Better Than Either and Better Than Nothing

I tend to agree with the editors’ of the Washington Post’s ideas about the tax reform bills now in reconciliation:

The first step to a less-bad agreement would be to excise extraneous provisions tacked onto one bill or the other in order to pay off a particular lawmaker or to satisfy narrow ideological preoccupations. The Senate bill eliminates Obamacare’s individual mandate, a big step toward repealing Obamacare without any sufficient replacement policy included or promised, and it allows drilling in the precious Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. These should go. The House bill would open a gigantic campaign-cash loophole that in the name of “religious freedom” would enable people to funnel vast amounts of dark money into politics and claim a tax deduction for it. Strike that, too.

Next, bicameral negotiators should reduce the impact on the debt by scaling back the most unjustifiable giveaways to the wealthy. Rather than lowering the top individual income tax rate, they should agree to keep it at 39.6 percent, as the House bill would. Rather than accepting the House proposal to eliminate the estate tax, which applies only to very wealthy heirs, they should keep it as is — or, if they must help the idle rich, adopt the Senate’s idea to pare it back temporarily. They should accept the Senate’s plan to maintain the individual alternative minimum tax, which ensures that wealthy wage earners cannot use loopholes to entirely escape paying a fair share.

Negotiators should take up President Trump on his willingness to drop the 35 percent corporate tax rate to 22 percent, rather than the 20 percent each bill currently prescribes. Instead of spending the extra cash, they should use the savings to limit the damage GOP tax cuts would do to the nation’s already stretched budget.

Finally, negotiators should soften their blatant attacks on Democratic states and other constituencies Republicans have singled out for punishment. Instead of chopping away at the deduction for state and local taxes, which would target taxpayers in blue states, they should reduce tax breaks in a fairer way, perhaps by further limiting the home mortgage deduction. The House bill, for example, would cap the applicability of the mortgage deduction at $500,000 in loans. And negotiators should drop all of the provisions in each bill that would slam universities and their students. These provisions raise little money, serving primarily as shortsighted legislative assaults on the country’s crucial institutions of learning and innovation.

First and foremost that’s how our legislative process is supposed to work. The best parts of the bills passed by the House and Senate should make it into the final legislation. And laws should be limited to a single matter rather than the everything but the kitchen sink bills that have been normalized by the excessively partisan process that legislation has become.

Democrats should stop engaging in sophistry and come to terms with the reality that removing money from the private sector reduces private sector growth. And they need to realize that the Supreme Court victory of the Affordable Care Act was pyrrhic. Declaring the individual mandate a tax meant that putting it into a tax bill was not unreasonable.

Republicans should come to terms with the equal reality that increased debt reduces economic growth, too. I also think that Republicans will be disappointed in just how little growth reducing the personal income tax rates will produce. I’ve written about that in length so I see no reason to repeat those arguments here.

0 comments

Walking to School

The first couple of times I went to kindergarten my mom walked me there. It was a little less than a mile away, through a tough urban sort of neighborhood. After that I walked there by myself. When my younger siblings started school, we all walked together.

After we left the gritty neighborhood where I spent my first decade, I also walked to school. It was 2-3 miles away from our new house in our new neighborhood. For the first two years of high school I either took what is now called the MetroBus but was then called the Bi-State Transit Authority or I walked. It was about eight miles. Eight miles is a rather long walk but the bus pass cost $5 a week and when I walked I could save the money and buy books.

I just read the statistic that only 9% of kids these days walk to school. I don’t know whether to believe that or not but I can think of several reasons that might be including more people have cars, more school systems use buses than used to be the case, schools are farther way for most kids than they used to be, or parents are afraid of letting their children walk to school. I don’t know whether that fear is justified or not. For most people it couldn’t possibly be more dangerous than my walk to school was.

One big difference might be that my parents both walked to school through urban neighborhoods so they didn’t think anything of it. The suburbs can be corrupting.

5 comments

Who?

Given free rein if you were the Editor-in-Chief of Time who would you name Person of the Year? Just about every suggestion I’ve seen so far has bordered on the unhinged.

