Why So Mealy-Mouthed?

In his Wall Street Journal column James Taranto asks a simple question about the mealy-mouthed reactions from world leaders to Fidel Castro’s death: why?

Most of the public reactions to Castro’s death were true to form: Those on the right rightly mourned his life, not his death; while those on the left offered praise or at best neutrality, in either case playing down the horrors he inflicted on Cuba over more than half a century.

That includes Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and our own president. He also gives credit where credit is due:

The most notable exception: Nancy Pelosi, beleaguered leader of the House Democrats. “After decades under Fidel’s doctrine of oppression and antagonism, there is hope that a new path for Cuba is opening,” she said in a statement Saturday. How much hope is an open question: Cuba is still a one-party communist state ruled by the Castro family; Fidel’s younger brother, Raul, has held the title of president since 2008.

What caught my eye were the mocking tweets lampooning some of the leaders’ praise:

Andrew Coyne: “While a controversial figure, even detractors recognize Pol Pot encouraged renewed contact between city and countryside.”

Curtis (@FowlCanuck): “Today we mourn painter and animal rights activist, Adolf Hitler. His death also highlights the need for suicide awareness”

Peggy Noonan: “Booth was a fiery, forceful actor; he once left members of a Washington audience literally standing and screaming.”

Some of the remarks reminded me of nothing so much the famous comments made by Italians after the appointment of Benito Mussolini that he had made the trains run on time.

I tend to adhere to the Latin dictum, de mortuis nil nisi bonum (speak no ill of the dead). Heaping praise goes a step too far.

Why did Justin Trudeau and President Obama make the statements they did after the announcement of Castro’s death? The only explanation I can come up with is that it’s what they would have wanted to be said after their own deaths. The problem with that is that Barack Obama is no Fidel Castro. You can’t even make the claim that Castro was well-intentioned with a straight face.

0 comments

Smart Manufacturing?

I like this essay by Steven L. Blue at IMPO very much. Here’s a snippet:

What is the sense in spending millions on automating your factory if our workforce could care less? What is the sense in buying expensive machine tools if your workforce can’t wait to get to the bowling alley, yet drag themselves to work?

I’ll tell you why. Because too many CEO’s view their employees as expendable assets. They should view them as renewable resources. And renew them.

IMO the objective of too much automation (maybe too much management) is to absolutely minimize payrolls rather than to build the best possible company. One of the big problems is that by the time managers realize the error of their ways the damage has already been done.

1 comment

Has the Syrian Government Retaken Aleppo? (Updated)

The New York Times is reporting that rebels in Syria have left the areas of the north-east of the city they occupied and that the Syrian Army is advancing to secure those areas:

BEIRUT, Lebanon — Thousands of people were sent fleeing for their lives on Monday as rebel fighters lost a large swath of territory in the northern Syrian city of Aleppo to government forces and Kurdish fighters, in what could prove to be a turning point in the conflict, both militarily and psychologically.

Residents described desperate scenes of people being killed by shells as they searched for shelter after their homes came under the heaviest bombardment yet in a grinding battle that has destroyed entire neighborhoods of the city, once Syria’s largest and an industrial hub.

At least 4,000 people have been registered with the Syrian Arab Red Crescent in a government-controlled western neighborhood of Aleppo, Jibreen, Jens Laerke, the United Nations humanitarian spokesman, said on Monday.

As the rebels absorbed the harshest blow since they seized more than half the city four years ago, it seemed increasingly likely that President Bashar al-Assad will eventually manage to take back all of Aleppo. That would give the Syrian government control of the country’s five largest cities and most of its more populous west, leaving the rebels fighting Mr. Assad with only the northern province of Idlib and a few isolated pockets of territory in Aleppo and Homs provinces and around the capital, Damascus.

There seems to be some confusion about the direction in which refugees are fleeing. The report above along with others I’ve seen seems to suggest that refugees are fleeing to western Aleppo. That’s towards the Syrian Army not away from it. Other reports say they’re fleeing the Syrian Army.

We’ll probably need to wait for the fog of war to lift before we actually know what’s going on.

Update

The independent news site South Front has noticed the same thing:

According to headlines in the mainstream media, the local population is running from “regime forces”.

Unfortunatelly, they just forgot to mention that locals are running to the “regime-held areas”.

At this point I’ve lost the ability to distinguish the fake news from the real news. The propaganda being dished out by notionally news sites has reached critical mass. A key example of this is that major news outlets seem to think that South Front is a Russian disinformation outlet while South Front seems to think that the major news outlets are dealing out propaganda from the U. S. government.

1 comment

Why Did Chávismo Wreck the Venezuelan Economy?

You probably won’t be surprised that in William Finnegan’s lengthy history of Venezuela under Chávez and since in his New Yorker piece only two explanations for Venezuela’s economy having been left in tatters are presented. The Venezuelan government’s position:

I asked about the current food shortages and failing hospitals. “It is an economic war totally orchestrated by fascistic factions on the right,” Ruiz explained. “In every country, you have an oligarchy, a bourgeoisie, working to prevent other groups from gaining power. Our economic situation is imposed by outside powers, by transnational companies like Polar.”

