Print the Legend

In reading an article at Atlantic outlining the complicated role of Poles in the murders of 90% of its Jewish population during World War II in reaction to the recent law banning mention of “Polish camps” during the period, I was struck by the degree to which mythology has overtaken reality regarding World War II.

The mythology is that we were fighting the Nazis. The reality is more that we were fighting the Germans. Were all Germans Nazis? Of course not. But many were and Hitler was popular.

The mythology is that the French bravely resisted the Germans. The reality is more that the French mostly just tried to get along during World War II. The fabled French Resistance consisted of a few hundred French Communists. They were far outnumbered by the French who collaborated actively with the Germans.

The mythology (here, at least) is that the United States won World War II. The reality is that the U. S., Britain, and the Soviet Union won World War II and the Soviet Union may have done more to accomplish the victory, at least in Europe, than either the British, the Yanks, or both. That’s certainly the Russian mythology.

It is true that the Danish resistance was heroic and typically stubbornly Danish in rescuing Danish Jews from Germans. It is not true that when the Germans ordered Danish Jews to wear yellow stars King Christian X wore a yellow star himself in solidarity with Danish Jews. That is a myth.

They mythology about the Dutch conveniently omits that there were more Dutch members of the SS than from any other country.

I could go on almost endlessly. As the line in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance says this is the West. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.

4 comments

The Difference

At RealClearPolitics Scott Rasmussen notes that although the parallels between the 2010 midterms and the 2018 midterms are striking, there’s also a significant difference. In 2010 the Democrats’ signature legislation, the Affordable Care Act, was unpopular and providing unpleasant surprises for many Americans. The Republicans’ signature legislation, tax reform, is likely to grow in popularity over the course of the year and is providing pleasant surprises for many Americans.

I think that Democrats are likely to gain seats in the House (that’s what history tells us). Will they gain enough seats to take control of the House? Will they gain seats in the Senate? Will they lose seats in the Senate? I have no idea and have lost any ability to predict.

3 comments

Is NHS Broken?

The editors of the Wall Street Journal say that Trump is right, British National Health is broken:

The NHS is in the middle of its annual winter crisis—wherein central planners forget which season follows spring, summer and autumn and must reschedule surgeries and leave the ill in hospital hallways because the health service hasn’t prepared for its busiest time. Hospitals are running at 95% occupancy, and patients are waiting longer for urgent treatment. Only 85% of emergency-room patients were seen within four hours of arrival in December, the lowest share on record and well short of the NHS goal of 95%. January was probably worse.

The pressure for more spending is constant but it must compete against other demands in a country with already high tax rates. Spending on the NHS has increased by 1.3% annually in inflation-adjusted terms since 2010. That’s faster than British living standards are growing as wage increases have lagged inflation since the 2008 financial panic.

The default is to ration care. Last year the NHS in England abandoned its decade-old pledge to deliver non-emergency surgeries such as hip replacements and cataract operations within 18 weeks of referral by a general practitioner. This is supposed to free up hospital space to improve abysmal emergency-room performance. British patients also wait longer than most other Europeans to see primary physicians and get tests such as CT scans.

Treatment for British patients diagnosed with common cancers such as lung, breast and prostate lags most other developed countries. Of women diagnosed with breast cancer, 90.2% of those treated in America now survive for at least five years, according to a study published last month in The Lancet. The five-year survival rate is 85.6% in Britain. In America the five-year survival rate for prostate cancer is 97.4%, compared with 88.7% in the U.K. That translates to thousands of “excess” deaths—people who would have survived in a health system other than the NHS.

This sure sounds like a health system that’s “broke and not working.” Britain will need to spend more money on health care as its population ages and life spans lengthen. A report last month from the government’s Office for Budget Responsibility estimates health spending will increase to 12.6% of GDP by 2067 from around 7% today. But much of that will be wasted in an unreformed NHS.

To place that rate of increasing costs into perspective Britain’s annual inflation rate, like ours, has varied from about 2% to about 3%. To say that health care has increased at 1.3% means that it has increasd from twice as fast as other costs to about half again as fast. Since health care only comprises about 10% of the British economy rather than the 17% it does here, that means that health care isn’t presenting the entirety of the increases in the cost of living but it’s a lot.

