Do It Yourself Analysis of Foreign Elections

So, what about the British elections? Their being foreign elections and my not knowing anything about the issues or background, I don’t have much to say about them. I welcome opinions from others, however.

The only comment I can make is that the Brits seem to be viewing all of the major parties as “the establishment” these days.

0 comments

The Real Problem

Writing at Bloomberg View economist Tyler Cowen explains why taxing the rich won’t make the poor much better off:

When we make personal decisions, we usually compare a choice to the best possible alternative, not the worst. Imagine if you suggested to your spouse that you go out to the movies, and your spouse asked why that might be a good idea. It wouldn’t be much of an answer to say that the movie is better than the very worst show on television at home. Rather you should focus on comparing the movie to the next best thing you might do, like watching your favorite TV show or going to a new restaurant you want to try.

The upshot is that we should compare anti-poverty programs to other anti-poverty programs, and favor only the prioritized ones. But just how much of a priority does a program need to be?

One way to proceed is to ask: If we expand some programs, what is the most likely political response? It could be either lower spending in some other program or, in fact, raising taxes on the wealthy. But the evidence on the “fiscal gap” — the space between what the government owes and what it collects — suggests that the opportunity cost of expanding one transfer program is likely some government spending elsewhere, rather than expensive handbags for the wealthy.

My skepticism has slightly different grounds. Rather than comparing the status quo with imaginary programs we should be comparing likely outcomes with today’s reality.

The largest single transfer program, one that transfers money from taxpayers to beneficiaries, is SSRI, Social Security, and it’s slightly regressive, i.e. although the poor get money from it they get slightly less back from Social Security than they’ve put in. Practically all of the other federal programs transfer money from the rich to the merely merely well-to-do, the slightly less rich. Notionally, it’s on behalf of the poor but somehow the well-to-do receive their checks regardless of the actual benefits to the poor.

Consequently, with a confidence founded in experience we can say that any expansion of federal programs is likely at best to be slightly regressive and at worst to give the merely rich a leg up on the extremely rich. But, hey, it’s all good as long as it keep bureaucrats in office, amiright?

0 comments

The Surreal World

I don’t have anything substantial to say about James Comey’s testimony yesterday. The entire thing is surreal. Lately Scott Adams has has been saying that Trump’s supporters and detractors are running different movies in their minds and I think that’s an apt metaphor. Everybody things that they, their side, their guy is Henry Fonda or Jimmy Stewart when they’re actually Claude Rains or Edward Arnold. What’s a more modern comparison? They all think they’re Tom Hanks when they’re actually Ian McDiarmid.

To my ear we learned absolutely nothing yesterday. Donald Trump is an arrogant jerk who doesn’t understand the office of president. James Comey is self-serving. We knew all of that before.

Despite all of the reaction pieces one way or another at this point I think that the odds that Donald Trump is still in the Oval Office in a year are higher than the odds that James Comey is not in jail. The answer is that it still remains the case that although Trump acted improperly and probably foolishly he didn’t act illegally but James Comey did. Some twisting of case law may clear Comey but that will be bad for all of us—a return to the FBI of J. Edgar Hoover.

1 comment

The Future of Work

In a good article at Reason on technological unemployment I found an interesting tidbit:

You can think of this another way: The average American worker today would only have to work 17 weeks per year to earn the income his counterpart brought in 100 years ago, according to Autor’s calculations—the equivalent of about 10 hours of work per week. Most people prefer to work more, of course, so they can afford to enjoy the profusion of new products and services that modern technology makes available, including refrigerators, air conditioners, next-day delivery, smartphones, air travel, video games, restaurant meals, antibiotics, year-round access to fresh fruits and vegetables, the internet, and so forth.

But if technologically fueled productivity improvements boost job growth, why are U.S. manufacturing jobs in decline? In a new study published in April, Bessen finds that as markets mature, comparatively small changes in the price of a product do not call forth a compensating increase in consumer demand. Thus, further productivity gains bring reduced employment in relatively mature industries such as textiles, steel, and automobile manufacturing. Over the past 20 years, U.S. manufacturing output increased by 40 percent while the number of Americans working in manufacturing dropped from 17.3 million in 1997 to 12.3 million now. On the other hand, Bessen projects that the ongoing automation and computerization of the nonmanufacturing sector will increase demand for all sorts of new services. In fact, he forecasts that in service industries, “faster technical change will…create faster employment growth.”

