The Worst? Not Nearly

If Jamie Fly thinks that what American presidents have done since 9/11 are “the worst impulses of the electorate”:

Americans look to their leaders, especially their presidents, to explain the challenges the United States faces on the world stage. Instead of providing this leadership, presidents of both parties have played to the worst impulses of the electorate, telling them that they were correct to believe that America needed to refocus on problems at home and dismissing the terrorist threat as minimal. When we did intervene militarily, Americans were told it would be quick, painless, and easy or they weren’t told at all because of the deniability of the military and intelligence tools used in an attempt to avoid public discussion of the fact that we were still at war.

as expressed in his Medium article, either he doesn’t get out much or his notions of good and evil are drastically different from mine. You don’t need to look too hard to find people who want to engage in an exterminatory, genocidal campaign against the people of the Middle East and North Africa. Overthrowing the government of Iraq or conniving at the overthrow of Qaddafi pale in comparison.

What has been done instead has been very bad but neither the worst nor the impulses of the electorate. I think the impulses of the electorate have been pulling to two contradictory directions. One has been in the direction of the use of overwhelming and largely indiscriminate force and the other has been in the direction of extricating ourselves from the Middle East and North Africa completely.

My explanation is different. Presidents have been responding to the median impulses of their donors and closest advisors. Those have resulted in ineffectual, futile, half-hearted feints in one direction or another but not an anti-terror strategy.

0 comments

The Hollowing of California

I don’t think that Francis Wilkinson is reading the statistics correctly in his Bloomberg piece on Californians moving to Texas:

According to a Sacramento Bee review of Census data, “Every year from 2000 through 2015, more people left California than moved in from other states.”

The departures are, in some broad sense, linked to a failure of liberalism. “The people leaving tend to be relatively poor, and many lack college degrees,” the Bee reported. “Move higher up the income spectrum, and slightly more people are coming than going.”

In other words, while California is a very nice place to be rich, and is attracting more affluent people as a result, it’s hard to get by there if you’re poor or working class, especially in California’s marquee cities.

What I think is happening is that those with from one standard deviation below median income to one standard deviation above median income, i.e. from family incomes of about $40,000 to family incomes of about $80,000, particularly the native born, are leaving California in large numbers and being replaced by immigrants from the extreme ends of the income distribution. If you think those leaving are the poor, you’ve been living in an affluent neighborhood too long.

When he was defeated in his bid for re-election to the U. S. Congress, the frontiersman (and general character) Davy Crockett famously declaimed “You can all go to hell. I’m going to Texas.” I think that’s pretty much what’s happening in California now.

The Golden State is in the midst of a great experiment to determine whether a state can build a viable economy based on the affluent, the poor, and public retirees. I wish them all the luck in the world but I don’t think it’s a model open to most other states and not to Illinois in particular.

4 comments

Anything But Basic

At Reason, mind you, Reason Jesse Walker traces the idea of a universal basic income not just back to Huey Long but all the way back 250 years to Tom Paine, claiming that a UBI may be the only policy on which Tom Paine, Huey Long, Milton Friedman, Timothy Leary, and Sam Altman could agree. In my view a UBI satisfies everything an income provides except the most basic: independence, a strengthening of non-state institutions, and providing meaning for one’s life.

If you think the mortality rate due to opioid abuse today is appalling, implement a UBI and you’ll learn what appalling is.

1 comment

Heed The Prince

At The American Conservative, mind you, The American Conservative Bert Peterson advocates a bizarre sort of universal medical benefit. I can’t excerpt it so you’ll need to read it in full. It hinges on medical debt and estates and is intended to replace all other forms of medical benefits including both Medicaid and Medicare.

I think the problems with his proposal are grave. Decades may pass between the point at which a medical debt is incurred and the death of the debtor. How will providers operate in the interval? Will they be forced to finance their expenditures, using debt as collateral?

These debts are likely to become confiscatory over time. I think he should heed Macchiavelli’s advice from The Prince:

But when it is necessary for him to proceed against the life of someone, he must do it on proper justification and for manifest cause, but above all things he must keep his hands off the property of others, because men more quickly forget the death of their father than the loss of their patrimony.

or, in other words, his calculations about harm are wrong.

