The Process Works Its Way Through

All of the major news outlets are full of news about yesterday’s indictments of individuals who figured highly in Donald Trump’s presidential campaign, to the exclusion of all else. I continue to be content with letting the process work.

To summarize where things stand now:

  • Going to foreigners and/or foreign governments for opposition research: ugly but not illegal.
  • Lobbying for foreign governments without registering, money laundering, and lying to the FBI: illegal.
  • Russia’s objectives in its activities in the 2016 election appear to have been to discredit the American system.
  • It worked, probably beyond their wildest dreams.
  • In that light it makes sense that they would focus their efforts on Hillary Clinton. Like most of us they thought she was going to win.

Have I missed anything?

I don’t think that foreigners or foreign governments should interfere in other countries’ elections. I don’t think that Russia should do it. I don’t think that we should do it. Other than by being honest and open I’m not sure how it can be prevented.

15 comments

Built On Sand

I disagree pretty fundamentally with Christian Caryl’s piece in the New Republic, “Why Democracy Didn’t Work in Russia”. I think that there are any number of reasons that liberal democracy hasn’t flourished in Russia following the collapse of the Soviet Union. Here are three.

First, institutions matter. After the collapse of the Soviet Union the only functioning institutions in Russia were the military, the KGB, organized crime, and to some extent the Orthodox Church. Those are the institutions that form the foundations for today’s Russia.

Second, Russia has no tradition of liberal democracy. Certainly none of the institutions listed above has any tradition of liberal democracy or any interest in it for that matter.

Third, the transition was bungled, abetted by the West. What needed to happen was a much more gradual transition during which liberal democratic institutions like a free press or an independent court system could be nurtured. We should have been willing to foster that. Instead the transition was abrupt and you can see the results.

Was the outcome we see inevitable? I don’t think so. Was the outcome inevitable given the sudden collapse of the Communist Party and the whole Soviet system followed by an overly rapid transition away? I believe it was. It was at least a foreseeable consequence and we’re partially to blame.

12 comments

How a One-Sided Market Actually Works

At RealClearPolicy Gary Wolfram proposes what looks to me to be a dystopian plan for health care reform:

A solution much more likely to aid the poor is for the government to move Medicaid and Medicare to a form of health savings account. It would provide complete coverage for catastrophic care, and fund an account for recipients that they could use on health care spending. This would cause people to ask “How much does that test cost here versus another clinic?” This in turn would incentivize places like Wal-Mart having to employ nurse practitioners at their pharmacy who can provide health care at reasonable prices. Additionally, it would also spur innovation in medical techniques and pharmaceuticals that make people healthier at lower costs.

Such programs would only be available to the bottom 20 percent of the income distribution, with a phase out of the benefit as income rose. And eliminating the tax deductibility of employer-based insurance or allowing a deduction for private insurance premiums would prompt a move to individual health insurance policies rather than employer-provided insurance. The result would end the fear of losing insurance due to unemployment.

Note that this plan only renders the consumer side of the health care equation “market-based”. The vast array of regulations and subsidies given to providers including patents, occupational licensing, certificates of need, etc. would remain in place.

If Medicare is eliminated, how would the present residency system be funded? Presently the Medicare system pays about $80,000 for every medical resident, an enormous subsidy to medical education. Would the subsidy be paid from the general fund or would it be eliminated?

His proposed system would only result in reduced spending if two things happen: there is presently considerable over-utilization and reduced consumption would not be made up for with increased prices, i.e. producers will accept pay cuts. Dr. Wolfram appears unaware that nearly all health care consumption is directed by producers rather than patients.

It seems more likely to me that medical billing would rise, whether through higher prices or more procedures, to make up for the elimination of Medicare and Medicaid spending. The elderly who don’t fall within the bottom 20% of the income distribution would be penurized and more and more of the middle income would become de facto working poor.

