Should the Government Protect Business Models?

We have been treated to a remarkable spectacle. A representative of public companies owned or with substantial stakes held by some of the richest men in the world writing an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal asking for exemption from antitrust laws so that they can maintain their business model:

The problem is that today’s internet distribution systems distort the flow of economic value derived from good reporting. Google and Facebook dominate web traffic and online ad income. Together, they account for more than 70% of the $73 billion spent each year on digital advertising, and they eat up most of the growth. Nearly 80% of all online referral traffic comes from Google and Facebook. This is an immensely profitable business. The net income of Google’s parent company, Alphabet, was $19 billion last year. Facebook’s was $10 billion.

But the two digital giants don’t employ reporters: They don’t dig through public records to uncover corruption, send correspondents into war zones, or attend last night’s game to get the highlights. They expect an economically squeezed news industry to do that costly work for them.

The only way publishers can address this inexorable threat is by banding together. If they open a unified front to negotiate with Google and Facebook—pushing for stronger intellectual-property protections, better support for subscription models and a fair share of revenue and data—they could build a more sustainable future for the news business.

But antitrust laws make such coordination perilous. These laws, intended to prevent monopolies, are having the unintended effect of preserving and protecting Google and Facebook’s dominant position. The digital giants benefit from legal precedent against collective action that has a chilling effect on publishers. Yet each newspaper or magazine on its own has only limited negotiating power.

Is that really their problem? Over the last decade total advertising spending has been flat in nominal dollars at around $200 billion, see here and here. The brief summary of what has happened is that newspaper advertising has declined by about $15 billion while online has grown by a little more than $15 billion. That sounds like the newspapers’ problem is slow private sector economic growth not Google and Facebook. I would also suggest that industry consolidation is a bigger problem for newspapers than Google and Facebook. National grocery chains are less likely to turn to local newspapers for advertising than small local grocers are.

To put the complaints of the president of the News Media Alliance into some perspective, very few of the 2,000 newspapers the organization claims to represent have any reporters. Most of them subscribe to wire services. Clearly, the pleading is on behalf of a very few media conglomerates, namely the New York Times and Washington Post. The Mexican billionaire Carlos Slim owns a major stake in the Times while Amazon’s Jeff Bezos owns the majority stake in the Post. One can’t help but speculate that these presumably savvy investors didn’t realize that these particular investment were actually very expensive hobbies.

Writing at Forbes Tim Worstall is skeptical of what’s being proposed:

When the US newspaper industry has slimmed down to that sort of level and also still can’t make a buck then perhaps something might need to be done.

There is also of course this other manner that we might want to consider. My fellow journalists think that having a large and vibrant newspaper industry is oh so terribly important to the citizenry of the country. By their actions the citizenry seem to be less convinced of this. I tend to think the people should get what they want, not what they’re told they should desire. No to the antitrust exemption therefore, let the newspaper industry adapt to the changing economic geography, don’t prop it up.

I think there’s good reason to be skeptical about the picture painted in the op-ed and not just for the reasons that Tim cites. The decline in newspaper ad revenues began more than a half century ago, long before Google and Facebook existed. What has actually happened is that media conglomerates have failed to change their business models even as the assumptions of those models failed.

The ad revenues of small local independent newspapers have declined much less in percentage terms than those of major newspapers. In some cases they’ve even increased. What I think has actually happened is that the subscription model for digital media has failed which has reduced online ad revenues for the digital outlets of major newspapers.

Instead of looking for exemptions from antitrust the Times and the Post might think less about being national journals and focus more on their local markets. That’s where the the ad revenues come from.

There’s another difference between small, independent local newspapers and media conglomerates. Media conglomerates have grown by taking on debt. It might just be the case the newspaper industry is not one in which carrying heavy debt loads is a good business decision. It isn’t the job of the federal government to indemnify investors against losses due to their own bad businesses decisions, Chrysler and GM notwithstanding.

0 comments

The Committed

Rather than repeat my old joke about the difference between conviction and commitment, I’ll just launch into a review of the reactions of Japan and South Korea to North Korea’s escalating provocations. If the editorials in the Japan Times and Korea Times are at all representative of those reactions, they are deeply conflicted to say the least.

Japan Times

North Korea must be stripped of the illusion that the U.S. can be decoupled from Japan and South Korea, its two Northeast Asian allies. Close coordination between Washington, Tokyo and Seoul is critical to the realization of that goal. Pyongyang’s dream is to divide our three nations; we must work harder to ensure that North Korea does not miscalculate or exaggerate its capabilities.