1 comment

Out of the Mouths of Banks

I don’t usually turn to the annual reports of banks for policy advice but this report from M&T Bank in upstate New York which primarily serves the Mid-Atlantic region is exceptional. On fiscal policy:

Rather than spending to promote growth, the government instead enacted legislation and regulation that in practice restricted it—effectively, a form of negative fiscal policy. Put forth in the name of preventing a recurrence of the circumstances that led to the financial crisis, the plethora of new regulations intended to limit taxpayer risk have ultimately proved a drag on growth. Regulation took many shapes and forms across all sectors of the economy, affecting not only the financial sector but also industries as diverse as energy, healthcare, housing, and construction. Businesses were no longer willing or able to take the prudent risks that even moderate growth expectations demand.

With the benefit of hindsight, it appears the economy in recent years has fallen out of balance—overly reliant on monetary policy not accompanied by traditional fiscal stimulus. Policies designed to benefit the majority have perversely only benefited a few. The impacts of these decisions or non-decisions are real. In particular, the middle class and small businesses are losing ground. So, too, are their communities. The details that follow illuminate trends that should be of concern to all.

“Recent years”, presumably refers to 2012 through 2016 since from 2007 through 2011 government spending assumed a percentage of total GDP unprecedented other than at the height of World War II.

The problems with fiscal stimulus were multiple. Changes in our economy rendered it much less effective and more concentrated than it had been in the past because of our greater reliance on imports. Fiscal stimulus was political to an unprecedented degree and there was relatively little actual additional spending—spending at the federal level was offset at the state and local levels.

Monetary policy posed problems, too:

Policymakers were compelled to reduce rates time and again, ultimately reaching a practical limit as short-term rates approached zero, the lowest level ever in the U.S., and remained there for more than seven years. The march into uncharted territory continued. To address the crisis and its aftermath, the Federal Reserve directly infused cash into the economy by purchasing more than $3 trillion of securities, equivalent to nearly a year of federal government spending. This unparalleled use of monetary policy helped to avert a depression.

[…]

This extended period of ultra-low interest rates no longer benefits the average U.S. household. The majority of the wealth of the typical M&T customer, like that of most Americans, takes the form of equity in their homes, retirement savings, bank deposits and, to a lesser extent, stock market investments. Low rates initially provided middle class households with relief both by lowering monthly mortgage payments and supporting a recovery in home values. However, the investments of these same families have suffered. Indeed, many middle class families, frightened by the precipitous market decline of 2008, responded by pulling out of the market. Only half of these households today hold any stocks or mutual fund shares; before the crisis, fully 72% did so. Crucially, without stocks and the growth in value and dividends they can provide, most households must rely on interest from their investments to save for college, a down payment on a home, or to prepare for and navigate retirement. It is here that they have felt the sting of near-zero interest rates.

Interest income for households has declined sharply in the aggregate. In 2014, it had, compared to 2005, fallen by some $64 billion. This disproportionately affected households with an income less than $100,000; their interest income declined by $44 billion, or 68% of the total decrease for all households. There are, to be sure, some who can take such a drop in stride—those, for instance, fortunate enough to hold dividend-paying stocks. Dividend income in 2014 was, in fact, $162 billion higher than it had been in 2005. But 95% of that increase in dividend income has accrued to households whose income was greater than $100,000. Indeed, only $9 billion of the $162 billion increase in total dividend income has found its way to households with annual earnings under $100,000—not enough to offset the lost interest income.

Investments managed on behalf of the typical American family are not immune to these economic trends. At the heart of the issue is the declining rate of return on investments—particularly secure investments like bonds. The practical implications for the alternatives through which typical households preserve and grow wealth, such as insurance, retirement accounts, and pensions, are troubling.

Indicative of what has happened in the marketplace, insurers that have traditionally invested premiums in safe, long-term instruments such as government securities and high-quality corporate bonds have come under pressure. The average yield on 10-year U.S. Treasury bonds since 2010 has, unfortunately, declined to a level 274 basis points, or 53%, below the 30-year average. Insurers ultimately have limited options to offset sustained low yields on their investments. Should rates remain low, it will eventually be necessary to raise prices or invest in assets that offer higher returns but also carry higher risk. Neither outcome would benefit middle class families.

Pension plans sponsored by employers, long a pillar of retirement savings for many workers, face similar pressures. Low rates that pension funds earn on investments mean either that businesses and governments must set aside more to ensure future benefits, or put those benefits at risk by under-funding them. The trend is disconcerting. Although, at the end of 2007, corporate pension plans showed a modest surplus, they had, by the end of 2016, developed a $408 billion deficit. Not even public sector employees can remain confident in the health of their pension plans, as some major state pension funds reduce their estimated rates of return and contemplate reductions in benefits. To offset the impact of low returns and still deliver on their promises to consumers, investment professionals are increasingly turning to alternative investments such as hedge funds and private equity that offer the potential for higher returns, but come with more risk.

