That’s Not Soft Power

I sometimes wonder whether there is any phrase more frequently misused than “soft power”. Coined by Harvard scholar Joseph Nye it is distinguished from hard power. Hard power is either military or economic power. Soft power is much more subtle. It consists in getting people to want what you want to accomplish. There are multiple ways of doing that. Setting the agenda is one of them. The strength and prevalence of your culture is another.

Foreign aid is not an exercise of soft power unless it results in people wanting what you want to accomplish. I think we should increase our foreign aid not to use soft power but because it’s the right thing to do.

As an exercise in soft power I think we should come to the sad conclusion that foreign aid has been a flop. Following the 2005 earthquake in Pakistan the U. S. spent billions on aid and, indeed, for years afterwards the U. S. Navy was Pakistan’s major health care provider. That didn’t stop terrorists based in Pakistan from killing Americans or induce the Pakistani government to turn over Osama bin Laden (make no mistake: the Pakistani government knew where he was all along). The reality is that lots of people don’t want what we want and no amount of foreign aid will convince them of anything but that we’re suckers.

Now to Adm. James Stravrides’s op-ed at CNN:

(CNN)Ten years ago, a little boy walked for two days with his mother to the USNS Comfort’s eye clinic. The Comfort is a Navy warship that operates as a hospital ship in the Caribbean and South America, with a crew from both the military and non-profit sectors providing free medical care. After his eye exam and treatment, the 8-year-old looked up and said, “Mama, veo el mundo.” “Mom, I see the world.”

In 2007, when I was commander of the US Army Southern Command, the Comfort treated close to 100,000 patients in 12 countries, performed 1,700 surgeries, issued more than 32,000 immunizations and trained 28,000 medical students and technicians.

Some people are shocked that military leaders are such strong advocates of what Harvard’s Joseph Nye called “soft power,” or the ability of a country to persuade without force or coercion. But I know first-hand how it enhances America’s security.

Which is why I am so concerned about the Trump’s administration proposed budget cuts to soft-power programs throughout the government. Under the budget proposal for 2018, military spending amounts to about 16% of the budget, while State Department programs account for less than 1%.

Worst yet, recently the President proposed a cut of 26% for global health programs — “the lowest level of funding since FY 2008,” according to an analysis by the Kaiser Family Foundation. Funds for AIDS alone would drop by about $860 million.

While I am not proposing a specific ratio of spending, I believe there is a symbiotic relationship between hard and soft power and that, in both cases, we need to invest in the programs that succeed.

Adm. Stravrides should go back to his sources. Whatever the merits of our foreign aid, what he’s describing isn’t soft power. It’s just another form of hard power and it isn’t convincing the world that we aren’t so bad any more if it ever did.

2 comments

Amerisclerosis

You used to read about “Eurosclerosis”, slow economic growth in Europe, quite a bit. At Bloomberg View Noah Smith points out that the United States has contracted it, too:

…the implication is clear — the U.S. needs to put the Great Recession behind it. During the downturn, it made a certain amount of sense to ignore those who called for structural reform of the U.S. economy — after all, there were more pressing, immediate issues to deal with. But now that the recession is long over and slow growth seems to be here to stay, economists and policy makers should put much greater focus on raising productivity growth and getting more Americans into the workforce. Rooting out Amerisclerosis won’t be easy, but it has to be done.

If I had to pick a single subject matter for this blog, that would be it. I’ve been writing about it now for nearly 15 years.

The most appealing target for fixing what ails us is reducing the deadweight loss of government and that in turn means returning government to its historic relationship to the rest of the economy, i.e. restraining taxation to 22% rather than surging towards 30%. That doesn’t mean cutting government spending to the bone. It means making prudent choices.

As me auld mither used to say we can have anything we want but we can’t have everything we want. It continues to be the case that there are no substitutes to thrift, industry, and other traditional American virtues.

2 comments

Where the Money Goes

I realize that Medicaid spending is an enormous drag on state budgets and is increasing at a frightening rate. I wish there were more recognition in the press that a third of Medicaid expenditures are devoted to long-term care and there is no other obvious alternative way of paying for it.

