The Canary

It seems like just a year ago that the editors of the WaPo were telling us that homicide rate was not really rising and that it wasn’t a problem. Now, apparently, it’s a problem:

THE NATION’S homicide rate has risen sharply in the past two years after a decades-long decline, and a record share of the murders, nearly three-quarters, are now committed with firearms. That has prompted some officials to endorse get-tough policies that, although politically popular, are ill-conceived and as likely to do harm as good.

Virginia is a focal point in the emerging debate over responses to the homicide spike, because candidates in the recent statewide political campaigns talked about it and because of a program implemented in Richmond in the midst of a previous surge in murders 20 years ago. That program, known as Project Exile, targeted gun criminals by diverting them from state to federal courts, where they received mandatory-minimum sentences in out-of-state prisons and were usually ineligible for bail.

but there is no quick fix:

Mandatory-minimum sentencing regimes are despised by many judges as a one-size-fits-all approach to crime-fighting; the late chief justice William Rehnquist was among those who denounced them. Politicians looking for quick fixes in the face of rising crime rates should examine the evidence first.

Comparing Richmond’s homicide rate with New York’s is specious. Sad as it is to point out, urban homicide rates are correlated with percentage black population. Richmond’s black population is over 50%; New York’s is 25%. Their respective black populations are different in other ways. New York has many more Africans and Caribbeans, for example.

I agree that there is no quick fix and I doubt that mandatory minimum sentences will do much to curb the problem. The problems in the black communities of Richmond, Baltimore, St. Louis, and Chicago have been 80 years or more in the making. They won’t be solved over night. IMO there will need to be more opportunity and much better law enforcement in the neighborhoods where the problem is most severe.

There must be social changes as well. More must be asked of young black men and they must be able to come through.

Oh, well. They say that the first step on the road to recovery is admitting that you have a problem. They’ve now acknowledged that there is a homicide problem. Maybe in a year or so they’ll summon up the courage to admit the nature of the problem.

0 comments

The Sources of Forgiveness

I think that David Brooks is onto something in his most recent New York Times column:

We once had a unifying national story, celebrated each Thanksgiving. It was an Exodus story. Americans are the people who escaped oppression, crossed a wilderness and are building a promised land. The Puritans brought this story with them. Each wave of immigrants saw themselves in this story. The civil rights movement embraced this story.

But we have to admit that many today do not resonate with this story. This story was predicated on the unity of the American people. But if you are under 45, you were probably taught an American history that, realistically, emphasizes division — between the settlers and the natives, Founders and their slaves, bosses and the workers, whites and people of color. It’s harder for many today to believe this is a promised land. It seems promised for the privileged few but has led to marginalization for the many.

Let me pause right there. Preaching division is “realistic” if your aspirations are for your preferred group to achieve power. It’s simply destructive if your aspiration is “E Pluribus Unum”.

“E Pluribus Unum”, “out of many, one” was adopted as the motto of the new United States in 1776. There is nothing in it that limits it to a single race, stratum of society, gender, nation of origin, religion, or anything else other than aspiring to reconcile competing factions. The story of division that has prevailed for 50 years isn’t realistic. It’s nihilistic. It arises from the attempt to, in Voegelin’s phrase, immanentize the Eschaton which will always be frustrated. He continues:

The story of America, then, can be interpreted as a series of redemptions, of injury, suffering and healing fresh starts. Look at the mottos on our Great Seal: “A New Order for the Ages” and “Out of Many, One.” In the 18th century divisions between the colonists were partially healed. In the 19th century divisions between the free and enslaved were partially healed. In the 20th, America partially healed the divisions between democracy and totalitarianism. In the 21st, we have healing fresh starts still to come.

The great sermon of redemption and reconciliation is Lincoln’s Second Inaugural.

This is a speech of tremendous intellectual humility. None of us anticipated this conflict, or its magnitude. All of us “looked for an easier triumph.” None of us are fully in control. “Let us judge not that we be not judged.”

This is a speech of great moral humility. Slavery, Lincoln says, was not a Southern institution, it was an American institution, weaving through our common history for 250 years. The scourge of war, which purges this sin, falls on both sides. Lincoln fought any sense of self-righteous superiority the Northerners might harbor. He rejected any thought that God is a tribal God. He put us all into the same category of ambiguity and fallenness.