And we haven’t even touched on the issues for the insurance industry, e.g. at this point for practical purposes the individual insurance market his system relies on no longer exists.

8 comments

What’s He For?

Okay, okay, I get it. E. J. Dionne thinks that tax cuts are a distraction from the graver problems facing the country:

It is a victory for Republicans that the political conversation — when it’s not being hijacked by President Trump’s assorted outbursts and outrages — is focused on tax cuts. No matter how critical the coverage gets, the sheer amount of attention risks sending a message that taxes are the most important issue confronting the country.

This is entirely wrong, and it’s essential to challenge the whole premise of the debate. The United States does not need tax cuts now. Reducing government revenue at this moment will do far more harm than good. Conservatives are proving definitively that they don’t care in the least about deficits. And their claims that tax cuts will unleash some sort of economic miracle have been proved false again and again and again.

However, the only thing in his column that he advocates is…a tax cut:

Meanwhile, as Dylan Matthews reported on Vox, Sens. Michael Bennet (D-Colo.) and Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) have introduced a bill that would dramatically expand the child tax credit to $3,600 a year per child for those age 0 to 5, and $3,000 a year for those 6 to 18. To direct the most assistance to the poor and the less affluent parts of the middle class, the credit begins gradually to phase out for incomes of single parents at $75,000 a year and married couples at $110,000.

The plan, Matthews writes, would cut child poverty in the country almost in half, from 16.1 to 8.9 percent. The cost: roughly $1 trillion over a decade, as against the $1.5 trillion Republicans claim would be the net price of their tax cuts after they are done shuffling the tax code around.

I would have been delighted if Mr. Dionne had told us what he thinks the graver problems facing the country are but he doesn’t even drop any hints. Russian disinformation? North Korean nuclear weapons? What?

Heaven knows I recognize that every post can’t be about everything. At least it should be about something.

5 comments

Dividing the Spoils

In an op-ed in the New York Times Michael Tomasky wonders why the leading Democrats aren’t articulating a vision of the future of the United States:

The Democrats are undergoing a historic transformation, from being the party that embraced neoliberalism in the early 1990s to one that is rejecting that centrist posture and moving left. There’s plenty about this to cheer — the neoliberal Democratic Party didn’t do nearly enough to try to arrest growing income inequality, among other shortcomings.

There will be necessary internecine fights, and they boil down to loyalty tests on particular positions demanded by the vanguard. Consider the debate within the party on Senator Bernie Sanders’s “Medicare for All” bill, which most (though not all) 2020 contenders rushed to attach themselves to. To fail to sign on to that legislation is to open oneself to criticism, even abuse, although it’s less a piece of legislation than a goal.

Forget about who’s right and wrong in these debates. Time will sort that out. My point is that they tend to consume a party experiencing a shift. The Democratic Party, because it is an amalgam of interest groups in a way the Republican Party is not, has always had a tendency to elevate the candidate who can check the most boxes. The current internal dynamics exacerbate that. It’s also worth remembering that no one besides party activists cares.

So when the party’s leaders tussle over this or that policy, they also need to take a step back, to see the direction the country — the West itself — is heading, and take a stand on it. This isn’t just a matter of high-minded idealism; it’s what separates great politicians from merely good ones.

The answer to the question is that they don’t have one. They don’t want to “make America great again”; they think it’s fine as it is. The Obama Administration made it eminently clear that Democrats believe what we’re experiencing is the new normal—slow to nonexistent growth. They don’t want to make things better. They want to manage the decline and divide the spoils.

I really wish that Democrats were paying a lot more attention to good governance and a lot less to political pandering. If they think we can have open borders and maintain a workable society, they should articulate that vision. If they think that higher corporate and personal income taxes will make this a better society, that’s a vision they should articulate as well. I’d like to explain the high homicide rates in Chicago, Baltimore, and St. Louis and the low homicide rates in New York and Los Angeles without referencing race.

