Dysfunctional Foreign Policy

Leon Mangasarian and Jan Techau provide an interesting critique of German foreign policy at Handelsblatt:

One of the problems with German foreign policy today is that it is strategically frivolous. This frivolity is a stance of comfort and convenience. Germany prefers to leave the tough decisions and dirty work of foreign and defense policy to others, in order then to criticize its allies from a moral high horse in a tone of smugness and complacency.

You know, I’d like for the United States to be in that position and I think that most ordinary Americans would, too. The irony is that the reason the U. S. can’t do that is Germany.

My own critique of German foreign policy would be somewhat different.

  • I don’t think that “soft power” means what the authors think it means. Both military force and economic pressure are hard power.
  • Germany has shown no reluctance to use economic pressure to further its foreign policy objectives.
  • Far from being frivolous German foreign policy has had the same strategic objectives for the last 150 years (or, possibly, the last millennium depending on how you reckon things) and has pursued it systematically and consistently, primarily using hard power. From 1870 to 1945 they used military power. Since then (and since recovery) they’ve used economic power.
  • The problem with Germany’s foreign policy objectives is that they are injurious to the rest of the world, particularly Europe and within Europe especially for small countries that want to preserve their own cultures.
0 comments

Where the Canoes Are Heading


There’s a nice summary of the movement of population in the United States at the Mises Institute:

When we look at the net number of residents moving in from other states, we find that the destination for most of these 7.5 million migrants was states in the South and in the West — excluding California…

The map, however, fails to account for just how large was the migration out of certain states, specifically, New York, California, Illinois, and New Jersey. When we ignore foreign migrants and look at just state-to-state flows, we find that more than 191,000 people left New York while more than 129,000 people left California. The top destinations for migrants were Florida, Texas, and North Carolina…

The short version: Illinois is screwed.

1 comment

Caveat patiens

I’m full of questions this morning. These questions are about health care reform.

  1. How can you have a free market in health care without changing both the consumer and producer sides of the equation?
  2. How can health care be internationalized while still protecting patients from quacks and medical malfeasance?
6 comments

The Sum of Good Government

In his commentary at Investor’s Business Daily James Dorn says something I agree with:

Tax reform is necessary to make America great again

and something I’m skeptical about:

so are effective limits on the size and scope of government

The reason for my skepticism is in an equation:

GDP = C + BI + G + (X – I)

or in words gross domestic product is equal to consumer spending plus business investment plus government spending plus net exports. Our economy is not the economy of the 1980s. We make far less of what we consume than we did then and import a lot more. Big businesses depend for their profits much more on their overseas operations than they used to.

There’s another even more crucial question. Should the objective of policy be to increase GDP? Or should it be to increase median income? I don’t see any practical way of effecting either objective without government playing a role.

I also hasten to point out that neither major political party is much interested in limiting the size and scope of government. They just want to spend the money having the government do different things.

14 comments

Amidst the Din

I’ve found a couple of things worth reading on the Comey firing. The first is Deputy Attorney General Rod Rubinstein’s memo to AG Jeff Sessions (PDF). Here’s an excerpt from it in reference to Director Comey’s July press conference:

The FBI director is never empowered to supplant federal prosecutors and assume command of the Justice Department. There is a well-established process for other officials to step in when a conflict requires the recusal of the Attorney General.

The other is Charles Lipson’s guide to the issues and the political postures of the Democrats and Republicans:

Donald Trump’s decision to fire James Comey has set off a firestorm, mostly along party lines, but not entirely. Some Republicans have expressed concern, too, and more will wring their hands in the next few days if the Democrats’ narrative takes hold.

How long the fire lasts and how much it consumes depends, crucially, on information that will emerge out over the coming days, as media organizations pump their sources and Comey defends himself.

To summarize the summary the Democrats and to a large extent the media are taking the position that Trump is the new Nixon and should be impeached. The Republicans, without nearly as unified a voice, are saying that Comey should have been fired for cause long since and are trying to tamp down any fires of a major scandal out of self-interest.

