Special Counsel Appointed

The Justice Department has named former FBI Director Robert S. Mueller as special counsel to oversee the Trump-Russia investigation.

New York Times

Robert Mueller III, who was named special counsel on Wednesday to oversee the Trump-Russia investigation, is charged with revealing the truth about suspicions that reach into the highest levels of the Trump campaign and White House.

Given the “unique circumstances” of the case, Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein said in making the appointment, a special counsel “is necessary in order for the American people to have full confidence in the outcome” of the investigation.

Mr. Rosenstein is absolutely right, and he has done the nation a service in choosing Mr. Mueller, one of the few people with the experience, stature and reputation to see the job through. Mr. Mueller led the F.B.I. for 12 years under Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama. In 2004, he and Mr. Comey, then deputy attorney general, threatened to resign if President Bush allowed a domestic-surveillance program to continue without Justice Department approval.

Washington Post

This was an essential and reassuring step after a series of alarming developments. The first question for Mr. Mueller will be whether the Russian government meddled in the 2016 presidential election. The second question will be whether anyone in the Trump campaign colluded in the meddling. And the third question will be whether anyone in the administration, up to and including President Trump, illegally tried to interfere with investigations into the alleged meddling and collusion.

An independent inquiry is needed because of statements and actions by Mr. Trump that raised serious concern about executive interference. These include his reported request in January that then-FBI Director James B. Comey swear his loyalty to the president; his reported attempt a month later to persuade Mr. Comey to drop an investigation of Mr. Trump’s first national security adviser, who had to quit after he lied about the nature of his contacts with Russian officials; and his decision last week to fire Mr. Comey. Mr. Trump initially put forward false explanations for that firing but eventually admitted that he was motivated by his displeasure with the FBI’s investigation of alleged Russian interference.

[…]

His job is not to inform the public or to pass judgment on actions that may have been unwise, inappropriate or unethical — but did not violate the law. That is why this appointment does not let Congress off the hook. The American public needs a full accounting of Russian interference in the 2016 election; of American cooperation in that meddling, if any; and of administration efforts to impede investigations into the meddling and collusion, if they took place. The House and Senate intelligence committees are working on aspects of all that, and those must continue. But a full accounting is likely to emerge only if Congress appoints a special commission like the one that investigated the 9/11 attacks. With the Trump administration having led the way, Congress too should act.

Wall Street Journal

The problem with special counsels, as we’ve learned time and again, is that they are by definition all but politically unaccountable. While technically Mr. Rosenstein could fire Mr. Mueller if he goes too far, the manner of his appointment and the subject he’s investigating make him de facto untouchable even if he becomes an abusive Javert like Patrick Fitzgerald during the George W. Bush Administration.

What the country really needs is a full accounting of how the Russians tried to influence the election and whether any Americans assisted them. That is fundamentally a counterintelligence investigation, but Mr. Mueller will be under pressure to bring criminal indictments of some kind to justify his existence. He’ll also no doubt bring on young attorneys who will savor the opportunity to make their reputation on such a high-profile investigation.

I think I agree most with the editors’ of the Washington Post’s take above. I welcome the appointment of a special counsel; it’s what I’ve wanted all along; I think the action should have been taken some time ago; it looks like Mr. Mueller is a good man for the job. I would also welcome the appointment of a special commission.

We’ll see where this takes us as events unfold.

4 comments

Richard Diamond, Private Detective

I quickly finished listening to the extant programs of the Philip Marlowe old-time radio program and moved on to Richard Diamond, Private Detective which I can only characterize as bizarre. The program starred Dick Powell.

As you may recall Dick Powell had two distinct screen personae. One was the happy-go-lucky song and dance man of 1930s Busby Berkeley movies, e.g. 42nd Street, Gold Diggers of 1933, but, unrecognized by many, Powell also turned in on of the very best portrayals of Philip Marlowe in the 1944 move, Murder, My Sweet.

Well, Richard Diamond had Powell giving us both of them. In the first 25 minutes of the program he’s the toughest of hard-boiled detectives in rough, even gruesome stories, sometimes verging into Mickey Spillane territory. Then in the last five minutes he goes over to his girlfriend’s, Helen Asher’s, apartment. Helen, played by the incomparable Virginia Gregg, presses him to sing and he does, usually a popular song from the 1920s or 1930s. The effect is a bit jarring.

There weren’t a lot of radio programs that translated successfully to television. The Benny program, Our Miss Brooks, Gunsmoke, a handful of others. Richard Diamond was one of them, running on television from 1957 to 1960, with David Janssen as Diamond and featuring, in its third season, the 22 year old Mary Tyler Moore as Sam AKA “Legs” (you only heard her voice and saw her legs or glimpses of her lips). Diamond on television bore little resemblance to the radio program.

