What If…

Reflecting on the assassination of Robert Kennedy on June 5, 1968, Kennedy biographer Evan Thomas muses at Newsweek over what might have happened if RFK had been elected president?

IMO that’s getting ahead of ourselves. If he had not been assassinated, Robert Kennedy probably still would not have been the Democratic nominee for the presidency in 1968. The political apparatus was a lot different then than now and the fix was in—Hubert Humphrey would still probably have been the Democratic nominee. Even if RFK had been the nominee he would probably have been defeated by Nixon.

I think it’s much more likely that he would have been elected president in 1976 and, given the many foreign policy errors of the Carter presidency, a lot might well have been different.

But what if he had been elected in 1968? I think the biggest differences would have been in the domestic economy rather than in foreign policy. I think that the illusions of Kennedy’s supporters notwithstanding he would have maintained our forces in Viet Nam and that would have unfolded much as it did regardless of who the president did.

What I think would have been different is that Nixon’s wage and price controls would probably never have been put in place. That set the stage for, among other things, the decline of American manufacturing, particularly the decline of American textile and clothing manufacturing.

5 comments

Losing Sight of the Goal

At Politico Matt Lattimer offers some advice to Democrats that is almost sure to be ignored:

Like Inspector Javert or, perhaps more appropriately, Wile E. Coyote, the Democrats remain fixated on getting their man, Trump, and proving wrong the voters who elected him. At first glance, the daily drip of new and shocking revelations over Russia looks like a mounting shadow over the White House, and it very well may prove to be its undoing. But the instant scandal—it seemed to start the minute Trump was declared president-elect—also threatens to further decimate the Democratic Party. And Democrats don’t seem to know it.

There is an odd sort of process of mental transformation. You go from wanting to accomplish certain goals to wanting to accomplish those goals while defeating your political opponents to just wanting to making your political opponents miserable.

Nowhere is that more evident than in the state of Illinois. We are now going on three years without a budget. Why? Because Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner has proposed a handful of reforms, each of which is anathema to the Democratic leadership. For most of the last three years Democrats have held supermajorities in both houses of the legislature. In other words they could have enacted a budget over the governor’s veto any time they cared to. Rather than doing that they have elected to do nothing.

They have no program. They have no policies. Illinois is losing population, jobs, and, not insignificantly, tax base. Chicago is the only major city that is actually losing population. The cost of borrowing both for the state and for the city is skyrocketing (another way of saying that their credit ratings are falling). Increasing taxes, presumably the go-to solution, will not solve any of those problems and may well aggravate them.

What do Illinois Democrats care about, other than defeating Gov. Rauner and keeping their phony-baloney jobs? I have no idea.

1 comment

The Human-Canine Bond

At the New York Times Emilie Le Beau Lucchesi explains the physiological basis of the relationship we have with other animals:

Studies have shown, for example, that piglets appear to become stressed by seeing and hearing other piglets that have been placed in restraints. Horses, too, appear to respond differently to people who smile or snarl; the horses responded to a snarling facial expression with an increased heart rate.

Other research found that dogs and people had a similar response to hearing the sound of a human baby crying. In the study, researchers exposed 75 pet dogs and 74 people to one of three distinct sounds: a baby crying, a baby babbling and radio static. Each sound was played for more than 10 minutes, and then researchers checked their salivary cortisol levels, an indicator of stress.

Neither the humans nor the dogs showed much response in cortisol levels to the sound of a baby babbling. The radio static also did not alter cortisol levels, though the humans described it as “unpleasant” and the dogs’ body language, which included lowered heads, flattened ears and lowered tails, suggested that it might have caused some distress.

But the sound of a baby crying produced a drastic response. Cortisol levels spiked in both people and dogs. The dogs responded with submissive behaviors like tucking their tails, a reaction that Ted Ruffman, a study author and professor of psychology at the University of Otago in New Zealand, described as low-level empathy.

“Emotional contagion is a primitive form of empathy,” Dr. Ruffman said. “It is plausible that when breeding dogs, humans would have selected for qualities that facilitated emotional links between dogs and humans.”

My wife has been giving workshops on this subject for years. The physical reactions aren’t limited to cortisol levels in both humans and dogs but extend through a variety of other responses as well.