7 comments

Take Religion Seriously

I have no remarks about Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission other than to note that it is an instance of the inability of many Americans to take religion seriously. The purpose of the free exercise clause is to create legal space to enable people to do what their religion demands that they do. The assertion that religion is merely a pretext for bigoted behavior is an explicit violation of the other part of the majority decision in Obergefell v. Hodges which said in part:

…many who deem same-sex marriage to be wrong reach that conclusion based on decent and honorable religious or philosophical premises . . . But when that sincere, personal opposition becomes enacted law and public policy, the necessary consequence is to put the imprimatur of the State itself on an exclusion that soon demeans or stigmatizes those whose own liberty is then denied.

I don’t know how the Court will find. We’re in new territory here and I believe that as a society we would be better served if we considered the questions opened by O v. H with understanding rather than impugning of motives.

9 comments

The Logan Act. The Logan Act?

At USA Today Bush Administration functionary James Robbins calls for, presumably, the Democrats and anti-Trumpers and, indeed, the entire country to move on from what he deems the “Russia collusion fantasy”:

On Friday, President Trump’s former national security adviser, Michael Flynn, pleaded guilty to lying to federal investigators about a perfectly legal conversation he had during the presidential transition with then-Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak.

Flynn should not have lied, and why he chose to remains a mystery, but the substance of the single-count indictment against Flynn shows that special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation has strayed far from its original purpose.

We have come down quite a way from the hyperventilation about Russia “hacking the election” a year ago. What happened to Democratic Sen. Mark Warner’s claim, later promoted by Hillary Clinton, that there were 1,000 Russian agents planting anti-Hillary fake news stories in key swing states? Or that Russians had delivered Wisconsin to Trump? All the conspiracy theorists have so far are a few Facebook ads that can’t credibly be shown to have changed even one vote.

This morning the New York Times features on op-ed calling for prosecution of members of the Trump transition team under the Logan Act and a piece at the Washington Examiner documents how this has been a talking point for the Democratic leadership since the Republican convention:

The documents outlining Michael Flynn’s guilty plea in the Trump-Russia investigation do not allege collusion or conspiracy between the Trump campaign and Russia to influence the 2016 election. They do, however, suggest that the Obama Justice Department was intensely interested in Flynn’s discussions with Russian ambassador Sergey Kislyak about policy issues — sanctions against Russia, a United Nations resolution on Israel — during the presidential transition, when Barack Obama was still in the White House and Donald Trump was preparing to take office.

At the time, top Justice officials suspected Flynn of violating the Logan Act, the 218-year-old law under which no one has ever been prosecuted, that prohibits private citizens from acting on behalf of the United States in disputes with foreign governments. Starting in the summer of 2016 and intensifying in the transition period, the Logan Act, while mostly unknown to the general public, became a hot topic of conversation among some Democrats. A number of lawmakers, former officials, and commentators called on the Obama administration to investigate the Trump team for a possible Logan Act violations — and to do it while Democrats still controlled the executive branch.

At the same time, inside the Obama Justice Department, it appears the Logan Act became a paramount concern among some key officials in the critical weeks of December 2016 and January 2017. Former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates has told Congress that the Logan Act was the first reason she intervened in the Flynn case — the reason FBI agents were sent to the White House to interview Flynn in the Trump administration’s early days. It was that interview, held on Jan. 24, 2017, that ultimately led to Flynn’s guilty plea.

In short, there’s no doubt the Logan Act, a law dismissed as a joke or an archaic irrelevancy or simply unconstitutional by many legal experts, played a central role in the Obama administration’s aggressive and enormously consequential investigation of its successor.

Democrats began accusing Trump of Logan Act violations in the summer of 2016, immediately after the Republican convention, when Trump sarcastically invited Russia to produce the 30,000-plus emails that Hillary Clinton deleted rather than turn over to investigators. “Russia, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing,” Trump said during a July 27 news conference. “I think that you will probably be rewarded mightily by our press — let’s see if that happens, that’ll be nice.”

