The Rule of Law

Do you remember that presidential election commission organized by President Trump and its request to the states for voter registration information? So far 14 states have refused, as catalogued in this piece at NPR, California among them. The response from California Secretary of State Alex Padilla to the request by the commission is here. It reads in part:

The President’s commission has requested the personal data and the voting history of every American voter–including Californians. As Secretary of State, it is my duty to ensure the integrity of our elections and to protect the voting rights and privacy of our state’s voters. I will not provide sensitive voter information to a commission that has already inaccurately passed judgment that millions of Californians voted illegally. California’s participation would only serve to legitimize the false and already debunked claims of massive voter fraud made by the President, the Vice President, and Mr. Kobach. The President’s Commission is a waste of taxpayer money and a distraction from the real threats to the integrity of our elections today: aging voting systems and documented Russian interference in our elections

Voter registrations are public records. Under the California Public Records Act, modeled after the federal Freedom of Information Act, he is required to provide that information—it does not fit under the exemptions listed in the act. The state routinely provides that information to political parties, candidates, polling organizations, and others. There is no presidential commission exception to the law.

Fortunately for the secretary of state, CPRA presently carries no penalties. Fortuitously, a bill, supported by the state’s major media outlets, is making its way through the California legislature that would impose penalties for non-compliance. The penalty is nominal but it’s something.

Most if not all states have similar public records acts. California and the other states that have refused to supply the voter registrations should comply. That is what it means to have a rule of law. Civil servants have no right of civil disobedience. Such a thing would be tyranny. They do have the right to resign rather than obey laws they believe to be wrong.

16 comments

The Origins of the Jews

In his Wall Street Journal review of Steven Weitzman’s book, “The Origin of the Jews”, Benjamin Balint writes:

The first to gauge the formative moment of this people’s story, Mr. Weitzman says, were 20th-century archaeologists who claimed that around 1200 B.C. the Israelites emerged from the earlier Canaanite culture. The archaeologists variously proposed that the Israelites were invaders from Egypt who seized Canaan in an act of conquest; migrants from Mesopotamia who infiltrated the land peacefully; or Canaanite peasants who revolted against their exploiters and gave birth to a new set of rituals and principles. The pioneering biblical archaeologist W.F. Albright (1891-1971) found evidence of an abrupt leap: “The Canaanites, with their orgiastic nature-worship . . . were replaced by Israel, with its nomadic simplicity and purity of life, its lofty monotheism and its severe code of ethics.”

Still other scholars locate the Jews’ founding moment in the encounter with the ancient Greeks. Drawing on Shaye Cohen’s study “The Beginnings of Jewishness” (1999), Mr. Weitzman takes up the theory that Judaism (itself a Greek coinage of the second century B.C.) was catalyzed by the Judeans’ cross-fertilization with Hellenistic culture. Before Alexander the Great’s conquest, Judean identity was a matter of ethnicity, determined by birth. Afterward, emulating the ways in which Greeks thought of their “Greekness,” it became a community of belief. Paraphrasing Mr. Cohen, Mr. Weitzman writes that “the Judeans realized under the influence of the Greeks that identity was not fixed by birth, that one could make oneself into a Jew through conversion.”

In his book “The Hebrew Bible: a Socio-Literary Introduction”, Norman Gottswald provides another explanation: Judaism arose as a religious, political, and social movement among Canaanites in the last millennium before the common era.

The subject has been a matter of intense investigation for many years, made more pressing by the founding of the state of Israel. When I was a kid there was a best-selling book “The Bible As History” by Werner Keller and Mr. Keller was a guest in our home at the time. It made for a fascinating dinner table discussion. More recently there have been genetic studies to determine the relationship between modern Jews and the Israelites of the Hebrew Bible. They’ve gone pretty much as you might have expected. Yes, today’s Jews have Middle Eastern ancestry. What we have learned pretty convincingly if not conclusively is that the Maronites of Lebanon are likely the descendants of the Phoenicians.

6 comments

The Award for Humor

Today’s award for humor goes to the editors of the Wall Street Journal. From their editorial on the challenges that remain after the retaking of Mosul:

A politically stable and independent Iraq, by contrast, would improve the chances of stabilizing Syria after ISIS is swept from Raqqa.