The government constantly cites this “economic war,” secretly directed from Washington, to explain the gutted economy. Polar is Empresas Polar, Venezuela’s leading manufacturer of food and beer. Polar has been threatened with expropriation, and is harassed and vilified by the government as a treacherous bastion of capital, but it has become indispensable to feeding the country. Ruiz explained that Polar is responsible for shortages because it has reduced production. Polar’s management contends that it cannot import essential ingredients, because the government, which controls all foreign exchange, declines to provide the dollars necessary. These claims are false, according to Ruiz. “They have enough.”

or that it’s just too complicated for us mere mortals to understand:

Understanding Venezuela’s failing state as just another failure of socialism, and of statism generally, is ahistorical. Venezuela before Chávez was often extravagantly statist. Corruption has been a major problem in every era. Even dire food shortages are not new. These things happened under capitalism, too, as did intense political repression. Today’s crisis is for most people the worst in memory, but it is not all about socialism. The predatory state, the extreme insecurity, the sheer weakness of the rule of law—these are problems more profound, at this stage, than a traditional left-right analysis can clarify, let alone begin to solve.

Actually, it’s quite simple. Making economic decisions politically always introduces inefficiencies into an economy. That’s as true in Venezuela as it was in the Soviet Union or Mao’s China or as it is in today’s United States or North Korea. Those inefficiencies are what I’ve been referring to here at The Glittering Eye as “deadweight loss”. China’s economy was supine until it incorporated some market economics into its system.

When enough decisions are made politically, incentives are completely bolloxed up. People do things they shouldn’t and don’t do things they should. They hoard. They become profligate.

When you add rampant corruption to the mix, something inevitable when economic decisions are made politically, it makes matters that much worse.

Stir in monetary mismangement and you’ve got Venezuela.

10 comments

Presidents of the Imagination

Speaking of presidents of the imagination, one of the benign outcomes of a Trump presidency might be to move Republicans once and for all to put the image of Ronald Reagan they’ve built up in their minds behind them. Reagan cut taxes and built up the military to scare the heck out of the Soviets, his approach to fighting communism. That was about it.

He didn’t eliminate any federal departments. He didn’t cut the size of government. He pulled our troops out of Lebanon with their tails between their legs. The economy grew in the 80s through a combination of Reagan’s cheerleading, cultivating Keynes’s “animal spirits”, and garden variety Keynesian fiscal stimulus conjoined with consistent Fed policy. What he did accomplish was reinstilling a sense of confidence in Republicans after Watergate, Nixon’s resignation, and the slow growth of the 1970s.

As James Taranto wrote in his Wall Street Journal column last week:

During the campaign, some Nevertrump conservatives had an annoying tendency to use “Reagan”—meaning what they imagined the 40th president would think and do today—as a rhetorical device to portray Trump’s supporters as apostates from conservatism.

Some are still at it. One of them is Evan McMullin, the former CIA officer and congressional aide who ran as a “true conservative” independent, receiving 0.4% of the nationwide popular vote and topping 20% in his native Utah. In response to the Moore report, he tweeted: “For conservatives who didn’t see this coming, it should be a wake up call. Trump is going to expand the size of the Federal Government.”

Then again, so did Reagan—or, to be precise, so did Congress during his presidency, usually with Reagan’s assent.

The problem with not knowing history is that you’re doomed to repeat your imagined accounts of it over and over again until you believe that what you say happened actually happened.

1 comment

Goodbye to All That

At Financial Times Edward Luce is already nostalgic somewhat prematurely for the Obama Era or, as he puts it, “Barack Obama’s world”:

Whatever precise form Mr Trump’s administration takes, we know this: Mr Obama’s legacy will be purged. In many cases all it will take is the stroke of Mr Trump’s pen.

The Obama erasure will go far deeper than undoing domestic laws, or foreign deals. Mr Trump will repeal ObamaCare, or alter it beyond recognition. He will “keep an open mind” about whether to pull the US out of the Paris agreement on climate change and quite probably blow up the US-Iran nuclear deal. These acts would undo Mr Obama’s most visible achievements. Less obvious ones, such as the ban on Arctic drilling and enhanced interrogation techniques and the intention of closing Guantánamo Bay (never completed) will also be consigned to the dustbin. It will be as if Mr Obama was never here.

I think he’s remembering a Barack Obama of the imagination rather than the one that actually sits in the Oval Office. The Barack Obama I recall cultivated no friendships, enlisted no allies, cut no deals, built no coalitions, formed no consensus, and generally disdained the ordinary political process that presidents have used to accomplish their goals and make them stick. He relied exclusively either on pure power politics or simply governing by fiat. That’s not salving problems by reason as Mr. Luce would have it. That’s using brute force.

He may be overestimating how much of President Obama’s legacy can be “consigned to the dustbin”. For many of his signature accomplishments the costs were frontloaded and the benefits backloaded. The costs have already been sunk with the benefits if any barely or still to be realized.

