It’s the Assumptions, Stupid

At the Health Affairs Blog Billy Wynne outlines a single-payer system for the United States:

My goal with this post is to demonstrate that a “unified” (punchline: It wouldn’t truly be single payer…), market-driven, federally regulated, privately delivered system need not possess any of these objectionable attributes. In fact, the parameters of such a system are all but staring us right in the face. I call it: Medicare Advantage Premium Support for All (MAPSA).

While any flavor of single payer may be the last thing that comes to mind when contemplating bipartisan initiatives, just as the far left and far right share some libertarian (and other) commonalities, we may have indeed finally come full circle in this tiresome, so-far-futile debate. By combining two shots of conservative orthodoxy with one overflowing progressive one, and stirring slowly, it is not at all far-fetched to envision an endgame cocktail for our health care system that covers everyone, decreases costs, and can pass Congress. Cheers.

I find his assumptions excessive at the very least. Here are the three most important assumptions:

If you remove employer and household spending from the equation for the moment, which means both elements would contribute nothing (you’re welcome), that leaves about $1.5 trillion or $5,371 per person available to fund the new system.

Now, Medicare spent about $11,642 per person in 2015, but keep in mind that these beneficiaries are aged or disabled, much less healthy, and more expensive to care for than the average American, which includes children, young invincibles, and so forth. If we take health plans and actuaries at their word, an “age rating band” (or ratio between what we charge the oldest and youngest members of the insurance pool) of 5:1 is appropriate. This is also, I’d note, the ratio advanced by Republicans in the AHCA.

This suggests that $6,985 is the average cost of coverage if we use Medicare spending as the benchmark (that is, calculating premiums at a 3:1 ratio if 5:1 is Medicare’s $11,642). That may be too high, because for this exercise we are actually excluding current Medicare beneficiaries, so the fifth quintile of the rest of the population would actually cost less, on average, to cover.

When contemplating health care reform I think there are several things to keep in mind:

  • Canada’s administrative expenses are about 15% of the whole.
  • U. S. administrative expenses are about twice that.
  • Once you’ve realized your savings by trimming administrative expenses, you’ve realized your savings. At the present rate of increase in health care costs, the savings realized by cutting administrative expenses would be offset in just a few years. That’s not a lot of headroom.
  • Cost savings beyond that can only be realized by cutting reimbursements, something we’ve shown little willingness to do, cf. “doc fixes”.

Mr. Wynne is less cynical than I. I think that if Medicare covered Americans for the first 18 years of life rather than the last 18 years we’d have the highest paid obstetricians and pediatricians in the world and med students would be jostling one another to get into those specialties.

I continue to believe that cutting costs, not just cutting the rate of increase but actually cutting costs, is the sine qua non of health care reform. Until we’re willing to do that anything else is just waste motion.

6 comments

What’s the Nature of the Warranty?

I’ve got to admit I was gravely tempted when I first read about Tesla’s solar roof. Here’s a good article about the product at Greentech Media:

According to Tesla, the product will cost $21.85 per square foot for an average American home — making it competitive with standard tile, metal or slate roofs. You can read more about Tesla’s assumptions here.

Speaking on a briefing call with reporters, Musk said a solar roof covering 40 percent of the average-sized American home would generate 10 percent to 20 percent more electricity than a standard solar system.

“It’s a better product at a slightly better price,” said Musk, comparing the product to conventional roofs.

“It’s the most affordable roof you can buy,” said Peter Rive, SolarCity’s chief technology officer, on the call.

Tesla has been known for making aggressively optimistic statements about its products and its abilities. A typical roof lasts for twenty years or more. Tesla has been around for less than 15 years and it’s lost money every year. What will its “infinity” warranty be worth if the company doesn’t exist in 20 years?

If they had to put down a bond for each roof sold, I doubt that the company could survive.

4 comments

Too Late Ve Get Schmart

I wish more people (other than me) had been saying what Ted Galen Carpenter is saying over the The National Interest:

The Bosnia conflict was a huge missed opportunity for the United States to set new, more rational, priorities for itself in the post–Cold War world. A far better policy would have been to inform the Europeans that a petty conflict in the Balkans did not reach the threshold of a serious security threat to the transatlantic community warranting direct U.S. involvement, much less requiring Washington’s leadership. NATO’s European members had no more right to expect a dominant U.S. role in dampening a Bosnian civil war than Americans would have had the right to expect European countries to take the lead in addressing a similar conflict in the Caribbean or Central America.

back when it might have done some good. That is practically verbatim what I said at the time and have maintained ever since. I understand the rationale of Lord Ismay first Secretary General of NATO’s characterization of NATO’s purpose as “to keep the Russians out, the Americans in, and the Germans down”.

