Observations on the Middle East

There are a couple of points I couldn’t work into my last post that I want to include here. I tend to think that the simplest explanations are best and I think that the greatest single problem in the Arab world is factionalism. In that light the Arab world’s problem isn’t Israel or colonialism. Those are just pretexts and they’re explained by factionalism rather than causing it. The Arab world’s tyrannical leaders exploit the factionalism to promote their own power and wealth.

The second point is that Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Turkey are all vying for leadership of the Muslim world and there can be only one. Don’t expect any lasting alliance between Iran and Turkey. Their interests are opposed. And each of their interests coincide only tangentially with ours.

And even less don’t expect a Muslim world to unite against us or anybody else on anything but the most temporary of bases.

1 comment

Separating the Wheat From the Chaff

An enormous amount has been written about President Trump’s announcement about the U. S.’s moving its embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. Almost all of it has been completely predictable and I haven’t learned a great deal from it other than that Tom Friedman is a terrible negotiator.

The one piece that I liked was Shadi Hamid’s piece at the Atlantic. He opens with something that is obvious but, judging from the opinion pieces I’ve read, may come to many as a bolt from the blue—other Arab leaders don’t give a darn about the Palestinians:

Most Arab countries won’t care much about Donald Trump’s recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, which might seem counterintuitive. The official announcement, though, comes at an important and peculiar time, when Arab regimes—particularly Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, and Egypt—find themselves more aligned than ever with Israel on regional priorities. They all share, along with the Trump administration, a near obsession with Iran as the source of the region’s evils; a dislike, and even hatred, of the Muslim Brotherhood; and an opposition to the intent and legacy of the Arab Spring.

and he closes with an expression of bewilderment or, possibly, rhetorical opposition:

To be sure, Arabs are preoccupied with their own domestic problems, and the centrality of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has always been overstated. But the status of Jerusalem, Islam’s third holiest site, has a way of resonating and sharpening divides. Why even test the proposition? Trump’s move on Jerusalem isn’t the end of the world or even the end of the peace process—which has been a fiction for some time now—but why give extremists or even non-extremists another way to stoke anti-American sentiment? Why further undermine an already undermined Palestinian Authority? If only there were Arab governments that were confident, cared about actual Muslims, and could reflect and convey the frustration that no doubt many Arabs will be feeling in the days and weeks ahead. That Arab world, as we’ve been reminded this week, does not exist.

Why, indeed? What does Trump want to accomplish by the move? Maybe, as his detractors could claim, it’s just another irrational tropism by Trump. Just for fun let’s assume it isn’t.

I tend to believe that domestic politics is always the best explanation of an American president’s actions whether in domestic policy or foreign policy. In the U. S. Israel is a wedge issue, dividing some Jews and evangelicals on the one hand from other Jews and progressives on the other. The Republican Party has been expressing unswerving support for Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu and Likud for some time. The move may just be another step in that direction.

What message if any would the move send to the Chinese? It might be that Trump isn’t Clinton, Bush, or Obama.

I continue to have no opinion on this issue but the implications of this story for American politics and policy does interest me.

17 comments

Getting Rid of the Tyrant But Not the Tyranny

At RealClearWorld Martin Van Staden notes with apparent dismay that reforming Zimbabwe requires more than ousting its long-time ruler, Robert Mugabe:

The end of Robert Mugabe’s rule in Zimbabwe has sparked hope among the people and the Zimbabwean diaspora. It is unfortunate, however, that the personality of Mugabe, rather than Zimbabwe’s dearth of institutions, has been declared as the principle barrier to the country’s progress. Zimbabweans don’t need simply to trade one despot for another. They need real property rights and a limited government.

but I’m afraid that he doesn’t realize the magnitude of the problem. Governments are like fruit trees or grave vines. They must be grafted onto native root stock to thrive and when a country has no native institutional basis for an independent court system, the rule of law, or the protection of minority rights it is unlikely that anything that we would recognize as a liberal democratic government will flourish there.

Mr. Van Staden observes, correctly, that the War of the American Revolution was exceptional:

A constant mistake made in postcolonial societies is to grant the incoming revolutionary regime broad powers to correct wrongs of the colonial past. One of the exceptions to this rule was when the United States was decolonized in 1776. The liberators recognized that the Constitution was not a transient instrument meant to fix the present problems faced by society, and thus appreciated that it needed to constrain the potential tyranny of future regimes. They created a political dispensation that has more or less survived for over 200 years by consciously setting out to limit government. Government was not to be empowered, but rather the people.

but I don’t think he recognizes how exceptional. The American Revolution was a conservative one in the sense that colonials thought they had the rights of Englishmen and sought to restore them. They didn’t blame all of their problems on colonialism. By the time the Revolution broke out the institutions on which the new Republic were founded had developed over a period of centuries.

