Those Were the Days

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are unenthusiastic about the Republicans’ template for tax reform, characterizing it as “half a tax reform”. The reforms to the corporate income tax are adequate but they’re dissatisfied with the changes to the individual income tax:

The dispiriting news is on the individual side. The House would double the standard deduction to $12,000 for individuals and $24,000 for married couples. This would improve simplicity for millions, and it compensates for the bill’s elimination of the personal exemption. But nearly half of American filers already owe no income taxes, and the larger deduction would make the federal fisc even more dependent on a smaller pool of taxpayers.

This is far better than the House bill’s new “family credit,” which increases the child credit to $1,600 from $1,000 in a forlorn attempt to appease the income redistributionists of the right like Senators Mike Lee and Marco Rubio. The credit would also offer an additional $300 for each parent and another $300 for each “non-child dependent.” The credits would phase out for married couples at $230,000 of income. Does anyone think a mid-level manager at J.P. Morgan deserves a subsidy to raise children?

The House also gradually makes more of the $1,600 credit refundable. In other words, this will be a check in the mail for those who owe nothing in taxes, which discourages work. The family credits cost $640 billion over 10 years in lost revenue with zero growth payoff. To make up the difference, the House keeps the top personal rate at 39.6%, on top of the 3.8% ObamaCare surcharge that Republicans failed to repeal. This would become the fourth tax bracket and kick in at $1 million for couples—half that for individuals—with 12%, 25% and 35% brackets below.

This top rate is a surrender to Democratic class warriors, though Republicans also fear that President Trump would sandbag them. No Members want to vote for a lower top rate and then have Mr. Trump tweet that they’re “mean,” as he did on health care. This is where presidential flightiness and lack of principle have a policy cost. Ideological surrender also gets Republicans nothing politically as Democrats are still attacking the House plan as a sop to the rich.

Here and there the House plan includes some good news on individual loopholes, such as eliminating the state and local deduction. The bill carves out an exception for property taxes, capped at $10,000, to win over New York and California Republicans, if the House can hold that cap. Another good move is a $500,000 cap on mortgage interest for new homes, and no more tax breaks for second residences. The Realtors will go thermonuclear, but then they refused to support the House blueprint that left the deduction untouched.

The overall impact of the individual tax changes is little reform but more income redistribution. The long-term damage to the tax-cutting cause will also be considerable. Adding credits and deductions for individuals makes rate-cutting that much harder since the affluent pay the vast bulk of all income taxes. The divorce of “pass through” and personal income rates will also make it even harder to reduce individual tax rates below 39.6%—ever.

They need to get their minds around the modern globalized economy. Nostalgia for economic growth through tax-cutting is all well and good but the same tax cuts today wouldn’t have the effects they did 35 years ago.

The benefits of any cut in the personal income tax will go overwhelmingly to “the rich” because that’s how the income tax is structured. They pay most; cuts mean they’ll get the most benefit. What will “the rich” do with the money? They may buy a few more Mercedes-Benzes, Audis, BMWs, or Maseratis, none of which are made here in the United States, or more French wine or single malt Scotch, neither of which are made here in the United States, and they may buy a few more expensive houses, something being discouraged by reforms in the mortgage interest deduction. What they’ll mostly do is buy financial instruments which do nothing do produce economic growth until and unless they’re sold and the money leaks into the real economy.

Don’t delude yourself into believing that giving more money to the less-than-rich will produce lots of domestic economic growth, either. The consumer goods that they buy are overwhelmingly produced somewhere else, mostly in China.

The reality is that the tax code is about tapped out as a way of producing economic growth and that more growth will require much more basic reforms. We need to produce more goods and services here in the United States and even that won’t produce the kind of economic growth we need for reasons you can probably figure out for yourself.

21 comments

Question

What do you think the odds are that Manafort’s attorney asks for the charges against his client to be dismissed on the grounds that Robert Mueller’s appointment as special counsel doesn’t meet the statutory requirements? In other words he challenges Mr. Mueller’s standing to file charges.

