Self-Sacking

If you’re not familiar with the history, you might find this post at RealClearHistory on the cities sacked by the Mongols nearly a millennium ago enlightening. The list includes Baghdad, something that broke the spine of the Arab Empire, Aleppo, Moscow, Kiev, Bukhara, and Lahore.

Nowadays we don’t need a Golden Horde for that purpose. We have politicians.

0 comments

What Drives the Deficit

Richard Kogan and Guillermo Herrera are right in their post at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities when they write that programs target at the poor aren’t driving the deficit:

Recent and future trends in spending on mandatory programs aren’t a justification for cuts, especially when Republican lawmakers just passed costly tax changes that primarily benefit the wealthy and corporations and do relatively little for low- and moderate-income people — and could hurt those affected by the law’s repeal of the mandate on individuals to obtain health insurance). Ultimately, addressing our nation’s longer-term fiscal challenges will require a broader approach that recognizes the need for additional revenues.

and neither is military spending. Health care spending, considered broadly, is. That’s because Congress doesn’t have the political courage to tell anyone “no”. As long as prices rise in health care and we aren’t willing to curtail the procedures covered or total amount of spending, that spending will rise as far as the eye can see. And as long as we decrease taxes we’ll finance that extra spending through borrowing.

4 comments

No Blacks Need Apply

This article at American Affairs puts a little academic heft behind a point I’ve been making here for some time to the effect that Hispanic workers, particularly immigrant Hispanic workers, are displacing blacks in the low wage workforce:

One of the first studies in this area reported by Skrentny, which was widely influential in galvanizing interest in on-the-ground research on low-wage employment, was published in the late 1980s by sociologists Joleen Kirschenman and Kathryn Neckerman.7 Working with the well-known sociologist William Julius Wilson, they conducted and reported on interviews with hundreds of Chicago-area employers and managers. When assured of anonymity, those in charge repeatedly bemoaned the poor quality of the native workforce, especially blacks. What emerges clearly from their research is employers’ uniform preference for Hispanic and Asian immigrants, as well as praise for the work habits of those groups as compared to native workers.

That hierarchy was confirmed by a wealth of interviews conducted in the Chicago area a few years later as part of the massive Urban Poverty and Family Life Study (UPFLS). As reported in William Julius Wilson’s book When Work Disappears: The World of the New Urban Poor (Knopf, 1996), the study, which was specifically focused on the employment prospects of inner-city blacks, repeated the patterns revealed in the ground-breaking Kirschenman and Neckerman article. When asked to comment on the job skills, attitude, work ethic, interpersonal skills, or dependability of black workers as compared to other categories, including immigrant laborers from different groups, the great majority of managers and supervisors interviewed—126 of the 170—expressed their belief that inner-city blacks brought traits to the workplace that negatively affected their job performance. Many complained that blacks, as well as other native American workers, had a poor work ethic compared to recent immigrants, and especially Hispanics and Asians. Native-born workers, black and white, were also perceived to be less cooperative, more demanding, and more entitled. A hotel manager stated, “I see far more blacks thinking the employer has the obligation to give him a check for doing nothing. There are some whites that think that way. . . . Not so much Hispanics.”

When I was in the low wage workforce, admittedly many years ago, there were no harder or more conscientious workers than blacks. Maybe things have changed. Or maybe some combination of bigotry, stereotypes, lack of understanding of the social affect of blacks, and that Hispanics are reluctant to organize for higher pay or better conditions has impelled employers to prefer them.

2 comments

Directions on DACA

There is no obligation or principle that dictates that we must grant people brought here by their parents as children permanent residency and citizenship. Other than due process there is no such thing as “immigration rights”, a phrase I’ve been seeing lately. In his post at RealClearPolicy Jeffrey Dorfman makes some valuable distinctions among policy, politics, clemency, and pragmatism and while doing so outlines the chain of reasoning that impels me in the direction in which my own views are taking me. For example:

The “Dreamers,” brought to the U.S. as children but now ranging in age from teens to early 30s, are at the center of the discussion. No principle dictates that Dreamers should be legalized and allowed to stay. It may not be their fault, but legal principles generally don’t let people benefit from another’s crimes. Consider an analogy: If parents robbed a bank and deposited the money in their kids’ college savings account, neither society nor the legal system would permit the kids to keep the money. (The Dreamers are those kids, but with citizenship in place of college tuition.)

Sympathy, not principles, is what drives support for Dreamers. But sympathy does not make for good strategy. Pragmatism is the better approach. Here, a number of arguments favor the Dreamers. They are familiar with the U.S., have a place in society already, generally speak English, and often already have jobs. They are more likely to be of economic benefit to the American taxpayer than new immigrants we might admit to replace them. Plus, Americans are simply not mean enough to deport them.

