lower IQs can’t hack it and people with higher IQs aren’t interested. There are exceptions at both ends of the spectrum.

The IQs of college students tend to be at the mean or above and that appears to be cross-cultural, i.e. as true in Japan as it is in the United States.

That, for example, is why, when our political leadership points to the importance of higher education, I invariably respond “What do you plan to do with the other half of the people?”

1 comment

The Rank and File or the Leadership?

I don’t know how Ryan Cooper can write this in The Week with a straight face:

But more fundamentally, in terms of positive, pro-labor policy, unions have little to show for their loyalty. Since 1976 Democrats have repeatedly sold out the working class with deliberately vicious recessions, trade deals that led to massive outsourcing and job losses, and weak at best domestic policy. In 2009, when Democrats had super-majorities in both chambers of Congress, they barely even tried to pass a card check law which would have made it easier to organize a workplace. Both moderate Democrats and the Obama administration basically gave up on that without a fight.

Consider the following list of wages paid to union bosses in 2014:

Union Salary
Independent Pilot Association $1,132,607
Air Line Pilots Assoc. AFL-CIO $825,539
Directors Guild Of America Inc $824,475
Boilermakers AFL-CIO $697,714
State County & Muni Empls AFL-CIO Local Union 3930 $680,721
Laborers $670,403
Boilermakers AFL-CIO $639,034
SAG-AFTRA $586,079
Food & Commercial Wkrs Local Union 464 $579,828
Int’l Brotherhood Of Trade Unions $574,501
Transportation Communications Union/Iam, AFL-CIO $564,194
Teachers AFL-CIO $557,875
National Education Assoc. $541,632

Obviously, these are not union leaders of the stamp of Eugene Debs or even Walter Reuther. Many of them have never really worked as rank and file members. They’re professional union organizers, members of the elite. And it’s equally obvious what they’ve received for consistently supporting Democrats.

One of the things that emerged from the last election was the chasm between union leadership and the rank and file. The union leaders uniformly endorsed Hillary Clinton while union members, even members of the Teachers and NEA, voted for Trump.

Democrats are the party of organized labor. They’re just not the party of the laborers. Given a choice between them and the technocrats, they’ve chosen the technocrats. If there’s a way for them to change course towards being a party of the workers rather than the union bosses, I don’t see any way to pull off that maneuver.

19 comments

Fidel Castro, 1926-2016


Without doubt the news of the day is that long-time Cuban leader Fidel Castro has died. From the New York Times:

Fidel Castro, the fiery apostle of revolution who brought the Cold War to the Western Hemisphere in 1959 and then defied the United States for nearly half a century as Cuba’s maximum leader, bedeviling 11 American presidents and briefly pushing the world to the brink of nuclear war, died Friday. He was 90.

His death was announced by Cuban state television.

In declining health for several years, Mr. Castro had orchestrated what he hoped would be the continuation of his Communist revolution, stepping aside in 2006 when he was felled by a serious illness. He provisionally ceded much of his power to his younger brother Raúl, now 85, and two years later formally resigned as president. Raúl Castro, who had fought alongside Fidel Castro from the earliest days of the insurrection and remained minister of defense and his brother’s closest confidant, has ruled Cuba since then, although he has told the Cuban people he intends to resign in 2018.

Fidel Castro probably did as much as anybody to influence U. S. foreign policy. Initially, he cozied up to the United States. When that did not result in U. S. support, he turned his attention to the Soviet Union and Cuba remained a close Soviet ally until the Soviet Union’s collapse.

IMO his ideological views have been much exaggerated, as much by him as by his opponents. I don’t believe that he was ever actually a Marxist. His attentions were focused single-mindedly on concentrating power in his own hands. When being a democrat furthered that end he was a democrat; when being a communist did he was a communist. As Castro biographer Georgie Ann Geyer wrote:

“The Cuban regime turns out to be simply the case of a third-world dictator seizing a useful ideology in order to employ its wealth against his enemies,” wrote the columnist Georgie Anne Geyer, whose critical biography of Mr. Castro was published in 1991.

In this view of Mr. Castro, he was above all an old-style Spanish caudillo, one of a long line of Latin American strongmen who endeared themselves to people searching for leaders. The analyst Alvaro Vargas Llosa of the Independent Institute in Washington called him “the ultimate 20th-century caudillo.”

