Robots Taking the Fed Governors’ Jobs?

You might want to take a look at this post at Investopedia on the Taylor Rule:

First, AI came for our jobs, now it wants to set monetary policy. With Fed Chair Janet Yellen’s first term as the leader of the Federal Reserve Committee coming to an end, there talk President Donald Trump may appoint a new chairperson who would adopt a rules-based policy, essentially turning the Fed into a robot. Setting monetary policy this way would see the Fed adjust interest rates based on key economic indicators such as inflation, GDP, and the unemployment rate.

The most popular formula is the Taylor Rule, which would see the Fed set a real fed funds rate, usually 2 percent, and then derive the nominal rate using current inflation, inflation expectations, GDP and GDP expectations.

The graph at the top of this page illustrates what interest rate the Taylor Rule would have produced over time.

Here’s the question: would protracted negative interest rates have been worse than what actually happened? That boiled down to increased financialization of the economy, preservation of zombie banks, and subsidies for rich people and did not produce the economic growth predicted by the Fed governors. I open the floor for debate.

12 comments

An Unjust Health Care System

I found physician Marc Siegel’s New York Times op-ed sufficiently thought-provoking that before completing it I immediately headed over to the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality of the Department of Health and Human Service’s report on health care spending. Here’s the summary of its findings. The big health care spenders are more likely to be white, old, prosperous, female, and, unsurprisingly, sicker than the general population.

If an insurance plan premiums must be proportional to risk for the plan to remain viable. What we implement as a matter of policy, whether you’re talking about Medicare or the health insurances exchanges of the still-breathing Affordable Care Act, is not insurance. Basically, we’re subsidizing the health care of old white women at the expense of poor black men.

I don’t believe the real big spenders in our system are women like Dr. Siegel’s 60 year old patient who comes in for a checkup every couple of weeks because she’s worried that her seasonal allergies are pneumonia. I think they’re more likely to be Medicare beneficiaries who are desperately trying to preserve their lives but the point remains.

Here’s another fact, unmentioned in the op-ed: co-pays constitute a much higher proportion of health care spending in other OECD countries. You can find the statistic in an article I cited last week if you’re interested in tracking it down.

Our system will remain fundamentally unjust—not to mention horribly expensive and just plain bad policy—unless we take a number of steps:

  • Create a single health care system rather than four or ten as we have now.
  • Abandon the insurance metaphor in characterizing how we pay for health care.
  • Patients pay for more of their own care.
  • Subsidies are based more on need than political clout.
  • We maintain a commitment to controlling the costs of health care.

We will also need to end the agonistic appeals to emotion and put on our green eyeshades. I am not hopeful. The Republicans’ plan is no more a step in the right direction than the ACA was.

3 comments

ss;mr

George P. Schultz and Martin Feldstein’s Washington Post op-ed on trade is so short you should read it in full:

If a country consumes more than it produces, it must import more than it exports. That’s not a rip-off; that’s arithmetic.

If we manage to negotiate a reduction in the Chinese trade surplus with the United States, we will have an increased trade deficit with some other country.

Federal deficit spending, a massive and continuing act of dissaving, is the culprit. Control that spending and you will control trade deficits.

The first sentence is axiomatic; it’s a tautology—true by definition. The third sentence combines tautology with hypothesis. Its truth really depends on circumstances.

I believe the fourth sentence is only true if you make certain assumptions, for example, that we must allow the Chinese to purchase and hold Treasuries with the dollars they receive in trade. That is not true. We could and IMO should force them to hold dollars.

I think we have a trade deficit with China for four reasons:

  • The cost of labor in China is very low.
  • In the 1990s the Chinese maintained an artificially low yuan in a deliberate move to siphon away U. S. productive capacity. That has had lingering consequences.
  • The Chinese hold Treasuries rather than purchasing American goods and services, we allow them to, and they can enforce it in China because they’re still an authoritarian country.
  • There’s an uneven playing field. Chinese goods are produced under conditions we consider abusive to workers, without the environmental, safety, human rights, and other protections enforced here. We could and should impose a Pigouvian tax on goods made in China to account for the factors we allegedly believe in.

Change those factors and the balance of trade between the U. S. and China will change, too.

“tl;dr” is Internet slang for “too long; didn’t read”. My “ss;mr” is the opposite of that—”so short; must read”.

4 comments

Adolph Kiefer, 1918-2017

Adolph Kiefer, who won a gold medal in the 1936 Olympics, has died at the age of 98. From the Los Angeles Times:

Addolph Kiefer, the 100-meter backstroke champion at the 1936 Berlin Games who was America’s oldest living Olympic gold medalist in any sport, has died. He was 98.

He died Friday at his home in Wadsworth, Illi., about 50 miles north of Chicago, according to the International Swimming Hall of Fame. It said Kiefer had been hospitalized with pneumonia in recent months.