Sympathy suggests their parents will stay, too — we don’t want to break up families — but so does pragmatism. Yet, because legalizing the Dreamers’ parents is so generous, a pragmatic deal would also require permanently banning the parents from future citizenship. This is pragmatic both because it assesses a penalty and minimizes the potential impact of the newly legalized immigrants on elections.

Read the whole thing. I don’t agree with him that enhanced border security is a pragmatic imperative. As I’ve said before border security is only as strong as the weakest border control agent.

The present conflict over DACA isn’t either a moral argument or a pragmatic one. It’s a political argument and that’s the reason for the impasse. The maudlin appeals to sympathy are highly selective.

17 comments

When You’re Pilloried

Pilloried by the media, Rebekah Mercer has taken to the pages of the Wall Street Journal in response. Here’s her op-ed in its entirety:

Over the past 18 months, I have been the subject of intense speculation and public scrutiny, in large part because of the philanthropic investments of the Mercer Family Foundation and the political contributions made by my father and me. I don’t seek attention for myself and much prefer to keep a low profile. But my natural reluctance to speak with reporters has left me vulnerable to the media’s sensational fantasies.

Some have recklessly described me as supporting toxic ideologies such as racism and anti-Semitism. More recently I have been accused of being “anti-science.” These absurd smears have inspired a few gullible, but vicious, characters to make credible death threats against my family and me.

Last month a writer for the Financial Times suggested mysteriously that my “political goals are something she has never publicly defined.” In broad strokes this is what I believe:

I believe in a kind and generous United States, where the hungry are fed, the sick are cared for, and the homeless are sheltered. All American citizens deserve equality and fairness before the law. All people should be treated with dignity and compassion. I support a United States that welcomes immigrants and refugees to apply for entry and ultimately citizenship. I reject as venomous and ignorant any discrimination based on race, gender, creed, ethnicity or sexual orientation.

As a federalist, I believe that power should be decentralized, with those wielding it closely accountable to the people they serve. There is obviously a role for the federal government. But I support a framework within which citizens from smaller political entities—states, counties, cities, towns and so on—can determine the majority of the laws that will govern them. Society’s problems will never be solved by expensive, ineffective and inflexible federal programs.

I am deeply committed to research and the scientific method. I have degrees from Stanford in biology, mathematics, and operations research and engineering economic systems. I believe that genuine scientific discovery flourishes only in an atmosphere of dispassionate, open-minded inquiry, with research evaluated according to neutral, evidence-based criteria. I oppose politicized science, in which researchers cannot study certain subjects—or even ask certain questions—for fear of career-ending backlash and persecution.

These beliefs shape my philanthropy and my political activity. I support ideas and policies, not individual politicians as people. The only thing I ask of the politicians I back is that they be true to the promises that they made to their constituents during their campaigns.

I supported Donald Trump’s 2016 presidential campaign because he promised to tackle entrenched corruption on both sides of the aisle. I continue to support President Trump, which does not mean I agree with every position he has taken or every thought he has tweeted. I remain hopeful that he will continue striving to fulfill his campaign promises.

I own a minority stake in Breitbart News (where I have no editorial authority) because I believe it adds an important journalistic voice to the American conversation. Stephen Bannon, its former chairman, took Breitbart in the wrong direction. Now that Mr. Bannon has resigned, Breitbart has the opportunity to refine its message and expand its influence.

I have chosen to involve myself with important policy issues, and with some of the institutions that discuss them, because I am, first and foremost, a mother. I am raising my children to be humble, productive citizens who will treat all people with dignity, respect and empathy. I want them to accept personal responsibility and to be aware that they alone will have to answer for their choices and actions. I hope that my children will show stoicism and perseverance through adversity, as well as an ability to think for themselves and challenge conventional wisdom when necessary.

I also hope that they will embrace debate as a vital part of human progress. I am devoted to protecting individual rights to ensure that my children will mature in a country where they cannot be persecuted or imprisoned or have their livelihoods destroyed because of their thoughts and beliefs.

This country was founded on the principle of open discourse. Intellectual diversity and vigorous, reasoned debate have been fundamental to America’s success, making us the freest, most prosperous and most innovative society in human history. But we have lost our way. As my family and I know firsthand, America is now a society that threatens, pillories, and harms those who dare to question the status quo.

But questioning the status quo is more important now than ever. America’s future depends on it.

Is her support for Trump sufficient cause for speculation and arch criticisms? Has she been treated unfairly? Support for Breitbart.com? If you think so, what should an individual with the libertarian beliefs exhibited in the op-ed have done in 2016? How do we cope with a media in which its journalists are no longer non-combatants in politics as war?