In other words if the Fed’s policies had been specifically designed to aggravate income inequality it could hardly have been more effective. In summary:

No wage growth. No investment earnings growth. No wonder families are stretched and stressed. We should hardly be surprised, then, to see a sharply increased rate of savings—fully 1.5 percentage points higher than that in 2000-2004. Accompanied by lower interest income, this has led middle class families to spend less, dampening economic growth. Simple math suggests that a 1.5 percentage point increase in the savings rate equated to nearly $200 billion in consumer spending—spending that did not occur as families instead saved more to make up for their lost income. Monetary policy was intended to act as an accelerant for an economy in recession, and did in fact accomplish that goal early on; however, its benefits have waned, if not reversed, over time.

As James Freeman notes at the Wall Street Journal, that’s about as far as you need to look to figure out why Trump won in the states he did.

4 comments

Circling the Drain

I think I’ve mentioned before that I’m on an email mailing list for requests for bid for the state of Illinois. I’ve noticed a trend over the last 18 months or so.

At first a few of the RFB were cancelled because no one registered to attend the hearing required under state law. Then a quarter of them were cancelled. Then half.

Today alone I’ve received at least 30 notifications of cancellation. That’s new since the state legislature’s latest refusal to enact a budget.

A lot of these RFBs are for hardware maintenance and software licensing and support. Pretty quickly the state is going to be in real trouble, unable to function.

5 comments

Drug Deaths in 2016

In comments yesterday I was made aware of this New York Times article on the striking surge in drug overdose deaths in 2016:

AKRON, Ohio — Drug overdose deaths in 2016 most likely exceeded 59,000, the largest annual jump ever recorded in the United States, according to preliminary data compiled by The New York Times.

The death count is the latest consequence of an escalating public health crisis: opioid addiction, now made more deadly by an influx of illicitly manufactured fentanyl and similar drugs. Drug overdoses are now the leading cause of death among Americans under 50.

The article is pretty horrifying. I recommend you read it in full to get an idea of the scope of the problem.

I don’t know whether the incidence of opioid addiction is rising dramatically (the available data seems to suggest tha the number of deaths due to overdose are rising a lot faster than the rate of use) but it appears that a lot of the deaths due to overdose are a consequence of fentanyl, an opioid more than three orders of magnitude more potent than morphine. Fentanyl is being sold as other, more expensive but less potent drugs, e.g. OxyContin, Xanax, even cocaine. Abusers may think they’re taking these other drugs when they’re actually taking the more deadly fentanyl.

Fentanyl is not something that can be made by a casual cook. My reading on its synthesis suggests that it requires a pretty fair level of sophistication and a lot of the fentanyl hitting the streets is coming into this country from China.

The editors of the Washington Post have come out in support of a lawsuit by the state of Ohio against pharmaceutical manufacturers for their role in the increase in opioid abuse:

OHIO ATTORNEY GENERAL Mike DeWine filed a lawsuit against five leading opioid painkiller manufacturers May 31, accusing them of misleadingly minimizing the real addiction risks associated with the powerful pills, thus triggering the nationwide epidemic of opioid addiction and death. Mr. DeWine brought his case in an Ohio state court, choosing as his venue the courthouse in Chillicothe, a small city whose struggle with the addiction crisis was the subject of a heartbreaking report by The Post’s Joel Achenbach.

This suit joins similar efforts against the drug companies filed by jurisdictions as different as Everett, Wash., which has charged Purdue Pharma with failing to blow the whistle on massive diversion of its product to that city’s black market, and the Cherokee Nation, which is suing pharmacy chains and their wholesale suppliers on similar allegations. We hasten to add that all of the companies accused, Purdue Pharma included, deny any wrongdoing, and argue that they work hard to comply with federal regulations and prevent the improper use of their products. It is also true that, even though the opioid lawsuits are often compared to the litigation that ultimately held Big Tobacco accountable, prescription opioids have legitimate health uses, unlike cigarettes.

The fact remains, however, that more than 183,000 people have died in the United States from overdoses related to prescription opioids between 1999 and 2015, according to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Such deaths were rare prior to the 1990s, when prescription opioids became commonly prescribed for non-cancer pain — at the urging of the pharmaceutical industry’s marketing teams. Mr. DeWine’s lawsuit and others like it might not be equivalent to the tobacco lawsuits, legally or morally, but they express widespread and understandable public feeling. They amount to a cri de coeur in the courtroom.