I don’t know whether NHS is broken or not. Here’s James Ball at the Guardian:

The first thing that Americans should know about the National Health Service is that it’s free at the point of use to anyone who needs it. You don’t have to fill out much paperwork, and you get no bills, whether you go to see your family doctor, or go to hospital. No one in the UK goes bankrupt through medical costs, no one needs to delay medical treatment until they can afford it, and virtually no one is uninsured.

The healthcare it provides is … OK. This is a controversial assessment in the UK, as the NHS often ranks as the most popular institution in the UK, more popular than the military and even the royal family, with nurses and doctors being the two most trusted professions in the country.

Despite its popularity, though, the NHS performs roughly mid-table in terms of bang for its buck: some countries spending roughly the same on health get considerably better outcomes, others get much worse. One country the UK outstrips by a huge amount, though, is the US.

According to data gathered by the OECD, the average UK spend per head on healthcare is $4,192 (£2,989) – and it has a life expectancy of 81.6 years. The US spends more than twice this amount, $9,892 – far more than any other country in the world – and yet life expectancy is far lower.

What I can say with confidence is that even a fully nationalized health care system like Britain’s is not a panacea. Costs are still increasing faster than the British can afford. I can’t say this for sure but I think the basic problem is that it’s very hard to deny people the health care they need or want or to cut salaries in health care to the point where you can’t get the professionals you need. So costs increase beyond the ability to pay.

1 comment

Where the Wheel Meets the Road

In Rod Douthat’s recent column in the New York Times he covers a lot of the ground on immigration that I’ve addressed here and concludes:

But the calculus is not simple, a middle ground is actually worth seeking, and recent immigration plays a role not only in America’s greatness, but in our divisions and disappointments as well.

Casting immigration or health care or or poverty or going to war or any of the other issues we face as grave moral issues oversimplifies them. They are moral issues but not solely moral issues and the pragmatic costs and secondary effects of policy cannot be waved away.

The United States has a low level of social cohesion to begin with and, as Mr. Douthat points out, mass immigration weakens already weak social bonds. It is possible that the carrying capacities of different countries for immigrants are different because of the different social conditions that prevail in those countries. Past history suggests that the United States is near or at its level of tolerance for immigration. Mass illegal immigration may reduce Americans’ tolerance for legal immigration; they may be in a trade-off position.

We can’t afford to give everyone all of the health care they want. No one can. It’s not a case of virtue—giving everyone all the health care they want—vs. vice—letting some people go without. In any foreseeable system some people will get less care than they want or even than they need. The questions are who gets what care, how much will it cost, who pays, and who decides.

I’ve expressed many times here that I think we’re too willing to go to war. I think that absolute security is impossible and we need to learn to live with some level of risk. There are grave moral issues in going to war but it’s not solely a moral question. There are also questions of responsibility, the implications of not going to war, and willingness to pay.

We must take the moral implications of our decisions seriously. With the declining agreement on standard of morality that will become increasingly difficult to do. In casting issues solely as moral issues we do ourselves a disservice. Practical considerations will always intrude themselves.

1 comment

Risks, Issues, and China

A risk is an eventuality, positive or negative, which might happen. An issue has happened.

The Chinese military presents a risk. It is also the least proven of any major military. That tends to mitigate the risk somewhat. How big a risk does the Chinese military present to us? I don’t know and I doubt that the very best Stateside experts know, either.

I do know that the Chinese military is not an issue, at least not for us. Treating a risk as though it were an issue does us no good. Where the Chinese military is an issue is in cyberwarfare, that is the area in which it is the most proven, and that’s why I suspect that the most likely source of confrontation between China and the United States is in unconventional warfare and, indeed, that’s already where we are. That’s where they’re strong and the most proven rather than where they’re unproven. We should be responding with more strenuous measures, exploiting our own strengths, but, puzzlingly, we aren’t.

1 comment

Dividing the Spoils

I think that Henry Grabar is wrong in his piece at Slate. As long as the primary economic policy consists in dividing the spoils small towns do have to die if large metropolitan areas are to prosper. When government at all levels is primarily in the business of redistribution the spoils will necessarily go to the places where they’ll bring the most votes, i.e. major metropolitan areas.

There is an alternative but it would involve reforms along the lines I suggested earlier which would hurt those major metropolitan areas disproportionately. Don’t expect them any time soon.