My own pet view is that looking at the human-canine relationship as one in which humans bred dogs for reduced stress response in contact with humans is too limited. I think that humans and dogs have co-evolved, with one species influencing the other over a period of thousands of generations. Dogs who could live with humans were more successful than those who couldn’t. Humans who could live with dogs were similarly more successful.

7 comments

Unhappy Immigrants or Their Children

At ZipDialog Charles Lipson remarks on the challenge we face:

The problem is how to prevent these attacks, both in the short run (surveillance, arrests, etc.) and long run (tougher restrictions on immigration and rethinking the obvious failure to integrate the communities into the liberal west).

I agree. It’s a problem. Here in the United States at least tougher restrictions on immigration will do nothing to address the problem we actually have which is with the native born children of immigrants. Unless you have a time machine or intend to ban all immigration, how does that do anything about the children of the immigrants you do accept?

Also left unanswered: what if the problem is not that we’re not integrating immigrants into our communities but that our immigrants no longer want to be integrated into our communities? Integrating immigrants is so 20th century.

14 comments

Why Is the UK’s Mortality Rate Due to Prostate Cancer So High?

As I was reading this article at the Guardian on a combined therapy for advanced prostate cancer, I was struck by this statement:

More than 27,000 men in the US and 11,000 men in the UK die of prostate cancer each year, according to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prostate Cancer UK.

To put that in some perspective, the U. S. population is about five times that of the U. K. That tells us that the mortality rate due to prostate cancer in the U. K. is about twice what it is here. That’s a big difference.

This study suggests that genetic differences give us at least part of the explanation. I wish that there were better data for West Africa (this study gives us a few tantalizing hints). This study is interesting, too, fortifying the idea of a genetic basis.

So, why is the mortality rate due to prostate cancer so high in the U. K. relative to the U. S.?

  1. Genetics
  2. Health care
  3. Diet
  4. All of the above
  5. None of the above
5 comments

The London Attacks

I would not presume to say what the Brits should do in response to the attacks in London yesterday. It was the third terrorist attack with multiple fatalities in three months.

British Prime Minister Theresa May has proclaimed “enough is enough” but I don’t know what that means in practical terms.

I do know that if the U. S. had experienced something similar Americans would react, possibly precipitously and rashly.

In each case in the UK the police have responded decisively. That doesn’t appear to have been enough to deter more attacks.

There’s something about these terrorist attacks that grab at the heart and capture the attention. I don’t know what it is. Is it their apparent unpredictability? You can’t just avoid a bad neighborhood and stay safe.

11 comments

The Status of World Terrorism

Since May 5, 2017, over the period of the last month, there have been 147 terrorist attacks worldwide. The preponderance of these have taken place in the countries of the Middle East and North Africa plus Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Nigeria. A dozen of these attacks have entailed mass fatalities.

The attacks haven’t been restricted to those countries, however. Among the continents only Australia and Antarctica have been spared.

Several hundreds of people have been killed in these attacks and many more injured.

At Geopolitical Futures Kamran Bokhari outlines the bloody history of Ramadan which began May 26:

Given this history, Ramadan is viewed as more than a religious holiday; it has always had a geopolitical dimension. Groups like the Islamic State, al-Qaida, the Taliban and others invoke this history to further their agendas. Having accused the Muslim regimes and most Muslims of abandoning Islam, the jihadists claim to be the rightful heirs to this legacy. Their narrative is infused with historical references, which the jihadists use to galvanize their fighters during the holy month. This explains why, since 9/11, jihadist attacks during Ramadan have spiked.

Ramadan has also been politicized by those representing the Sunni and Shiite sects of Islam. The two principal players in this struggle, Saudi Arabia and Iran, use this month to energize their supporters. The Saudis, who are the leaders of the Sunni Islamic world, encourage their supporters to defend their faith from the “deviant” Shiites, while Iran, which leads the Shiite sect, tries to incite hostilities as well.

To my eye terrorist attacks do not appear to have spiked this Ramadan. They’re continuing at about the same rate we’ve seen for the last year. Most just take place safely out of sight in Iraq, Syria, or Libya where we don’t notice them.