The next day, Tom Vilsack, Obama’s secretary of agriculture and on Hillary Clinton’s vice presidential short list, accused Trump of violating the Logan Act. “That’s a no-no, you can’t do that,” Vilsack said. “That’s not legal.”

Following Vilsack was Democratic Sen. Claire McCaskill. “I believe it violates the Logan Act,” McCaskill said, “and I think he should be investigated for that.”

House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi called Trump’s statement “a treasonous act.” Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid said it “borders on treason.”

Harvard Law professor Laurence Tribe weighed in the next day. “The Logan Act, which was enacted back in 1799 and fundamentally says that you cannot engage in negotiations with a foreign power,” Tribe told MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell. “It hasn’t been used, but that’s because we haven’t had very many Donald Trumps, thank God, in our history. I think he’s violated that act.”

On Aug. 3, two more Democratic senators, Chris Coons and Sheldon Whitehouse, called for a hearing on Trump and the Logan Act. “Mr. Trump’s comments implicate U.S. criminal laws prohibiting engagement with foreign governments that threaten the country’s interests, including the Logan Act and the Espionage Act,” they wrote.

On Aug. 9, Democratic Reps. Patrick Murphy, Andre Carson, and Eric Swalwell called for a House hearing to examine whether Trump violated the Logan Act, among other statutes.

In September, Rep. John Conyers, the top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, asked the FBI’s then-director, James Comey, whether the bureau was investigating Trump for a possible violation of the Logan Act. Comey declined to answer.

At that same hearing, another Democrat, Rep. Ted Deutch, asked Comey about reports that sometime Trump foreign policy advisory board member Carter Page traveled to Moscow in July 2016. “If an American citizen, Director Comey, conducted meetings with a Russian individual who has been sanctioned by the United States about potential weakening of U.S. sanctions policy, in violation of the Logan Act, would the FBI investigate?” Deutch asked.

“I don’t think it’s appropriate to answer that,” Comey responded.

There wasn’t much public discussion of the Logan Act in October and November, as the campaign reached its final weeks and the political world dealt with the shock of Trump’s victory. The subject re-emerged in December as Democrats, stunned and angry, watched Trump prepare for the presidency — and prepare to undo many of Obama’s policies.

On Dec. 8, Democratic Rep. Jared Huffman introduced the “One President at a Time Act of 2016.” The bill would have amended the Logan Act to specify that a president-elect, or anyone acting on a president-elect’s behalf, was specifically subject to its restrictions. The bill “just makes it explicitly clear that the president-elect is just like every other private citizen during the transition period,” Huffmann told MSNBC’s O’Donnell. “They can’t go around purporting to conduct U.S. foreign policy.”

On Dec. 20, Reps. Conyers and Sheila Jackson Lee asked the Justice Department to investigate Trump for a possible violation of the Logan Act.

On Dec. 22, former Obama State Department official Wendy Sherman told MSNBC that Trump’s actions on a UN resolution concerning Israeli settlements implicated the Logan Act. “People have said to me today it crosses the line of the Logan Act,” Sherman said. “We have one president at a time. And Donald Trump is really playing with fire.”

On the day Sherman appeared, Flynn spoke on the phone with Kislyak about that pending U.N. resolution concerning Israeli settlements. “Flynn informed the Russian ambassador about the incoming administration’s opposition to the resolution, and requested that Russia vote against or delay the resolution,” said the “Statement of the Offense,” the Mueller document released with Flynn’s guilty plea. The next day, Dec. 23, the two men spoke again and Kislyak informed Flynn that Russia would not do as the Trump team requested.

A few days later, on Dec. 29, Flynn and Kislyak spoke again, according to the Mueller statement. This time the subject was the new sanctions Obama imposed on Russia in retaliation for election meddling. Flynn “requested that Russia not escalate the situation and only respond to the U.S. sanctions in a reciprocal manner.”

Two days later, on Dec. 31, Kislyak called Flynn to say that “Russia had chosen not to retaliate in response to Flynn’s request.”