This needs to be considered in context. Lincoln grew up in the environment of non-orthodox Christianity. In the theology of non-orthodox Christianity not only is the individual “born again” but born again and again and again. That’s the reason that Arkansans voted Bill Clinton into office first as Lieutenant Governor and then twice as governor. It isn’t that they were unaware of his failings. It was that they forgave him. He transgressed; he said he was sorry; they believed him. That career would not have been possible outside of that context.

We do need either to revive our historic national “narrative” or to formulate a new one. However, I also think Mr. Brooks’s grasp of American history and Christian theology is too weak for him to understand the underpinnings of Lincoln’s Second Inaugural or why his hope for a new American secular religion based on forgiveness and redemption is doomed to disappointment. Repeated forgiveness is incompatible with the lex talionis of post-Christianity, something so evident in the campus demonstrations all over the country, BLM, and other contemporary groups.

Quite to the contrary, IMO never has “e pluribus unum” been so relevant but so hard to achieve. When the country of your birth is just a Skype call away and returning to it just a matter of hours after hopping on a plane, coming to the United States isn’t nearly the commitment it was a century ago. Today coming to the United States is more like commuting to work—no commitment required, least of all to forgiveness and redemption.

The rededication of the last paragraph of Lincoln’s Second Inaugural:

With malice toward none, with charity for all, with firmness in the right as God gives us to see the right, let us strive on to finish the work we are in, to bind up the nation’s wounds, to care for him who shall have borne the battle and for his widow and his orphan, to do all which may achieve and cherish a just and lasting peace among ourselves and with all nations.

demands that you had that commitment to start out with. When I look around me I just don’t see that.

8 comments

Posts from Thanksgivings Past

Here’s a little list of some of my posts from Thanksgivings past from 2004 to 2014:

Thanksgiving 2014

The Unbearable Awfulness of Thanksgiving Movies

Shenandoah at Thankgiving

Cross’s Thanksgiving Proclamation

Thanksgiving Resources

Thanksgiving 2004

1 comment

Leaderless?

With all of the handwringing about Angela Merkel’s inability to form a government after the recent German elections, that pretty well scotches her chance at the title of “leader of the free world”. Trump is so widely despised (at least publicly) that he’s ruled out. Theresa May’s and Emmanuel Macron’s respective problems disqualify them.

The free world such as it is will just need to get by without a leader. I think we’ll get by. I just wish we were freer.

1 comment

Waving a Red Flag in Front of a Whole Herd of Bulls

Well, Marc Thiessen’s Washington Post column is sure to raise the ire of a significant number of the WaPo’s readers:

This Thanksgiving, I am grateful for many things — but when it comes to politics, I am especially thankful that Hillary Clinton is not sitting in the Oval Office.

I am thankful that Neil M. Gorsuch is on the Supreme Court and that President Trump has secured a conservative majority that will protect human life, religious liberty, the Second Amendment and limited government. I am also thankful the president is moving at record pace to fill the federal appeals courts with young conservative judges. While the Supreme Court only hears about 80 cases a year, the federal appeals courts get final say on about 60,000 — and because Democrats ended the filibuster, they can’t stop Trump from filling those courts with conservative legal rock stars. The Senate has already confirmed eight of Trump’s nine appellate nominees — the most this early in a presidency since Richard Nixon – and Trump will appoint plenty more before his first term expires. As former Clinton adviser Ronald A. Klain complained in The Post, “the next two generations of Americans will live under laws interpreted by hundreds of [Trump-appointed] judges.”

I’m not nearly as thankful for all of the things he lists as he is. I have mixed feeling about practically all of them. Perhaps Mr. Thiessen’s column is click-bait and I’ve fallen for it. Is he trolling?

However, in a similar vein there’s one thing I can say I’m thankful for this year. I’m thankful that the president and the federal government generally is getting more critical scrutiny from the media than it has for a a number of years.

3 comments

Africa

In the aftermath of Robert Mugabe’s ouster as Zimbabwe’s president, I’ve been reading a lot of articles about sub-Saharan Africa’s problems that fail to acknowledge some grave issues for the people of those countries:

  1. Africa had problems before it was colonized by Britain, France, Spain, Italy, Germany, Portugal, and Belgium.
  2. Indeed, IMO it was colonized because of those problems.
  3. Mugabe was hailed as an anti-colonialist hero. You see how that turned out.
  4. Whatever of Africa’s problems were caused by colonialism, its biggest problems now are corruption, tribalism, factionalism, and just plain bad government.
  5. That billions of dollars are fleeing the countries of sub-Saharan Africa to fill private accounts in European banks isn’t the fault of the European banks but they’re not helping matters.
  6. Debt is a serious problem for many sub-Saharan countries.
  7. Most of that debt is held by the IMF, the World Bank, European banks, and China.

