The Overhang

I’m in substantial agreement with the views expressed in this newsletter from First Trust Portfolio, particularly this passage:

Every dollar the government spends must be either taxed or borrowed from the private sector. The bigger the
government, the smaller the private sector. Not only does increased spending mean higher tax rates are expected in the future, but also a smaller private sector as it’s forced to fund a bigger government. It’s the Spending that crowds out growth, not deficits themselves.

Look, we get it. The world is a dangerous place and we are sure there are parts of our military that need better funding. But the government can’t do everything. If we need more spending on defense, those funds should be found by reducing spending elsewhere. Otherwise, eventually, the country won’t be able to afford to defend itself, either.

But, in order to reach the minimum of 60 votes needed in the US Senate, Republicans capitulated to Democrats demands for more non-military spending. The result was a budget blowout.

That’s not 100% true. The federal government as a monetary sovereign could simply issue credit to itself, “print money”. That has risks of its own and wouldn’t negate the point that choices need to be made.

I’m also skeptical that absolutely everything our military is presently doing is positively required for the country’s security. Some is being mandated by Congress but some of the necessary cuts could and should come from within defense. The military needs to be a better steward.

Making tough choices is not only the role of Congress, it’s the only role of Congress. We do not need a Congress that is too stupid or too cowardly to do its job which, after padding its portfolio for 40 years, retires to lobbying its former colleagues. Endlessly increasing the budget can be done with a computer program. A computer program would do a better job—it wouldn’t be self-serving.

5 comments

The Ladder of Truth-Telling

There’s a sort of Maimonides Ladder of telling the truth.

  1. The highest level above which there can be no higher, at least not for us mortal humans, is telling the truth as you see it and that is supported by an overwhelming preponderance of both empirical and logical evidence for it, whether it helps you, helps others, supports your views, or not.
  2. The next level of truth-telling is saying what you believe to be the truth and that has some empirical and logical evidence.
  3. The next level is making claims for which there isn’t much empirical or logical evidence but you find so compelling they just have to be true.
  4. The next level is only telling the truth when it benefits you or supports your position.
  5. Below that is saying things you know to be untrue in a good cause.
  6. Then telling untruths to benefit yourself.
  7. The lowest level is lying for the sake of lying.

As a society I think we’re stuck between #3 and #4.

5 comments

Why We Can’t Cut Spending

A whopping 79% of federal spending consists of transfer payments, mostly Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid. When taken in aggregate health care spending is by far the largest part of the federal budget. Health care spending can’t be cut without a) cutting the reimbursements paid to providers; b) not paying for the health care that somebody wants or needs; or c) both.

That would evoke howls of anguish from providers, beneficiaries of federal health care spending programs, the well-intentioned, and the politically opportunistic.

And that’s why we can’t cut federal spending. The same argument applies to the second largest chunk, Social Security. The howls would just be coming from a slightly narrower (but overlapping) slice of the population. It is now true that if defense spending were cut to zero, it would not balance the budget. And we’re increasing defense spending.

8 comments

Europe’s Problem

Wow. Read this interview with human rights activist and UN advisor Rebecca Sommer. Her comments remind me of the remarks of nuns in this country who worked with the poor 40 years ago. The experience tended to toughen them up.

This is Europe’s problem. Our immigration problems are minor in comparison, something we can address in a reasonable and humane way if we merely put our minds to it.

18 comments

Tired of the Governor’s Election

I’m already tired of the Illinois governor’s election and it’s still 9 months away. We’re being deluged with TV spots for all three Democratic candidates and both Republican candidates, all making absurd claims, each trashing all of the others.

0 comments

Reductio ad Trump

I do not buy James Crabtree’s reductio ad Trump argument for the risks to developing Asian economies expressed in his op-ed at Nikkei Asian Review than I do the closely related reductio ad Washington argument:

The report outlines a range of risks that could weigh on poorer and lower middle income nations, but two stand out in particular. The first is rising protectionism, as prospects dim for future trade liberalization and U.S. President Donald Trump threatens punitive tariffs against China and others. The second, and arguably the more worrying, relates to manufacturing, which allowed earlier generations of Asian workers to move from farms to basic factories and onward to advanced exporting sectors, raising productivity along the way.