0 comments

The Dawn

Slowly, slowly the scrum is moving forward and writers at center-left journals are acknowledging openly what I presume they knew all along: that Hillary Clinton lost the election in November because of her own errors and failings. After a nod to the usual suspects (the Russians, Comey, the media) at Salon Conor Lynch outlines the evidence:

Of course, it is possible that the DNC had excellent data but was poorly managed (by Clinton loyalist Debbie Wasserman Schultz, incidentally), and that Clinton was a terrible candidate whose political baggage doomed her campaign from the start.

In other words, the problem wasn’t bad data, as Clinton chooses to believe (on top of everything else), but bad politics.

[…]

In the end, myriad factors contributed to Clinton’s defeat — and she is right to point to Comey, the Podesta email hack, “fake news” propaganda and so on. But underlying it all was an uninspiring candidate who made some horrible decisions leading up to her inevitable presidential run.

“We lost because of Clinton Inc.,” a “close friend and adviser” told Allen and Parnes. “The reality is Clinton Inc. was great for her for years and she had all the institutional benefits. But it was an albatross around the campaign.” According to the authors, a number of Clinton loyalists share this sentiment, but the majority remain in denial — or are reluctant to contradict their boss.

What is happening today, as I have been saying for some time, is a battle for the apparatus of the Democratic Party. To paraphrase LBJ, if you’ve got the party by the apparatus, the hearts and minds generally follow. Ostensibly the battle is being waged between Clinton supporters and Sanders supporters. For decades the DNC had been set up with the objective of getting Hillary Clinton elected president. They did their job, supporting her and strangling her opponents’ campaigns in the womb.

What will happen now? I have no idea. I think the present leadership has to go but I don’t see who will replace them. The present instinct—to exclude all but the most loyal—does not appear to be a willing formula to me.

16 comments

Reluctant Reaction

In this post I’m reacting, reluctantly, to President Trump’s announcement yesterday that the U. S. would begin the process of withdrawing from the Paris Agreement, the global agreement-in-principle on reducing carbon emissions. I’m commenting because it’s obviously yesterday’s biggest news story and has elicited substantial comment. Reluctant because of how little of the commentary on the move heretofore has been objective, fair-minded, empirical or, frankly, anything other than putting down markers on what you think about Trump (or the United States) and I find the entire subject a thankless task.

I think the president erred. Of the available alternatives I think the best would have been to do nothing. We could have maintained the kabuki put in place by President Obama indefinitely. As it is we’re getting the worst international press without getting much benefit from it. The editors of Le Monde are basically saying that we’re throwing in the towel on climate change and abrogating leadership:

Le monde assiste à une séquence diplomatique sans précédent. Sur l’un des sujets les plus graves de l’heure pour l’avenir de la planète – le réchauffement climatique –, l’Amérique se retire. Elle renonce à l’exercice de son « leadership ». Elle ne sera ni un exemple ni un guide. Elle rapetisse, pays continent replié sur lui-même et accusant les autres de lui vouloir du mal. Par la voix de Donald Trump, c’est l’Amérique du Charles Lindbergh de 1940, du nom du pionnier de l’aviation civile et ardent opposant à l’entrée des Etats-Unis dans la deuxième guerre mondiale, qui s’est exprimée, jeudi 1er juin à Washington.

L’Amérique, reniant les engagements pris et ardemment défendus par Barack Obama, quitte l’accord de Paris sur la lutte contre les émissions de gaz à effet de serre. Elle fuit la bataille pour le climat. Elle ne participera pas aux efforts décidés par les 194 autres pays signataires. Elle estime ne plus avoir d’obligations à cet égard – ni techniques ni financières. Elle juge que son développement économique en serait entravé, a dit M. Trump.

They characterize the move as “defeatist”. The Der Spiegel columnist Thomas Fricke follows suit:

Die Welt reagiert mit Entsetzen auf Donald Trumps Entscheidung, die USA aus dem Pariser Klimaabkommen herauszulösen. Staatschefs schimpfen, Umweltorganisationen drohen mit Klagen, selbst große Energiefirmen können nicht fassen, dass der Präsident diesen Schritt wirklich gegangen ist.