Personally, I find even a minority ownership of Breitbart.com troubling but I’m glad she acknowledges that it had gone “in the wrong direction”. I did not and would not have supported Trump and I think she was mistaken to do so but I can see how enough dissatisfaction with the status quo could lead one to that. I’m not sure who would survive the sort of guilt by association that’s become commonplace today. Certainly no sitting politicians.

5 comments

Growth From Where?

In his column at the Wall Street Journal Jason Furman has it about right:

Economic growth comes from two sources. First is a cyclical rebound in demand as the economy gets closer to full capacity (or even proceeds beyond it). Second is an increase in the economy’s underlying potential output—also called the supply side—driven by growth in either the workforce or productivity.

The trouble is that more than half of last year’s economic growth came from the cyclical factors, which have little left to contribute given that we’re at or near full employment. What this means is that absent much bigger productivity improvements, it will be a challenge for the U.S. to achieve sustained economic growth of even 2%.

He goes on to explain why rapid economic growth is unlikely—the Social Security actuaries have been predicting less than 2% growth over the next couple of decades for nearly 15 years.

That’s why I’m skeptical that fiscal stimulus is going to produce much growth at this point. We’re already at or near potential product and it will take reliable, sustained inputs to induce increasing productive potential not just a quick hit.

Then there’s that pesky supply and demand stuff. As the Baby Boomers die or downsize and sell their homes, the increased availability will provide downward pressure on housing prices that will persist for decades. There will be increased demand for health care services but that will be a drag on the private sector as well. The elderly have what amounts to a bottomless pocketbook for paying health care bills, the supply of health care is limited, and everyone else is in competition with the elderly for them. Of course prices will rise.

As long as wages are kept low by automation, offshoring, and competition from workers imported from abroad, paying more for health care means less available to spend on everything else.

If only someone could have envisioned the enormous flood of old people and planned for that future!

6 comments

Warning About the Wrong Things

The editors of the Wall Street Journal warn about rising inflation, of all things:

New Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell can thank predecessor Janet Yellen for another parting gift: rising prices. The Labor Department reported Wednesday that consumer inflation rose 0.5% in January, or 2.1% over the past year, a bigger spike than most economists predicted.

The markets reacted better than expected with stocks rising after early losses. But the yield on the 30-year Treasury bond popped above 3.16% and is near its two previous peaks of the past three years. The yield on the 10-year Treasury note also climbed above 2.9%. The cost of money is going up, which by itself isn’t alarming as economic growth accelerates.

The bigger question is whether the Fed is repeating its mistake from the early 2000s when it kept interest rates too low for too long even as the economy surged after the 2003 tax cut. This fed the housing bubble, commodity price spikes and a general financial mania that ended in panic and crash.

The January report is at least a warning. Core prices, which exclude food and energy, were more restrained, rising 0.3% for the month, or 1.82% over the past 12 months. The price of oil rose above $66 a barrel in January and has since fallen below $61. But the overall increase in prices is still notable amid modest wage gains.

That’s basically alarmist poppycock. If you look at the Labor Department’s report, you’ll see that most prices increased below 2% on a year-over-year basis.

The exception was fuel oil and what the report tells us is that there been cold weather in New England and the Northeast. Gasoline prices have also risen sharply faster than other prices. That might mean higher prices for all goods and services down the line but higher fuel oil prices (22.5% increase YOY) and higher gas prices (8.5% YOY) are not something the Fed has much to do with.

There are other things that are increasing in price, too, notably insurance. I honestly don’t know why the insurance industry continues to offer liability insurance in California. Multi-million dollar houses built on hillsides in earthquake and mudslide zones aren’t insurable risks.

3 comments

Making Radicals

My only reaction to Shadi Hamid’s op-ed in the Wall Street Journal outlining his views on how Democratic centrists are transmogrifying into immoderate partisans:

In polarized times, political competition comes to resemble tribal warfare. Everyone is under pressure to close ranks and boost morale. Lacking an animating vision beyond expert-led incrementalism, center-left politicians and pundits have few options to rally the Democratic base other than by attacking adversaries and heightening partisan divides. The other option—laying out an alternative that differs from what Hillary Clinton or even President Obama offered—requires ideological conviction.

That would explain why Rep. Adam Schiff —previously “known as a milquetoast moderate,” according to the New Yorker—has emerged as one of the most outspoken figures in the Russian collusion investigation. Before being appointed to succeed Mrs. Clinton in the Senate, Kirsten Gillibrand was an upstate New York representative who belonged to the Blue Dog Coalition. Her 2013 New Yorker profile was titled “Strong Vanilla”—and she now boasts the upper chamber’s most anti- Trump voting record.