You can’t just send Mom to live with her eldest daughter any more. That daughter is working a full-time job now. She needs to. Without that job the family won’t be able to afford the mortgage payment. Very few people have enough income or savings to pay for long-term care. Very few people have insurance that will cover it.

35 years ago there was an attempt at finding another solution but it was repealed more quickly than it was enacted. It created an enormous flap. Elders outright refused to pay the insurance premiums.

Consequently, if you’re going to get Medicaid spending under some sort of control, you’ll need to come up with a solution for long-term care to do it. If your solution is compulsory savings, keep in mind that will reduce the consumer spending on which our economy is far too dependent.

If this stuff were easy, we’d’ve done it a long time ago.

1 comment

Illinois’s Riddle

What do you get when your state legislators have either entered a dissociative fugue or are maliciously conspiring against the people of Illinois? You get the budget recently enacted here. As Steven Malanga notes at City Journal:

As I’ve pointed out before, the national economic recovery has been weak, and many states are struggling to balance their books in the face of diminished revenues. But no other state faces the combination of a mountain of unpaid bills, a pension system whose funding levels are already among the lowest anywhere, and judicial rulings that have narrowed the state’s options to wiggle out of the mess.

Considering that situation, bold reforms were necessary. What Illinois did, instead, was the least that it could do to avoid getting its bond rating dropped to junk status. You have to wonder how much deeper the crisis has to become to get the state’s leaders to act decisively, and whether they’ll miscalculate and run out of time before they have that chance.

Reality has a way of intervening. The last time the state income tax rate was increased it did not realize revenues proportional to the increase. It realized less and that was when Illinois had more residents and businesses than it does now, something else that’s a consequence of Illinois’s misfeasant, malfeasant, and nonfeasant legislature.

There are no legal democratic solutions to our problems. Mssrs. Madigan and Cullerton are not elected by the people of Illinois but by the voters in their districts who are, apparently, happy with them. Illinois is doomed to continue its downward spiral.

1 comment

The Seven Cent Solution

A story posted on by Heather Cherone at DNAInfo Chicago highlights a point I’ve been making for some time. State and local governments chronically overestimate the taxes they’ll realize from increases:

CHICAGO — The good news is that Chicago’s effort to keep plastic and paper bags out of area landfills by imposing a 7 cents-per-bag tax is succeeding beyond officials’ wildest dreams.

The bad news is that the success of the fee in dissuading shoppers from taking single-use bags means the city’s coffers are taking a steep hit.

Chicago officials balanced the city’s 2017 spending plan based on an assumption that the city would earn $9.2 million this year from the tax.

But that assumption appears to have missed the mark by at least $1.5 million based on data complied by the city through June 18.

In debating the 7 cent per bag tax the stated reason was to reduce the number of plastic bags used by Chicagoans. In other words if it were completely effective the city would realize no revenues from the tax. That rationale didn’t stop the city from including the tax in its budget projections.

To some people $1.5 million doesn’t sound like a lot but it’s a 15% shortfall. That’s a substantial gap for a city whose tax base is declining and whose bonds are teetering on the edge of junk status. And it’s the same error the county and city made when they increased the sales tax and the same error the county is making in imposing a steep tax on sugar-sweetened soft drinks.

I have not bought a single plastic bag since the city imposed its tax. It was an avoidable expense so I avoided it. Other Chicagoans are clearly doing the same thing. The tax on bags is a regressive one so the likelihood is that it’s falling hardest on the poorest Chicagoans.

Contrary to the beliefs of state and local government officials incentives matter and taxes have consequences. Wages do not magically rise to match tax increases. An increase in taxes will either reduce consumption or savings.

5 comments

Trending at the Watcher’s Council Site

Watcher of Weasels

[VIDEO] Being a millennial: “self-responsibility is a form of cruelty” 

 (Cartoon) Poor Democrats…Milking A Dead Cow! 

 President Trump In Poland ‘The West WIll Not be Broken’ 

 [VIDEO] Brandon Morse gives CNN the public apology it deserves 

 California’s New ‘Sanctuary State ‘ Law 

 Heroin: “When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best.” 

