Great Expectations

At Bloomberg View David Gluckman and Peter Orszag present their findings about business executives’ expectations of health care reform:

We’ve just finished a study involving 300 senior health-care executives from leading companies in health-care services, pharmaceuticals, biotechnology and medical devices, along with top investors in the field. And it’s clear that they see big changes in the years ahead, driven largely by pricing pressure across the industry.

The pricing pressures, in turn, are expected to drive innovation. Interestingly, in the coming years, changes in how health-care payments are made are expected to be the most important form of innovation, though scientific breakthroughs will also play a critical role. What’s more, these leaders expect health-care companies to engage in new partnerships and collaborations — including with nontraditional competitors in the technology world, such as Google, IBM, Apple and Fitbit.

Most surprisingly, we found strong expectations that value-based payments for medical care will displace the traditional fee-for-service model, transforming the industry over the next five to ten years.

What’s driving these expectations? I can’t find any rational basis for them. They seem to be based on the “it just has to” hypothesis—the belief that because something is obviously out of whack and needs change that change simply must occur and not only occur but occur along certain lines.

Are Democrats calling for an end to fee for services? Are Republicans? Are providers? Are patients? Here’s a telling part of the findings:

About 30 percent of respondents in medical devices and health-care services said nontraditional players will transform the industry over the next few years, but only 14 percent of pharma and biotech respondents agreed.

In other words only one in seven of those on the frontlines in the arenas most at risk for disruption by “nontraditional players” think it will occur. Would anyone care to place a small side wager that they’ll exert substantial efforts to avoid being disrupted?

5 comments

The Real Reasons

At The Conversation Timothy Callaghan outlines three reasons that the United States doesn’t have a national health care system:

  1. The United States is uniquely more individualistic.
  2. Interest group opposition.
  3. It’s hard to us to enact entitlement programs.

and concludes that a national health care system is unlikely in the United States for the foreseeable future:

Its culture is unusually individualistic, favoring personal over government responsibility; lobbyists are particularly active, spending billions to ensure that private insurers maintain their status in the health system; and our institutions are designed in a manner that limits major social policy changes from happening.

As long as the reasons above remain, there is little reason to expect universal coverage in America anytime soon.

Let me suggest some other reasons that a national health care system is unlikely in the United States.

  1. The U. S. is too large and diverse for the idea of a national health care system to gain much traction. No country of 200 million or greater in population has a national health care system (press releases to the contrary notwithstanding).
  2. The U. S. is geographically too large for a national health care system. Canada’s system is administered by the provinces. Russia’s system is national. Do we really want to compare ourselves with Russia?
  3. Path dependency. Other OECD countries adopted their systems a long time ago when health care was much less expensive and represented much less of their economies than it does now. We might have been able to implement a national health care system 60 years ago (when such a system was vehemently rejected by the AMA). Now?
  4. Proponents of reform insist on a national system. That’s the Great White Whale. Try Vermont (or Hawaii) first.

It would be helpful if proponents of reform stopped comparing us with Denmark or Singapore. The latter is a city; the former is the size and population of one of our counties. Such comparisons just make them seem ridiculous. The comparisons should be to Russia, Mexico, Brazil, Indonesia, India, or China.

The reality is that the U. S. is sui generis and systems for it need to be adapted to it and the unique conditions that obtain here.

8 comments

What Goes Around

At the progressive journal Democracy Jonathan Blanks speaks out in praise of the bracero program:

And as my colleague Alex Nowrasteh has written, a large reason we have so many unauthorized immigrants in the first place is that the government shut down programs that allowed people to come and work legally. Among these was the Bracero program that allowed seasonal migration for labor…

as I’ve been saying for years. That we need a guest worker program in the United States is obvious and I can only speculate about why such programs are resisted so vehemently.

However, other than that he’s opposed to Trump’s wall (so am I) and doesn’t like enforcement of existing law, he doesn’t elaborate on what he thinks a “sane immigration policy” would be.