Es ist ja auch richtig: Trumps Wende ist eine Bankrotterklärung der Vereinigten Staaten in vielfacher Hinsicht. Sie ist zynisch, weil der Präsident bei einem Thema, in dem es um Leben und Tod geht, agierte, als wäre er der Macher einer Gameshow. Sie ist gefährlich, weil sie offenlegt, wie groß Trumps innerer Drang ist, der Weltgemeinschaft den Mittelfinger zu zeigen, egal, was es kostet. Sie ist verantwortungslos, weil der Präsident so tut, als sei die Haltung zum Klimawandel nicht mehr als ein Chip im Poker um geopolitischen Einfluss. Vor allem aber ist sie dumm, weil die Wende im Kern darauf basiert, die Kohleindustrie zu stärken, eine sterbende Energie. (Lesen Sie hier mehr zu den möglichen Auswirkungen der US-Entscheidung.)

calling the move a declaration of moral and political bankruptcy on the part of the U. S. The Guardian reports:

Trump’s move has been met with a chorus of disapproval from global leaders and blue chip companies including Facebook, Apple, Ford and Microsoft.

A number of the governors of US states have vowed to ignore Washington. The mayor of Pittsburgh also fired back against Trump, who told reporters on Thursday: “I was elected to represent the citizens of Pittsburgh, not Paris.”

Bill Peduto wrote on Twitter: “Fact: Hillary Clinton received 80% of the vote in Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh stands with the world and will follow Paris agreement. As the mayor of Pittsburgh, I can assure you that we will follow the guidelines of the Paris agreement for our people, our economy and future.”

The German chancellor, Angela Merkel, said Trump “can’t and won’t stop all those of us who feel obliged to protect the planet”. She said the move by the US to join just Nicaragua and Syria outside the accord was “extremely regrettable and that’s putting it very mildly”.

Li Keqiang, the Chinese premier, and Jean-Claude Juncker, the European commission president, also spoke together on Friday morning of the importance of continued international cooperation to defeat global warming.

I fail to see what the U. S. gains from the announcement.

The Paris Agreement is not a good one and never has been—mostly an exercise in feelgoodery. It relies on countries to adhere to “nationally determined contributions” on a strictly voluntary basis. The U. S. communique on its first NDC is here.

For it to have any legal standing in the United States, it should have been formally submitted to the Senate where two-thirds of the senators would have needed to vote in approval. President Obama never saw fit to expend political capital on the agreement, to lobby for it, or even to attempt to strike bargains to achieve approval.

Although the United States is frequently singled out as an offender, that’s not entirely fair. Per capita carbon emissions in the U. S. are about what they were 50 years ago. On an overall basis (the only really important statistic) China emits a total of about twice as much carbon as does the U. S. We emit carbon on a per capita basis at a high rate but our rate is lower than Australia’s and not much different than Canada’s. Our total emissions are high because we’re the most populous rich country and our per capita emissions are high because we’re rich and geographically large. Our emissions are trending in the right direction; China’s, Russia’s, and India’s aren’t.

My own views are that I think that human-produce carbon emissions probably have some effect on climate, the models tell us directionality but probably not quantity or timing, and the neoliberal strategies that have been proffered to date are both regressive and ineffective. To me the record seems to show that carbon emissions increase geometrically with income. Few would find the most obvious solutions appealing: don’t import anything from China, reduce the U. S. population, impose draconian taxes on the mega-wealthy. That’s why I tend to turn to technological solutions.

11 comments

The Poll

I’ll probably be conducting this completely unscientific poll periodically for the next several years. Which of these is most likely to happen?

  1. Trump remains in office through the end of his term.
  2. Trump resigns before the midterms
  3. Trump resigns after the midterms
  4. Trump is impeached by the House but not removed from office by the Senate
  5. Trump is impeached by the House and removed by the Senate
  6. Trump is assassinated

I’ve listed these more or less in what I think is decreasing likelihood. There’s what seems to me to be a reasonable argument for B on the grounds that governing is a lot less fun than running and that things are only likely to become less pleasant.

Wishful thinking by Democrats and establishment Republicans notwithstanding, President Trump appears to have a floor of support of just under 40% (cf. the RealClearPolitics average of polls) and that’s probably a solid majority of Republicans. If that floor gives way, anything could happen. If it doesn’t it’s too high for impeachment. The House Republicans will not fall on their swords to get rid of Trump.

18 comments