The existential threat posed by North Korea motivates virtually all South Korean presidents to visit the U.S. on their first overseas trip. South Korean President Moon Jae-in was no exception. Last week, he journeyed to Washington to meet President Donald Trump and ensure that their two governments are in sync in dealing with Pyongyang. Although problems may blossom over time, their meeting was, by all accounts, a success. While those two countries alone cannot solve the North Korean problem, a meeting of the minds is a necessary condition for success.

[…]

Trump tweeted after their dinner that the two men had a very good meeting, while Moon said in a joint appearance that he and Trump had forged a friendship of “deep mutual trust.” Speaking in the Rose Garden, Trump said that the U.S. “will always defend our allies.” According to their joint statement, the presidents “affirmed their commitment to fully implement existing sanctions and impose new measures” on North Korea. Moon also offered support for the Trump administration’s policy of “maximum pressure and engagement.”

How that is translated into policy and how that balance is struck are unclear. For all the smiles, Moon and Trump see the North in fundamentally different ways. Moon would like to reopen the Kaesong Industrial Complex, a North-South economic project that has been shuttered since February 2016, which would undercut U.S. efforts to force Pyongyang to negotiate. Trump’s insistence that North Korea is a regime that “has no respect for human life” and “no regard for the safety and security of its people or its neighbors” undercuts the logic of engagement that Moon has championed.

Korea Times

President Moon Jae-in’s peace proposal to North Korea in Berlin, Germany, indeed sounds hollow, considering the palpable tension on the Korean Peninsula following Pyongyang’s recent test-firing of what it claims to be an intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM).

It is hard to miss a striking contradiction between Moon’s peace initiative and the joint condemnation he made at the same venue together with U.S. President Donald Trump and Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe. So are the decades of efforts to deal with this pariah state that keeps coming back to haunt the world.

Now the world is preoccupied with this isolated state’s latest blackmail but, if the past is any guide, it will pass and a relative lull will ensue. Despite loud alarms, the latest rocket is short of a working ICBM that can deliver a miniaturized nuclear payload through the stress of re-entry through the atmosphere.

Both of these reactions strike me as containing hints of desperation. When will North Korea’s nuclear-armed ICBM program be a threat? When San Francisco is in ashes?

It seems to me that Japan and South Korea should be taking more active steps rather than merely counting on the U. S. to handle the situation for them. As I’ve written before if I were in South Korea’s shoes I’d think I’d be doing a lot of digging right about now.

6 comments

The Trouble With Germany

The Economist has joined me on the anti-German bandwagon:

There is much to envy in Germany’s model. Harmony between firms and workers has been one of the main reasons for the economy’s outperformance. Firms could invest free from the worry that unions would hold them to ransom. The state played its part by sponsoring a system of vocational training that is rightly admired. In America the prospects for men without college degrees have worsened along with a decline in manufacturing jobs—a cause of the economic nationalism espoused by Mr Trump. Germany has not entirely escaped this, but it has held on to more of the sorts of blue-collar jobs that America grieves for. This is one reason why the populist AfD party remains on the fringes of German politics.

But the adverse side-effects of the model are increasingly evident. It has left the German economy and global trade perilously unbalanced. Pay restraint means less domestic spending and fewer imports. Consumer spending has dropped to just 54% of GDP, compared with 69% in America and 65% in Britain. Exporters do not invest their windfall profits at home. And Germany is not alone; Sweden, Switzerland, Denmark and the Netherlands have been piling up big surpluses, too.

For a large economy at full employment to run a current-account surplus in excess of 8% of GDP puts unreasonable strain on the global trading system. To offset such surpluses and sustain enough aggregate demand to keep people in work, the rest of the world must borrow and spend with equal abandon. In some countries, notably Italy, Greece and Spain, persistent deficits eventually led to crises. Their subsequent shift towards surplus came at a heavy cost. The enduring savings glut in northern Europe has made the adjustment needlessly painful. In the high-inflation 1970s and 1980s Germany’s penchant for high saving was a stabilising force. Now it is a drag on global growth and a target for protectionists such as Mr Trump.

That isn’t true only of Germany. No developed country should have as high a current account surplus as Germany’s. China at least has the excuse of the many millions still in poverty. Germany doesn’t have such a complaint.

What should Germany do? Either the government, businesses, or consumers should spend more. It should import more. It should not use the same currency as Greece or Romania. It should pay for its own defense. Don’t expect any of those things any time soon.

3 comments

I Have Seen the Future

And it is Texas? That’s what Lawrence Wright claims in his article in the New Yorker:

Texas leads the nation in Latino population growth. Latinos account for more than half the 2.7 million new Texans since 2010. Every Democrat in Texas believes that, if Latinos voted at the same rate in Texas as they do in California, the state would already be blue. “The difference between Texas and California is the labor movement,” Garnet Coleman, a Houston member of the Texas House, told me. In the nineteen-sixties, Cesar Chavez began organizing the California farmworkers into a union; that kind of movement didn’t happen in Texas, a right-to-work state. “Labor unions create a culture of voting and political participation,” Coleman observed. In Texas politics, he says, “everything is about race—it’s veiled as public policy, but it encourages people to believe that their tax dollars are going to support lazy black and brown people.” Political views have become more entrenched because of redistricting, and yet the demographic majority in Texas is far more progressive than its representatives. Coleman predicts a showdown: “This is a battle about the future of the country, based on a new majority, and we have to have this out.”