I can tell you what my idea of a sound immigration policy would be: a guest worker program specifically tailored for Mexican workers, strict workplace enforcement of the laws, and requiring employers to pay prevailing wages or higher for workers brought into the country. I also like the idea of a central clearing house that employers would be required to advertise on before being given H-1B visas to bring workers in from outside the country.

4 comments

The Obama Effect

At the Washington Post Kim Soffen and Scott Clement report that Trump’s victory in November was not due to a higher turnout from uneducated white voters as had been speculated:

White non-college-educated people were no more likely to vote in this presidential election than in the previous one. Trump’s victory was not due to a spike in turnout among his base supporters.

But there were significant changes in turnout in other demographics. Significant drops in black and Hispanic turnout in some states may have cost Hillary Clinton some previously blue states.

Turnout among blacks plummeted from 66 percent in 2012 to 59 percent in 2016 — similar to where it was when John Kerry was on the ballot. No other racial group saw such a substantial change between the elections.

When you break those numbers down further, a peculiar trend emerges: White people without college degrees turned out at just under 58 percent, less than a percentage point higher than in 2012.

In other words the reason that Obama won in 2008 and 2012 was due to the high black turnout in those election years. This year Obama wasn’t on the ballot and that black vote did’t materialize.

The effect was apparently particularly pronounced in Midwestern states:

The other states that flipped between the elections saw no meaningful change in white non-college-educated turnout. For many of them, what made the difference was the drop in black or Hispanic turnout. In Ohio, where Clinton lost by 8.6 points and Obama won by 2, black turnout dropped from 72 to 65 percent.

And in Michigan, where Clinton lost by a mere 0.3 percent and Obama won by 9, Hispanic turnout may have dropped by half, according to Census Bureau estimates. That number has a significant margin of error —14 points — but the drop is nonetheless significant.

I’m not sure what to make of those results but they can’t be comforting to Democrats. Will another black candidates be able to garner the support among blacks that Obama did? Will a black vice presidential candidate be able to supply the magic?

I also wonder if there’s been a sort of reverse Great Migration. Are all of those expected black voters in Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin still there?

5 comments

Hitchcock’s Actresses

Last week I asked about Hitchcock’s actors. What about the actresses in Hitchcock movies? No actress appeared as a lead in more than two of Hitchcock’s movies.* Four were the lead actresses in two of his movies each. Who were they? Highlight the white space below to reveal the answer.

Madeleine Carroll (The 39 Steps and The Secret Agent)
Ingrid Bergman (Spellbound and Notorious)
Grace Kelly* (To Catch a Thief and Rear Window)
Tippi Hedren (The Birds and Marnie)

Update

*In comments I was corrected. Grace Kelly did, indeed, star in three of Hitchock’s pictures, the only actress so distinguished: Dial M for Murder, To Catch a Thief, and Rear Window.

2 comments

Without Looking

Without looking it up, who wrote “I Will Always Love You” and for whom was it written? If you highlight the blank area below it will reveal the answer.

Dolly Parton wrote it for her mentor (and lover) Porter Wagoner when she left him to pursue her own solo career.

This post was prompted by this Washington Post article. Harrumph.

1 comment

How to Solve Problems

As I read Elizabeth Bartel’s post at the RAND Blog on how to deter cyber-attacks on non-government computers:

Over the years, a great deal of attention has been paid to gaining security in cyberspace to prevent unauthorized access to critical infrastructure like those that control electrical grids and financial systems, and military networks. In recent years a new category of threat has emerged: the cyber-theft and subsequent public release of large troves of private communications, personal documents and other data.

This category of incident includes the release of government data by inside actors such as Chelsea Manning and Edward Snowden. However, hacks of the Democratic National Committee and John Podesta, a Democratic party strategist, illustrate that the risk goes beyond the theft of government data to include information that has the potential to harm individuals or threaten the proper functioning of government. Because the federal government depends on proxies such as contractors, non-profit organizations, and local governments to administer so many public functions, securing information that could harm the government — but is not on government-secured systems — may require a different approach.

I sincerely wished that she had greater familiarity with proven strategies for solving problems and that the RAND Blog had a comments section. The proven strategy is that you start by addressing the biggest facets of the problem first. Even fractional solutions of the biggest facets can produce big payoffs while even if you solve 100% of something that’s only 10% of the problem you’ve only solved 10% of the problem and you can never solve 100% of anything.

