There is a single sentence in Lawrence Summers’s Washington Post op-ed, cautioning the Fed governors, that tells us an enormous amount. Here’s the sentence:
Given how little the administration has actually changed policy, recent economic performance was pre-determined before Donald Trump took office.
Contrast that with this passage from John Maynard Keynes’s seminal work, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money:
Even apart from the instability due to speculation, there is the instability due to the characteristic of human nature that a large proportion of our positive activities depend on spontaneous optimism rather than mathematical expectations, whether moral or hedonistic or economic. Most, probably, of our decisions to do something positive, the full consequences of which will be drawn out over many days to come, can only be taken as the result of animal spirits—a spontaneous urge to action rather than inaction, and not as the outcome of a weighted average of quantitative benefits multiplied by quantitative probabilities.
That comparison illustrates why Keynes was the greatest economist of the 20th century while Summers is an enormously lesser figure. Keynes understood that economics is a science of human behavior and can only be understood in the context of enormously variable and mercurial human behavior. It is not mathematics; it is not physics.
As long as prominent economists insist on treating economics as though it were mathematics or physics rather than a science of human behavior, we should be very cautious in taking their advice.
Economic behavior is not determined by underlying physical factors. It is subject to random and even irrational variations from what those factors would dictate.
One of the reasons for the Clinton boom was that Bill Clinton was a cheerleader for the economy. One of the reasons that the economy has not had as robust a recovery following the financial crisis of 2007 as it might have was that Barack Obama wasn’t that kind of a cheerleader.
We ignore animal spirits at our risk.
German Chancellor Angela Merkel won big twice yesterday. As reported at Deutsche-Welle her Christian Democratic Union party won the state elections in Schleswig-Holstein:
Chancellor Angela Merkel’s conservative Christian Democrats (CDU) easily defeated the ruling Social Democrats (SPD) in state elections in Schleswig-Holstein on Sunday, exit polls and early returns broadcast by public service TV stations show. Provisional results show the CDU received some 33 percent as compared with around 26 percent for the SPD. The SPD has been governing in coalition with the Green party and the regionalist SSW in the northern state for the past five years.
The anti-immigrant Alternative for Germany (AfD) will enter the state parliament for the first time. The populist party garnered 5.5 percent of the vote, clearing the 5 percent hurdle needed to enter a German legislature. Although receiving just 3.5 percent of the vote, former junior coalition partners the SSW – a party representing the interests of Danish and Frisian minorities in the state – will keep some seats, as it is not subject to the same hurdle as other parties.
and Macron was elected French president. As Marine Le Pen quipped in anticipation of the election whoever was elected a woman would rule France.
I think we’re going to see majorities of both the Germans and the French voting to maintain the status quo. That the status quo cannot be maintained is irrelevant. They’ll try to kick the can down the road.
What is not being mentioned sufficiently is that the right-wing parties, the FN in France and the AfD in Germany, both showed increased strength yesterday. The Eurocrats have received their reprieve but it looks like it’s only temporary.
So, Macron won the French election as expected and as I suggested would happen yesterday. I don’t have much to say about it since I tend not to get into other countries’ politics for a simple reason: politics doesn’t travel well.
Some Republicans here backed Le Pen because she’s the “right wing” candidate without digging into what that means in France. Some Democrats backed Macron because he’s the center-left candidate, equally without learning what that actually means. IMO that’s incredibly short-sighted. You can’t understand another country’s politics without getting an in depth understanding of its economics, history, current events, and culture or, in other words, unless you’ve lived there, speak the language, and immerse yourself in it. Even then you probably won’t appreciate the nuances.
Yesterday I spent some time with a dear old friend who, coincidentally, happens to be one of the country’s foremost health care attorneys. We had brunch at a fabulous place called the Bryn Mawr Breakfast Club, a walkable distance from here if you’re into that sort of thing. I recommend it enthusiastically. It’s a joint, something I like, and I think I’d call its cuisine “fusion”.
After exchanging pleasantries about wives (one each), kids (his), and dogs (multiples), he asked me if I’d read the House’s health care bill. I responded that I was waiting for the ink to dry and to see what the Senate would do. For him that’s his job and I suspect he’s digging into it today.