I don’t have a pat solution for Zimbabe and the other countries of sub-Saharan Africa or the Middle East or South America or even Russia, Romania, or Hungary. They need better institutions and those don’t grow overnight. My concern is more with my own country where many want to counter the failing of corrupt, venal, and self-serving state and local governments by turning more power over to a corrupt, venal, and self-serving federal government. It’s easier to overturn old institutions than it is to grow new ones.

5 comments

The New Difficulty of Writing Blog Posts

You know it’s getting darned hard to write blog posts without defending Trump or appearing to defend him, something I don’t care to do. For example consider the conclusion of this post at Ozy by John McLaughlin:

When it comes to the Middle East, Trump has created a lot of sound, fury and drama, but much of this is either unfinished, uncertain or unwise. Overall, the region is no more stable than when Trump came to power, and in some ways the region’s volatility may even be increasing.

Consider a list of post-war presidents:

Truman
Eisenhower
Kennedy
Johnson
Nixon
Ford
Carter
Reagan
Bush I
Clinton
Bush II
Obama

After which of their terms of office was the Middle East more stable than when he assumed office? I think there’s a reasonable argument that the answer is none of them. It’s too early to tell with Trump but IMO believing he will bring more stability to the Middle East where 70 years of American presidents have failed is wishful thinking.

There’s plenty of things to blame Trump for without complaining that he’s no more successful than other American presidents.

15 comments

Just Because

Just because you’re a lawyer it doesn’t mean you’re a good lawyer. Right now I’m having an argument with a lawyer in the comments of another blog about whether the states can sue the federal government over matters relating to the enforcement of state law. My understanding is that states have special standing WRT suing the federal government regarding matters of enforcing state law.

Among other things I believe that this means that states could impose a state payroll tax analogous to FICA that would apply to federal employees working in those states. I doubt that states could require the federal government to pay the employer side of such a tax but even on that I’m not sure. It would be an interesting test.

14 comments

The Web

The New York Times explains the web of friends and connections that Harvey Weinstein used to maintain his pattern of abuse over decades:

Harvey Weinstein built his complicity machine out of the witting, the unwitting and those in between. He commanded enablers, silencers and spies, warning others who discovered his secrets to say nothing. He courted those who could provide the money or prestige to enhance his reputation as well as his power to intimidate.

In the weeks and months before allegations of his methodical abuse of women were exposed in October, Mr. Weinstein, the Hollywood producer, pulled on all the levers of his carefully constructed apparatus.

He gathered ammunition, sometimes helped by the editor of The National Enquirer, who had dispatched reporters to find information that could undermine accusers. He turned to old allies, asking a partner in Creative Artists Agency, one of Hollywood’s premier talent shops, to broker a meeting with a C.A.A. client, Ronan Farrow, who was reporting on Mr. Weinstein. He tried to dispense favors: While seeking to stop the actress Rose McGowan from writing in a memoir that he had sexually assaulted her, he tried to arrange a $50,000 payment to her former manager and throw new business to a literary agent advising Ms. McGowan. The agent, Lacy Lynch, replied to him in an email: “No one understands smart, intellectual and commercial like HW.”

Mr. Weinstein’s final, failed round of manipulations shows how he operated for more than three decades: by trying to turn others into instruments or shields for his behavior, according to nearly 200 interviews, internal company records and previously undisclosed emails. Some aided his actions without realizing what he was doing. Many knew something or detected hints, though few understood the scale of his sexual misconduct. Almost everyone had incentives to look the other way or reasons to stay silent. Now, even as the tally of Mr. Weinstein’s alleged misdeeds is still emerging, so is a debate about collective failure and the apportioning of blame.

The capper is in the concluding quote from investor Paul Tudor Jones:

“I love you,” he wrote, while detailing the steps Mr. Weinstein should take to rehabilitate his image. Mr. Jones told The Times that he condemned Mr. Weinstein’s alleged misconduct and wanted to encourage him to get help.

“Focus on the future as America loves a great comeback story,” he wrote to the movie producer.

He finished: “The good news is, this will go away sooner than you think and it will be forgotten!”

If you think that Harvey Weinstein is an isolated instance, you’re kidding yourself. The victims are not limited to young women thirsty for stardom but extend to young men and children as well. The pattern of abuse is endemic and widespread in Hollywood, as we refer to the modern entertainment industry, and any honest person in the business would tell you so. It’s not new. It began in the very earliest days of Hollywood.