Many Democrats are unwilling to accept that Mrs. Clinton actually lost to Donald Trump. Those who find her standard center-left technocratic worldview congenial are disinclined to accept ideological explanations, so they look for scapegoats: Russia, James Comey, even the voters who supported Donald Trump. Mrs. Clinton herself pre-emptively offered the last explanation in September 2016, when she consigned half of Trump supporters to “the basket of deplorables”—“they are irredeemable, but thankfully they are not America.” As 2020 approaches, Democrats run the risk of repeating that mistake, taking for granted, as Mrs. Clinton did, that Mr. Trump’s unique flaws will be sufficient to ensure his defeat.

is “poppycock”. He’s confusing a lack of principles other than the urge to power with being a moderate. It may be that some moderates are what were once called “Nixonian centrists” (striking the middle between the “Right” and the “Left”). Does that characterize Adam Schiff?
I have no idea. When you have guiding principles you follow them. When all you have is the urge to power, you go whichever way the wind is blowing.

Technocracy has failed. Its advocates, presumably including Mr. Hamid, refuse to acknowledge that. Technocrats led us to war in the Gulf in the 1990s and are proximally responsible for our being at war ever since. Technocrats created the boom-bust cycle we’ve seen over the last 30 years. Technocrats have caused the enormous increase in income inequality that has metastasized in the U. S. That’s a disastrous track record.

In one critical sense technocracy is like Christianity or communism. The real sort has never been tried. It probably never will.

3 comments

Find Permanent Homes for the Games

In his Washington Post column Robert Samuelson looks at the economics of the Olympic Games:

The numbers are (as they say) eye-popping. In 1997, there were 12 cities competing for the 2004 Summer Games, which were ultimately hosted by Greece. By contrast, the bidding for the 2024 Games ended with two contenders — Paris and Los Angeles — after Boston, Toronto, Rome, Hamburg and Budapest dropped out.

The story is the same for the Winter Olympics. In 1995, there were nine candidates for the 2002 Winter Games. By 2011, there were only three for the present 2018 Games.

What has happened is no secret, writes Zimbalist in the current issue of the Milken Institute Review. To host either the Summer or Winter Games requires massive construction projects for new stadiums, dormitories and local transportation systems. But the prospective revenue from the Games doesn’t come close to covering the costs. As a result, the Games impose a permanent burden on the host country’s taxpayers.

Zimbalist roughly calculates the cost of the next Summer Olympics at $15 billion to $20 billion against prospective revenue of $4 billion to $5 billion. While costs are going up, the prestige and long-term economic benefits — in increased tourism and investment — seem to be going down.

I think that permanent homes should be sought for both the Summer and Winter Games, Greece for the former, Switzerland for the latter. Some attempt, too, should be made to restore the Games to their original meaning—international accord through sport.

The Games’s present form is a relic of fascism and the Cold War.

1 comment

Equivalences

To his credit in his New York Times column today Frank Bruni breaks ranks with some of his anti-Trump colleagues. In reaction to some of the more rhapsodic characterizations of North Korea’s leader’s younger sister, Kim Yo-jong’s performance as a spectator at the Winter Olympics:

The response to North Korea’s overtures at the Olympics was epitomized by what quickly became a popular characterization of Kim Yo-jong. South Korean journalists called her “North Korea’s Ivanka.” Straight-faced American journalists repeated it.

I get it. Both young women attempt to put a pretty, pert face on a clan — and a government — of transcendent ugliness. Both decided to do that in the context of triple axels and the luge. Ivanka is due in South Korea for the closing ceremony.

But not all ugliness is created equal, Donald Trump is not Kim Jong-un, the United States is nothing like North Korea and to come anywhere near that suggestion is nuts. Be outraged about what’s going on in America. Don’t be ridiculous.

In doing her father’s bidding, Ivanka Trump is trying to tell the world that a sexist really wants to empower women, that a racist really cares about equal opportunity and that a narcissistic plutocrat is acting in the high-minded interests of the little people. She’s willfully delusional, totally complicit and compiling one hell of an Instagram feed, which is what she’s ultimately all about.

In doing her brother’s bidding, Kim Yo-jong is airbrushing a dictator who authorizes public executions that, according to defectors, must be watched by all adult citizens, so that they can savor the wages of disobedience. She is diverting attention from his roles in the murders of his half brother, who was smeared with a fatal toxin while walking through an airport, and of many senior government officials, slaughtered in grotesque ways. Is it any wonder that she’s making the effort? The alternative, apparently, is being drawn and quartered.

That should get him disinvited from some cocktail parties.

0 comments