1 comment

Clap Your Hands If You Believe…

I genuinely, sincerely wish I believed that Brian Domitrovic’s assertions in his Forbes article about cutting taxes was right:

The big item in the Trump proposal is the cut in the corporate tax rate, reduced from 35% to 15% and expanding its definition to include small businesses. Such a cut would undermine the value of exemptions from and avoidance of the current corporate rate, things that constitute big-company strategy in this slow-growth era. Such a cut would refocus American business on making things and selling them—the stuff of real growth.

The rest of the plan, the trimming of the top personal income-tax rate, the reduction in the number of personal-rate brackets, and the cashiering of the estate tax and the alternative minimum tax, will have similar effects. These reforms will prompt Americans to pay less attention to the tax consequences of what they are doing and be themselves. And when Americans act naturally, booming growth and mass affluence is the result.

Why won’t cutting the business income tax rate result in more businesses buying back their own stock rather than “making things and selling them”? And why will cutting the personal income tax rates “have similar effects”? Why won’t people just buy more stuff made in China, France, or Germany? Which will result in negligible effects on the domestic economy. Distribution is pretty darned efficient these days. The short version: Amazon could sell a multiple of what it does now without adding many employees.

I support a cut in the business tax rate because it’s inefficient and giving companies incentives to engage in various strategies, e.g. inversions, to avoid taxes. I’m skeptical about cutting the personal income tax rate because of recent experience. Look at how short-lived the stimulative effects of the Bush tax cuts were. We just don’t have an economy in which cutting the personal tax rates will stimulate any more.

5 comments

The Minarchist’s Conundrum

or, Government Is Hard.

At The Imaginative Conservative Bruce Frohnen muses about the “gig economy”. The post is difficult to excerpt but these two passages seem to express the kernel of his thoughts:

An old-line Social Justice Warrior and even a traditional conservative could find plenty of evidence to support the claim that the gig economy is exploitive. Ironically, if typically enough, the worst offenders, here, are the supposedly civic-minded tech companies. Corporations like Microsoft are massive promoters of the gig economy. A number of these powerful corporations have taken advantage of lax immigration rules to bring in guest workers who will toil for half the wage demanded by labor markets in the United States. They then leverage this “diversity” to force many of their remaining American workers to accept being pushed off the payroll into lower-paying, insecure contract positions that lack employee benefits. This is not the market economy at work. It is, rather, abuse of political power to undermine labor market forces for the benefit of a few very rich and powerful manipulators.

and

Many would call the new economy freer, but what I see too often in those who seek gigs is isolation and constant stress. Some might say this is what entrepreneurship requires. But many who are very good engineers, or programmers, or warehouseman, are not so good at sales. Are we not, then, rewarding people for a skill set (sales) that has little to do with actually producing useful things? Are we not devaluing yet more the skills and hard work that built our successful economy and society?

Workplaces are, or should be, communities. I mean this in a very practical sense. Most of us forge friendships at work. Sometimes we become close, sometimes that friendship is merely a kind of trust that we will look after one another on the assembly line, at the meeting, or in covering for one another’s failings to make certain the company does not lose contracts or customers. However common it may have become, workplace sabotage is known even today as something dishonorable and harmful to the company. But the common habits, outlook, and shared assumptions that make professional trust and honor possible are much more difficult to form when we become mere casual acquaintances who happen to meet up on a particular gig. As church, community, or other local associations die when we no longer actually do things together on a regular basis, workplaces die when people no longer come together at a particular place.

Let’s consider just the companies he mentions by name. Microsoft in its present form exists solely due to intellectual property law. Ironically, without the copyright protections that he freely violated, Bill Gates would still be working in his parents’ basement. As it gained wealth and power Microsoft has been able to mold the laws to suit itself.

Uber and Lyft are niche companies that exist because of bungled regulation. The taxi industry is tremendously regulated and notoriously corrupt. What the existence of Uber and Lyft tell us is that the regulated price for taxi service was set above the market clearing price.

I also think that underestimates the importance and value of sales but that’s the subject for another post.

My point in all of this is only that promoting, formulating, and maintaining effective policy is hard. However, it is necessary because the state of nature is worse. Once a policy has been adopted it won’t be set in stone. It must be changed if found ineffective or if circumstances change. And there will always be those who want to ensure that the law furthers their own, personal ends. Eternal vigilance, etc.