Hollywood is incapable of policing itself and unless the incentives change or preventive measures are imposed on it, Mr. Jones is right.

1 comment

Rebuild Our Economic Strength

I honestly do not believe that I have ever read a bigger load of codswallop than in this post by Dan Blumenthal at The Hill:

Since the Cold War, the United States has divested itself of its strategic-level political warfare capabilities. It needs to rebuild those to prepare for an intensification of the “three warfares” should a conflict arise, push back now against the tenuous claims of China’s inevitable “rise,” and begin to target the regime with an information campaign that saps its morale and takes advantage of the Chinese population’s deep mistrust of Chinese political leaders. In other words, while Washington must reverse its military decline, it also has ways, as yet undeveloped, to counter China’s attempts to “win without fighting.”

What we need to do is revitalize the American economy. As long as that’s strong we have nothing to worry about from China. Without that not only can’t we support our enormous military machine, it will be of no use to us.

U. S. geopolitical strength is based on economic strength. There is no substitute for it.

3 comments

The Wisdom of Crowds

At RealClearDefense Bonnie Kristian outlines three areas where veterans and the public are in agreement:

  1. Veterans and the public are not convinced post-9/11 foreign policy made us more secure.
  2. Veterans and the public are not happy with how the military is managed.
  3. Veterans and the public do not want the executive branch waging war without end.

There are a few much more fundamental areas of American foreign policy I wish had been addressed. First, how much security is enough? Perfect security is beyond our reach. We need to come to terms with reality that today, tomorrow, and ever after we will be dealing with some level of risk. IMO that risk should not extend to Saudi tourists and students seizing airliners and using them to destroy buildings or unhappy Chechen refugees setting off IEDs during marathons but there’s a host of other risks we’ll just need to learn to tolerate.

Second, is American hegemony one of our goals or even our primary goal? I think that other countries’ having their own foreign policies is completely acceptable but my perception is that quite a few Americans, many in the foreign policy establishment, don’t agree.

To what degree should we accept the foreign policies of other countries as our own? Does Saudi Arabia’s war with Yemen further U. S. foreign policy interests? I don’t see how. How about a “Greater Israel”?

To what degree should doing good and punishing evil in the world be American foreign policy, particularly American military policy? I’ve referred to this as the “Batman model” of America’s role in the world. I don’t have a Wilsonian bone in my body but I recognize that for many Americans that’s a central component of what we should be doing.

1 comment

Affordable Health Care

You might want to read Scott Atlas’s thoughts on genuinely affordable health care at Defining Ideas. He proposes three different sets of changes:

  1. Incentivize and equip consumers to consider price.
  2. Strategically increase the supply of medical care to stimulate competition.
  3. Introduce the right incentives into the tax code.

While I think he’s on the right general track, I’m afraid that even if fully adopted those measures would prove inadequate. Basically, the evidence that people make prudent choices about health care, regardless of incentives is weak. They economize in ways that increase long term costs and fail to economize when it would make sense. They assume that increased care can make up for reckless behavior.

You can have fee for services or you can have physicians determining the course of treatment. The sad reality is that if you have both, there’s no practical way to control costs while preserving reasonable levels of public health.

Let’s define our terms. I think that health care should be deemed unaffordable in any system in which spending on health care rises faster than spending outside of health care. Who pays is less important than how much.

Most of the argument over the last decade has been over who pays. IMO that’s misdirection, sleight of hand.

3 comments

Increasing Domestic Investment

At Bloomberg View Tyler Cowen has noticed something about the emergent Trump Administration policies:

I’ve seen hundreds of articles on President Donald Trump and trade, but the real significance of the Trump economic revolution — for better or worse — is a focus on investment. There is no coordinating mastermind, but if you consider the intersection between what the Trumpian nationalists want and what a Republican Congress will deliver, it’s this: wanting to make the U.S. a new and dominant center for investment, including at the expense of other nations.

Read the whole thing.

That would be exactly the right policy. My dissatisfaction with present economic policy, whether taxes or trade, is that it doesn’t do enough to encourage honest to gosh domestic business investment. Where the Bush tax cuts fell short was that they proceeded under the incorrect assumption that there had been a shortfall in personal consumption expenditures. There hadn’t been. As I said at the time there was a shortfall in business investment.

Right now there are at least two gold rushes going on. One is in artificial intelligence. Another is in blockchain. I’m skeptical that either will produce the enormous economic growth that the business investment in personal computers and networking made in the 1980s and early 1990s did in the late 1990s and early Aughts but who knows? I’m darned sure that money chasing itself in the financial sector will inflate balance sheets but won’t produce the sort of economic growth that we need.

4 comments