U.S. intelligence agencies recorded the calls; Kislyak was the subject of American monitoring, so a wiretap on him on these occasions picked up Flynn, too. It appears Obama administration officials immediately saw the Flynn-Kislyak conversations as a possible Logan Act violation. They knew, of course, that given the history of the law, a Logan Act prosecution was a virtual impossibility. They knew that many foreign policy experts would see such contacts between an incoming administration and a foreign power as an acceptable and normal course of business in a presidential transition. Nevertheless, approaching the Flynn-Kislyak talks in the context of a criminal violation — the Logan Act — gave the Obama team a pretense to target Flynn, and thus the new Trump administration.

I’m on record as saying that, if members of the Trump transition team are prosecuted under the Logan Act, it would mark the end of the republic. Over the years I’ve probably mentioned the Logan Act as frequently as anybody. What is it and what would be the implications of a prosecution of Trump transition team members under the Logan Act?

The Logan Act was enacted in 1799 as a response to George Logan’s entering into negotations with France. Logan was a pacifist state legislator from Pennsylvania. Here’s the text of the act:

Any citizen of the United States, wherever he may be, who, without authority of the United States, directly or indirectly commences or carries on any correspondence or intercourse with any foreign government or any officer or agent thereof, with intent to influence the measures or conduct of any foreign government or of any officer or agent thereof, in relation to any disputes or controversies with the United States, or to defeat the measures of the United States, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both.

This section shall not abridge the right of a citizen to apply himself, or his agent, to any foreign government, or the agents thereof, for redress of any injury which he may have sustained from such government or any of its agents or subjects.

In its 218 year history no one has ever been convicted of breaking the Logan Act and there has been only two indictments under the act, one in 1803, of a Kentucky farmer who advocated federation of Kentucky with France, and the other in 1852 of an American merchant who negotiated authorization with Mexico to build a railway in Mexico. It is widely considered both obsolete and an unconstitutional violation of the freedom of speech.

Since then lots of accusations have been flung around but none are really substantive; they’re invariably politically motivated.

As to why I think an actual prosecution under the Logan Act would be so divisive, consider the list of Americans who’ve ever had direct contacts with agencies or representatives of foreign countries when they were not official representatives of the U. S. government. The list includes every living former president, every president-elect, and many other prominent Americans including:

Jimmy Carter
George H. W. Bush
Bill Clinton
George W. Bush
Barack Obama
Hillary Clinton
Rev. Jesse Jackson
Al Gore

Most CEOs of large companies have violated the Logan Act; indeed, any American tourist who’s ever gone into a post office in another country may have violated the act.

A prosecution under the Logan Act would be a purely political act and a pretext for embarrassing and/or removing the president; it would be barratry and would invite if not demand reprisals. No presidential transition team that ever accepted a congratulatory phone call from overseas would ever be safe from prosecution which is to say none of them.

14 comments

Drinking Spree

Apparently it isn’t just “Florida man” who gets into all sorts of unlikely situations. If this report from ABC is to be believed so do Florida possums:

FORT WALTON BEACH, Fla. — An opossum that apparently drank bourbon after breaking into a Florida liquor store sobered up at a wildlife rescue center and was released unharmed.

Emerald Coast Wildlife Refuge officials say the opossum was brought in by a Fort Walton Beach, Florida, police officer on Nov. 24. A liquor store employee found the animal next to a broken and empty bottle of bourbon.

“A worker there found the opossum up on a shelf next to a cracked open bottle of liquor with nothing in it,” said Michelle Pettis, a technician at the refuge. “She definitely wasn’t fully acting normal.”

Pettis told the Panama City News Herald the female opossum appeared disoriented, was excessively salivating and was pale. The staff pumped the marsupial full of fluids and cared for her as she sobered up.

“We loaded her up with fluids to help flush out any alcohol toxins,” Pettis said. “She was good a couple of days later.”

Pettis says the opossum did not appear to have a hangover.

I just don’t know what to think of this younger generation of possums. Why would Pogo say? Maybe “Lookin’ back on things, the view always improves.”