0 comments

Comey’s Termination

As you no doubt have heard President Trump dismissed FBI Director James Comey yesterday. The Washington Post reports:

President Trump fired FBI Director James B. Comey on Tuesday, at the recommendation of senior Justice Department officials who said he had treated Hillary Clinton unfairly and in doing so damaged the credibility of the FBI and the Justice Department.

The startling development comes as Comey was leading a counterintelligence investigation to determine whether associates of Trump may have coordinated with Russia to interfere with the U.S. presidential election last year. It wasn’t immediately clear how Comey’s ouster will affect the Russia probe, but Democrats said they were concerned that his ouster could derail the investigation.

Early reactions serve mostly as a barometer of the views of their authors on Trump’s election and presidency. The editors of the New York Times declaim:

By firing the F.B.I. director, James Comey, late Tuesday afternoon, President Trump has cast grave doubt on the viability of any further investigation into what could be one of the biggest political scandals in the country’s history.

The explanation for this shocking move — that Mr. Comey’s bungling of the investigation into Hillary Clinton’s private email server violated longstanding Justice Department policy and profoundly damaged public trust in the agency — is impossible to take at face value. Certainly Mr. Comey deserves all the criticism heaped upon him for his repeated missteps in that case, but just as certainly, that’s not the reason Mr. Trump fired him.

while the editors of the Wall Street Journal intone:

The FBI isn’t supposed even to confirm or deny ongoing investigations, but in July 2016 Mr. Comey publicly exonerated Mrs. Clinton in the probe of her private email server on his own legal judgment and political afflatus. That should have been the AG’s responsibility, and Loretta Lynch had never recused herself.

“It is not the function of the Director to make such an announcement,” Mr. Rosenstein wrote. “The Director now defends his decision by asserting that he believed Attorney General Loretta Lynch had a conflict. But the FBI Director is never empowered to supplant federal prosecutors and assume command of the Justice Department.”

Mr. Rosenstein added that at his July 5 press appearance Mr. Comey “laid out his version of the facts for the news media as if it were a closing argument, but without a trial. It is a textbook example of what federal prosecutors and agents are taught not to do.”

Then, 11 days before the election, Mr. Comey told Congress he had reopened the inquiry. His public appearances since have become a self-exoneration tour to defend his job and political standing, not least to Democrats who blame a “Comey effect” for Mrs. Clinton’s defeat. Last week Mr. Comey dropped more innuendo about the Trump campaign’s alleged ties to Russia in testimony to Congress, while also exaggerating the new evidence that led his agents to reopen the Clinton file.

For all of these reasons and more, we advised Mr. Trump to sack Mr. Comey immediately upon taking office. The President will now pay a larger political price for waiting, as critics question the timing of his action amid the FBI’s probe of his campaign’s alleged Russia ties. Democrats are already portraying Mr. Comey as a liberal martyr, though last October they accused him of partisan betrayal.

The view closest to my own is expressed in this article at Reason:

In the short term, though, this looks very, very bad for Trump.

The three-paragraph letter announcing Comey’s firing reads like the world’s worst “the dog ate my homework” note and is hard to take seriously. Trump blames Comey’s firing on, of all things, Comey’s handling of Hilary Clinton’s classified emails last summer and makes a lame, backhanded attempt at clearing his own name (“While I greatly appreciate you informing me, on three separate occasions, that I am not under investigation…,” Trump wrote). It would be laughable if the matter were not so serious.

[…]

We don’t know whether Comey’s firing is a shrewd political calculation designed to cover-up something Trump doesn’t want the world to know—”Nixonian” has been the word of evening on cable news—or whether it was the impulsive decision of a president who appears to lack much concern for the prestige of the office he holds or for the limits of its powers.

On the question of whether Trump broke laws or whether Comey’s firing was part of a cover-up, Trump deserves to be treated as innocent until proven guilty. The same principle does not apply to the political ramifications of Tuesday’s firing.

Trump should lose any benefit of the doubt that he’s been getting from members of Congress and the general public.

All that I can add is that I believe that throughout this whole sorry mess Director Comey’s actions have been motivated primarily by a desire to protect the FBI’s reputation and his own. He rather clearly failed at both of those objectives.