I recently read something, articulated by a progressive, that we should figure out how to return to the conditions of income equality of a half century ago. I don’t think he realized what he was saying.

2 comments

The Beginning of the End or the End of the Beginning?

The investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election being conducted by former FBI Director Robert Mueller has made its first arrests. The New York Times reports:

WASHINGTON — Paul Manafort surrendered to federal authorities Monday morning, after a person close to the case said the first charges were filed in a special counsel investigation.

The charges against Mr. Manafort, President Trump’s former campaign chairman, were not immediately clear but represent a significant escalation in a special counsel investigation that has cast a shadow over the president’s first year in office. Also charged was Mr. Manafort’s former business associate Rick Gates, who was also told to surrender on Monday, the person said.

There’s an excellent summary of what we may expect going forward at Wired:

Monday’s charges are only the beginning of what’s sure to be a complex and deeply partisan process. And, if this weekend’s release of half-century-old files related to JFK’s assassination is any guide, we, as a country, may never feel like we fully understand what transpired in 2016.

While my view continues to be what it has been along (I’m content with the investigative process unfolding), IMO the entire matter may be hugely anticlimactic. There won’t be any charges of collusion (there is no such crime), there won’t be any charges of treason (it doesn’t remotely fit anything that actually happened), and President Trump himself won’t be charged with anything (the only recourse is impeachment and that won’t happen as long as his support among Republicans is as high as it is). Anyone who’s banking his or her hopes on that should get used to disappointment.

Will these be the only arrests and the only charges? How high will they go? Stay tuned.

Update

Here are the indictments.

3 comments

Interdicting North Korea

I found this backgrounder about the complexity of maritime interdiction operations against North Korea at the Proceeding of the U. S. Naval Institute interesting. Here’s a snippet:

China and Russia both maintain strategic relationships with North Korea and likely will turn a blind eye to evasion of sanctions. The Arabian Gulf is a confined waterway, approximately 600 miles end to end, and all maritime traffic has to pass through the narrow Strait of Hormuz. One of the most difficult challenges there was stopping vessels that tried to avoid interdiction by sailing through Iranian territorial waters. North Korea’s ports and waterways connect directly to “safe-harbor” Chinese and Russian territorial waters, which extend for thousands of miles in either direction and lead directly to open ocean. With summertime melting of Arctic ice increasing, a ship could depart a North Korean port and travel through the Russian Northern Sea Route all the way to Norway—the first such transit without an icebreaker occurred in August 2017.

Developing interoperability and complementary rules of engagement among the 16 navies enforcing UNSC resolutions took many years in the Gulf. While the Navy continues to work with other naval services routinely, starting MIO operations with a new coalition of navies adds a significant layer of complexity. This will take time, and DPRK shipping doubtless will exploit any cracks in the coalition’s capabilities until they are made seamless.

Expect calls for a naval blockade of North Korea to increase.

3 comments

Raise the Congress!

In response to Joseph Postell’s complaints about situational constitutionalism and Congressional inaction at the Library of Law and Liberty, I would point out that the end of the “Golden Age of Congress” and the beginnings of the imperial presidency coincided with the capping of the number of Congressmen in the Appointment Act of 1911.

The Civil Service Reform Act of 1883 played a role, too, but that’s a subject for another post.

3 comments

Politics, Policies, Science, and Parenthood

I found this article at the Wall Street Journal interesting for several reasons. Let’s start with an excerpt:

Ms. Komisar, 53, is a Jewish psychoanalyst who lives and practices on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. If that biographical thumbnail leads you to stereotype her as a political liberal, you’re right. But she tells me she has become “a bit of a pariah” on the left because of the book she published this year, “Being There: Why Prioritizing Motherhood in the First Three Years Matters.”