In fact most of the articles have been poppycock. If you’re going to solve problems, you’ve got to understand what they are.

I also think that the most important thing that the United States could do to help poor, sub-Saharan countries is to end our agricultural subsidies but that’s a topic for another post.

1 comment

It’s Dismal Alright But Is It Science?

At the LA Times scholar John Ioannidis leaps to the defense of economics:

The financial crises of the past two decades, and our failure to predict them, have wreaked havoc on more than just the global economy. The bursting of the dot-com bubble in 2000, the Enron scandal and the global financial crisis of 2008 have led to a loss of faith in economics itself.

But these crises and scandals do not mean that the science of economics is inherently unreliable. Most of them occurred because we ignored what we knew.

He goes on to point out two of the problems: people with lots of money don’t necessarily know anything about economics and, consequently, are not good sources of economic advice and politicians are even worse.

To these I would add three more. First, economics is inherently politicized. Anything that involves money inevitably will be. The second is something I complain about routinely here: you will always find economists who are willing to twist their economic judgment to further political goals.

The last issue is that economics is only weakly predictive. We can calculate with enormous precision what it takes to put a satellite into orbit or produce a pharmaceutical. Economists can generally tell you the directionality of events but can’t tell you how much or when with any precision.

That’s still useful because it gives you insight into the domain of the likely outcomes of this change or that. Perhaps if economists become more empirical things will get better but that hasn’t been the trajectory of economics for the last century. That’s been more towards mathematicalization than about observation.

7 comments

Candidates for Neologism of the Year (Updated)

I’m taking nominations for neologism of the year. As you presumably know, “neologism” is a big word for a new word. So far the best I’ve heard (read, actually) is “Clintenacious”.

Update

Candidates proposed:

Turkollusion
Brexit
antifa

6 comments

Always With Us

At City Journal Kay S. Hymowitz explains why problems of poverty among children as so persistent in the United States:

Articles about America’s high levels of child poverty are a media evergreen. Here’s a typical entry, courtesy of the New York Times’s Eduardo Porter: “The percentage of children who are poor is more than three times as high in the United States as it is in Norway or the Netherlands. America has a larger proportion of poor children than Russia.” That’s right: Russia.

Outrageous as they seem, the assertions are true—at least in the sense that they line up with official statistics from government agencies and reputable nongovernmental organizations like the OECD and UNICEF. International comparisons of the sort that Porter makes, though, should be accompanied by a forest of asterisks. Data limitations, varying definitions of poverty, and other wonky problems are rampant in these discussions.

The lousy child-poverty numbers should come with another qualifying asterisk, pointing to a very American reality. Before Europe’s recent migration crisis, the United States was the only developed country consistently to import millions of very poor, low-skilled families, from some of the most destitute places on earth—especially from undeveloped areas of Latin America—into its communities, schools, and hospitals. Let’s just say that Russia doesn’t care to do this—and, until recently, Norway and the Netherlands didn’t, either. Both policymakers and pundits prefer silence on the relationship between America’s immigration system and poverty, and it’s easy to see why. The subject pushes us headlong into the sort of wrenching trade-offs that politicians and advocates prefer to avoid. Here’s the problem in a nutshell: you can allow mass low-skilled immigration, which many on the left and the right—and probably most poverty mavens—consider humane and quintessentially American. But if you do, pursuing the equally humane goal of substantially reducing child poverty becomes a lot harder.

You’d think this would be obvious but it’s amazing how many obvious things need explanation these days. A quarter of poor children are immigrants or the children of immigrants. If you have a way of ameliorating that while continuing to import a large population of people without skills that pay good wages or command of English, I’m all ears.

7 comments

Moore Problems

I don’t know what’s going to happen in Alabama’s special election. I hope that Roy Moore is not elected but you never can tell. I wouldn’t vote for him.

However, I strongly suspect that anybody who’s banking on the Senate to act where the people of Alabama did not is doomed to disappointment. Contrary to popular opinion (including among Senators), the Senate does not have the power to refuse to seat an elected member, cf. Powell v. McCormack. The Senate might be able to get the House to impeach him and then try him and remove him from office. I doubt the Senate will do that.

12 comments