The American people deserve complete, impartial, and de-politicized investigations of Hillary Clinton’s use of a private email server, the hacking of the DNC’s email, and any connections of Donald Trump or his subordinates with Russia. As of this writing it does not appear that we will get any of those.

14 comments

We Are All Immoral

Sometimes I think that a little perspective is in order. Take this article by A. Q. Smith in Current Affairs:

Here is a simple statement of principle that doesn’t get repeated enough: if you possess billions of dollars, in a world where many people struggle because they do not have much money, you are an immoral person. The same is true if you possess hundreds of millions of dollars, or even millions of dollars. Being extremely wealthy is impossible to justify in a world containing deprivation.

Even though there is a lot of public discussion about inequality, there seems to be far less talk about just how patently shameful it is to be rich. After all, there are plenty of people on this earth who die—or who watch their loved ones die—because they cannot afford to pay for medical care. There are elderly people who become homeless because they cannot afford rent. There are children living on streets and in cars, there are mothers who can’t afford diapers for their babies. All of this is beyond dispute. And all of it could be ameliorated if people who had lots of money simply gave those other people their money. It’s therefore deeply shameful to be rich. It’s not a morally defensible thing to be.

I think that Mr. or Ms. Smith is missing something basic. The world median household income is under $10,000. The U. S. median family income is nearly five times the world median and more than three standard deviations above normal, rich by any reasonable standard. In other words an ordinary U. S. family is rich.

2 comments

Wondering About the Gig Economy

There’s an interesting article by Nathan Heller at the New Yorker on the gig economy. I can’t quite decide whether it’s a lament for the jobs the Millennials’ grandparents had or not:

The reason for Perez’s visit was an unusual feature of Hello Alfred’s model: although the taskers can work part time, on a schedule they determine, all are full W-2 employees. Perez considered the company to be a model—creative, well-intentioned, and kind toward its employees—and praised it between pulls on his Coke heavy. “I appreciate that you’re understanding the high road is the smart road,” he said. “This is not an act of charity! This is an act of enlightened self-interest.”

He would have been more correct to call it self-interest tamed. Sapone told me later that it’s expensive to carry a staff of W-2 workers on a gigging schedule. The tax burden is greater for Hello Alfred than it would be on a 1099 model, the hourly rate is high, and the required human-resources infrastructure drives up the cost. Attrition is low, but W-2 companies are also vulnerable to various employee lawsuits from which 1099 employers are insulated.

For now, however, companies such as Hello Alfred, going above and beyond market demands out of principle, may be the gig economy’s best hope. And, occasionally, the principles travel. Blake Hinckley has already moved the most senior three of his six Happy Host staff cleaners onto W-2 status. The reason, he told me, is Sapone: they knew each other in Boston, and she convinced him that any honorable company owed its workers employment benefits.

There are a couple of things I found conspicuous by their absence in the article. The first was any real understanding of what working conditions of a half century ago were like. Since that was the working world in the early part of my career, I think I can sketch a picture of it.

You showed up at work on time and you stayed at work until the end of the day. Unless you were in shift work everyone worked the same schedule. In Germany bells actually sounded when you should start work, when it was time for a coffee break, when it was time to return from coffee break, when it was time for lunch, when lunch time was over, and when work was over. The company told you how to dress, how you should groom yourself, how you should speak and comport yourself on the job (in some cases off as well).

There were no cubicles. If you were a manager, you had an office. If you weren’t, you sat in a bullpen. In the bullpen there was no personalization of workspaces.

You didn’t have a computer on your desk. Unless you were a secretary you didn’t even have a typewriter. If you had a phone, it was a company phone. You didn’t make personal calls or long distance calls.

It was a severely hierarchical world. You reported to a superior and in the big business world, there was layer after layer of structure. Generally, your opinion was neither asked for nor wanted.

You corresponded in writing. You didn’t send memos up the chain. I’ve known people who were discharged for writing a memo to their boss’s boss. All of that means that you were dependent on other people for even basic business communications.

I think that most Millennials today would find that intolerable. I don’t believe they have the equipment to handle it.

The other thing I missed is that there did not seem to be any recognition that benefits, taxes, and administrative load figure in employee compensation. The more rules are imposed on the employer-employee relationship, the less predisposed employers are to add new employees.

0 comments