Environmental Stewardship and the 90% Rule

I found this passage in apiarist Todd Myers’s RealClearMarkets post on bringing our notions of environmentalism into the 21st century attention-grabbing:

In 2010, Bill Ruckelshaus, the first director of the EPA, described the dramatic changes since the agency was launched. He noted that when the EPA was created, “85% of the problems of water pollution in the country were large, point-source discharges, like municipal sewage-treatment plants or industrial operations.” Today, by way of contrast, 85 percent of remaining pollution comes from “non-point sources,” like runoff from streets, lawns and other distributed sources.

There’s a phenomenon well-known to project managers called the “90% rule”. It can be summarized as 90% of the time and cost in doing anything will be in executing 10% of the project. If Mr. Ruckelshaus’s characterization of the EPA’s mandate is correct, the EPA accomplished that portion of its mandate long ago. Getting beyond that will take much, much more money and be significantly more intrusive than the first 90%. Perhaps cost-benefit analysis is long overdue.

While I found Mr. Myers’s plea for an updated environmentalism intriguing, I’d be happy if we got beyond what I would call “NIMBY environmentalism” or, possibly “SOBBY” (Some Other Bugger’s Back Yard), the belief that as long as it isn’t happening here it isn’t happening at all.

Our European cousins have been very proud of their efforts in conservation and reducing emissions but I can’t help but wonder if most of what they’ve accomplished has been simply due to offshoring their heavy manufacturing to China. The VW emissions scandal certainly suggests that some of their assumptions should be revisited. If their autos weren’t as green as they thought, they can’t be producing the results that have been claimed.

2 comments

Picking and Choosing Infrastructure Projects

At RealClearPolicy Chris Spear provides yet another self-serving post about U. S. infrastructure which, like most, takes the civil engineers’ professional society’s report uncritically:

Our nation’s economy relies on the continuous and efficient movement of goods and people, but the current condition of our nation’s infrastructure puts that at risk. The American Society of Civil Engineers gave America’s infrastructure a D+ on its 2017 report card. Among the recipients of the lowest marks were the nation’s highways, which the report described as “often crowded, frequently in poor condition, chronically underfunded, and are becoming more dangerous.”

As I respond whenever the topic comes up, the ASCE’s report tells us nothing about what’s worth repairing, only what would need to be repaired if you repaired everything.

The nature of our system requires us to pick and choose. We aren’t going to repair everything, build everywhere, or build everything. Among the many projects vying for federal, state, or local dollars, how to decide which are most deserving?

If we’re looking at the present and the inevitable future, I would think we’d give priority to refurbishing our sewer systems. We’ll undoubtedly need them in the future and the ASCE’s report on our combined sewer system isn’t much rosier than their report on our roads.

If we were looking to the future, we’d give priority to the energy grid and data infrastructure. On both we need to face facts. Private power companies just don’t have much interest in improving the national grid. If it is to be improved and if we plan to increase, for example, the number of electric vehicles on the road, it will need to be improved, doing so will require government funding and leadership.

In terms of data infrastructure although broadband usage in the United States is fairly high (87%), the speed of our broadband and its cost are an embarrassment. Broadband speeds over 25 mbps greatly lag behind Japan, South Korea, Sweden, Norway, and most other European countries and our broadband costs are consistently among the highest in the world. Neither of those are likely to improve without government involvement.

The other aspect of identifying spending priorities is just how long will that road you’re building be used? When the The Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956 was enacted, kicking off the present system of interstate highways, we could expect to amortize the expense over the lifetime of the roads. Is that still the case?

If the hype of those promoting autonomous vehicles and the warnings of environmentalists are to be headed, it isn’t. We won’t need more roads in 30 years but fewer.

1 comment

Reforming Medicaid

I really like the three principles that Charles Blahous lays out as a framework for “forging a consensus” on the reform of Medicaid in his post at e21:

  1. Distinguish between problems created by the ACA and those that existed before.
  2. Distinguish between the ACA’s Medicaid eligibility expansion and its elevated federal match rate.
  3. Recognize that the ACA’s elevated match rate is a problem warranting correction.

Read the whole thing for the explanation and significance of those three bullet points.

Of course, to those I would add that the basic underlying problems are that health care costs are rising faster than incomes and that we’re importing workers at the same or higher rate than the rate at which we’re creating jobs. As long as those are the case we’re going to need to subsidize somebody’s health care and the proportion of those somebodies to the population will increase over time.

4 comments

Coincidence?

The world’s greatest authorities on malware, hacking, and cyber-security are the Chinese, the Russians, and the Israelis. Coincidence?

4 comments

Will Discovers Baumol’s Cost Disease

“Baumol’s cost disease” is the phenomenon by which the wages of workers in jobs that have not experienced an increase in productivity increase in response to increases in wages of workers whose jobs have increased in productivity. William Baumol identified the phenomenon and analyzed it fifty years ago. George Will has apparently now discovered it:

Goldberg’s 1962 encounter with Baumol’s disease in the Met’s orchestra initiated thinking that led in 1965 to the National Endowment for the Arts (and, on the Great Society principle of no conceivable claimant left behind, the National Endowment for the Humanities). This elicited Moynihan’s corollary to Baumol’s theory: “Activities with Baumol’s disease migrate to the public sector.”

