Disruption

If the gigantic brains in Silicon Valley want to disrupt something, they might turn their attention to creating a dry-clean sanitary sidewalk for San Francisco:

How dirty is San Francisco? An NBC Bay Area Investigation reveals a dangerous mix of drug needles, garbage, and feces throughout downtown San Francisco. The Investigative Unit surveyed 153 blocks of the city – the more than 20-mile stretch includes popular tourist spots like Union Square and major hotel chains. The area – bordered by Van Ness Avenue, Market Street, Post Street and Grant Avenue – is also home to City Hall, schools, playgrounds, and a police station.

As the Investigative Unit photographed nearly a dozen hypodermic needles scattered across one block, a group of preschool students happened to walk by on their way to an afternoon field trip to city hall.

“We see poop, we see pee, we see needles, and we see trash,” said teacher Adelita Orellana. “Sometimes they ask what is it, and that’s a conversation that’s a little difficult to have with a 2-year old, but we just let them know that those things are full of germs, that they are dangerous, and they should never be touched.”

In California water is too precious to be used for cleaning sidewalks.

3 comments

From Liberalism to Progressivism to What?

I found James Traub’s article at Atlantic, “Selfishness Is Killing Liberalism” (apparently, originally titled “Liberalism in the Trump Era”), made interesting reading. I had some problems with his definitions. I think that liberalism as a political force in the United States began to die around 1970 and has been dead now for decades. The last liberal candidate for president was Walter Mondale and that was almost 35 years ago. It has been supplanted by progressivism and unlike liberalism progressivism isn’t about freedom at all. It’s about the pursuit of some ever-changing imagined future.

And “meritocracy” is in desperate danger of becoming an auto-antonym. When meritocracy means “having certain characteristics, abilities, or accomplishements” it’s one thing but when it becomes “belonging to the right clubs” how is it to be distinguished from hereditary aristocracy?

I agree with him about selfishness. I think that Elbert Hubbard, the Sage of East Aurora, (not to be confused with Ron Hubbard) said it pretty succinctly: when 51% of the people want to give rather than get I’ll be a socialist. A politics primarily about self-interest isn’t conservative, liberal, or progressive. It’s just dominance.

4 comments

Why Don’t Americans Vote?

I’ve reproduced a graph above which illustrates American voter participation from the founding of the Republic to the present. What are most notable are the sharp decline starting at the beginning of the 20th century and the smaller decline starting about 1960. The factors that produced the decline in voter participation in the early 20th century include civil service reform, extending the franchise to women, demographics, and restrictions placed on voting, particularly on black voters.

Civil service reform led to the political parties having less to offer their supporters. It used to be that when the presidency or governorships changed parties all of the old employees, appointees of the previous administration, were swept out an replaced by appointees of the incoming administration. Eliminating that “spoils system” reduced the influence of the political parties and reduced the stake that people had in voting. So they stopped voting.

We have learned through repeated experiments that extending the pool of eligible voters does not increase participation. Consequently, when the franchise was extended to women it didn’t increase participation. Paradoxically, it might even have decreased participation a bit.

The beginning of the 20th century marked the largest influx of immigrants to the United States in its history with just about 15% of the population being immigrants. As these people became citizens they did not have the same cultural traditions on voting that the previous cohorts of citizens did and, consequently, participation declined.

Finally, in the early part of the 20th century various laws including but not limited to poll taxes worked to suppress the African American vote. Working together all of these factors reduced participation.

What happened in the late 1960s? We extended the franchise to 18 year olds. They became eligible to vote but didn’t vote which meant that participation declined. There are any number of possible explanations for that including cognitive ones and lack of a stake in the outcomes. If we reinstituted the military draft I wouldn’t be surprised if the turnout of 18 year olds increased.

I think that extending the franchise to 16 year old would be extraordinarily imprudent? Why have an age limit at all?

If I were to change voter eligibility I’d eliminate any age limits but limit the franchise to those who paid the majority of their own bills but I’m pretty unreconstructed.

BTW, don’t expect the uptick of 2008 in turnout for presidential elections to persist. I believe that can be explained by people wanting to be part of something historic. That’s already largely been borne out in subsequent elections.

14 comments

Lie, Damned Lies, and Mass Shootings

After every mass shooting, particularly mass shootings in schools, I’ve seen emotional outpourings not limited to pleas for gun control but for all sorts of other measures including lowering the voting age to 16. Here are a series of facts about homicides and mass shootings. I may fill them in with citations as I have the energy and interest but those are easy enough to find if you’re interested.