For reasons that eluded me during the 1960s he was quite a media darling, possibly propelled to stardom by red diaper babies in the U. S. Basically, he was just the dictator of an unimportant Latin American country adjacent to the United States.

Cuban troops, presumably acting as Soviet surrogates, were at one time or another fighting in Congo, Ghana, Bolivia, Algeria, Syria, Ethiopia, Angola, the Sinai (during the Yom Kippur War), Namibia (then Southwest Africa), Grenada, Nicaragua, and El Salvador. That gave credence to the idea of the dangers of worldwide communist revolution, something that drove U. S. foreign policy for a half century and remains influential.

More recently his image, the idea of Castro rather than his actuality, has inspired Chavistas in Venezuela and similarly-minded people in Bolivia. If the list of countries in which Fidel Castro has wielded influence sounds like a trail of woe, I don’t think that’s a coincidence.

7 comments

The Cold Equations

You might find Uwe Reinhardt’s piece at Vox.com on the iron grip of actuarial mathematics on the fate of healthcare insurance interesting:

The unfolding drama may seem to be driven largely by ideology and partisanship. In the end, however, there is no getting around the actuarial mathematics on which health insurance everywhere in the world rests — public as well as private.

Unless, that is, our government is content to leave millions of Americans without the benefits of health insurance, and the access to essential health care it provides.

The presence of millions of citizens lacking health insurance remains a uniquely American problem.

I’ve mentioned it before but it bears repeating. Trying to fit U. S. policy into a Procrustean bed of policies designed for the ethnic states of Europe will inevitably fail. We are better understood as a European-type developed country that is simultaneously a developing Third World country like Mexico or Brazil.

Heck, don’t be surprised if policies designed for the Sweden, Germany, or France of 40 years ago start collapsing too. It’s a new world.

4 comments

Putting Down Markers

Maybe it’s too early but I think this would be a good time to start giving odds on a few things.

For example, what do you think are the odds are of the electors of the Electoral College electing Hillary Clinton to the presidency, as urged by Lawrence Lessig at the Washington Post? That seems to me to be a plan that only a law prof could love and actually quite likely to provoke armed rebellion.

More likely: after looking at the practical implications of putting his business affairs into a blind trust Donald Trump decides thanks but no thanks on the presidency. That would be a fine kettle of fish.

Or of the Affordable Care Act being repealed and replaced within one year of Trump’s taking office? Frankly, I’m skeptical more on the practicality than on the merits.

Or of the State of Illinois defaulting on its debt? Presently, interest on the debt comprises about 11% of state revenues. Some state expenditures are actually mandated by the courts and Illinois remains without a budget, only paying the bills the courts have forced it to. I think the odds are still pretty long on this but it could happen.

Here’s something even more likely: the City of Chicago or one of its appendages, e.g. the Chicago Public Schools, defaulting on its debt? You can impose higher tax rates but that doesn’t necessarily bring in more money.

What other eventualities should we be betting on or against?

4 comments

There Are Some Things States Can’t Do

As soon as I read the title of Ed King’s post at Climate Home, “If Trump quits, California could apply to join UN climate talks”, I knew I had to comment:

Asked by Climate Home on Thursday if the golden state could replace the United States, California senate leader Kevin De Leon said it was an “option that I want to keep open”.

Legal experts at Harvard and Yale were already researching if a sub-national body could join the UN climate talks he said, but added this would be a “political decision”.

“We will continue to be active in the international movement to address climate change,” said De Leon, who branded Trump’s threat to the UN process as a “jobs killer”.

“To the extent the UN wants to coordinate with work we are doing we are more than willing to take part in these discussions,” he added.

My impression is that Mr. King is a Brit and as such can be excused for not knowing about Article I, Section 10 of the U. S. Constitution:

No state shall enter into any treaty, alliance, or confederation; grant letters of marque and reprisal; coin money; emit bills of credit; make anything but gold and silver coin a tender in payment of debts; pass any bill of attainder, ex post facto law, or law impairing the obligation of contracts, or grant any title of nobility.