But how did keeping the “Germans down” transmogrify into pursuing German foreign policy objectives? Destabilizing Yugoslavia was a German foreign policy objective as was NATO expansion.

More recently from a practical standpoint NATO has been a mechanism for venue-shopping for approval in U. S. military actions rejected by the United Nations Security Council with no moral or legal standing.

3 comments

Welcome Assistance

Today Barry Eichengreen takes over the job of Germany-bashing at Project Syndicate:

In 2016, Germany ran a current-account surplus of roughly €270 billion ($297 billion), or 8.6% of GDP, making it an obvious target of Trump’s ire. And its bilateral trade surplus of $65 billion with the United States presumably makes it an even more irresistible target. Never mind that, as a member of the eurozone, Germany has no exchange rate to manipulate. Forget that Germany is relatively open to US exports, or that its policymakers are subject to the European Union’s anti-subsidy regulations. Ignore the fact that bilateral balances are irrelevant for welfare when countries run surpluses with some trade partners and deficits with others. All that matters for Trump is that he has his scapegoat.

The Reader’s Digest version of his post is that the Germans save a lot, don’t invest much, don’t consume much, and export a lot.

Interesting factoid: there are no German universities in the global top 50. Those are absolutely dominated by American and British institutions of higher learning.

5 comments

The Lowest Common Denominator

Despite the case that Michael Kramer presents at Investopedia, I still don’t believe that Macy’s decline or the decline of brick-and-mortar chain stores more generally is being caused by online:

We could go on, but honestly, these numbers paint a dismal picture for the state of the company and retail as a whole. The company has declining sales, declining margins, swelling inventories, and dwindling receivables. The ship is headed in the wrong direction.

I turned to Macy’s income statement and what jumped out at me were rising costs, especially cost of operations, interest, an non-recurring expenses in the face of declining sales.

I think that what has happened to retail is two things. They’re being pressed on prices (Amazon’s retail generally operates at a loss) and large, national chains must try to appeal to the mass market. That has resulted in making the experience of going to a Macy’s store a miserable one. If you get a comparable price online and can avoid the miserable experience, is it any surprise that online is growing? It’s still a relatively small segment of the total retail picture.

I think this parallels the airline industry. Air travel has gone from being a luxury experience to a commodity one. From the Gold Leaf Service on the Rocky Mountaineer to the Greyhound bus. Who wouldn’t avoid it?

3 comments

Bring Me Giants!

I don’t believe that Philip Delves Broughton’s explanation, expressed in the Wall Street Journal, for the mostly meager display of talent among the candidates for the French presidency holds water:

All those graduates of Paris’s famed lycées, Henri IV and Stanislas, and the products of its vaunted grandes écoles looked at what France had to offer and hoofed it, some for New York, a few for Silicon Valley, and a great thundering herd for London.

They have earned millions as hedge-fund traders and investment bankers, or by setting up businesses free of the mind-bending constraints of French employment law. London has prospered from their presence. They have bought townhouses in South Kensington and filled the private schools with hordes of little Xaviers and Sylvies. If some enterprising PR company were to set up a cross-Channel croissant-making contest, the winner would be as likely to come from Mayfair as from the Marais.

Maybe. How then to explain how weak the Republican aspirants for the presidency were? All of the talented have become investment bankers? I don’t buy it. For one thing I don’t believe that wealth is an intelligence test. My experience has been more the contrary: if you’re so rich why ain’t you smart?

Allow me to offer an alternative explanation. The talents of years gone by just weren’t that talented. The incredible visibility and lack of anonymity in a world in which every passing stranger holds a movie camera and can publicize his or her findings instantly just reveals how ordinary they are. As Montaigne put it, “No man is a hero to his value.”

So, we find ourselves in a world in which the dangers, challenges, and complexities call for gods and heroes and we’re left with mere ordinary men and women. From my point of view that calls for better processes and institutions rather than a search for greater leaders.

0 comments

It’s Complicated

As I read Laurence Kotlikoff’s comparison of the Trump tax reform outline with the Republicans in the House’s “Better Way” tax reform bill in the Wall Street Journal, it impressed on me once again what a complicated country the United States is. If the House’s plan becomes law, here’s Dr. Kotlikoff’s description of what will happen to the business income tax:

The Better Way plan transforms the corporate income tax into something different: a business cash-flow tax with a border adjustment. Notwithstanding innumerable mischaracterizations by the press, politicians and business leaders, the cash-flow tax implements a standard value-added tax, plus a subsidy to wages. Every developed country has a VAT, which is an indirect way to tax consumption. All of these levies have border adjustments, which ensure that domestic consumption by domestic residents is taxed whether the goods in question are produced at home or imported. Unlike the Better Way, Mr. Trump’s plan does not include a border adjustment, which means it effectively taxes exports and subsidizes imports. This undermines his goal of reducing the U.S. trade deficit.

