In Theory

At USA Today Alex Berezow explains the inevitable outcome of socialism:

In an ideal socialist society, “the people” own the means of production. Everyone’s basic needs are met. Leaders are elected democratically.

When implemented, however, human nature intervenes. Powerful elites take charge. This group, which usually consists of a charismatic individual and his politically loyal kleptocrats, becomes the true owners of the means of production. They exist largely to serve themselves, so voices of opposition must be suppressed. Free speech is abandoned and, eventually, fair elections are too.

Look no further than Venezuela for an example of how an allegedly socialist utopia necessarily leads to a communist crackdown. We are watching history repeat itself. As the socialist system collapses, Maduro implements tyranny. That’s how it works. That’s how it always works.

Make no mistake. The same is true of capitalism. Human nature will always intervene. Deals will always be cut for the politically connected or your relatives or just people that a powerful politician likes. It’s why the laws constraining monopolies go unenforced. It’s why Jeff Immelt was named a high advisor to Barack Obama in an area in which he was a prime offender.

It is true of every -ism. It is fine for your views to be informed by socialism, capitalism, egalitarianism, libertarianism, or a thousand other values. When they become your views it inevitably points the road to disaster.

My solution to that is to keep government small and close, limited and pragmatic and pay attention to it. That doesn’t prevent the disaster. It just mitigates the risk.

Fellow St. Louisan Yogi Berra once said that in theory there is no difference between practice in theory. In practice there is. That’s the problem with the -isms.

3 comments

The Reader’s Digest Version

Here’s the Reader’s Digest version of Aussie A. Odysseus Patrick’s explanation in the New York Times of why an Australian-style gun confiscation won’t work in the United States. Australia and the United States are different countries. Different histories. Different politics. Different people.

We never had a revolution. We never fought foreign troops on our soil. There was no antipodean civil war. From the moment the First Fleet arrived in Botany Bay in 1788 in what is now Sydney, security was provided by the British Army.

The indigenous population was displaced by force of arms, disease and appropriation of land, crimes for which many Australians still feel guilty. Prosperity, universal health care and unemployment benefits helped suppress crime. The few race riots that took place didn’t involve shooting.

concluding

Australian political leaders are rightly proud of our tight gun laws, which have also reduced criminal homicides and suicides. But it is unfair to grieving and distressed Americans to pretend that the Australian solution to mass shootings can be carried out in the United States. A homegrown plan is needed.

That’s the sort of obvious, commonsensical observation that leads me to suspect that political animus and fundraising are as much explanations for the agonistic outpourings that follow these isolated incidents as a desire to prevent needless deaths. A lot more could be done with a jobs program targeted at young men in inner cities than would ever be accomplished by bans.

11 comments

Nanette Fabray, 1920-2018

Nanette Fabray, Broadway, stage, and television star, has died at 97. From her Variety obit:

Born in San Diego, Nanette Ruby Bernadette Fabares was a singer and tap dancer in vaudeville as a child.

As an ingenue, she appeared in the 1939 films “Essex and Elizabeth,” “The Monroe Doctrine”and “A Child Is Born,” credited as Nanette Fabares, but she never developed a substantial movie career.

Much later, she appeared in “The Happy Ending” (1969) and was among the stars of the 1970 comedy Western “Cockeyed Cowboys of Calico County” and of the comedy “Harper Valley P.T.A.” (1978). She appeared in the 1981 indie “Amy,” starred as an IRS investigator in the 1987 film “Personal Exemptions” and made her last bigscreen appearance in 1994’s “Teresa’s Tattoo.”

She was a fixture on television in the 1950s and 60s. I remember vividly when she replaced Imogene Coca as Sid Caesar’s comedic partner when Your Show of Shows folded and Caesar and Coca started their own shows.

However, if she had appeared in nothing else, she’d still be eternal for her performance in The Band Wagon. Vincent Minelli could really coax great performances from his leading ladies, couldn’t he? She was just luminous in it, more than holding her own against top stars Fred Astaire, Jack Buchanan, and Oscar Levant, playing a character inspired by Betty Comden. Maybe her greatest acting feat was looking beautiful while standing next to Cyd Charisse.