 John Podesta, Hillary’s Campaign Chief Is The One With The Real Russia Ties 

 The Actual War On Women, Part 2 

 Spanish civil war and human “Anti-Zionist” garbage

0 comments

You Can’t Handle the Truth

At the New York Times Robert Frank attempts to explain why health care prices are lower under single-payer systems:

Total costs are lower under single-payer systems for several reasons. One is that administrative costs average only about 2 percent of total expenses under a single-payer program like Medicare, less than one-sixth the corresponding percentage for many private insurers. Single-payer systems also spend virtually nothing on competitive advertising, which can account for more than 15 percent of total expenses for private insurers.

That’s true. But Canada’s Medicare system has costs of administration of around 15% while ours are around 25%—down from a high water mark of about 30%. Said another way, don’t expect a single-payer system in the United States to have administrative costs of 2%. A cost something in between 15% and 25% is probably more realistic. Said yet another way: don’t expect converting to a single-payer system to cut costs dramatically.

The most important source of cost savings under single-payer is that large government entities are able to negotiate much more favorable terms with service providers. In 2012, for example, the average cost of coronary bypass surgery was more than $73,000 in the United States but less than $23,000 in France.

That “negotiate” is a tricky word. Can anyone cite an example of any other country negotiating lower prices from providers other than pharmaceutical companies? I can’t. Drugs account for about 8% of U. S. health care spending. You could cut those to the bone and it wouldn’t result in tremendous savings overall. There’s a lot of squawking about high drug prices because they account for a lot of the out-of-pocket spending by the elderly but you’re not going to realize big savings from that direction.

I can think of examples of other countries dictating prices to providers but not negotiating them down. High health care prices in the U. S. are a direct consequence of an unwillingness by American politicians or public health care administrators to negotiate substantially lower prices. Claiming that they will is an extremely strong assertion that deserves some proof. I wish Mr. Frank would provide it.

You’d also need to believe that providers will accept pay cuts. Cutting prices for individual line items on the tab isn’t enough; you’ve got to keep the line items the same or trim them back, too. I see no reason to expect any of those things to happen and they need some substantiation, too.

As long as providers think they should be earning high salaries, patients insist on getting all of the health care that they want, and neither politicians nor public health care administrators will chaffer prices down, I don’t think it makes much difference whether we have a single-payer system in the U. S. or not. Prices will remain higher and continue to rise, more than we can afford.

The sad truth is that health care prices are high in the U. S. because we won’t cut them.

13 comments

Greatly Exaggerated

I don’t need to explain why the death of the internal combustion engine has been greatly exaggerated, Volvo’s announcement that it was getting out of the internal combustion engine business notwithstanding. Chris Isidore has already done it for me at CNN Tech:

The first reason is profitability. The stock of tiny Tesla (TSLA) may be worth more than either General Motors (GM) or Ford (F), but it has yet to report an annual profit. Traditional automakers are making billions of dollars selling millions of gasoline-powered cars each. No one has yet figured out a way to make a profit selling electric-only vehicles.

Here’s a little quiz question. At the present rate of electric vehicle sales when will there be no more internal combustion vehicles on the road? Answer: never.

159,000 EVs were sold in 2016. In comparison a total of 17.5 million light vehicles were sold. That’s a 1,000-fold difference.

Let me try another way of explaining it. Sales of EVs are not doubling every year. But let’s assume they were. If they were it would take six years for EV sales to equal sales of non-EVs. If EVs maintain a 38% increase every year it will take 12 years for EVs to equal non-EVs in sales. The time to turn over the entire fleet is 20 years.

In other words it is unlikely that I’ll ever see a time when EVs are the majority of cars on the road let alone the only cars on the road. And that’s assuming the present rate of increase and all of the technical and logistical problems are solved.

0 comments

Lessons Learned

I found the infographic sampled above summarizes the interesting article at Defense One on the lessons learned in the battle for Mosul. I sincerely hope that one of the lessons isn’t it ain’t over ’til it’s over.

1 comment

One Picture

I just love this picture of the leaders assembled for the meeting of the G20 countries. It tells you everything you need to know.

One of these things is not like the others.

5 comments