3 comments

State and Local Governments as Pension Plan

Increasing state and local governments are transmogrifying into public employee pension plans with the power to levy taxes to the detriment of all of their other functions. At Democracy Richard Vague proposes some solutions:

  1. Let the Feds pick up the tab.
  2. Lower funding requirements.

The first sounds to me like a license to steal and the second sounds like denial.

I haven’t studied the spending of every state but I am pretty familiar with Illinois’s. Here are my counter-proposals. No solution to Illinois’s particular problems in this area can be understood except in the understanding of the reality that between 1995 and 2010 Illinois froze the contributions to public employee pension plans while increasing public employee wages sharply. And many public employees in Illinois don’t contribute at all to their retirements. Their jurisdictions pick up both the government’s and the employee’s share of pension contributions and they’re exempt from paying FICA.

  1. The state’s constitution must be amended to allow the state to deal with the situation.
  2. All public employees should immediately be transferred to a defined contribution plan. #1 is necessary for #2 to happen.
  3. Double-dipping should be banned.
  4. An absolute cap should be established for Illinois public pensions. Here there are some retired public employees collecting more than $1 million per year in pensions.
  5. Public employees unions should be banned from engaging in political activity. This is an obviously corrupt practice.

Even those draconian measures won’t be enough to save Illinois. The state can’t even muster the political courage to enact regular budgets let alone deal with the massive pension overhang. It can increase tax rates but it can’t force people to stay.

9 comments

It’s All About Power

At The Hills Kimberley Wiehle notes in an op-ed that at least Hollywood and the media have purged some of its sexual predators, a far better record than politics:

Lately, a slew of sexual-misconduct accusations have been leveled against powerful men in Hollywood and the media, as well as in politics and the law. It’s the #MeToo moment.

While the alleged sexual predators in the first two categories have been paying the ultimate professional price — getting canned and banned — the situation is different when it comes to politicians and judges. Those guys have been getting away with it.

Perhaps that’s because in the final analysis entertainment and infotainment are about making money while politics is about wielding power and, as Charles Dudley Warner observed well over a century ago, it makes strange bedfellows. Having your CEO revealed as a sexual predator can hurt the bottom line for a business. Not so in politics.

2 comments

Too Soon We Get Old

At The Federalist Saritha Prabhu closely parallels my own views:

My awakening came accidentally when I realized in 2016 that I just couldn’t support Hillary Clinton (I ended up protest-voting for Gary Johnson). I thought Clinton was arrogant, entitled, corrupt, and dishonest. I couldn’t believe the Democratic Party would nominate someone who was the subject of an FBI investigation.

But as 2016 rolled on, I became quietly incensed. I couldn’t help noticing repeatedly that the mainstream media was shielding and enabling Clinton in her dissembling and media avoidance. I noticed that the commentators at CNN, MSNBC, and the NYT either ignored or made light of Clinton’s many problem areas: the private email server, compromising of state secrets, and the questionable multimillion-dollar donations to the Clinton Foundation. (Yes, the Times broke the story in 2015 about Clinton’s personal email account, but I’m talking here about its 2016 treatment of her candidacy.)

Read the whole thing.

I’m not a liberal but I’m a Democrat. I couldn’t support Hillary Clinton for president. Like Ms. Prabhu I protest-voted for Gary Johnson. I agree with her assessment of Hillary Clinton’s character. I agree that the DNC erred in foisting her upon the party as its standard-bearer in 2016.

Where I differ is that it didn’t come as a bolt from the blue for me. I’ve recognized the incredible bias of our major media outlets for some time.

I can’t bear to watch television news. I get my news by reading a sample of newspapers, hoping to separate the chaff, editorial opinion presented as news, from the wheat, actual news. I don’t honestly see how ordinary sane Americans who don’t follow things as closely as I do, God love them, can possibly do so.

11 comments

What Do You Think of the Trump Tax Reform?

Let’s have a little poll. How much net economic growth per year in the United States will be produced by the tax reform soon to be enacted into law?

  1. 10%
  2. 1%
  3. .1%
  4. Zero
  5. Negative growth

I think the answer is C. It will produce a little growth but nothing like what its proponents have claimed.

9 comments