He paints a picture of Texas politics in all its garish, bizarre, contradictory glory. Read the whole thing. It’s a whole ‘nother country.

Regardless of the pretensions of the residents of both of those states, I don’t believe that the future of the United States is either California or Texas. I think it’s much more depressing. What I think is likely to happen is resegregation. Mexican-Americans will become an ever-larger proportion of the populations of California, Arizona, New Mexico, and, probably, Texas. Blacks will flee the violent dysfunctional cities of the North in a reverse Great Migration and move to Georgia, Mississippi, Alabama, and Louisiana. White flight will take the form of moving to the upper Midwest, Plains States, and mountain West. New York will become like London where in many parts of the city you need to mount an active search to find an Englishman. It will be a poorer, angrier, less egalitarian, less optimistic country.

It will more closely resemble the America of my grandparents than it will the one I expected to see in my adulthood when I was a kid. Fortunately, I won’t live to see it.

1 comment

Understanding the Theory of Trade

I think that I understand the theory of trade better than Allan Golombek does. In his post on reciprocity in trade at RealClearMarkets this:

Given that the advantages of free trade are obtained by any country that embraces it, why should adopting it depend on reciprocity? When Great Britain adopted free trade in 1846 by abolishing the Corn Laws, it did so unilaterally. The Brits did not demand that any other country match its move to free trade. They wanted, instead, to curb spiraling food prices that had exacerbated the Irish famine. The result of Great Britain’s unilateral embrace of free trade? Food prices went down, the cost of living declined, manufacturers were better able to afford workers’ wages – and Great Britain prospered.

is a fair characterization of the theory of trade but this:

Faced with a protectionist U.S. Administration, the G20 for the first time issued a final statement that included the concept that trade must be “reciprocal.” There are advantages to reciprocity, of course. But the truth is, even if a country reduced trade barriers unilaterally, without any guarantee of reciprocal access for its goods, its people would be better off. The biggest advantage of free trade isn’t that it makes it easier for us to export – it is that it makes it easier for us to import.

is not because the theory of trade is about countries not individuals. On average free trade makes the people of the countries that embrace it better off but it can penurize some people while making other fantastically wealthy because it has nothing to say about distribution within countries but only about trade between countries.

That defect could be remedied if countries like the United States that adopt free trade also adopted policies that taxed the beneficiaries of trade and redistributed the proceeds to those harmed by free trade. But somehow that never happens.

4 comments

Mythologies

I found James Duesterberg’s essay at The Point, “Final Fantasy”, fascinating but I don’t really know how to characterize it. It purports to be a discursion on “neoreactionary politics”, his vague term for what is equally vaguely deemed the “alt-right”, but it aspires to be much more. Here’s a snippet:

Western democracy, Mencius Moldbug tells us, is an “Orwellian system,” which means that its governments are “existentially dependent on systematic public deception.” Nominally, a democracy like the U.S. is founded on the separation of church and state, and more fundamentally, of government policy and civil society. With a state church, government power shapes what citizens think, which means citizens can no longer shape government policy. Rather than expressing or even guiding the will of the people, the state aims only to increase its own power by producing the people it needs. But a state church, according to neoreaction, is what we have: Moldbug calls it “the Cathedral,” and exposing it, critiquing it and trying to destroy it is neoreaction’s avowed goal. The Cathedral, like the Matrix in the 1999 film (a favorite reference point for neoreaction), is everywhere; it infects every experience, shapes all aspects of our waking lives. Its main centers of power are the university, the mainstream media and the culture industry.

Want to earn enough money to support your family? You’ll need a college degree, so you’d better learn how to write a paper on epistemic violence for your required Grievance Studies 101 class. Want to keep your job? You’d better brush up on climate-change talking points, so you can shift into regulatory compliance, the only growth industry left. Want to relax with your friends after work? It’s probably easiest if you like movies about gay people, pop music that celebrates infidelity and drug use, and books about non-Christian boy wizards. Want to communicate with other people? Better figure out how to use emoticons. Which race of smiley face do you use when your employer texts you on the weekend?

It characterizes the modern world as a duel between competing fictional mythologies. Since I don’t share the aspirations of either of the conflicting armies, I find it all terribly sad and actually destructive to my preferred outcome. But that’s the modern world for you.