To give you some idea of how to approach solving the problem of computer attacks I’ll return you to a mesmerizing map I’ve posted on before. Look at it (and the associated data) for five minutes and, if you can avoid an epileptic seizure, you’ll have a pretty good idea of what needs to be done.

4 comments

States That Have Won and Lost

At Bloomberg View Justin Fox produces six bar charts that illustrate which states have prospered the most over the last year, which the least, which states have prospered the most since 2009, which the least, and which states have prospered the most since 2000 and which the least. Just two states appear on all three “the most” graphs: California and Utah. Three states appear on all three “the least” graphs: Louisiana, Mississippi, and West Virginia.

Searching for commonalities among winners or losers is tough. California and Utah are both west of the Mississippi but so is Louisiana. The other things that I can see that distinguish California and Utah from the rest of the United States is that both have mountains and both have percentages of black population far below the national average (California 6%, Utah 2%). However, West Virginia has mountains and just 4% black population. Go figure.

While high educational attainment doesn’t seem to be much of a factor among the states in becoming a winner, low educational attainment does link Louisiana, Mississippi, and West Virginia as does all being Red States. California is a reliably Blue State while Utah is reliably Red.

Guess which state has had the worst millennium to date? You hardly have to ask. Illinois.

0 comments

Scarcity and Star Trek Economics

You might be amused at the post at RealClearFuture by Robert Tracinski analyzing the economics of Star Trek:

You hear this sort of thing quite a lot, particularly from advocates of the basic income, who somehow think that the world of “Star Trek economics,” where robots will do all of the work for us (despite the fact that there are hardly any actual robots in the Star Trek franchise), is just around the corner.

The obvious error is in projecting the viability of a whole economic system based on a fictional technology that is nowhere near to being available. The less obvious error is the misuse of the term “scarcity.” Saadia and other boosters of this school of economic futurism use “scarcity” to mean something like “poverty”: the inability to afford certain basic necessities of life. So they look forward to a society that will be so technologically advanced that such poverty is unnecessary. It will be a “post-scarcity” economy.

But this is not what “scarcity” means in economics. “Scarcity” means the existence of an economic good in a finite, limited quantity. This is pretty basic economics and can be figured out in about five second on Google. As the Wikipedia entry for “scarcity” explains, “The notion of scarcity is that there is never enough…to satisfy all conceivable human wants, even at advanced states of human technology.” Make a note of that phrase, “all conceivable human wants.” I’ll return to that later.

Read the whole thing.

What I believe is disturbing to some people about the World According to Star Trek is that it’s not minarchist. Most people, at least here in the United States, are woefully ignorant about history, political philosophy, and economics and tend to conflate things like liberal democracy, the market system, capitalism, etc. into a single lump. They ought to read some early 20th century or Soviet science fiction. Before Robert Heinlein most science fiction assumed socialism.

6 comments

Doomed to Repeat It

At the American Conservative Daniel L. Davis takes note of an exchange between Gen. John Nicholson and South Carolina Sen. Lindsey Graham in testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee. Read the exchange, quoted in the linked piece, but here is how Mr. Davis summarizes it:

The senator asked and the general confirmed that in order to win, the U.S. had to “destroy” al-Qaeda, the Islamic State, and have the Afghan government be “on a trajectory” toward a system of rule of law. Even if we do destroy al-Qaeda, ISIS, and any other terrorist groups that arise in the region, the Afghan government is not headed toward effective governance. In other words, this exchange lays the groundwork for the U.S. military to, literally, be made the Armed Forces of the Afghan state forever.

The Trump Administration is on the way to becoming the third consecutive presidential administration to misunderstand an old engineering wisecrack: “Don’t force it. Use a bigger hammer!” That is intended as sarcasm not as prescriptive.

We cannot achieve at least one of the objectives laid out by Gen. Nicholson—a competent, self-sufficient Afghan government—at any time in the foreseeable future regardless of the amount of force applied. We can’t even accomplish that here.

7 comments