She was just about the same age as my mom. I wonder if their paths ever crossed? She was in vaudeville at just about the same time, presumably playing in the same western circuits. Well, their paths have crossed now.

0 comments

What’s New?

I’ve already said my piece about gun control and school shootings.

I’m uninterested in Billy Graham and American Protestantism in general. Eternal rest grant unto him, O Lord.

I’m still content to let the Mueller investigation run its course. I won’t attempt to prejudge its findings.

I think the situation in Syria is terrible and I think it will continue to be terrible for a long time. I don’t think we should be aiding Al Qaeda or DAESH or any other Islamists for that matter.

I find Donald Trump unpleasant. I wish he weren’t president but he is and probably will be for until January 2021. At least. I wish he were managing the federal government better. The major news media other than Fox and the Wall Street Journal are against him to the point of obsession.

I don’t much care about the Olympics.

I don’t care about the mayor of Nashville or the governor of Missouri. I don’t see why anyone other than Nashvilleans or Missourians should.

So, what’s new?

9 comments

Everything We Want

In his op-ed at the Wall Street Journal Stanford scholar John E. Cogan makes it pretty clear that he doesn’t like deficits or debt:

As the chart makes clear, all—yes, all—of the increase in federal spending relative to GDP over the past seven decades is attributable to entitlement spending. Since the late 1940s, entitlement claims on the nation’s output of goods and services have risen from less than 4% to 14%. Surprising as it may seem, the share of GDP that is spent on national defense and nondefense discretionary programs combined is no higher today than it was seven decades ago.

The contrast between the long-term increase in entitlement spending and the long-term decline in defense spending reflects the profound transformation of the federal government’s priorities from providing for the nation’s defense to redistributing income. The Vietnam War, President Reagan’s defense buildup, and the Iraq and Afghanistan wars were costly, but the increase in defense spending in each case pales in comparison with the astonishing growth in entitlement spending.

If you’re seeking the reason for the federal government’s chronic budget deficits and crushing national debt, look no further than entitlement programs. Show the accompanying chart to your friends or acquaintances who continue to assert that defense spending is causing the budget deficit. Since the early 1970s, entitlements have been the federal budget’s largest spending category, the sole source of the federal budget’s growth relative to GDP, and the primary cause of chronic budget deficits.

Today, entitlement spending accounts for nearly two-thirds of federal spending. Defense spending still only accounts for about a sixth of the federal budget, even with recent increases. Defense spending could be doubled and it would still be only half what the federal government spends on entitlements. Significant reductions in the budget deficit can only be achieved by restraining the growth of entitlement spending.

History shows that such restraint is not possible without presidential leadership. Unfortunately, President Trump has failed to step up. His budget proposes to shave a mere 1% from entitlement spending that is growing at 6% a year. The president has ruled out any significant reform of Social Security and Medicare, the two largest entitlement programs. His budget shows that this year Social Security and Medicare expenditures will exceed the payroll taxes and premium payments dedicated to supporting them by $420 billion. Social Security and Medicare deficits will account for half this year’s total budget deficit.

The situation is no better at the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue. Democrats are getting domestic spending increases and Republicans are getting increases to the defense budget. Instead of offsetting higher spending with reductions elsewhere, Congress simply increased both defense and domestic spending in the recently enacted continuing resolution to fund the government. At the same time, by eliminating the need to vote on a debt ceiling this year and ruling out the reconciliation process for any budget bill, Congress signaled that it has no stomach for entitlement restraint.

The continuing resolution’s two-year spending binge has been rightly criticized as excessive. But the size of the increase in spending it authorizes should be kept in perspective. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that the resolution will add $174 billion in discretionary spending to the budget in 2019, the year of its maximum impact. At the same time, entitlement expenditures will automatically increase by about the same amount.

What about the future? Social Security and Medicare expenditures are accelerating now that baby boomers have begun to collect their government-financed retirement and health-care benefits. If left unchecked, these programs will push government spending to levels never seen during peacetime.