Where is the progressive element to the cash-flow tax? It’s in the subsidy to wages, which insulates workers from the brunt of the VAT. They will pay VAT consumption taxes when they spend their paychecks, but they also will have higher wages thanks to the subsidy. The folks who truly pay the cash-flow tax are the rich, because they pay the VAT when they spend wealth that was earned years or decades ago.

So, let’s look at the scorecard. If enacted the United States will have a VAT (the new business border-adjusted cash flow tax), a graduated income tax (the personal income tax), and a flat tax (the payroll tax, at least it would be flat if FICA max were also eliminated as Dr. Kotlikoff mentions).

That’s reminiscent of our health care system. We have a private insurance system, a publicly-subsidized health care insurance system (the health care exchanges), the largest single-payer insurance system in the world (Medicare), and the largest fully socialized health care system in the world (the VA).

Of France Charles De Gaulle once quipped “How can you govern a country with 246 varieties of cheese?” France ain’t got nothing on the U. S.

0 comments

Cowen on Health Care Reform

Tyler Cowen has a good post on health care reform at Bloomberg View. The gist of it is this: health care reform that makes most people worse off while helping a few is unlikely ever to be popular.

One possible solution is to make the penalties for not signing up tougher, to ensure participation. But it is no political accident that the mandate was so lax to begin with, because such tougher pressures would have made Obamacare less popular. Furthermore, what is the point of a health-care reform that makes so many policyholders worse off by the standards of their own preferences?

Another way to manage health-care subsidies would be a single-payer system, and some commentators suggest that is where the Democratic Party is headed. I wouldn’t be so sure. Obama made his (partially incorrect) “if you like your health care plan, you can keep it” promise for a reason. The Americans who get health insurance through their jobs often enjoy privileged access to doctors and benefit from superior reimbursement rates.

If the price of covering the sick is for millions of wealthier and more influential people to give up those advantages, I don’t see that happening. The health-insurance industry and other medical lobbies will be opposed, too, with doctors fearing that a single-payer system would bargain down their reimbursement rates. Even a relatively progressive state such as Vermont could not make a single-payer system happen.

The Affordable Care Act took the form it did for good reasons, almost none of them policy reasons. Under what conditions would some future reform be any different?

2 comments

China’s Challenge

If you’re a long-time reader of The Glittering Eye, there’s nothing in Michael Schulman’s Bloomberg View op-ed, “China Has World’s Biggest Productivity Problem”, that you won’t have read here:

China, like other economies in Asia, is facing the consequences of its past success. The region’s economies achieved eye-popping growth rates by tossing their poor and primarily agrarian workers into industry and global supply chains. That unleashed a torrent of productivity gains, as peasant farmers started making everything from teddy bears to iPhones.

In other words, China propelled its rapid development by shifting underutilized labor and capital into a modern capitalist economy.

Maybe somebody living in China will have more authority to say it.

I quibble with his prescription a bit:

Of course, what China really requires is the sort of free-market reform that the current leaders in Beijing have been so reluctant to implement. The state needs to allow market forces to allocate money and talent to the country’s most competitive and productive industries and companies.

I don’t think that greater producer efficiencies are the key to China’s future growth. I think that the Chinese authorities need to stop subsidizing exports (done in any number of ways), weed out corruption (mostly theirs), let wages grow, and rely on domestic private consumption much, much more for economic growth. Magic 8-Ball says “Outlook not so good”.

0 comments

Legs

Nate Silver is skeptical that the Trump-Russia story is a scandal with any legs and is looking for a gauge for that:

So if you want to track the progress of the Trump-Russia story, the most important benchmark is how Senate Republicans are behaving. Are Republicans, especially those who have a reputation for being loyal to the administration, taking concrete steps toward forming a select committee, for example? Or are they following Majority Leader Mitch McConnell’s lead and blowing the Comey story off? I don’t mean these as rhetorical questions; we’re in the midst of tracking down Republican senators’ positions on Russia and how they’ve evolved over time. But these will be the most important indications of whether the story has legs.

I would say that a significant gauge is whether Trump’s approval falls through the roughly 40% floor he’s had since his election. The members of Congress are sheep. They’ll bolt if Trump’s approval rating goes below 30%.

3 comments