12 comments

Inside the DNC

At Politico Democratic Party apparatchik Donna Brazile recounts the corruption, malfeasance, misfeasance, and nonfeasance she saw at the DNC:

On the phone Gary told me the DNC had needed a $2 million loan, which the campaign had arranged.

“No! That can’t be true!” I said. “The party cannot take out a loan without the unanimous agreement of all of the officers.”

“Gary, how did they do this without me knowing?” I asked. “I don’t know how Debbie relates to the officers,” Gary said. He described the party as fully under the control of Hillary’s campaign, which seemed to confirm the suspicions of the Bernie camp. The campaign had the DNC on life support, giving it money every month to meet its basic expenses, while the campaign was using the party as a fund-raising clearing house. Under FEC law, an individual can contribute a maximum of $2,700 directly to a presidential campaign. But the limits are much higher for contributions to state parties and a party’s national committee.

Individuals who had maxed out their $2,700 contribution limit to the campaign could write an additional check for $353,400 to the Hillary Victory Fund—that figure represented $10,000 to each of the thirty-two states’ parties who were part of the Victory Fund agreement—$320,000—and $33,400 to the DNC. The money would be deposited in the states first, and transferred to the DNC shortly after that. Money in the battleground states usually stayed in that state, but all the other states funneled that money directly to the DNC, which quickly transferred the money to Brooklyn.

“Wait,” I said. “That victory fund was supposed to be for whoever was the nominee, and the state party races. You’re telling me that Hillary has been controlling it since before she got the nomination?”

Gary said the campaign had to do it or the party would collapse.

“That was the deal that Robby struck with Debbie,” he explained, referring to campaign manager Robby Mook. “It was to sustain the DNC. We sent the party nearly $20 million from September until the convention, and more to prepare for the election.”

Read the whole thing.

Perhaps I’m being unkind but there’s something about Ms. Brazile’s op-ed that reminds me of the media accounts I’ve read retelling stories of horrific sexual abuse and assault. Why didn’t she mention something while all of this was going on? Presumably, for the same reason the actresses didn’t: she didn’t want to hurt her career. What has changed?

13 comments

If It Weren’t for Malfeasance They’d Have No Feasance At All

Sexual harassment charges are being levied against figures other than show biz and media stars. They’ve spread to teh political world. The Chicago Tribune reports:

Fallout from the sexual harassment scandal at the Illinois Capitol continued Wednesday, as a state senator lost his leadership position and top Democrats scrambled to find a leader for the agency tasked with investigating such complaints after letting the job remain vacant for years.

Democratic Sen. Ira Silverstein of Chicago “will no longer serve” as Senate Democratic majority caucus chair, according to Senate President John Cullerton. The move came a day after Denise Rotheimer, an activist for victims of violent crime, told lawmakers at a public hearing that Silverstein made unwanted comments about her appearance, sent her hundreds of Facebook messages and placed midnight phone calls as she was working with him to pass legislation for nearly 18 months.

Silverstein has disputed the allegations and said he apologized “if I made her uncomfortable.” Losing his leadership spot will cost him an $20,649 annual stipend on top of the $67,836 base salary lawmakers get for what’s considered a part-time job. Reached by phone Wednesday evening, Silverstein said he was in the middle of grocery shopping at Mariano’s and would have to call back.

I could make all sorts of wisecracks but I’ll refrain other than to say that a) I’d think a victims’ rights activist is the last person you’d want to harass; b) Ira Silverstein represents the senatorial district in which I live; and c) $90K ain’t bad for a part-time sinecure. How hard is it to vote however Cullerton wants you to?

Also, lest you think that the Illinois legislature is only a do-nothing legislature in passing budgets, solving the state’s economic problems, there are any number of areas in which they also do nothing:

That announcement came as a Republican senator questioned why no one has acted on more than two dozen ethics complaints filed at the legislative inspector general’s office since 2015. Sen. Karen McConnaughay, who sits on the panel of lawmakers that oversees such complaints, also wanted to know why she was only just now learning that those unresolved complaints existed.