4 comments

Which Came First?

I think that James Wallner has the causality reversed in his op-ed at the Washington Examiner:

American democracy is resilient. It is so because individual Americans are able to engage in deeply divisive debates within the institutions created by the Constitution. It will be resilient so long as we refrain from delegitimizing those with whom we disagree.

To that end, Cohen would do well to spend less time talking about the fact that he dislikes Trump and more time talking about the areas where he and Trump disagree. That kind of debate, no doubt still contentious, is the very essence of politics; allowing it to take place is vital to identifying those areas where Americans must compromise with one another in pursuit of justice and the general good.

It is disdain for debate that has culminated with Trump; Trump didn’t cause it. The castigation of political opponents as racists, sexists, and/or tools or the rich, all tactics for ending debate, were hallmarks of our political process long before Trump ran for the Republican nomination for president.

16 comments

Working As Designed

In his op-ed at RealClearPolitics Mort Kondracke does an able job of explaining the problems with our present political system but I’m afraid he hasn’t come to terms with the reality. Here are the areas he outlines for reform:

The Democrat-Republican “duopoly,” Porter said, sets the rules by which politics operates in America. The parties battle savagely for power, but collude to polarize the electorate so it has only two choices in elections. They freeze out Independent and moderate competition and write campaign finance and lobbying rules ensuring that they, their consultants and special interests will grow in money and power without independent regulation.

The methods include partisan gerrymandering (which may be outlawed by the U.S. Supreme Court, or not), primary elections closed to all but party members in most states, “sore loser” laws in 44 states barring primary losers from running as Independents in general elections, and rules making it all but impossible for an Independent or third-party candidate to participate in presidential debates.

to which I’d add smaller more numerous Congressional districts and devolution. But here’s the basic problem:

“The system is not broken,” said Gehl. “It works just fine for the people who designed it—the parties, their donors and the special interests they serve. The system is not broken. It’s ‘fixed.’”

Mr. Kondracke’s evaluation of the progress of his organization is:

The movement scored some limited successes in 2015 and 2016…

but I’m going to rain on his parade. Limited success is all that can be achieved within the present conventional political process. The sitting Congress are the robber barons and the political system is the Rhine. The original robber barons’ excessive tolls ended when Emperor Rudolph burned their castles and hanged them. Nothing short of that will bring reform to our system.

The alternatives we have are a Constitutional convention which would open an enormous can of worms or a civil war overthrowing the present system which would open an even more enormous can of worms.

0 comments

Conflicted

What can I say? I agree with William Galston’s column in favor of merit-based immigration at the Wall Street Journal but I have problems with the way he’s making his argument. For example,

But contrary to common belief, the pace of immigration to America is modest by international standards—just 0.3% a year as a share of the U.S. population. The comparable figure was higher in two-thirds of countries in the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, and between double and quadruple as high in countries ranging from Canada to Norway.

That has a number of problems. First, it’s a snapshot. Rather than just looking at the headline rate, compare the U. S. with the other OECD countries over, say, the last century and it paints a very different picture. Second, most if not all of the OECD countries are experiencing social unrest as a consequence of high immigration rates. Countries with high rates of immigration that are faring best are those experiencing robust economic growth, have high standards for the immigrants they’ll accept, and the will and ability to enforce those standards, e.g. Switzerland.

Here’s another example:

There is little evidence that immigrants are arriving too fast for the U.S. labor market to absorb. As a share of the American workforce, the annual inflow of workers with green cards was 0.04%, far below the OECD median. The equivalent figure was 12 times as high in Australia, 10 times in New Zealand, and seven times in Canada.

That’s sleight of hand. He begins with “immigrants” and transitions to “immigrants with green cards”. There is ample evidence that the U. S. labor market is unable to absorb the number of low-skilled illegal immigrants we have accepted in the form of declining wages for low-skilled workers. Also, bear in mind that the costs are proportional to total number of immigrants while the benefits are proportional to the total number of skilled immigrants.

Finally,

Moreover, Canada has accepted 35,000 Syrian refugees in recent years with a minimum of public controversy.

It might help if we weren’t making war against refugees’ countries of origin and refugees weren’t setting bombs along marathon routes and killing people.