I think that a better explanation is that China has built enormous overcapacity, that overcapacity crowds out other countries trying to use the same export-based strategy that was successful for Japan, South Korea, and China, and the American consumer has run out of gas.

Trade liberalization for these countries should start at home. If they weren’t all maintaining one-way autarkies, trade amongst themselves could provide the growth engine they need.

Shorter: a China without a faster-growing domestic market that imports is a drag on the entire developing world.

0 comments

Uganda 1971 vs. U. S. 2018

Is Allan Golombek actually arguing in RealClearMarkets that the United States in 2018 is exactly the same as Uganda in 1971? I don’t recall skilled Indian workers being compelled to train their unskilled Ugandan replacements and I don’t hear an outcry here for a mass ejection of South Asian physicians.

Contrariwise I think the two situations are almost exactly the opposite of each other and that there’s a group in the United States going to great lengths in an attempt at commodifying all labor (other than a few fields that have the influence to protect themselves). In other words they want to make the “lump of labor” a reality.

1 comment

Who Decides?

At Outside the Beltway Doug Mataconis presents his argument in favor of giving DACA beneficiaries and “other illegal immigrants” a path to citizenship. Here’s the meat of his argument:

As it stands, of course, the conservative position regarding citizenship for illegal immigrants is one that is not held by most Americans. According to many polls taken over the last five years or longer, the majority of Americans and even the majority of self-identified Republicans support a path to citizenship for both DACA beneficiaries specifically and illegal immigrants generally. I’ve made note of the results of many of these polls in posts that can be found here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, here, and here. This issue, of course, is just one of the examples of the extent to which the hardline position that conservatives continue to take on immigration issues is out of step with the rest of the country, and it’s one of the many reasons why Republicans continue to lose ground with Latino voters, especially younger Latino voters who will become more and more of an important segment of a voting bloc that is only going to grow over the coming years. Taken in that light, I suppose that it’s understandable why many on the right would take the position that people who are in the United States illegally should never be allowed to become citizens. Given current voting patterns, such a prospect would be bad news for the GOP in many states, or even worse news considering that many states such as Arizona, Virginia, Georgia, and Florida are seemingly destined to become less hospitable to Republicans in the future unless the GOP becomes more palatable to Latino voters.

In reality, of course, isn’t any valid policy-based or moral argument against the idea that DACA beneficiaries, or indeed anyone who is in the country illegally, should eventually be allowed to become citizens provided that they meet the criteria.

or, in other words, proof by assertion and appeal to popular opinion, both fallacies.

I’ve made my views of immigration clear. I think that total immigration is presently higher than our society can reasonably assimilate, especially immigration of unskilled workers with poor command of English, and I think that mass immigration of low-skill and unskilled workers injures the workers with whom they’re in competition for jobs, particularly blacks. That’s what the preponderance of the evidence shows.

Here’s the Migration Policy Institute’s summary analysis of the present Mexican population in the United States. The MPI is generally favorably disposed to immigration, Mexican immigration in particular:

  • In 2010, over 11.7 million Mexican immigrants (of all ages) resided in the United States.
  • There were more than 10.6 million Mexican immigrants ages 18 and older in the United States.
  • Nearly half of Mexican adults reside in two states: California and Texas.
  • About three-quarters of Mexican adults residing in the United States were non-U.S. citizens in 2010.
  • Nearly two-thirds of adult Mexican immigrants in the United States came after 1990.
  • Six in ten Mexican immigrants in the United States did not have a high school diploma in 2010.
  • In 2010, three out of four Mexican immigrant adults were limited English proficient.
  • More than one-third of all employed Mexican-born men reported working in construction, extraction, and transportation in 2010.
  • Over 62 percent of Mexican adults living in the United States were in low-income families in 2010.