No state shall, without the consent of the Congress, lay any imposts or duties on imports or exports, except what may be absolutely necessary for executing it’s inspection laws: and the net produce of all duties and imposts, laid by any state on imports or exports, shall be for the use of the treasury of the United States; and all such laws shall be subject to the revision and control of the Congress.

No state shall, without the consent of Congress, lay any duty of tonnage, keep troops, or ships of war in time of peace, enter into any agreement or compact with another state, or with a foreign power, or engage in war, unless actually invaded, or in such imminent danger as will not admit of delay.

What’s the excuse of the “legal experts” from Harvard and Yale? Such participation would also seem to violate the Logan Act.

My dad used to complain about lawyers for whom the only law with which they seemed to be familiar was the U. S. Constitution. Now, apparently, they aren’t even familiar with that.

5 comments

How About $2,000 a Pound?

And you thought you paid a lot for your Thanksgiving turkey. From RealClearFuture:

This Thanksgiving, Paul Mozdziak will be giving thanks that people are finally paying attention to his big idea.

He wants to grow turkey meat in 5,000-gallon tanks.

Mozdziak is an expert in growing avian muscle cells in a lab flask. That obscure corner of research recently landed the North Carolina State University professor of poultry science at the cutting-edge of “cellular agriculture,” or the idea that animal protein could be manufactured in bioreactors rather than by animals.

The technology, also known as in vitro meat cultivation, may sound strange. But it has been drawing a following of environmentalists, animal-rights activists, and investors who think meat can be made by biotech companies rather than on farms.

and

Lab-grown meat is still far from being economical. In Mozdziak’s lab, his team grows cells as a thin layer inside plastic flasks. If the cells become too thick, nutrients can’t get in. Growing a turkey-size amount of white meat this way would require about 11,340 flasks and about $34,000 worth of growth serum.

My back-of-the-envelope calculation suggests that translates into about $2,000 a pound.

So, think of the bargain you got when you cut into your Thanksgiving turkey today.

3 comments

We Serve No Whine Before Its Time

The latest whine about the outcome of the 2016 presidential election comes from Rebecca Traister in New York Magazine:

And now, the women and people of color who made up Clinton’s base and were the most enthusiastic supporters of her campaign, the ones who have the most to lose under the Trump administration, have found themselves on the receiving end of the lion’s share of the blame for our recent national cataclysm.

[…]

It is unconscionable, this know-better recrimination, directed at the very people who just put the most work and energy into defeating Trumpism, coming from those who will be made least vulnerable by Trump’s ascension.

Clinton’s erstwhile primary opponent, Bernie Sanders, seemed to amplify Lilla’s message on his book tour this week by recommending that Democrats embrace the working class and “Ditch Identity Politics,” according to one headline. In fact, the headline was overblown: Sanders did not say we should dump identity politics, and affirmatively noted that “we should bring more and more women into the political process” and that “we need 50 women in the Senate!”

But Sanders did say something telling. Asked by a young woman who described herself as wanting to become “the second Latina senator in U.S. history” for tips, Sanders offered not advice, or even acknowledgment of the particular roadblocks — sexism, racism, fundraising, party support — she might encounter. What he offered instead was an insulting reaction to what he assumed must motivate her ambition: an argument based purely on identity. Noting that she “would not like” what he was about to say, he scolded her that it was “not enough” to say, “Hey, I’m a Latina, vote for me”; that it was “not good enough for somebody to say, ‘I’m a woman! Vote for me!’ No, that’s not good enough.” Never mind that nobody has ever made that argument for a female or minority candidate except in the fevered imaginations of Hillary haters. It is clear that this is what Sanders hears when someone describes a desire to overcome representational inequality in politics: an infantile, politically unsophisticated, feather-brained appeal to narcissistic self-advancement.

I don’t blame “Hillary Clinton’s base” for her loss in the election. I blame them for her candidacy. It was blind loyalty to Hillary Clinton at the expense of the Democratic Party.

In grossly oversimplified form, the electorate is presently 30% Republican, 30% Democratic, and 40% independent. You can’t win national elections just by turning out Democrats, let alone a single person’s “base”.

That Hillary Clinton couldn’t trounce Trump handily is proof positive that she was the wrong candidate at the wrong time. Look in the mirror, people.

0 comments