One of the implications of that is that the greater your efforts to prop up “mature markets” the more you will suppress the growth of new jobs.

Do you remember that picture of my nephews and nieces I posted a while ago? Most of them have jobs that didn’t exist 25 years ago and I believe that only one or two of them have jobs that existed a century ago.

0 comments

Over-Utilization Isn’t the Problem

There’s a simple lesson that I learned in one of my econ courses, now more than 50 years ago. In the absence of increases in productivity wage increases require an increase in prices. I do not believe that physician Marty Makary has ever taken an economics course. In his post at RealClearHealth he calls for a reduction in excessive treatment in favor of a more “patient-centered” approach and in the interests of reducing spending:

The trend to recognize over-treatment led my Johns Hopkins colleagues and I to conduct a study of approximately 2,000 physicians nationwide asking them how often is medical care unnecessary (excluding the respondent’s own practice)? The result—doctors say that 15-30 percent of everything done in medicine is unnecessary, a finding consistent with that of a 2012 Institute of Medicine report that stated that 30 percent of health care spending ($750 billion) is spent on things that do not make us healthier.

His suggestions are benign but, unless providers can be persuaded that they should not expect their pay to rise, it won’t reduce costs. Health care is notoriously lacking in increases in productivity and Baumol’s cost disease will inevitably lead to higher costs whether treatment is necessary or not.

7 comments

Still Too Big to Fail

At RealClearMarkets finance prof Sanjai Bhagat, noting that despite Dodd-Frank many large banks are still simultaneously vulnerable and too big to be allowed to fail, advises:

Our bank capital proposal has two components. First, bank capital should be calibrated to the ratio of tangible common equity to total assets (i.e., to total assets independent of risk) not the risk-weighted capital approach that is at the core of Basel. Second, bank capital should be at least 20% of total assets. Also, total assets should include both on-balance sheet and off-balance sheet items; this would mitigate concerns regarding business lending spilling over to the shadow banking sector.

Greater equity financing of banks coupled with the aforementioned compensation structure for bank managers and directors will drastically diminish the likelihood of a bank falling into financial distress; this will effectively address the too-big-to-fail problem. Our market-based solution (greater bank equity, and reforming bank executive and director incentive compensation) will accomplish Dodd-Frank’s worthy objectives without the need for much of the pursuant regulations. Our bank capital reform is also consistent with the essence of the CHOICE Act regarding bank equity capital.

Back in the early days of the financial crisis, I suggested that our problem was that everyone was pursuing the incentives they had. As long as you keep the incentives in place, you’ve changed nothing. All of the same incentives are still in place.

1 comment

How Not to Win Votes

At Washington Monthly Martin Longman gives advice very much along the lines I’ve been giving. After taking note of an article advising Democrats to offer white working people “palliative care” rather than the opportunity to thrive, he writes:

But it’s not actually a misinterpretation of political self-interest that appalls me in this case. It’s the idea that the modern left can self-define itself in a way that leaves out any hard-pressed community. I believe Anti-Monopoly policy can bring economic vitality back to these communities and that it is simply irresponsible to tell them that their communities are doomed without having made a real effort to save them. If I lived in a culturally working class county, it would be as clear as day to me that the left, as currently comprised, has no plan for me. I completely understand why the Democrats have cratered in county after county after county in this country. We like to tell them that they’re voting against their self-interest, but how is it in their self-interest to latch onto a party that thinks they’re beyond help?

I’m not saying the whole Democratic Party feels this way, but the default position among a lot of progressives since the election has been that to even talk about these folks is to pander to their racism and dilute the party’s commitment to civil rights, women’s rights, gay rights, and the environment. If we want to draw up our battle lines like that, then they sure as shit are going to take the hint.

It is a question of priorities. As long as searching for heretics maintains a higher priority than looking for allies, you are more likely to find the former than the latter. Structural considerations and simple mathematics dictates that getting out the base isn’t enough.

5 comments

Older Than You Think

Homo sapiens fossils found in Morocco demonstrate that our species is older than had been thought, reports the New York Times:

Dating back roughly 300,000 years, the bones indicate that mankind evolved earlier than had been known, experts say, and open a new window on our origins.