Democratic lawmakers cited two technical reasons. One is that there’s no legislative inspector general, so there’s no one with the power to turn complaints of any nature into an actual investigation. The other is that sexual harassment is not currently included as a specific violation of the state’s ethics act, meaning that the Legislative Ethics Commission can’t hold a hearing or issue punishments on such complaints.

The General Assembly has been without a permanent chief watchdog for more than three years. Three of the four legislative leaders have to agree on a nominee before the commission can consider installing the person in the role, said Democratic Sen. Terry Link, who is chairman of the legislative ethics panel.

Cullerton attempted to assign blame to himself on Wednesday. “It’s our duty to fill that post. I take responsibility for my role in that lapse, and I apologize for it,” he said in a statement.

But legislative leaders have failed to hire a permanent legislative inspector general since Tom Homer left at the end of June 2014. The following week, the Chicago Tribune published details of a secret report put together by Homer in the wake of a 2013 Metra scandal that offered new insight into how Democratic House Speaker Michael Madigan navigated the intersection of public business and ward-style patronage through his Southwest Side office and Illinois Capitol suite.

Just sticking with what they’re good at.

Update

The editors of the Trib remark:

The current uproar reflects badly on Cullerton, whose reliance on protocol is no excuse: He referred Rotheimer’s complaint to an office that he knows full well is rudderless and ineffectual. “It is our understanding that there is an open investigation” — spoken Tuesday by a Cullerton spokesman — is a pretty hollow assurance.

This reflects badly, too, on Madigan, who sprang into action only after a groundswell of protest about a culture of creepiness in the Capitol. Madigan desperately wants to avoid looking like he hasn’t taken sexual harassment seriously. Too late.

which provides a little context for the complaints I’ve made about the Illinois legislature over the years.

1 comment

They Don’t Get It

The editors of the Chicago Sun-Times, in reference to the television spot I linked to yesterday, say this:

First, they suggest that Illinois’ problems can be chalked up to the Legislature’s refusal to politely sign off on Rauner’s supposedly pro-business, but certainly anti-union, agenda. In reality, much of what ails our state is a result of the political and governmental paralysis — for which Rauner and Madigan must share blame — that set in immediately after Rauner was elected more than two-and-a-half years ago.

Illinois, already hurting, quickly became a fiscal basket case, racking up more than $16 billion in unpaid bills, along with growing debt and pension obligations.

Second, the three governors overlook that Rauner, unlike themselves, must work with a Democratic Legislature. It’s a trickier business to govern effectively when you must bridge party differences. But plenty of Illinois governors, Democrats and Republicans, have found a way. Rauner has not.

I think the editors are the ones who don’t get it. It’s not an ad for Rauner. It’s an ad against the Illinois state legislature in general and Mike Madigan in particular. The message is that the only way for Illinois’s economy to grow is to elect enough Republican state legislators to force a leadership change.

I’m not sure of the merits or practicality of the argument but I think that’s the obvious message.

0 comments

Not Recommended

On Monday afternoon a patch of rash appeared on the right side of my abdomen—a patch about two inches across and an inch high, 8-10 large raised bumps. Very painful. Yesterday the doctor confirmed what I had suspected. I have shingles.

Not recommended as a pastime.

I can work after a fashion but I think that not going into the office is probably a corporal act of mercy at this point.

11 comments

Thanks, Madigan

We’re presently being inundated with showings of the television ad above. It doesn’t say anything I haven’t said a dozen times but it does say it pretty dramatically.

I think it will be very difficult for Rauner to be re-elected. Even more unfortunately it will be a victory for the do-nothing legislature in Springfield. I see little hope for Illinois if another governor who will just rubber stamp everything Madigan wants to do is elected but that’s likely what will happen.

If Democrats have a plan for resuscitating Illinois, I’d certainly like to see what it is. As it is it looks like their policy is that the beatings will continue until morale improves.

5 comments

It’s All Been Said

What more is there to be said about the terrorist attack in New York City yesterday that hasn’t already been said? Terrorist attacks are clearly retail as well as wholesale, something law enforcement has no means of stopping that aren’t draconian.