I understand the concern but this suit makes me nervous. It seems to me that physicians are a much more proximate source of the problem than pharmaceutical companies. As many as 75% of opioid abusers begin as users of prescription painkillers.

If this suit against pharmaceutical companies prevails, can a suit against medical doctors and/or hospitals be far behind?

11 comments

Tips on Ticks

As we enter tick season USA Today has some good tips on the nasty things:

Tick season is officially here.

A recent population boom of white-footed mice has led to an increase in ticks in the Northeast, which feed on mice blood and can acquire the bacteria that cause Lyme disease. In areas where ticks are rampant, like in the Northeast, upper Midwest and Mid-Atlantic, it’s important to be on the lookout for ticks and know how to treat a tick bite.

If you’ve been told ticks jump off of trees and onto your body, and that the best way to remove a tick is burning it off, it’s time to read up.

When it comes to ticks, there are many common myths about how to treat tick bites and remove them. We talked to Durland Fish, a Yale school of health professor of epidemiology and Kevin R. Macaluso, professor at the Louisiana State University school of veterinary medicine, about debunking tick myths.

I can testify from personal experience that while ticks may not jump they can and most certainly do drop from trees.

I probably have a lot more intimate experience with ticks than most of you. I’ve told this story before but it bears repeating. When I was a kid, probably around 7, I waded up to my hips in a stream in rural Missouri just after a herd of cows had crossed the stream. I emerged from the water with hundreds of ticks attached to me from the waist down. Despite removal both by my mom and our pediatrician within a few days I had dozens of boils on my back, my butt, and in my groin. I may still have lingering health effects from my tick bites—it’s possible that I contracted some tick-borne disease those many years ago that resulted in the chronic pain condition I have now.

2 comments

Hacking, Leaking, and Russian Interference

I find the report of attempted Russian hacking of voting machines a lot more concerning than phishing attacks against the DNC. From NBC News:

Barely an hour after a news organization published an article about a Top Secret National Security Agency document on Russian hacking, the Justice Department announced charges against a 25-year-old government contractor who a senior federal official says was the leaker of the document.

The May 5, 2017 intelligence document published by The Intercept, an online news organization, describes new details about Russian efforts to hack voting systems in the U.S a week prior to the 2016 presidential election. While the document doesn’t say the hacking changed any votes, it “raises the possibility that Russian hacking may have breached at least some elements of the voting system, with disconcertingly uncertain results.”

I’m not linking to the “news organization” because I think that they acted improperly in publishing the story.

Note that there are multiple crimes here. The hacking was a crime and, if the Russian government was indeed involved, that should have consequences. I think that interference in the electoral process is wrong regardless of who does it, the Russians or us.

But the leaking, too, was a crime and that shouldn’t be ignored. Passionate indignation is no excuse for criminal wrongdoing.

2 comments

Peter Sallis, 1921-2017

Peter Sallis, who voiced Wallace in the stop animation Wallace and Gromit animated films and played Norman Clegg in the very long-running BBC comedy series, The Last of the Summer Wine, has died. From the Hollywood Reporter:

Peter Sallis, a much-loved face on British TV and known internationally as the voice of Wallace in the Wallace & Gromit animated films, has died. He was 96.

The actor’s agent announced the news Monday, saying Sallis had died peacefully with his family by his side on June 2.

In the U.K., Sallis was known for decades as the flat-capped and mild-mannered Norman Clegg from the long-running comedy series Last of the Summer Wine. He starred on the show from its very first episode in 1973 right up until its end in 2010, the only actor to appear in all 295 episodes.

But it was his vocal work as Wallace in Nick Park’s award-winning animated films that gave him a global legacy.

The Sun adds a little color to the story of how the first Wallace and Gromit film, “A Grand Day Out” came to be:

In 1983, a student, Park, wrote to Sallis asking him to be the voice of a clay character called Wallace.

The actor agreed to do it in exchange for a £50 fee to his favourite charity.

But it was not until 1989 that the first Wallace and Gromit film, A Grand Day Out, finally reached the screen.

The short film was nominated for an Oscar.

Its follow-ups The Wrong Trousers (1993) and A Close Shave (1995) were Oscar winners.

Each of the films won a Bafta.

Wallace and Gromit’s first feature-length movie, The Curse Of The Were-Rabbit, was released in 2005 and became a box office hit on both sides of the Atlantic.

It also earned him the Annie Award for Best Voice Acting in an Animated Feature Production.

I thought that this tweet by Disney cartoonist Louie del Carmen was touching:

3 comments