The fossils also show that early Homo sapiens had faces much like our own, although their brains differed in fundamental ways.

Until now, the oldest fossils of our species, found in Ethiopia, dated back just 195,000 years. The new fossils suggest our species evolved across Africa.

“We did not evolve from a single cradle of mankind somewhere in East Africa,” said Phillipp Gunz, a paleoanthropologist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, and a co-author of two new studies on the fossils, published in the journal Nature.

My hypothesis about the development of our species looks better with each of these new discoveries.

3 comments

The Brave New World of Virtual Communities

In a piece at The Federalist the writer tells a sad, lonely story:

Let me tell you about my Southern California neighborhood. I have lived in this one for 22 years. I don’t know anyone, but it’s not for lack of trying. Each time a new neighbor moves in I bake a loaf of bread and take it to them. They thank me at the door and then close it. That is the last I see of them other than when they go to their cars.

One neighbor was pregnant and her husband was employed, so I gave her my phone number just in case she needed anything. She thanked me and didn’t give me her number. We spoke over the fence occasionally, but not in any way that would turn us into buddies or even casual friends. They moved.

Our newest neighbors dropped a card on our front porch before their bread was baked to tell us their names and gave us their phone number. I still have it four years later. I baked the bread and the mister thanked me at the door. I have never met the Mrs. in person.

I hosted a coffee klatch and made up fliers and put them on the 12 nearest homes. I got donuts, cut up fruit, and made coffee and tea. Six people came, drank the tea, and no one touched the donuts or fruit. They chatted about who all used to live here in this neighborhood over the years, said thank you and left. No one asked a single question of me. I have never been to their homes or had a conversation with any of them since.

By way of comparison let me tell you about my Chicago neighborhood. In my neighborhood we know each other, know each other’s children’s names, and care about each other. We exchange Christmas cookies. We hold block parties. On occasion we exchange the keys to each other’s homes. We watch each other’s homes when someone goes out of town. We shovel each other’s walks when it snows. We share the produce from our gardens. We talk with each other over our backyard fences or sitting on the stoops in front of our houses or when walking our dogs.

Maybe what the author of that article has experienced is the well-documented collapse of community in the United States chronicled in Bowling Alone. But I think there may be something else at work as well.

We’re choosing our communities differently than we used to. It’s far less common that we’ll have a geographically-based community like a neighborhood or the things that go along with that like block clubs. We’re also less likely to form communities around our work. There are fewer company bowling leagues or baseball teams than there used to be. Bowling leagues and baseball teams aren’t being replaced by company videogame groups or cosplay clubs or something else more 21st century.

Our communities are much more likely to be virtual ones—our Facebook friends or people on Pinterest or what have you—or based on other affinities, e.g. shared interests like canine agility or collecting stamps or some other interest. It will be different than the communities of the past and I don’t know what the implications will be. It may be cold and lonely as the author of the piece believes. I don’t think it is reversible.

4 comments

In Common With Iran

As of today as reported in the Washington Post France and the United Kingdom have something quite significant in common with Iran—all are being attacked by Sunni Islamist terrorists:

Gunmen stormed two major sites in Iran’s capital Wednesday, killing at least 12 people in gunfire and suicide blasts in parliament and at the revered tomb of the nation’s Islamic revolutionary leader. The Islamic State claimed responsibility for the Tehran attacks, which would mark the group’s first major strikes in Iran.

The twin attacks — coming in the middle of the Islamic holy month of Ramadan — also appeared calculated for maximum shock among Iranians.

Parliament is widely respected as a voice on domestic policies even as the supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has the final word on most international and security issues. The vast shrine complex of Khamenei’s predecessor, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, is a centerpiece of homage to the 1979 Islamic revolution that overthrew Iran’s Western-allied monarchy.

The timing, meanwhile, could have been designed as an attempt to boost the Islamic State’s stature among backers as it faces a two-pronged assault against its key urban strongholds: Mosul in northern Iraq and the Islamic State’s de facto capital, Raqqa, in Syria. An expanded offensive by U.S.-backed forces against Raqqa began Tuesday.

It will be interesting to see how the Iranian government responds to this challenge and whether it resembles or is in contrast to the reactions in France and the United Kingdom.

2 comments