Financing this spending will require either record levels of taxation or debt [ed.: probably both]. Economics teaches us that high tax rates reduce economic growth and living standards. History teaches us that high public debt aggravates economic volatility and makes a country’s financial system more prone to crisis. Congress can avoid these harmful outcomes only by taking action soon. Its first step should be to send the president’s budget proposal back with a request that he come up with a plan to rein in entitlement spending.

It didn’t have to be this way. Nearly all of the increase is a result of uncontrolled health care spending. Ironically, that’s a consequence of attempting to keep health care within the private sector. If, instead of creating Medicare and Medicaid in the 1960s, the VA had been used as a model and the federal government had opened a series of clinics offering a limited array of services for the poor, the elderly, and, particularly, the elderly poor—the stated intent of the programs—costs might not have risen as they did. That would have needed to have been coupled with a commitment to cost control, the lack of which is the fundamental source of our present problem.

In preemptive response to the inevitable retort that Medicare costs less than private sector health are with lower administrative costs a) because of their structures Medicare and Medicaid administrative costs are largely hidden; b) we’re unlikely to push health care administrative costs below Canada’s which are presently around 15%; and c) they won’t be under a single-payer plan unless you believe that providers will take a pay cut.

As me auld mither used to say we can have anything we want but we can’t have everything we want. Right now most federal government spending is on health care or old age pensions and state and local spending is on health care and public employee pensions and both are increasing in cost faster than economic growth or incomes. Increasing taxation, borrowing more, or simply issuing credit are all likely to create additional problems without addressing the underlying causes of the problems.

I don’t know what the solution is. When you’ve kicked the can down the road long enough, ultimately you run about of road. Whatever the solution is it’s likely to make a lot of people miserable and some people extremely miserable.

12 comments

Après Moi le Déluge

Both the New York Times and the Wall Street Journal lead their opinion pages today with anti-Assad editorials. The editors of the NYT declaim:

It is now tragically apparent that degrading the Islamic State has not created an opening for peace in Syria. Instead, the country’s vicious president, Bashar al-Assad, and his enablers in Russia and Iran have exploited the battlefield successes against ISIS to unleash a new round of carnage on civilians, as the leaders of the United States and other world powers largely stand by, unwilling or unable to do anything to stop it. Shame on them all.

The Assad-led bombardment of eastern Ghouta, a Damascus suburb of about 400,000 people and one of the last rebel-held areas, is being called one of the most violent episodes of the seven-year war. Since Sunday at least 310 people, many of them children, have been killed. That’s in addition to nearly 500,000 Syrians killed countrywide since 2011.

Ghouta has been under siege for years, although it’s technically part of a negotiated de-escalation zone, leaving the district facing chronic shortages of food, medicine, medical personnel and other necessities.

This week’s massive attack — which has involved rocket fire, shelling, airstrikes and helicopter-dropped barrel bombs that struck hospitals and other civilian infrastructure — intensified the misery. It seems intended to force rebels to surrender so the government can reclaim the territory. Most of the civilian casualties resulted from airstrikes on residential areas, the United Nations’ human rights office said. There have been signs that a government ground assault may soon follow.

while the editors of the WSJ lament:

Bashar Assad’s Syrian military committed more atrocities this week, bombing the opposition stronghold of Eastern Ghouta and killing at least 200. Rescue workers had to haul dead civilians from the rubble, including a family of five. As everyone deplores the killings, the point to keep in mind is that the driving political power here is Iran and its attempt to make Syria part of its growing Shiite-Persian empire.

Iran has propped up Assad since the Syrian civil war erupted in 2011, and along with Russia is largely responsible for the regime’s survival. After its 2016 victory in Aleppo and the ouster of Islamic State from Raqqa, this axis is now trying to roll up the last opposition strongholds. The trio will then use Russia-sponsored peace talks to re-establish Assad’s control over Syria. Russia will keep its military bases, and Iran wants to establish a new imperial outpost on the border with Israel.