0 comments

1 Million Years AD

The problem that I had with this article at Space.com and, presumably, the National Geographic Channel series it uses as its springboard on the human species in the far, far future is that is seem to presume Whig history.

In a million years will our species still exist? Will we be big-headed monstrosities? Will we have returned to non-reasoning brutes?

What makes them think that Homo erectus wasn’t Homo sapiens? And try explaining an office job to the Pirahã of Brazil.

I don’t believe that we can predict what we’ll be like 1,000 years in the future let alone a million.

1 comment

What Happens in Venezuela?

It doesn’t seem like things could get much worse in Venezuela. With a rate of inflation over 700%, relatively high unemployment rate, declining labor force participation rate, and lack of basic staples in the stores, you have to wonder how long it can go on.

But what will happen? Will Venezuela become an unarguable military dictatorship without even the trappings of democracy? Will it just dissolve into chaos? Is there a risk of that spreading?

I don’t know the answer to any of those questions but it really sounds bad there.

2 comments

The Case for Tax Reform

At RealClearMarkets Pinar Cebi Wilber makes the case for reforming the corporate income tax:

According to IRS data for 2013, there were close to 1.6 million corporations in the United States. We do not know the exact amount of taxes paid by each company, but we can rely on government and private calculations of effective tax rates paid by overall U.S. corporate businesses. A recent study by PricewaterhouseCoopers reviewed the ranks U.S. effective corporate tax rates against major competitors, including the European Union and OECD.

As the PwC study points out, the United States always ranks among the top four countries in terms of the highest effective corporate tax rate. According to the European Commission, in 2015 the U.S. had the second highest effective marginal tax rate among 35 countries, which included the European Union, Japan, Canada, and five other major economies.

The most recent government study, published by the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) in March 2017, also confirms the rank of the United States. Based on 2012 tax data, the CBO found that the United States had the highest statutory rate, third-highest average corporate tax rate, and fourth-highest effective corporate tax rate among the G20 countries.

Our high effective corporate tax rate provides an incentive for inversions, moving the headquarters of U. S. companies overseas via accounting gymnastics. That’s not good for U. S. workers.

If you don’t believe in lowering the corporate income tax rate so that we’re competitive with other OECD countries, please present your plan for discouraging inversions and explain how you’re going to get your plan through the House.

0 comments

Is Trump in Trouble?

The outrage of the day is over President Trump’s allegedly sharing classified information with the Russian foreign minister and ambassador. That is either high treason or wholly appropriate, depending on who you listen to.

If those now calling for Trump’s impeachment hadn’t been calling for his impeachment for the last six months, their position would be stronger. As it is, they might just be background noise.

At this point I have no opinion on the material facts or on whether Trump should be impeached over it. I would remind people that building a case for impeachment is not a matter of marshalling objective facts. Impeachment is a political and subjective act.

A “high crime and misdemeanor” is whatever the House of Representatives thinks it is and, contrary to what you might believe, nothing passes the House against the wishes of the House leadership.

As of this morning the RealClearPolitics average of polls on Trump’s approval rating is 40.1% and falling. That’s still not in the danger zone. If it falls below the previous apparent floor of 38% into the 20s, Trump will be in trouble. Otherwise not so much.

I did not vote for Trump. I wish he were not president. I don’t think his shenanigans improve his bargaining position.

However, I don’t believe in government by impeachment and the only advice I can provide to those who do is be careful what you wish for.

The Republican-led Congress didn’t impeach President Obama. That wasn’t because he didn’t provide grounds. It was because his approval rating was too high and impeaching him would have placed the Republicans’ majority and their own jobs at risk.

Trump’s approval rating is dreadfully low. It has both a ceiling of around 49% and a floor of around 38% so far. If that floor doesn’t hold, Trump could be in trouble.

22 comments

The Twilight of American Internationalism

Hal Brands’s article at War on the Rocks on American internationalism in the Trump years is a good one, too. IMO American internationalists have quite a chore on their hands. They’ve got to convince a lot more Americans that internationalism, at least as they define it, is good for them.

How that can be accomplished when immigrants capture a large percentage of the job gains and the wealthiest 1% of Americans capture most of the income gains is hard for me to reckon. A very large number of Americans clearly don’t think internationalism has worked for them. What if they’re right?

2 comments

More Great Expectations

When I read this by Paul Katzeff in IBD:

Say you start in your twenties. Forty years later, if your retirement savings account averages a modest 6% annual rate of return compounded quarterly, you’ll have nearly $173,000 from those $20 a week additions to your retirement savings.