Moynihan, thinking that it would be “the undoing of modern government” if there was too much migration, worried especially about health care. In 1993, at a health-care hearing before the Senate Finance Committee, Chairman Moynihan received blank looks when he asked three medical deans what they could do about Baumol’s disease. So Moynihan elaborated: “Montefiore Hospital was founded in New York City in the 1880s. At that time, how long did it take for a professor of medicine to make his morning rounds, and how many interns would he take along with him?”

Dean: “Oh, about an hour; say 12 interns.”

Moynihan: “And today?”

Dean: “Got it!”

Two fields that are frequently thought to suffer from the cost disease are health care and education.

Whatever the case in those two fields, I think that Baumol’s original findings may be suspect. He originally studied musicians. I can’t help but think that he was looking at the wrong statistics.

In 1900 the population of the United States was around 76 million and the number of musicians and music teachers was more than 92,000. In 2014 the population of the United States was about 320 million and according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics the number of musicians was around 173,000. In other words although population of the country had increased more than four-fold the number of musicians had less than doubled. Throughout the 19th century and the early part of the 20th century the number of musicians increased with the population. Now that’s obviously not the case.

There are any number of reasons for that not the least of which is electronic reproduction. Today when people listen to music they don’t listen to live music; they listen to recordings.

I haven’t been able to discover what the average musician was paid in 1900. I’m confident that it was lower in real terms than today’s average $24/hour ($24/hour would have been about $.80/hour in 1900 and that wasn’t a bad wage). But here’s my question. Is that due to Baumol’s cost disease or because musicians are relatively scarcer today? How do you disaggregate the two?

0 comments

New York’s Steps Towards Single-Payer

The lower house of the New York legislature has passed a bill authorizing a single-payer plan for the state of New York. Via Modern Healthcare:

New York’s state Assembly passed a single-payer healthcare bill Tuesday that would provide universal coverage statewide. However, the bill faces a difficult path through the Republican-controlled state Senate, and economists have conflicting views on how it would affect spending and taxation.

The bill’s sponsor, Manhattan Democrat Richard Gottfried, said House Republicans’ passage of the American Health Care Act makes it more important that the state Legislature act to preserve affordable healthcare.

“As bad as things are today … what Washington is looking at doing to Medicaid and Medicare and private insurance is going to make it a lot worse,” he said.

The New York Health Act, which previously passed the Assembly three times but stalled in the Senate, would provide no-cost coverage to every New Yorker with no out-of-pocket costs and no network restrictions. It would be paid for through a progressive payroll tax and levies on non-earned income, such as capital gains. A 2015 analysis from Gerald Friedman, professor of economics at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, showed a potential savings of $45 billion in the first year of implementation

There are some estimates that the plan would require a four-fold increase in New York’s state taxes. Given that the plan has been rejected by the New York Senate three times this certainly looks like posturing.

6 comments

Talking About Real Money

Kaiser Health News reports that UnitedHealth, a major managed health care company, is being charged by the Justice Department with fraud in the management of their Medicare Advantage programs:

The Justice Department on Tuesday accused giant insurer UnitedHealth Group of overcharging the federal government by more than $1 billion through its Medicare Advantage plans.

In a 79-page lawsuit filed in Los Angeles, the Justice Department alleged that the insurer made patients appear sicker than they were in order to collect higher Medicare payments than it deserved. The government said it had “conservatively estimated” that the company “knowingly and improperly avoided repaying Medicare” for more than a billion dollars over the course of the decade-long scheme.

A billion here and a billion there and pretty soon you’re starting to talk about real money. $1 billion is not a negligible sum, even for UnitedHealth which accounts for about a third of all of those covered under Medicare Advantage plans.

It also makes me wonder about the other plans.

7 comments

Our Afghan Strategy

I want to commend Jeff Goodson’s article on our Afghan strategy at RealClearDefense to your attention. Here’s the paragraph that I think deserves the most attention:

Third, we can’t just walk out. The likelihood is far too high that Afghanistan would go the way of Iraq after the last administration naively pulled the plug there. That executive decision will cost us more in blood and treasure over the long haul than if we had stayed put, with far less salutary effect. We need a modest but robust long-term military presence in Afghanistan, and now is the time to secure that presence. The worst outcome would be wishing in retrospect that we had built and maintained that capability when we had the chance, and suffering the consequences for not having done so.

although this passage runs a close second:

There is nothing wrong with our existing strategic objective in Afghanistan. Preventing terrorists from using the country as a safe haven to attack the U.S. homeland is as appropriate an America first strategy today as it was when formulated—maybe more so, since twenty of the 61 U.S.-designated foreign terrorist organizations operate in the Af-Pak theatre. That is the largest concentration of terrorist groups anywhere, and neutralizing their ability to support the global jihad is critical to U.S. national security.

There is no wiring diagram for pursuing the Afghan sub-theatre of the war, but the best way to the stated end is what others have already proposed: an enduring partnership between our two countries, and the use of Afghanistan as an enduring platform for counterterrorism operations. These are military and security imperatives.