A flying unicorn would be nice, too. They are such kidders.

0 comments

If You’ve Just Tuned In

In reaction to the revelations of yesterday in which Donald Trump, Jr. released his emails with a Russian lawyer the editors of the Washington Post say:

THERE CAN now be no doubt: The Russia meddling story is not just smoke but fire. Donald Trump Jr.’s interactions with Russians during last year’s presidential campaign were abnormal and alarming. An incriminating email chain has made it impossible for the administration to deploy its always flimsy argument of last resort — that the whole story is just “fake news.”

Not only Mr. Trump but also presidential son-in-law Jared Kushner and then-campaign chairman Paul J. Manafort are involved. Following a string of misleading and false statements, Americans must also wonder: Were other Trump associates involved? Did other meetings take place? Was President Trump aware of them? What more did the Trump camp know about Kremlin support for the Trump campaign?

And then there is this recurring question: How long can the rest of the Republican Party prioritize partisanship and agenda over decency and patriotism?

I don’t recall having said that there were no communications between the Trump campaign or people connected with the Trump campaign and Russians but if I did I was wrong. Clearly, there were such communications.

At this point here’s what we know:

  • There were in fact communications between the Trump campaign and/or people connected with the Trump campaign and Russians.
  • As the New York Post remarks, Donald Trump, Jr. is an idiot.
  • If the Trump campaign and/or people connected it with it said that there were no communications between them and Russians, they were either mistaken or lying.
  • The FBI investigation continues.
  • These revelations give them more fuel for their fire.

Communicating with Russians is still not a crime, let alone treason as some maintain.

At this point we don’t know:

  • Whether there was any underlying crime.
  • Whether any of this is a “high crime or misdemeanor”.

As Alan Dershowitz points out, there may be no underlying crime involved. The most likely would be a violation of the Logan Act. The complication of prosecuting it as such would be that it would open up every CEO of a major company or many large NGOs for prosecution under the act.

Whether any of this constitutes a political crime serious enough for impeachment will depend on the president’s approval rating. If it falls below what appears to be his present floor, Trump could be in real trouble. If my theory holds, nothing will change.

This isn’t politics any more. It’s Kafka.

Update

The editors of the Wall Street Journal weigh in:

In the daisy chain from Russian oligarch to singer to PR go-between to lawyer to Trump scion, which is more plausible? That Don Jr. was canny enough to coordinate a global plot to rig the election but not canny enough to notice that this plot was detailed in his personal emails? Or that some Russians took advantage of a political naif named Trump in an unsuccessful bid to undermine the Magnitsky law they hated?

The problem is that President Trump has too often made the implausible plausible by undermining his own credibility on Russia. He’s stocked his cabinet with Russia hawks but dallied with characters like the legendary Beltway bandit Mr. Manafort or the conspiratorialist Roger Stone. His Syrian bombing and energy policy are tough on Russia, but Mr. Trump thinks that if he says Russia interfered in 2016 he will play into the Democratic narrative that his victory is illegitimate.

Thus in retrospect the John Podesta and Democratic National Committee hacks—still so far the tangible extent of Russian meddling—did less damage to U.S. democracy than it has done to the Trump Presidency. The person who should be maddest about the Russian hacks is Mr. Trump.

The “Magnitsky law” is H.R. 4405, a law enacted in 2012 that imposes sanctions on named Russian individuals deemed responsible for the death of Sergei Leonidovich Magnitsky, a lawyer and auditor who investigated corruption in the Russian government.

14 comments

Trending at the Watcher’s Council Site

Watcher of Weasels

Russia Russia Russia 

 Natalia Veselnitskaya, Magnitsky Act, Russian hackers, Putin’s tentacles, you name it…

 Forum: Will Media Outlets Like CNN Ever Practice Journalism Again? 

 Amerisclerosis

 Michael Brown: Punishment 
 

 CNN’s White House propagandist claims Trump delivered ‘white America’ speech in Warsaw. 