We then started to talk policy. I think that he and I are largely in agreement although I think I’m more cynical about the prospects for reform than he. I think we’re in agreement that there are more questions than “who pays”, the primary topic under discussion over the last eight years. My view is that as long as prices rise at a multiple of increase in GDP, other prices, incomes, etc. in the final analysis it doesn’t matter who pays: it will be unaffordable and the system will need to change.
Judging from the casts of his movies, Alfred Hitchcock preferred working with the same actors and actresses when he could. Which actors were cast as leads in more than two of his pictures? More than one? (Highlight the blank area below for the answers)
Four each: Cary Grant, James Stewart
Two each: Ivor Novello, Carl Brisson, Gregory Peck, Joseph Cotten, Michael Wilding, Robert Cummings, John Forsyth, and, of all people, Edmund Gwenn (depending on who you think the lead actor is).
Today the French go to the polls to vote for a new president. French media are reporting what is to them a shockingly low turnout but which to us would be astonishingly high. We’ll see if that holds when the polls close.
Yesterday my wife pointed out that for the French election day is a Sunday. I responded that reflects the difference between secularist France and the culturally Calvinist U. S. The French want to maximize the likelihood that people will actually turn out and vote. We think or at least used to think that people should be in church on Sundays.
When the votes are tallied we’ll learn whether the conventional wisdom—that Macron is a shoe-in—is right or wrong, that is, whether there is a reason it is the conventional wisdom.
Eurocrats must be anticipating the vote’s result as a man anticipates his own execution. Will they receive a reprieve?
I’m still listening to old radio programs. After I gave up listening to the decreasingly listenable Yours Truly, Johnny Dollar, following its move to New York and cast change, I started listening to that most archetypal of hard-boiled detective radio dramas, The Adventures of Philip Marlowe. The series began as a summer replacement in 1947 with the screen actor Van Heflin as the titular character. Only a few episodes with Heflin as Marlowe are extant and two of those are the pilot and the first episode, both dramatizations of Chandler’s story Red Wind. To my ear they have slightly different casts, delivery, and music so at this point I think they’re actually different performances of the same script.
The series returned in 1948, this time moving from NBC to CBS and featuring Gerald Mohr as Marlowe. The new version also opened with that same script and there’s really no comparison. Mohr was immeasurably better than Heflin as Marlowe, arguably the best portrayal of the character. Raymond Chandler, who had little connection with the radio series other than cashing his royalty checks, was reportedly happy with Mohr’s performance and he should have been.
Thank goodness someone is pointing out that the reason that large retail chains are having a horrible year isn’t just because of the rise of online buying. From CNBC:
With more than half of 2017 still ahead, the retail industry is seeing a record-setting pace for bankruptcy filings and store closings — and more are expected in the not too distant future, despite what most consider a healthy consumer.
This tipping point for retail is the result of a number of compounding reasons, but the inability to pay looming, massive debt bills is dealing the final death blow to many.
Yes, more shopping is shifting online in general, and to Amazon specifically, as in-store shopping traffic and sales trends fall for many retailers and shopping centers. Slice Intelligence said 43 cents of every online dollar is spent on Amazon, based on its analysis of millions of email receipts.
However, according to the latest Commerce Department retail sales data, 86 percent of all retail sales (excluding motor vehicles and parts and food service and drinking locations) are still made in physical, brick-and-mortar locations. To be sure, the online versus in-store sales breakdown varies wildly from retailer to retailer.
I think the more important answer is that massive retail chains, cobbled together through leveraged buyouts and financed by debt, just don’t serve people very well. And, importantly, depend on certain basic assumptions which aren’t panning out, specifically that you’ll always be able to make your interest payments based on increasing sales. And that there will always be increased returns to scale.
At Quartz Mark Manson presents five rules (or “levels”) for winning the game of life:
Level 1 – Find food; find a bed to sleep in at night
Level 2 – Know you’re not going to die
Level 3 – Find your people
Level 4 – Do something that’s important and valuable to both yourself and others
Level 5 – Create a legacy
For those of you who don’t recognize it, that’s a restatement of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs.
I had Levels 1 and 2 licked by the time I was 17. I haven’t been nearly as successful with the others. By most standards I’ve failed at Level 5.
Unless this blog has informed people and change some minds, in which case I may never know. It could be that my dogs have created my legacy. Ah well, they also serve, etc.
I would add one reminder to his advice: the house always wins.
You might be interested in this quiz on retirement income from the Center for Retirement Income of New York Life. I passed but just barely. I knew more about current law than investment which doesn’t surprise me a bit.