Inputs, Outputs, and the Military

One of the earliest subjects on which I posted and to which I’ve returned from time to time over the years is Gammon’s Law. To refresh your memory Gammon’s Law is the rule of thumb that in a bureaucratic organization as expenditures increase production decreases. It’s been identified in education by Milton Friedman, in health care (the “law” was first enunciated in Gammon’s analysis of British National Health), and other organizations.

Does it apply to the military? How would you define production in the military? How can it be measured?

3 comments

Forgetting

I want to encourage you to read Rich Karlgaard’s interview of George Gilder at Forbes. Here’s a snippet:

In my last book, The Scandal of Money, I talk about governments having forgotten what money is for and how it works. As a result, they’re issuing more and more of it, on the assumption that somehow money constitutes wealth, instead of realizing that money measures wealth. Now, the biggest industry in the world economy is the $5.1 trillion per day currency-trading carnival, which, in the end, doesn’t even yield stable currencies. It doesn’t even provide a measuring stick for entrepreneurial activities. So I think it’s perfectly possible for people to blind themselves to the real sources of their progress and prosperity.

Other topics discussed include that technology isn’t inevitable, the importance of changes at the margin, consolidation, blockchain, student loans, Elon Musk (“the Elmer Gantry of Silicon Valley”, an apposite characterization), “nerd fascism”, peak Google, artificial intelligence, and autonomous vehicles. My favorite passage from the interview is this:

The advances in machine learning that Google trumpets and preens about are really just advances in the speed of processing. The Google guys woke up with a Moore’s Law bonanza from the chip industry and imagined that they had invented it.

Gordon Moore himself has said that Moore’s Law is running out of gas.

1 comment

The Triumph of the Plutocratic Technocrats

Michael Barone has noticed that what I’ve been predicting is happening. From his piece at RealClearPolitics:

Modest-income Jews used to be the key group in New York. White married homeowners were it in Los Angeles. “Bungalow ward” ethnics dominated in Chicago. In time, they faced challenges from candidates with nonwhite political bases — blacks, Puerto Ricans and Dominicans in New York, Mexicans in Los Angeles, and blacks and Hispanics in Chicago. Now gentry liberals are on top.

This reflects demographic change. Blacks have been moving from central cities to suburbs and the South. Mexican immigrant inflow largely shut down circa 2008. Affluent professionals and single college graduates have colonized — gentrified — neighborhoods such as Park Slope, Silver Lake and Wicker Park, with bedraggled but potentially attractive housing stock convenient to downtowns.

and

Gentrification thus inevitably reshapes the Democratic Party, which, from its beginnings in 1832, has been a series of coalitions of people regarded as somehow unusual Americans but who, taken together, are a national majority.

“Majority minority” hasn’t resulted in more attention being paid to the issues that matter to blacks, the issues that matter to Hispanics, or both. it’s enabled each group to be played off against the other by well-heeled, mostly white political operatives and apparatchiks who’ve cross-ruffed appointive and/or elective office with Rolodex hires by banks and other large companies, particularly financial companies into wealth.

They always claim they’re going to sock it to the rich but somehow it never happens. They are the rich.

The issues that will dominate the agenda among Democrats are the issues that matter to these “gentry liberals”, as Mr. Barone calls them.

10 comments

Let It Snow


Overnight we had 4-5 inches of snow and, of course, I was out shovelling at 5:30am this morning. It’s just about time for me to go out again. Another inch has probably fallen since then and, if the snow keeps falling at this rate, we’ll probably reach 8 inches. We might even make the 10 inches they forecast.

One of the great things about my neighborhood is that just about everybody shovels or snow-blows their walks and, frequently, do it for their neighbors. When I shovelled my walk first thing this morning, I shovelled my neighbor’s walk as well. I think he ran his snowblower over my walk a couple of hours later after another inch had fallen.

It’s just the kind of people we are.