That’s exactly what the French, at even graver risk of such retail terrorist attacks than we are, have done. They have imposed what appears to be a permanent state of emergency and certainly appear to be moving inexorably towards becoming a police state. Égalité, oui. Liberté, non.

The most obvious response for the United States is also the longest overdue: we should abolish the diversity visa program. It has served its purpose and outlived its rationale. Now it poses risks that weren’t imagined when it was enacted into law. How much benefit do the citizens of the United States derive from randomly selected Uzbeki immigrants? Is it greater than the risk posed by randomly selected Uzbeki immigrants?

I also wonder if the murderer’s wife has been taken into custody. It is not credible to me that she didn’t know what her husband was preparing to do. If she isn’t in custody and hasn’t flown already, expect her to flee. That’s been the pattern.

0 comments

The Challenge to the Regulatory Framework

This article at Atlantic opens a discussion of something that I think is a critical issue for the use of artificial intelligence in health care:

At a large technology conference in Toronto this fall, Anna Goldenberg, a star in the field of computer science and genetics, described how artificial intelligence is revolutionizing medicine. Algorithms based on the AI principle of machine learning now can outperform dermatologists at recognizing skin cancers in blemish photos. They can beat cardiologists in detecting arrhythmias in EKGs. In Goldenberg’s own lab, algorithms can be used to identify hitherto obscure subcategories of adult-onset brain cancer, estimate the survival rates of breast-cancer patients, and reduce unnecessary thyroid surgeries.

It was a stunning taste of what’s to come. According to McKinsey Global Institute, large tech companies poured as much as $30 billion into AI in 2016, with another $9 billion going into AI start-ups. Many people already are familiar with how machine learning—the process by which computers automatically refine an analytical model as new data comes in, teasing out new trends and linkages to optimize predictive power—allows Facebook to recognize the faces of friends and relatives, and Google to know where you want to eat lunch. These are useful features—but pale in comparison to the new ways in which machine learning will change health care in coming years.

which is how can our present regulatory framework deal with machine learning? The topic is particularly thorny in that even the designers of the algorithms can’t tell you why the program reaches the conclusions it does.

It’s also why I think that a likely scenario is that not just the United States but all countries with large health care systems and sophisticated regulatory frameworks are likely to become technological backwaters in health care. When the choice is between a computer program and nothing, the computer program is going to look much more attractive.

6 comments

Perspectives on the 2016 Election

You might want to read this article at The Nation on a report that presents a post-mortem of the 2016 presidential election that is discordant with the prevailing narrative:

The Democratic Party lost just about everything in 2016, but so far it has offered only evasive regrets and mild apologies. Instead of acknowledging gross failure and astounding errors, the party’s leaders and campaign professionals wallowed in self-pity and righteous indignation. The true villains, they insisted, were the wily Russians and the odious Donald Trump, who together intruded on the sanctity of American democracy and tampered with the election results. Official investigations are now under way.
While the country awaits the verdict, a new and quite provocative critique has emerged from a group of left-leaning activists: They blame the Democratic Party itself for its epic defeat. Their 34-page “Autopsy: The Democratic Party in Crisis” reads more like a cold-eyed indictment than a postmortem report. It’s an unemotional dissection of why the Democrats failed so miserably, and it warns that the party must change profoundly or else remain a loser.

Reading the particulars of this critique, I had the impression that maybe the party got what it deserved in 2016. I do not mean that Trump deserved to win. Indeed, “Autopsy” mentions Trump’s campaign largely in passing, and the Russians only once. But this analysis does suggest that Trump became president mainly because the Democratic campaign was inept, misguided, smug, and out of touch with the country.

While the report does address the cul de sac into which identity politics is leading the Democrats, it doesn’t seem to come to terms with an even more basic problem, as great for Republicans as it is for Democrats. Professionalization is the doom of political parties. When you professionalize every aspect of politics, it is inevitable that you will not believe you need the voters and you will show it.

4 comments