  • The U. S. has a much higher homicide rate than any European country.
  • The U. S. has a much higher rate of gun ownership than any European country.
  • Mass shootings are rare incidents, both here and in Europe.
  • The U. S. has more incidents of mass shootings than any European country.
  • The U. S. has four times the population of the largest European country (Germany).
  • The rate per 100K population at which mass shootings take place in the U. S. is just about the same as in Germany.
  • The rate per 100K population at which mass shootings take place in the U. S. is lower than in some European countries, at least recently.
  • The gun homicide rate in the U. S. is sharply different between urban blacks and urban whites with urban blacks being most of the perpetrators and most of the victims.
  • The rural black homicide rate is roughly the same as the rural white homicide rate and much lower than the urban black homicide rate.
  • Mass shootings have taken place even in countries with very strict gun control.

Now the analysis and opinion part.

  • It’s hard to do meaningful analysis or make predictions about rare incidents.
  • Strict gun control laws in the U. S. will almost undoubtedly reduce the rate of suicide by gun and fatal accidents involving firearms.
  • They probably won’t do much to reduce the rate of gun homicides or mass shootings. The horse is already out of the barn on those.
  • The NRA isn’t the problem but it makes a convenient whipping boy.
  • The NRA does mobilize a segment of the population that elects politicians that progressives don’t like (and not just because they oppose gun control) pretty successfully.
  • The reason that stricter gun controls are politically difficult is that there are a lot of 2nd Amendment abolutists just as there are a lot of 1st Amendment absolutists and with equal legitimacy.
  • The overall homicide rate can probably be lowered with a combination of economic development focused on the inner cities, counseling not limited to young black men, and promoting social organizations other than gangs.
10 comments

Pointing the Finger

The editors of the Wall Street Journal echo the point about the Russian indictments I’ve been making, in their case pointing the finger at the CIA:

The indictment also makes us wonder what the Obama Administration was doing amid all of this. Where were top Obama spooks James Clapper and John Brennan ? Their outrage became public only after their candidate lost the election. If they didn’t know what was going on, why not? And if they did, why didn’t they let Americans in on the secret? President Obama sanctioned Russia for its meddling only after the election.

The difference between the FBI and the CIA is that the FBI has an affirmative responsibility for dealing with domestic espionage while the CIA is proscribed from such efforts.

They also make the following prescription:

he indictment’s details underscore Russia’s malicious anti-American purposes. An authoritarian regime spent tens of millions of dollars to erode public trust in American democracy. As Senator Ben Sasse (R., Neb.) put it Friday, “Putin’s shadow war is aimed at undermining Americans’ trust in our institutions. We know Russia is coming back in 2018 and 2020—we have to take the threat seriously.”

All of which makes the White House reaction on Friday strangely muted. Its statement understandably focused on the lack of collusion evidence and made one reference to “the agendas of bad actors, like Russia.” But given how much Russia’s meddling has damaged his first year in office, Mr. Trump should publicly declare his outrage at Russia on behalf of the American people. The Kremlin has weakened his Presidency. He should make Russia pay a price that Mr. Obama never did.

with which I concur.

13 comments

My Advice for President’s Day

While I believe that Washington and Lincoln are worthy of commemoration I deeply disapprove of President’s Day. I think we should celebrate Washington’s Birthday and Lincoln’s Birthday on the actual anniversaries of their births and commend the rest to sweet oblivion.

However, I will offer some advice in recognition of the day. End the Imperial Presidency. Return the presidency to its pre-Rooseveltian insignificance. Demand a more responsible, more responsive Congress. Seats in Congress shouldn’t be sinecures with lifetime tenure. Congress should also limit the appellate jurisdiction of the federal courts as is within its power but that’s a different subject.

2 comments

Caging the Tiger

I think that if Robert Samuelson is going to warn us about impending inflation he has a moral obligation to explain to us why we haven’t seen significant inflation in a very long time. I’ve already given my answer. Inflation isn’t rising. Prices are rising in health care and gasoline and the Northeast had a cold winter. Those may have run-on effects. They may not. But those price increases call for a different policy response than inflation would.

1 comment

What Should Be Done?