The bottom line for me is that we should accept more legal immigrants under a points system, accept fewer under “family reunification”, eliminate the diversity lottery, allow fewer illegal immigrants, make war a lot less, and look at our policies and the ways in which they interact unflinchingly. Sugar-coating and cherry-picking aren’t helpful.

1 comment

What Should the Policy Be?

Here’s an interesting case study. If this op-ed at the Wall Street Journal is accurate, China, the United Nations, and the United States are all subsidizing Chinese exports:

President Trump tweeted in December that the U.S. Postal Service isn’t charging Amazon enough to deliver merchandise. But it’s not Jeff Bezos who is getting the lowest rates. In fact, it’s a major economic competitor of the United States—China—that is getting a sweetheart deal from the USPS.

I learned of this because it undercuts my company, Mighty Mug. We sell a patented travel mug that we mail customers from our warehouse in New Jersey. Over the past two years, China-based competitors have flooded the market with knockoffs of our product.

We pay the USPS $6.30 to ship a Mighty Mug within the U.S. In a web search for infringing items, we came across a fake Mighty Mug for $5.69, with free shipping all the way from China. How is a Chinese retailer able to sell a product and send it 8,100 miles for less than our shipping costs alone?

The answer has to do with an international agency I’d never heard of—the Universal Postal Union, founded in 1874 and now a United Nations agency. It sets intercountry rates for mail delivery.

The UPU has 192 members divided into groups based on the strength of their economies. This classification dictates the amount each country pays in terminal dues—that is, the fee to a foreign postal service for delivering inbound mail. Less-developed countries get significant discounts on shipments to more-developed ones. The UPU classifies China a “Group 3” country, along with countries like Cuba and Gabon—even though China has the world’s largest e-commerce market.

Many developing countries can take advantage of this system, but China has done so like no other, partly because of the volume of its exports to the developed world and partly because its government aggressively subsidizes the trans-Pacific leg of the journey.

While it costs my company $6.30 to deliver a one-pound package within the U.S., the USPS delivers the same package from a Chinese shipper for just $1.40—less than a quarter of our cost. And the Chinese advantage increases with the weight of the package.

This low-cost shipping arrangement is not a two-way street. While a Chinese company can ship a mug here for a little more than $1, the USPS would charge my company $22 to ship a mug to China.

Adding insult to industry, the USPS loses money on these inbound China shipments. And American citizens are paying for it. As the Government Accountability Office stated in a 2017 report, “inbound international terminal dues mail does not cover its costs for delivering that mail in the United States. As a result, USPS’s net losses on this type of mail more than doubled from 2012 to 2016.” Meanwhile, “rates for outbound international terminal dues mail has resulted in net positive revenues for USPS.” In other words, American businesses are hurt by low-priced Chinese imports, and above-market shipping rates for exports.

What should the policy be? First, the United Nations needs to recalibrate the formula it uses for calculating shipping rates or, better yet, it shouldn’t be setting international shipping rates at all. The United States should be putting pressure on the United Nations to that end.

The United States should impose a tariff on Chinese goods in the amount of China’s export subsidies. And another tariff in the amount of the cost to American intellectual property owners of China’s failure to enforce protections on intellectual property in international accords to which China is a signatory. That would, at least, be a start.

Here’s a question. How much of the competitive advantage of China’s goods would vanish without their various subsidies? Note that I’ve barely scratched the surface of the ways in which we’re subsidizing China’s exports not merely to the United States but to the world.

Why don’t we take those commonsense steps? IMO it’s a combination of inertia, nostalgia, romanticism, political guile, and ideology. Inertia and nostalgia because many of our policies were formulated when the U. S. had the unquestioned largest economy in the world. Romanticism because we must help the poor Chinese, mustn’t we? Political guile because consumers (read: voters) like cheap consumer goods. And ideology because there is a consensus among American politicians that trade is always good and it’s not possible for any country to jigger its trade to be a weapon of economic warfare.

The effect of our “dumb as a post” polices is to penalize American manufacturing and intellectual property creators to the benefit of service industries (which we also subsidize). That has had the effects of refactoring our economy away from manufacturing and towards service industries, increasing income inequality, and subsidizing the parts of the country that are better able to attract service industry workers.

We really are our own worst enemy.

6 comments