Assad is terrible. I’m in complete agreement with that. Where we disagree is that I think that any foreseeable government in Syria will be terrible and we should be cautious about which misery we seek to inflict on the Syrians.

A little background. In the Northeast of Syria along the coast is the homeland of people who practice a distinctive version of Islam, loosely related to the Shi’ism practiced in Iran and in the Arab Gulf states. It’s trinitarian, after a fashion, something abhorrent to Muslims who practice more conventional forms of the religion. These people are referred to as “Alawites”.

Under the Ottoman the Alawites were persecuted, their rights were severely limited, they experienced periodic pogroms, and by every account they were miserably poor. When the French established their Mandate in Syria following World War I, they put the Alawites in charge, first of their own statelet, then of Syria.

In the 1960s Hafez al-Assad, an Alawite general, was one of the founders of Syria’s secularist Ba’ath movement and quickly became Syria’s military dictator, an event that has been compared with a member of the untouchable caste becoming maharajah. Bashar al-Assad, Syria’s present leader, is Hafez al-Assad’s son.

He represents not just the al-Assad family but a whole cadre of Alawites in the Syrian government and they have plenty to fear. It’s estimated that as many as a third of Alawite men have been killed in the civil war with the rebels. They’re literally fighting for their own survival and that of their people.

If Assad were eliminated he would merely be replaced by another Alawite who would do all of the same things that Assad has done for all of the same reasons. The alternative is that he would be replaced by a violent, radical Islamist, i.e. Al Qaeda or DAESH, who would proceed to exterminate the Alawites and, as we have seen, would be even worse than Assad.

So, editors of the NYT and WSJ, name your poison. Whom do you support? A secularist albeit a despicable secularist or a violent radical Islamist?

6 comments

Boon and Bane

In his latest column at the Washington Post Robert Samuelson is worried about the Internet:

Relying on data from Verizon, the CEA study classifies cyberwarriors into four major groups: (1) nation-states that spy on or disrupt their adversaries; the major players here are China, Russia, North Korea and Iran (the United States should probably be added to this list); (2) criminals engaging in identity theft and “ransomware” — the stealing of data that is promised to be returned upon payment of a given fee; (3) business competitors that steal proprietary technologies and trade secrets; (4) company “insiders,” usually disgruntled workers “looking for revenge or financial gain.” In addition, there are various freelancers: people with a political agenda or who hack for fun.

According to the Verizon data, about half the “threat actors” are criminals and about a fifth are groups affiliated with nation-states. Interestingly, about a quarter of cyberattacks are caused by insiders.

I can only judge by my own experience. When I blocked every Chinese IP address I could identify, the volume of malicious and nuisance traffic on this blog declined dramatically. IMO Mr. Samuelson’s list doesn’t quite show us just how much his categories overlap. So, for example, North Korean hackers aren’t just spying and disrupting. They’ve been identified as responsible for serious ransomware attacks, notably the “Wannacry” attack of last year.

I would turn things around. I think that the general failure to take cybersecurity seriously is the actual threat. How do you mitigate the risk of your house being burgled? Locking your doors at night would be a good start. You could keep valuables in a safe deposit box. There are measures than can be taken. Alternatively, you could write an op-ed complaining that there are burglars.

But the federal and state governments rarely even follow their own security protocol and the failure to do so is never punished. Businesses, large and small, have the same problem.

The reason for such lax security is actually pretty obvious. There are costs associated with security, both direct and indirect including opportunity costs. There are some things that just don’t make financial sense when the cost of security is taken into account.

We could cut cyberattacks from China, Russia, North Korea, and Iran down to a trickle by blocking them at their choke points. Shut those countries off the Internet. We won’t do it because there’s too much money to be made by making communications easy, even with bad actors.

1 comment

Number 1?

I was struck by this remark from Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis, quoted at The National Interest:

U.S. Defense Secretary Jim Mattis is reaffirming that NATO remains the United States’ most important alliance. That is despite a perception that the Trump Administration is skeptical of the alliance.