I was taken aback. Where in the world has he been getting a 6% return over the last 20 years? He hasn’t been getting it in the stock and/or bond market. In the 20 years from 1991 to 2011, the average investor realized 2.1%.

He didn’t get it from CDs. They’ve been below 5% for the last twenty years and below 3% for much of the last 15 years.

The only way he could get that kind of return on the entire original principal is by taking significantly higher risks. How much risk can a retirement portfolio stand?

Calculating returns over the last 91 years as he does is facetious in the extreme. And over the 20 year period from the mid-1960s to to the mid-1980s there were no gains at all. All of those gains are concentrated in a relatively few boom years. Averages mean nothing under the circumstances.

If that hypothetical investor started saving at age 20, she’s 111 now. The reason not to start your calculation over the last 20 years or even the last 30 years is that most of you’d miss the boom years.

1 comment

The Argument Against Cutting Marginal Tax Rates

In her most recent Washington Post column Catherine Rampell finally gets around to giving some reasonable reasons to be against the tax cuts proposed by the Trump Administration:

In fact, in a recent paper, University of Chicago Booth School of Business economics professor Owen Zidar looked at changes to the tax code over the postwar period, with an eye toward comparing the economic effects of tax cuts felt by the rich vs. the poor. He found that the relationship between tax cuts and job growth is primarily driven by cuts for lower-income groups and that the economic effects of tax cuts for the top 10 percent are tiny.

A slew of earlier studies on the earned-income tax credit supports this view that tax policy aimed at putting more money in the pockets of the poor and lower-middle-class provides a bigger bang for your buck.

Or maybe you think cutting corporate taxes and capital gains rates would encourage more investment. This argument would be more convincing if companies were not already sitting on mountains of cash that they can’t find sufficient investment opportunities for. Or if the last time we tried something similar there had been any effect at all on corporate investment. (There was none.)

As I’ve said before, those who think that cutting the marginal personal income tax rate will do much to stimulate the economy are engaging in nostalgia. They’re thinking of an economy very unlike the one we have now in which so many consumer goods are made in another country or an increase in retail will result in hiring more employees in brick and mortar stores. Retail is already over-capacity.

Although I support cutting the marginal business income tax it’s for very narrow reasons. The business income tax is inefficient. The burden of high rates falls on employees. Our having higher rates than other OECD countries incentivizes inversions which prompt decreases in higher-paying jobs here.

The cut in personal taxes most likely to stimulate the economy would be a cut in the payroll tax but that would need a change in the way that SSRI is thought of and funded. Mustn’t have that. The people it would help most are too deplorable.

4 comments

Let the Finger-Pointing Begin!

In the nervous aftermath of the most extensive ransomware attack to date, the assignment of blame is already beginning. CNet reports that in a rather obvious attempt at pre-emption Microsoft’s chief counsel is calling the attack a “wakeup call”:

Microsoft is criticizing government agencies for hoarding software flaws and keeping them secret, calling a massive, new ransomware attack a “wake-up call” to the problem.

Brad Smith, Microsoft’s chief counsel, said Sunday in a company blog post that by keeping the vulnerabilities secret from vendors, governments open up users to attacks like Friday’s WannaCry hack in which malware locked down computers worldwide while demanding hefty sums for freedom. He also compared WikiLeaks’ release of US spy agencies hacking tools earlier this year to a theft of weapons from the US military.

“An equivalent scenario with conventional weapons would be the US military having some of its Tomahawk missiles stolen. And this most recent attack represents a completely unintended but disconcerting link between the two most serious forms of cybersecurity threats in the world today — nation-state action and organized criminal action,” he said.

“The governments of the world should treat this attack as a wake-up call. We need governments to consider the damage to civilians that comes from hoarding these vulnerabilities and the use of these exploits.”

That’s almost a perfect example what I call a “reverse Voltaire”. I agree with what he says but I don’t think he’s in any position to say it. The personal computing monoculture created by Microsoft is one of the main sources of today’s tremendous vulnerability. I also feel the need to point out that cyber-security is almost the diametric opposite of physical security. The advantage is almost completely on the side of the attacker.

So, what are the takeaways from the WannaCry attacks? The first few that occur to me are:

  1. Very few companies are capable of maintaining a serious security policy.
  2. Neither is the federal government.
  3. The only real solution is active measures.
  4. That would require a complete change in attitude on the part of the federal government.

Consequently, I expect things to get much, much worse but they become even a little better. If ever.

8 comments