The premise of Ms. Komisar’s book—backed by research in psychology, neuroscience and epigenetics—is that “mothers are biologically necessary for babies,” and not only for the obvious reasons of pregnancy and birth. “Babies are much more neurologically fragile than we’ve ever understood,” Ms. Komisar says. She cites the view of one neuroscientist, Nim Tottenham of Columbia University, “that babies are born without a central nervous system” and “mothers are the central nervous system to babies,” especially for the first nine months after birth.

What does that mean? “Every time a mother comforts a baby in distress, she’s actually regulating that baby’s emotions from the outside in. After three years, the baby internalizes that ability to regulate their emotions, but not until then.” For that reason, mothers “need to be there as much as possible, both physically and emotionally, for children in the first 1,000 days.”

The regulatory mechanism is oxytocin, a neurotransmitter popularly known as the “love hormone.” Oxytocin, Ms. Komisar explains, “is a buffer against stress.” Mothers produce it when they give birth, breastfeed or otherwise nurture their children. “The more oxytocin the mother produces, the more she produces it in the baby” by communicating via eye contact, touch and gentle talk. The baby’s brain in turn develops oxytocin receptors, which allow for self-regulation at a later age.

Women produce more oxytocin than men do, which answers the obvious question of why fathers aren’t as well-suited as mothers for this sort of “sensitive, empathetic nurturing.” People “want to feel that men and women are fungible,” observes Ms. Komisar—but they aren’t, at least not when it comes to parental roles. Fathers produce a “different nurturing hormone” known as vasopressin, “what we call the protective, aggressive hormone.”

One of the aspects of the story that I found interesting is that I think it’s practically a Rorschach test for political views. If you’re an absolutist about equality between the sexes, I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if you found this story highly objectionable. So what if men and women are different?

A traditionalist conservative on the other hand will probably read this story as a vindication of his or her views of gender roles and the family. And so on.

It seems to me that, assuming the claims made in the article are correct, the empirical questions are what are the implications of this for child development and how persistent are they? Are the social changes of the last thirty or forty years in the developed world producing lasting psychological or emotional problems for our people? It would seem to that these matters should be verifiable but in all likelihood so politically volatile that they’re unlikely to be investigated.

The question it raises for me is that, again assuming that the claims made in the article are correct, there is no substitute for the relationship between mother and child, and that the harm is lasting, is what is the correct policy?

In the areas of parental leave and maternal leave the United States is, as in so much else, an outlier. Although employers may provide paid or unpaid parental or maternity leave as a benefit, they are not obligated to do so. Every OECD country other than the United States provides for some sort of obligatory paid maternal, in many cases paid by social insurance, i.e. the government. I hasten to note that by the standards articulated by Ms. Komisar (9 months after a child’s birth) no OECD country’s policy provides for adequate maternal leave.

I also don’t see how a reasonable policy governing maternal can be formulated without goring an entire herd of sacred cows. What I think is clear is that our present policies are inadequate.

6 comments

Spanish Split

What to say about the contretemps in Spain? In case you’re just tuning in here’s what’s happened so far:

  1. The political leaders of the wealthy Catalan province of Spain decided to conduct a plebiscite on independence for the province.
  2. The Spanish government asserted that the plebiscite was illegal under the present Spanish constitution.
  3. A very large majority of a very small minority of the eligible voters in Catalonia voted in favor of independence.
  4. Madrid condemned the result.
  5. The Catalan regional government declared independence.
  6. Madrid dissolved the Catalonian regional government and assumed direct rule.

Madrid has acted as expected, as it must, and as it should. It’s somewhat as though Silicon Valley had declared its independence from the State of California.

I’ve already asked my questions about this before. Does Catalonia really have a history distinct from Spanish history? My casual researches don’t suggest that it does. A linguistic community isn’t necessarily a country.

What’s the unit of measure of sovereignty? The province? The city? The block? The individual? Whatever the answer how is that to be managed?

IMO countries aren’t granted sovereignty, they seize it. Maybe things are different in Europe.

Update

If Catalonia’s police force remains neutral, Madrid’s takeover of the provincial government will stand.

7 comments