Ah, love, let us be true
To one another! for the world, which seems
To lie before us like a land of dreams,
So various, so beautiful, so new,
Hath really neither joy, nor love, nor light,
Nor certitude, nor peace, nor help for pain;
And we are here as on a darkling plain
Swept with confused alarms of struggle and flight,
Where ignorant armies clash by night.

4 comments

The End of Economists

I found Matt Seybold’s poetic essay at the Los Angeles Review of Books, “The End of Economics”, interesting, uniting, as it does, Virginia Woolf, T. S. Eliot, and John Maynard Keynes. That sounds like the beginning of a joke but as it works out, as related in Woolf’s journal, the three were friends, at least to the extent that any of them could be a friend. The essay makes intriguing reading.

Artificial intelligence is much in the news these days and the term covers a lot of territory. It includes rules-based systems, natural language processing, and machine learning. Contrary to what’s suggested in Mr. Seybold’s article I don’t believe that its inherent contradictions, its lack of predictive power, or the irresistible temptation that economists face to pursue their own preferences and agendas over where the science leads them that will doom economics. I think that artificial intelligence will.

0 comments

Self-Answering Questions

First they excommunicated the conservatives. Then they expelled the moderates. Then they removed the moderate leftists. At Quillette Uri Harris asks the question “Are the Social Sciences Undergoing a Purity Spiral?”:

A couple of years ago, six social scientists published a paper describing a disquieting occurrence in academic psychology: the loss of almost all its political diversity. As Jonathan Haidt, one of the authors of the paper, wrote in a commentary:

Before the 1990s, academic psychology only LEANED left. Liberals and Democrats outnumbered Conservatives and Republican by 4 to 1 or less. But as the “greatest generation” retired in the 1990s and was replaced by baby boomers, the ratio skyrocketed to something more like 12 to 1. In just 20 years. Few psychologists realize just how quickly or completely the field has become a political monoculture.

It seems to me that ship had sailed before most of the people alive today were born. It was true when I was in college a half century ago and I can’t even imagine what it’s like now. Those many years ago I sat in on one Intro to Sociology class in which the prof said “People become psychologists to come to an understanding of their own psychological problems. People become sociologists to come to an understanding of their own sociological problems. That’s why all sociologists are Jews or black.”

If that’s the case, why do people become economists?

12 comments

Welcome to Our Startup

This morning I’ve read several interesting posts and articles about which I don’t actually have much to say. Since I think they’re deserving of your attention I’ll post on them anyway.

The first is at McSweeney’s Internet Tendency, written by Bob Vulfov, and is entitled “Welcome to Our Startup Where Everyone Is 23 Years Old Because We Believe Old People Are Visually Displeasing and Out of Ideas”. Here’s a snippet:

As you can probably tell by looking around, every employee at our startup is 23 years old. On the morning of your 24th birthday, the barcode on your employee ID stops working and you can no longer enter our building. We do this to ensure our company has a ceaseless, youthful energy. We believe old people are displeasing to look at and also, bad at ideas.

Recently, I spent several months on an assignment at just such a startup and I can testify that there is more truth in the piece than not.

If you’re not familiar with McSweeney’s Internet Tendency, I recommend it. If you swing by there, check out “Kafka’s Joke Book”.

3 comments

Visit Harpo’s Place

I want to encourage to visit a delightful web site: Harpo’s Place. Written by Bill Marx, one of Arthur “Harpo” Marx’s kids, it is dedicated to his father’s life and work:

Welcome to the Harpo Marx Website. My name is Bill Marx, and my dad is Harpo Marx. I created this site on behalf of The Harpo Marx Foundation and his family so that visitors who stop by can see a different perspective on Harpo… and learn sides of the man that might not be very obvious from that crazy fright-wigged character who chases girls in Marx Brothers movies. In other words – the complete man.

Dad always said there were two Harpos – the actor and the man. The actor was the one who horsed around with his brothers and pulled all sorts of junk from that bottomless pit of a trench coat. But it was also the man who sat down and played the harp.

And it was the man that I knew best. The man I just called – Dad.

When I was a kid Harpo was my favorite of the Marx Brothers for a simple reason: he wasn’t cruel.

I learned a few things in reading it, for example, that the original characters portrayed by the Marx Brothers were intended as stereotypical vaudeville characters: Groucho as the “stage Jew”, Chico as the “stage Italian”, and Harpo as the “stage Irishman”. Pretty obviously by the time their movies came around those characters had changed considerably and Harpo in particular had much more in common with Arthur Marx than he did with any Irishman who ever lived, onstage or off.

When you’ve got a few minutes to spare go and visit a gentle, loving place dedicated to a gentle, loving man. You’ll be glad you did.

1 comment