He had neuropathy that kept him confined to a wheelchair later in life, but he continued swimming because he could still stand in the water, according to the Hall of Fame in Fort Lauderdale, Florida.

Kiefer became an Olympic champion as a 17-year-old in an Olympic-record time that stood for 20 years. He was also the first man to break 1 minute in the 100 backstroke, doing so as a high school swimmer in Illinois. He later competed for the University of Texas.

His accomplishments didn’t end there. After joining the U. S. Navy in 1942 at the age of 23 he redesigned the Navy’s swim training program. The Navy had been losing more men to drowning than to bullets and his “victory” backstroke was credited with saving many lives.

He went on to found a successful swimwear company. His company was the first to market a nylon swimsuit, he invented the kickboard, and his company introduced the world’s first turbulence-resistant swim lane. His company biography is here and his company’s obituary of him is here. They make interesting reading.

0 comments

AHCA

I won’t have much to say about the Republicans’ health care reform reform bill until the ink dries and we see what the Senate does with it. When I get around to writing about its merits I suspect there won’t be any.

All I can is that this is what happens when you enact major social legislation without substantial bipartisan support.

The tragedy of it all is that once it’s stamped out the Affordable Care Act the Congress might think it’s finished with health care but health care will definitely not be finished with the Congress.

5 comments

My Day Yesterday

Yesterday after a very successful day of meetings in Toronto I had the misfortune of flying out of Toronto’s airport. I don’t think I’ve ever had a more miserable experience in an airport and I’ve flown in and out of the Lafayette, Indiana airport. And Ontario International Airport outside LA. It makes O’Hare look like the Earthly Paradise by comparison.

Tom Friedman would have a field day. Why doesn’t he write about Canadian infrastructure? There’s an enormous amount of building going on in Toronto but its highways are obviously undersized for the need and any shortcomings of big city American airports are dwarfed by what I experienced in Toronto.

The Canadians certainly aren’t putting their money into infrastructure.

0 comments

I Dream of Afghanistan

Hawks continue to dream of an Afghanistan that does not exist, that has never existed, and that for all we know will never exist. Michael Gerson, writing at the Washington Post, reveals that he’s one of them:

The United States eventually needs a capable, nonradical government in Afghanistan that controls as much of its own territory as possible. This will not be achieved by bombing the hell out of the Taliban alone. It will also not be achieved without bombing the hell out of the Taliban, because it has no current incentive to come to the peace table.

If you throw out the qualifiers and weasel words, e.g. “eventually”, “as possible”, there isn’t much left there. In Afghanistan “the Taliban” isn’t a cohesive identifiable group. It’s Afghan religious conservatives who are willing to take up arms. You can be Taliban this week and not the next. They don’t have large military bases, lots of military collateral, or massed forces. They will be in Afghanistan next week, next month, and next year. Will we?

There will never be a “capable, nonradical government in Afghanistan” as long as government is looked at as a device for enriching yourself, your friends, and your family which is pretty much the way it’s always been.

Additionally, no imaginable Afghan government will ever have the resources to control its own territory. The numbers just don’t add up. It will be lucky if it can control Kabul and its environs.

Rather than dreaming of some fantasy Afghanistan, it might be helpful to consider what achievable objectives we have in Afghanistan, what is needed to accomplish them, and do that instead.

0 comments

Paying for the Care of People with Pre-Existing Conditions

At e21 Charles Blahous reviews the alternatives for paying for the health care of people with pre-existing conditions. He considers four alternatives:

1) Leave sick people to face the costs of their own treatment, whether out of pocket or through high-cost insurance, no matter how ruinous those costs become.
2) Mandate that other, healthier people overpay for the value of their own health insurance, so that sick people can underpay for the value of theirs.
3) Spread the costs of paying expensive health bills throughout society, for example by having taxpayers pick up the tab.
4) Require a targeted group to shoulder the costs.

My own preference is for a version of #3 but I would ask another question. Who should capture the economic surplus in health care? Consumers or producers? Right now producers capture the economic surplus.

14 comments

Policing Has Conflicting Goals

While I have some sympathy with German Lopez’s statement of the problem in his article at Vox:

But when you zoom out to look at all the investigations the Justice Department has done over the past several years, typically after protests ignite due to a police shooting perceived as unjust, a pattern emerges: Whether it’s Baltimore; Cleveland; New Orleans; Ferguson, Missouri; or, most recently, Chicago, the Justice Department has found horrific constitutional violations in how police use force, how they target minority residents, how they stop and ticket people, and virtually every other aspect of policing. These issues come up time and time again, no matter the city that federal investigators look at.

One is left with just one possible conclusion: Policing in America is broken.