 Everybody wants you — flattering and overwhelming 

 Baltimore: Clueless 

 Face the Nation: US Ambassador Nikki Haley on Trump and Putin’s G-20 meeting 

 Testing Tyranny, Part 4 

 [VIDEO] Being a millennial: “self-responsibility is a form of cruelty” 

0 comments

Powers

Russia is a regional power. China is a regional power. India is a regional power. The regions in which they are regional powers overlap. Some level of conflict is inevitable. Each of them has territorial disputes with the others.
A low level shooting war between China and India has been going on for decades.

The U. S. is a global power. Our interests are not the same as Russia’s, China’s, or India’s. We will have points of agreement with each of them and points of disagreement with each of them. We have no territorial disputes with any of them. We should work with each when it makes sense for us to do so and oppose each of them when it makes sense for us to do so.

We have no permanent alliances or enemies only permanent interests.

This stuff should be obvious. Apparently, it isn’t.

6 comments

The Retaking of Mosul

As you are probably aware that other than some mopping up the Iraqi army has retaken Iraq’s second largest city, Mosul, which has been occupied by DAESH for most of the last two years. There will be months of cleanup, disarming IEDs and other booby traps, and years even decades of rebuilding.

How big a story is this? I’m inclined to think it’s a “dog bites man” story as opposed to the “man bites dog” story of DAESH’s taking Mosul in the first place, something that was only made possible by the national government’s incredible ineptitude.

It will have implications. Iraq is likely to be less interested in the Syrian border than otherwise might be the case; DAESH will devote more resources to southwest Syria and its notional capitol.

5 comments

Getting to Yes

First, go over and look at the RealClearPolitics average of polls on Donald Trump’s approval rating. It’s stable at 40%.

It’s not worsening, it’s not improving. It’s stable at 40%. His floor of approval seems to be at about 38%.

Much of that approval is probably among Republicans. Indeed, if Gallup is to be believed his approval rating among Republicans is 85%. Do the math.

He’s not going to be impeached. The Republicans are likely to hold the House through the midterm elections. What we will probably see for the next three years is three years of depressing sameness. Where is there a basis for agreement with this dichotomy of views?

18 comments

Truth and Reconciliation

Frankly, I doubt that many progressives will take Kay Hymowitz’s City Journal review of progressive takes on reconciliation with the white working class seriously. Maybe I’m being unkind but I think that for every progressive like Kevin Drum or Michael Tomasky there are three who are just waiting for white working people to die.

Consider this:

A more complex analysis of liberal elitism comes from Joan Williams, a feminist law professor whose best-known previous book is Unbending Gender. In White Working Class: Overcoming Class Cluelessness in America, Williams takes her fellow liberal professionals to the woodshed for their indifference to the hard-knock realities of working-class life and for their blindness to the shortcomings of their own cosmopolitan preferences. Married to the Harvard-educated son of a working-class family, Williams is astute about the wide disparities between liberal and white working-class notions of the meaning of work, family, community, and country. One of her proposals for solving class cluelessness is a conservative favorite: reviving civics education.

As long as progressives don’t recognize that today’s feminism is far too separated from most women’s lives and experience there will be a problem. Too much about more women in the professions and boardrooms of Fortune 500 companies and not nearly enough about the problems faced by lower income women. Lower income women have always worked outside the home. My maternal grandmother and her mother both worked, the latter as a cook for a wealthy home. My sympathy for that last is with the wealthy family. She was by most accounts an awful cook.

The emphasis should be on marriage, how women are treated in marriage, preserving intact families, working conditions for women in blue collar workplaces, and greater economic growth and employment. The real women’s issues are archetypally conservative ones.

4 comments

If You Don’t Share Something, It’s Not Shared

May I kvetch about a minor thing? The slug on Catherine Rampell’s Washington Post column is “The left as well as the right are spurning our shared democratic values.” With a lead-in like that I couldn’t bring myself to read the column. If something is spurned by both the left and the right, by definition it is not shared. How about saying “historic values”, “legacy values”, or just “past values”?

I think that the decline of literacy has lent itself to an increasingly agonistic style of expression, fewer appeals to reason, and increasing tribalism. Our problem is not that the extremes are spurning previously shared values. The problem is that the values are no longer shared.

0 comments