“NATO remains our number-one alliance. So I spent a fair amount of time on that effort at EUCOM. Obviously heartened coming out of the NATO ministerial would be an understatement, but the continued climbing of the defense budgets,” Mattis told reporters on Feb. 17.

Given European militaries’ state of preparedness and how little the Germans in particular spend on improving their situation, I’d say it looks more like Number 2.

To be a bit more explicit there are only five militaries in the world at the highest level of readiness, as the U. S. military calculates these things: U. S., Russia, China, India, and France. France is just barely at the highest level of readiness.

5 comments

The Pestilence of Modern Times

At Defense One Eliot Cohen, reporting on the Munich security conference, remarks:

What has happened here is the same phenomenon that explains so many of the ills of the last couple of decades: the algae-like bloom of elites and their simultaneous loss of substance. A younger John McCain would not have been unique for his qualities of wisdom and character at the earlier iterations of this conference. He would have been met by acute thinkers like Thérèse Delpech of France, staunch public servants like Manfred Wörner, a German defense minister and secretary general of NATO in the 1980s, or politicians like Dennis Healey of Britain. Their successors are cautious functionaries, pallid experts, and colorless politicians who think carefully about domestic audiences before speaking up abroad.

This political entropy seems to be a near-universal phenomenon in the Western world; why this is so is unclear, and probably has many explanations. But the nicely tailored generation represented in Munich this year seemed baffled by the re-entry into history of today’s authoritarians and fanatics. One wonders whether the attendees possess the steel of the earlier generation that took part in World War II, and in the subsequent struggle with Communism. Attempted Russian subversion of democratic elections in the United States and Europe elicited concern from some at the conference, but few were willing to call for a punitive response sufficient to inflict real pain on Moscow. Meanwhile, Russian oligarchs happily hobnobbed with Europeans looking to do business on the side.

I’m tempted to observe, paraphrasing the late Mayor Daley, that global elites aren’t there to prevent turmoil; they’re there to preserve turmoil. Every single global problem today has been created and abetted by the policies put into place by that elite.

Credentials are not character and wisdom, a virtue, is promoted by practicing wisdom. It’s not something that can be read in a book or something that is conferred on you by being appointed to head a ministry. Or a government. Rejoicing at the overthrow of institutions while bemoaning the consequences of their loss is sophistry.

America’s military umbrella is a consequence of America’s economic strength as well as promoting it. That economic strength grew from America’s people; it was not handed down to them by elites like the tablets of the law.

0 comments

What Happens?

An article at Newsweek puts additional heft behind a point I’ve been making for some time. Moore’s Law, the rule of thumb predicting that the density of transistors on a chip would double every two years, appears to have run out of gas:

In 1965, Gordon Moore, co-founder of Intel, came up with a theory of technology progression that held true for more than 50 years. Coined “Moore’s law,” the theory suggested that the speed of computer processors would double every two years. The transistors inside of computer chips would continue to decline in cost and size but increase in power. Those predictions held true for decades, but a new study suggests that Moore’s law may have finally run out.

The study, published in Nature Electronics, suggests that technology can no longer get any smaller and innovators will have to figure out a new way to make it better. What this new way is, no one yet knows. As outlined in the new study, the future of microprocessors, the tiny computer chips that help run our lives, is complicated.

“The underlying science for this technology is as of yet unknown, and will require significant research funds—an order of magnitude more than is being invested today,” said Hassan Khan, a researcher at Carnegie Mellon University who specializes in engineering and public policy, Tech Explore reported.

And there’s no guarantee that the investment would pay off. Technology doesn’t necessarily advance geometrically or even continually but in fits and starts. Contrary to what you might have heard there haven’t been a lot of basic discoveries over the period of the last half century. Most have been elaborations of existing understanding.

It seems to me that the most obvious thing that an end to Moore’s Law would do is that lousy computer software wouldn’t be as easy to tolerate as it is now. Software developers could no longer depend on hardware to save them.

And to whatever extent autonomous vehicles and the robot apocalypse more generally depend on rapidly improving hardware, they may be practical later than has been anticipated.

2 comments