Here are the bullet points of his proposed solution:

  1. Police need to apologize for centuries of abuse
  2. Cops should be trained to address their racial biases
  3. Police should avoid situations that lead them to use force
  4. Officers must be held accountable in a very transparent way
  5. On-the-job incentives for police officers need to change
  6. We need higher standards for police — and better pay for cops
  7. Police need to focus on the few people in communities causing chaos and violence
  8. We need better data to evaluate police and crime

Even if fully implemented I don’t think his list would change much. For example, #1 is flummery. It would make Mr. Lopez feel better but it wouldn’t do much to change the underlying issues. I don’t believe an apology would result in people on the South Side of Chicago trusting the CPD more. And while we’re apologizing how about an apology for generations of indifference and corruption on the part of mostly-Democratic city officials?

I think a much more basic problem is that police departments have conflicting goals. Here’s an example.

Something that police officers are taught at the academy is “command bearing” and strategies for maintaining it. The reality is that command bearing is a lot easier when you’re a 250lb. 6’2″ man than when you’re a 110lb. 5’2″ woman. My point is that introducing women and minorities into the police force has changed policing in both good ways and bad. I strongly suspect that one of the effects it’s had has been to make the use of deadly force more likely.

But that brings us to #3. Let’s get real and back to the basics of why we have police departments at all. If force protection is the highest priority (“avoid situations that lead them to use force”), we shouldn’t have police departments at all. You can’t avoid situations in which the use of force is required any more than that.

#6 sounds nice but in Chicago police officers already make six figures when you include overtime and have very generous benefits packages. By far the greater effect of raising pay is to pay more for the police officers you already have and, frankly, Chicago has no problem attracting applicants, suggesting that present pay is already above the market-clearing price. Also, where does he expect Chicago to get the money? The city is already broke.

#7 is fatuous. It boils down to “only arrest criminals”. The problem, to repurpose Chou En-Lai, is that criminals are fish and people in the neighborhoods are the sea.

My priorities would be different than Mr. Lopez’s. Among them would be changing the requirements for joining the police force so that military service does not substitute for education (as it does now at least in Chicago). I’d also change the career path for police officers so that far fewer cops would spend 30 years on the streets. And I’d encourage police to enforce the law more and maintain order less.

3 comments

What in the World Did He Think Would Happen?

In an op-ed in the New York Times Robert P. Jones laments the collapse of American identity:

But recent survey data provides troubling evidence that a shared sense of national identity is unraveling, with two mutually exclusive narratives emerging along party lines. At the heart of this divide are opposing reactions to changing demographics and culture. The shock waves from these transformations — harnessed effectively by Donald Trump’s campaign — are reorienting the political parties from the more familiar liberal-versus-conservative alignment to new poles of cultural pluralism and monism.

An Associated Press-NORC poll found nearly mirror-opposite partisan reactions to the question of what kind of culture is important for American identity. Sixty-six percent of Democrats, compared with only 35 percent of Republicans, said the mixing of cultures and values from around the world was extremely or very important to American identity. Similarly, 64 percent of Republicans, compared with 32 percent of Democrats, saw a culture grounded in Christian religious beliefs as extremely or very important.

These divergent orientations can also be seen in a recent poll by P.R.R.I. that explored partisan perceptions of which groups are facing discrimination in the country. Like Americans overall, large majorities of Democrats believe minority groups such as African-Americans, immigrants, Muslims and gay and transgender people face a lot of discrimination in the country. Only about one in five Democrats say that majority groups such as Christians or whites face a lot of discrimination.

and he cites G. K. Chesterton from “What I Saw in America”, an essay I encourage you to read. In that same essay Chesterton characterizes the United States as a country founded on a creed, unlike other countries that were founded on ties of blood or shared history.

What he doesn’t point out is that Chesterton visited the United States the last time the percentage of immigrants in the country reached 15% and that time we responded very differently. We founded the public school system with the explicit purpose of teaching and promoting the American creed.

Now not only do our schools not promote the American creed, many of them reject it outright or even view it as disturbing. That is not a formula for developing a new shared creed but, as Mr. Jones observes, for fraction.

I don’t know what will happen. The one thing I caution those who long for a new American creed, “weaving a new national narrative in which all Americans can see themselves” as Mr. Jones puts it, that the latest wave of immigrants are much more socially conservative than previous waves and much less embracing of liberal democracy. If we don’t teach it, what do we think will happen?

As I’ve pointed out here before at length, every wave of immigrants has left its mark on our politics and society. New immigrants may not arrive with much in the way of material possessions but they do bring their political, social, and religious beliefs with them when they arrive here. Add that when immigrants come here today they don’t cut ties with the old country the way immigrants use to. I know lots of recent immigrants who still call Mama every night.

I don’t think that’s a durable foundation for a new American creed. Maybe I’m wrong.

16 comments