In an op-ed in the Washington Post Max Boot demands that something be done about Russian psy-ops directed against us. He opens with a hypothetical:

Imagine if, after 9/11, the president had said that the World Trade Center and Pentagon could have been attacked by “China” or “lots of other people.” Imagine if he had dismissed claims of al-Qaeda’s responsibility as a “hoax” and said that he “really” believed Osama bin Laden’s denials. Imagine if he saw the attack primarily as a political embarrassment to be minimized rather than as a national security threat to be combated. Imagine if he threatened to fire the investigators trying to find out what happened.

What if Franklin Roosevelt had ignored the attack on Pearl Harbor and taken no action afterwards? Would criticism be better directed at Truman or Roosevelt? It seems to me that the Russians are not the only ones engaging in psychological operations.

I agree that the Russians should pay some price for their psy ops actions directed against us. Beyond enforcing sanctions what should happen? Here’s my additional suggestion: reverse the move towards electronic voting.

4 comments

Best and Worst Presidents

In their op-ed at the New York Times poli sci profs Brandon Rottinghaus and Justin S. Vaughn list the best and worst presidents, based on a survey of other poli sci profs but helpfully broken down by the scholars’ party leanings. There is general agreement among them on who the four best presidents have been: Washington, Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, and Franklin Roosevelt although opinions on relative greatness among them vary by the party affiliation of those being surveyed.

In what will probably come as no surprise Trump is listed by all three groups (Democrats, Republican, and independents) as one of the five worst presidents. Others among the bottom five with all three groups are W. H. Harrison, Franklin Pierce, and James Buchanan.

It would be helpful if the professors listed the absolute numbers of Democrats, Republicans, and independents. That can be gleaned by going to the original report and looking at another question in the survey: roughly three-quarters of respondents are Democrats, less than 10% self-declare as Republicans and about 15% self-declare as independents. Compare this with American party affiliations: Democrats 32%, Republicans 22%, independents 44%.

It would be interesting to know where the respondents place within their parties and by age cohort. I suspect that most of the respondents skew left within their parties and skew old. That would explain why Truman is highly ranked among Democratic respondents and why Johnson is ranked low, for example (Truman because he integrated the military, Johnson because of the Viet Nam War).

In the end I’m not sure that this survey tells us as much about American presidents as it does about poli sci professors.

5 comments

Toxic Partisanship

At the New York Times Amanda Taub and Max Fisher point out that Russian meddling merely exploited a pre-existing opening:

Russian interference tended to focus on telling the targeted group to fear and distrust the other side. Posts that targeted Republicans, for instance, portrayed Mrs. Clinton as a threat to the Constitution and public safety, and in one memorable example said that her election would be a victory for Satan himself.

In taking this approach, the Russians were merely riding a trend that has been building for decades. Since the 1980s, surveys have found that Republicans and Democrats’ feelings toward the opposing party have been growing more and more negative. Voters are animated more by distrust of the other side than support for their own.

This highlights a problem that Lilliana Mason, a University of Maryland political scientist, said had left American democracy dangerously vulnerable. But it’s a problem driven primarily by American politicians and media outlets, which have far louder megaphones than any Russian-made Facebook posts.

“Compromise is the core of democracy,” she said. “It’s the only way we can govern.” But, she said, “when you make people feel threatened, nobody compromises with evil.”

We already have an ongoing investigation into Russian meddling and potential Trump campaign complicity with it and I support that. I think that there should be an additional investigation into why American law enforcement failed to detect these Russian activities or do anything about them in the period 2014-2016, the period during which the activities alleged in the indictments filed last week took place. Events move too fast these days, propelled on the wings of electronic communications, for the sort of tardy, long after the fact sort of activities presently being taken. Specifically, since the FBI has an explicit responsibility for counter-espionage activites, we need to understand why the FBI failed to do its job and how it can be reformed to do its job better.

I think that President Trump should order these investigations as well as enforce sanctions already in his power against Russians and the Russian government but I wouldn’t stop there. I don’t think the United States or Americans should meddle in other countries’ electoral process in any way other than as observers and we definitely should not overthrow foreign governments either directly or by abetting opposition groups.

Otherwise we should merely accept that these activities are business as usual and be prepared to oppose them domestically. They are asymmetric warfare in spades and its benefits accrue more to the weak than they do to us.

However, I don’t think that hysteria and hyperbole contribute to domestic political harmony, to addressing our manifest problems, or to moving forward.

6 comments