Generally, I think the DACA beneficiaries should be given legal status, I’m open on the idea of giving them a path to citizenship although I think there are good reasons not to, and I’m opposed to granting their parents a path to citizenship. Here are my reasons:

  • During the last amnesty in the 1980s only a minority of those eligible sought citizenship. We don’t have a lot of other evidence. Based on the information we have at hand, the issue of a path to citizenship isn’t nearly as pressing, except to those who want a grateful client population, as might seem to be the case.
  • There is no practical way to verify eligibility under any set of criteria other than no criteria at all.
  • No criteria at all is de facto open borders.
  • The same arguments being made in favor of a path to citizenship for DACA beneficiaries will be deployed to erode any criteria over time.
  • Unlimited immigration of people with no skills or low skills injures blacks, poor whites, and previous cohorts of immigrants.
  • The characteristics of Mexican immigrants noted by the MPI tell us that they’re creating their own subclass, we’re not creating it for them. That argument is misdirection. If you want more social equality you should want to limit immigration rather than incentivize its expansion.
  • The U. S. has poor social cohesion at best. It’s a structural issue.
  • A large concentration of immigrants from a single country reduces our already weak social cohesion.
  • Weakened social cohesion makes other things (e.g. sensible health care reform) politically more difficult than they otherwise might be.
  • We shouldn’t incentivize illegal immigration.
  • A path to citizenship is an incentive, even if a weak one.
  • Separating the issue of legal status from the issue of citizenship reduces the political incentives for unlimited immigration, shifting it just a little from the political arena to the economic one. It will make it easier to craft a policy.
  • The citizenry should decide who gets to be a citizen, not non-citizen immigrants.

In the absence of any actual counter-argument, any reasonable argument should prevail and the above are reasonable arguments.

14 comments

Are Deficits Always Bad, Always Good, or Does It Depend?

A quick take on the budget deal that has been reached.

  • We are not presently in a recession. The NBER, the official recordkeeper on the business cycle, says so. Consequently, by definition we are not in a recession.
  • We’ve been in a tepid recovery since June 2009, before disbursement of money under the America Reinvestment and Recovery Act (stimulus package) took place. That means that the ARRA played at most a minor role in preventing a “double dip” recession.
  • It’s more likely that it “time shifted” some economic growth which meant that growth was slower in the period from which the time shifting took place than otherwise might have been the case.
  • Debt burden has probably played a part in slowing U. S. economic growth.
  • According to the CBO the new budget deal will probably result in a deficit of nearly $1 trillion in 2018.
  • Since we’re not in a recession, there is no shortfall in aggregate demand and for the additional deficit spending to increase future growth it would need to be invested. Business investment has been slack for quite a while.
  • The increase in the deficit will definitely increase debt which will provide additional headwinds against growth.
  • It could be that other factors will outweigh those headwinds.

Or, said another way, I don’t think that deficits are always bad or always good but somewhere in between, dependent on circumstances. We’re now engaged in a great experiment in deficit spending and indebtedness. I hope it turns out well but I fear it won’t.

5 comments

Why Opinions Differ

I think that in his op-ed at Bloomberg View Hal Brande barely scratches the surface of the reasons for differences of opinion about China between Europe and the United States. Here’s a few more reasons just off the top of my head. I’m going to focus on Germany as an epitome of Europe. It’s Europe’s largest, richest country and it dominates the continent politically.

  • Germany and China’s bilateral trade is roughly in balance and until quite recently Germany ran a trade surplus with China.
  • The United States runs a $300 billion per year trade deficit with China.
  • Germany maintains a trade surplus; we have a gigantic trade deficit.
  • German jobs aren’t being siphoned off by China; American jobs indubitably are.
  • China continues to subsidize the vilest regimes on the planet (North Korea, Zimbabwe). From the U. S. standpoint that’s a security concern. For the Germans it’s just business.
  • Germany largely depends on the U. S. for its own defense.
  • The U. S. not only bears the cost of its own and Germany’s defense, it also bears much of the cost of Japan’s, South Korea’s, and the Philippines’s defense.

Here’s my suggestion. The U. S. should extract a tax of roughly $70 billion per year from Germany (approximately 2% of GDP). You can call it a fee if you like. That will make up the difference between what Germany should be spending on defense and what it’s actually spending. Then they can hold any opinion they care to.

I suspect they’ll chafe under that regime. That’s fair. We chafe under the cost of paying for their defense.

3 comments