A negotiated settlement is a fine target to aim for, but it is not something that we should pursue either naively or as the primary objective. First, so long as the Taliban don’t recognize the legitimacy of the Afghan government there’s not much to talk about. Second, there’s not much incentive for the Taliban to negotiate unless the military momentum shifts decisively against them.

Third, it is unlikely that the Taliban would accept any government that does not operate under the Pashtun version of sharia law. Few Afghans are eager to return to stonings and public amputations, however, and kidnapping of their wives, daughters and little boys for use as sex slaves.

Let me address that passage first. I think he misstates our strategic objectives. For the last 15 years we have been pursuing a counter-insurgency strategy in Afghanistan. This:

Preventing terrorists from using the country as a safe haven to attack the U.S. homeland is as appropriate an America first strategy today as it was when formulated

makes it sound as though our strategy were one of counter-terrorism.

The question we need to consider is whether we can maintain a successful counter-terrorism strategy in Afghanistan without a viable Afghan government as a partner. I think the answer is obviously “yes” but it would require a commitment to remain in Afghanistan indefinitely. As would Mr. Goodson’s preferred counter-insurgency strategy.

My preferred strategy is for us to maintain what has been characterized as a “small, lethal force” in Afghanistan with the objectives of counter-terrorism and force protection. Basically, they would be there to prevent Al Qaeda, DAESH, or any other radical Islamist group with global ambitions from mounting a mass terrorist attack on us from Afghanistan. I just wish that our leadership had been preparing us for what we’d need to do for the last 15 years rather than articulating beautiful fantasies.

I think I understand the risks of withdrawal although Afghanistan is not Iraq and, contrary to what Mr. Goodson suggests, the risks are very different between the two cases. What are the risks of changing from a counter-insurgency to a counter-terrorism strategy?

3 comments

Our China Policy

At Strategika Gordon Chang lays out his bearish outline of considerations that should guide our policy with respect to China:

Beijing has, for instance, permitted Chinese entities to transfer semi-processed fissile material and components to North Korea for its nuclear weapons programs. North Korean missiles are full of Chinese parts and parts sourced through Chinese middlemen. China even looks like it gave Pyongyang the plans for a solid-fuel missile.

China’s leaders have permitted North Korean hackers to permanently base themselves on Chinese soil, where they have launched cyberattacks on the U.S., such as the 2014 assault on Sony Pictures Entertainment. Beijing has itself hacked American institutions such as newspapers, foundations, and advocacy groups, and it has taken for commercial purposes somewhere between $300 billion to $500 billion in intellectual property from American corporates each year.

China violated its September 2015 pledge not to militarize artificial islands in the South China Sea; refused to accept the July 2016 arbitration award in Philippines vs. China; threatened freedom of navigation on numerous occasions with dangerous intercepts of American vessels and aircraft; seized a U.S. Navy drone in international water in the South China Sea; and declared without consultation its East China Sea air-defense identification zone. Its warning to a B-1 bomber in March was phrased in such a way as to be tantamount to a claim of sovereignty to much of the East China Sea. Official state media has issued articles that imply all waters inside the infamous “nine-dash line” in the South China Sea are China’s, “blue national soil” as Beijing now calls it.

Beijing also wants to grab land. It regularly sends its troops deep into Indian-controlled territory with the intention of dismembering that country.

China, under the nationalist Xi Jinping, is engaging in increasingly predatory trade practices with the apparent goal of closing off its market to American and other companies. Of special concern are its Made in China 2025 initiative and the new Cybersecurity Law.

These are not random acts, unrepresentative of the regime’s conduct. They form a pattern of deteriorating behavior over a course of years. And these acts flow from similar ones in preceding decades, suggesting the aggressiveness is not just related to any one Chinese leader.

What should U. S. policy with respect to China be? I think I’ve already made my views clear. China has not lived up to its obligations in its international agreements; I don’t think that China is a good global citizen; I don’t think that China can be a good partner. That is particularly aggravated by the zero-sum strategy employed by the Chinese authorities. They clearly believe that it is only possible for China to win if the U. S. loses.

So, what should our policy be?

0 comments

Household Debt Reaches New High


Wall Street 24/7 reports that household debt has now reached levels higher than it was in 2007:

The Federal Reserve Bank of New York has released its Household Debt and Credit Report for the first quarter of 2017. While the economy has been recovering and while things feel better on the business front, there are some very troubling internal metrics when it comes to debt levels and delinquency rates.

According to the report, household debt has now reached an all-time high. Gains in mortgage debt, auto debt and student debt were all cited. This all-time high now stands at $12.73 trillion and was $149 billion higher than in the fourth quarter of 2016. What stands out here is that it is about $50 billion above the previous peak reached back in the third quarter of 2008 — right before the recession kicked into overdrive.

I think it’s fair to say that deleveraging has ended. Indeed, as the graph above illustrates, it ended in 2013. The good news, such as it is, is that bankruptcy notations and credit inquiries are both declining. Although that suggests there is no imminent red flag, it also tells us that all other things being equal we shouldn’t expect strong growth in the near future.

6 comments