Sadly, President Trump shows very few prospects of improving on President Obama’s record. Do you see him as somebody who will use the ordinary tools of politics to build consensus? I don’t.

Still, the greatest prophet may astonishingly end up being Michael Moore who years ago predicted that Barack Obama would be remembered solely for being the first black president.

0 comments

Playing Injured

I think that Robert Samuelson has this issue almost completely backwards. From his Washington Post column:

The work ethic is such a central part of the American character that it’s hard to imagine it fading. But that’s what seems to be happening in one important part of the labor force. Among men 25 to 54 — so-called prime-age male workers — about 1 in 8 are dropouts. They don’t have a job and, unlike the officially unemployed, aren’t looking for one. They number about 7 million.

Just what role, if any, these nonworking men played in Donald Trump’s election is unclear. What’s not unclear is that these dropouts, after being ignored for years, have suddenly become a hot topic of scholarly study and political debate. There’s been a sea change. In the mid-1960s, only 1 in 29 prime-age male workers was a dropout. The explosion of dropouts strikes many observers as dire.

He goes on to suggest that some large number of unemployed men are either slackers or too injured to work:

Any debate may turn on whether dropouts are “shirkers” (able-bodied men avoiding work) or “victims” (workers left behind by disability or bad luck). There’s evidence of both. Eberstadt cites surveys that only 15 percent of dropouts “stated they were unemployed because they could not find work.” Other surveys indicate that dropouts spend about eight hours a day “socializing, relaxing and leisure” — watching TV, playing video games or just hanging out.

But nearly half of male dropouts report taking pain pills every day, according to a study by Princeton University economist Alan Krueger. Two-fifths of respondents said their disabilities prevented them “from working on a full-time job for which they [were] qualified.” Male dropouts report they are “less happy, more sad, and more stressed” than workers or the unemployed. In a society that worships the work ethic, being a labor-force dropout is often a ticket to misery.

Closer to the truth I think is that there are too few jobs available at decent wages and the long-term unemployed know it, disability insurance has become the unemployment insurance of last resort, and that a huge number of the people who work actually meet the criteria for disability.

0 comments

Trump Should Choose

In yet another sign of the apocalypse, I actually agree with E. J. Dionne’s assessment in his recent Washington Post column:

If Trump wasn’t ready to put his business life behind him, he should not have run for president. And if Republicans — after all of their ethical sermons about Clinton — do not now demand that the incoming president unequivocally cut all of his and his family’s ties to his companies, they will be fully implicated in any Trump scandal that results from a shameful and partisan double standard.

I’m still not sure how this issue will be resolved. My guess is that Mr. Trump will attempt to brazen it out. It would be a serious departure from the practices of presidents of the recent past but Trump himself is a serious departure from the presidents of the past let alone the recent past.

Another outside possible alternative is that, faced with the alternatives of becoming president and facing potential financial ruin (from his lofty vantage point) or refusing the presidency and maintaining his business empire, he’ll choose the latter. As I’ve said before that would be a fine kettle of fish.

4 comments

Give Us the Tools

What tools would be necessary to determine whether there was substantial voter fraud in our elections? I don’t believe that we have the tools at this point.

There are all sorts of different kinds of vote fraud. There are votes cast by people who are ineligible or don’t exist at all. There are votes cast in multiple jurisdictions by the same eligible person. There are votes cast in the name of someone who is eligible to vote by someone other than the voter.

Back when I was an election judge there were many people still on the voter rolls that we knew to be either dead or no longer living in the ward. We dutifully reported their names and addresses to the Board of Elections as we were supposed to. Nothing ever was done about it.

To identify fraud wouldn’t you need a national biometric ID? That would enable you to determine if the voter were the same individual as the one registered to vote, if the voter were eligible, and if the voter were eligible in the jurisdiction in which he or she was voting.

I think that there is unquestionably some level of vote fraud. Without better tools I don’t see any way we could determine whether you’d measure the numbers of fraudulent votes in the hundreds, the thousands, or the millions.

4 comments

Reminder

With Republicans soon to be in control of the White House and both houses of Congress, this might be a good time to recall “Jane’s Law”, coined by Megan McArdle, at that time blogging under the name “Jane Galt”:

The devotees of the party in power are smug and arrogant. The devotees of the party out of power are insane.

There is an inevitable tendency on the part of the Democrats or Republicans to view the smugness and arrogance on the one hand and the insanity on the other as permanent qualities of the opposing party rather than just attributes of their relative power.

The rising insanity of “devotees” of the Democrats are already apparent, particularly in the person of Paul Krugman. He has made a series of predictions, nearly all of which have immediately failed, most notably that the stock market would never recover from a post-Trump’s election slump.

It will be entertaining if depressing to see that rising insanity.

Keep your eyes out for increasing signs of smugness and arrogance among the “devotees” of the Republicans. Perhaps they will be kept so off-balance by President Trump, certainly not a Reagan Republican and by some reckonings not a Republican at all, that they won’t be able to bring the smugness and arrogance of their notional ascendancy into full flower.

I won’t keep my hopes up.

5 comments