2 comments

That’s a Good Question

Buried in this editorial from Bloomberg is a very good question. The Fed has been buying bonds in enormous, unprecedented quantity for the last decade. Shouldn’t any reasonably intelligent primate have recognized that couldn’t go on forever and have formulated a plan for addressing any adverse consequences when the Fed ended quantitative easing?

7 comments

I Will Not Fisk, I Will Not Fisk, …

There are so many things wrong with Conor Sen’s lament at Bloomberg View about there not being enough truckers that I hardly know where to begin. Rather than fisking it in detail I’ll just hit a few of the high points.

  • His own graph show that there are more truckers in the U. S. today than at any time in our recent history.
  • One of the provisions of NAFTA allows Mexican truckers to haul freight from Mexico into the United States. The more freight is brought in from Mexico, the more Mexican truckers are hauling freight. Those truckers don’t count into U. S. trucker employment.
  • It’s too bad there’s no way of hauling freight in the United States other than by truck.
  • Any shortage of truckers is due to a rules change that went into effect in 2013, coincidentally just about the time that the number of truckers stopped growing.
  • What’s trucker pay as a proportion of shipping costs?
  • It’s too bad that it’s impossible to manufacture consumer goods or grow food closer to the places where people live rather than shipping them from ports to where people live.
  • As I pointed out yesterday maybe if we weren’t subsidizing Chinese imports there would be less need for long haul trucking.

and that’s just off the top of my head.

Bottom line: I don’t believe that it would be a national tragedy if truckers were paid more and, if Mr. Sen believes it, he certainly hasn’t made a case for it.

7 comments

It’s a Gas, Gas, Gas

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are more frank than David Ignatius. They have objectives in Syria beyond eliminating Daesh. They want to rid Syria of Assad, too, because of his use of chemical weapons against his own people:

President Trump sent a powerful early message of U.S. resolve last year when he bombed a Syrian air base after the Assad regime used sarin gas against civilians. He may need to send another because Syria has been testing his red line with multiple uses of chlorine gas in recent weeks.

The State Department said this week that the United States is “gravely alarmed” by reports that the Syrian government has launched six chemical attacks against civilians over the past 30 days. Assad has dropped chlorine gas on his political opponents for years, but who’s going to stop him?

In August 2012 Barack Obama warned of “enormous consequences” if Assad used chemical weapons, dubbing it a “red line.” The next year the dictator killed more than 1,400 people with sarin gas. Mr. Obama responded by signing a deal with Russia to seize Damascus’s chemical arsenal. Chlorine wasn’t included, and U.S. intelligence concluded Assad had retained some chemical stockpiles.

Sure enough, the regime used sarin gas against civilians again last April, killing at least 85 people. Mr. Trump explained his missile launch in response as “in the vital national security interest of the United States to prevent and deter the spread and use of deadly chemical weapons.”

I agree that Assad is terrible but it’s not just Assad. It’s the entire Alawite regime. If Assad were removed, he’d be replaced by someone else from his regime who’d do the same things under the same circumstances.

A lot has changed in 25 years. 25 years ago we shrugged as Saddam Hussein used chemical weapons against the Kurds in northern Iraq. Now the use of chemical weapons is a red line that demands retribution.

For me it’s a question of priorities. Using chemical weapons is terrible but Daesh is even more terrible. Destabilizing Syria inevitably opens Syria up to control by violent radical Islamists. There is simply no moderating force capable of keeping them down. A stable basically secular Syrian government is better for the United States and for the Syrian people than control by violent radical Islamists but those are the available alternatives.

Unless we’re prepared to occupy Syria into the indefinite future. Or allow Sultan Erdogan to do it. Is an irredentist Turkey really in U. S. interests?

1 comment

Just Walk Away

Here’s David Ignatius’s prescription for the U. S.’s extricating itself from the “mess in Syria”, from his column in the Washington Post:

How can the United States untangle this mess so it can finish the job against the Islamic State? America needs “dialogue” and “de-escalation” quickly with Turkey, explains Lt. Gen. Paul Funk, the commander of U.S. forces in Syria and Iraq. The campaign against the Islamic State is “slowing down,” he warns, and the lull could “allow these people to escape” into Turkey and then to Europe.

I have a simpler prescription: just walk away. The Syrian government, Russians, and Iranians presently have the Daesh forces in Idlib encircled. They will soon have eliminated them. One by one they’re rooting Daesh out of Syria’s cities. They have the incentives and the ability. We could cooperate with them and if we can’t or won’t do that we should just get the heck out of their way.

Erdogan’s Islamist Turkey is not the same country as the secular Kemalist Turkey with which the U. S. was allied. Can anyone seriously believe that this Turkey’s interests are really aligned with ours? For that matter can anyone seriously believe that “finishing the job” against Daesh is either Turkey’s or the U. S.’s only objective in Syria?

0 comments

Choice of Words

When I read the slug on this op-ed at the New York Times, I was rather amused at their choice of words:

The North’s Olympic cheerleaders continue a practice of using pretty young women to represent Pyongyang. Why does South Korea embrace them?

Why the heck do you think? Who’s editing the NYT these days, anyway?

3 comments

Containment

I liked Graham Fuller’s post on containment at LobeLog quite a bit:

Containment has been a reasonably sensible way of dealing with hostile states that cannot be readily defeated militarily except at potentially huge military cost to the US itself—especially if it risks nuclear war. Both the Soviet Union and China for many decades were “contained” due to their perceived radical ideologies and hostility to the US-dominated world order. These two states also supported many radical leftist revolutionary movements around the world that ideologically opposed the US. (Often these movements had good reason to be hostile and revolutionary, frequently due to terrible domestic conditions in their own countries—and under regimes often supported by Washington. Cuba, Chile, and Nicaragua come to mind, although US eventually made efforts to overthrow them after their revolutions.)

He raises several interesting questions. The first is who is containing whom?

If we were then to settle on any one single description of the psychology that characterizes Chinese and Russian strategy these days it is indeed “containment” of the US. The EU too, for example, increasingly believes it needs to take its relations with Russia into its own hands, rather than potentially be led into a military confrontation with Russia via dubious NATO exercises on Moscow’s borders. Supporting US “credibility” is not high on the European foreign policy wish list (except understandably for those few small neighbors sadly doomed to eternal life next to the Russian Bear.) South Korean leadership too finds playing the US card sometimes diplomatically useful, but posing a huge danger if Washington is actually willing to unleash war—in which Seoul has everything to lose. Indeed, the one state in the world that tends to completely support US military action almost anywhere in the world these days is Israel.

I do have one question of my own. Has containment ever actually been successful anywhere? One of the examples he gives of a U. S. policy of containment is Cuba. Over the last 50 years Cuba has become the leading member on the United Nations Human Rights Council, founded the Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas, hosted a summit of the Non-Aligned Movement of which it is one of the key members, and intervened militarily in Nicaragua, Chile, Angola, and Ethiopia. Cuba was and is a small, poor country. What would it have done had it not been contained? If Cuba cannot be contained, how can Russia or China?

Has our policy towards North Korea been one of containment? How successful has it been?

Here’s his greater question:

How wise is it to maintain lists of enemy states and leaders who require containment? Few other states do so, partially because declaring another state to be an enemy has obvious negative consequences that easily lead to self-fulfilling prophesy. This phenomenon is fundamental to the very psychology of human relationships. If we signal to someone that we consider them a threat or an enemy, the chances are very good that the other party will reciprocate and that mutual relations will predictably deteriorate. That is why shrewd “good neighbor policies” represent more than just naive feel-goodism. Yet the US still spends a great deal of time drawing up and announcing lists of who is an enemy, or a rival, and who must be punished or contained.

2 comments