Pushing Wages Down

An op-ed at the New York Times from Alan Krueger and Eric Posner lists some of the ways in which companies keep wages low:

Even after eight years of economic recovery and steady private-sector job growth, wages for most Americans have hardly budged. It is tempting to think that wage stagnation is intractable, a result of long-term trends, like automation and globalization, that government is powerless to do anything about.

In fact, a growing body of evidence pins much of the blame on a specific culprit, one for which proven legal weapons already exist. But they are not being used.

The culprit is “monopsony power.” This term is used by economists to refer to the ability of an employer to suppress wages below the efficient or perfectly competitive level of compensation. In the more familiar case of monopoly, a large seller — like a cable company — is able to demand high prices for poor service because consumers have no other choice. It turns out that many corporations possess bargaining power over their workers, not just over their consumers. Their workers accept low wages and substandard working conditions because few alternative job opportunities exist for them or because switching jobs is costly. In other words, in the labor market, effectively a small number of employers are competing for their labor.

The other culprit at which they point the finger is outsourcing. I wish they had been a bit more precise about what they meant by that. Every company outsources. I don’t know of any company that operates its own phone system, generates it own electricity, builds its own office buildings, manufactures its own vehicles, and develops its own software. Even Microsoft uses non-Microsoft software. Companies outsource those functions because it’s more efficient to do so. That’s basic Adam Smith.

Outsourcing and particularly offshore outsourcing core business functions is a different issue. To those I would add importing workers from overseas to replace domestic workers, something that’s expressly prohibited but is done all of the time. There’s also employing illegal immigrants.

The authors’ implied solutions are bans on “no-poaching” employment contracts and increasing union power:

Unions used to offset employer monopsony power, but unions now represent only 7 percent of private sector workers, down from a peak of 35 percent in the 1950s.

which is self-refuting. Unions function most effectively when there’s a tight labor market.

My own view is that size itself is the enemy. Big companies exert monopsony power. It’s unlikely that your local bookstore wields the power that Amazon does.

The first step is having the guts to enforce laws already on the books. When monopolies use their power to push their way into other businesses, that’s an illegal violation of monopoly power. Such companies should be broken up.

6 comments

What’s the Compromise?

The editors of the Washington Post call for a compromise in Janus v. AFSCME:

THE SUPREME COURT heard arguments Monday in Janus v. American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, which presents the justices with two questions. The first is the legal issue in the case: whether governments may require public-sector workers to pay a fee to unions that represent them in collective bargaining, even if they disagree with the union on politics and other matters. The second, and broader, question is the implicit one of how the court should conduct judicial review in a deeply polarized society.

Few matters are more consequential, in partisan terms, than the flow of funds to public-sector unions, a key constituency of the Democratic Party. There are good-faith reasons to be concerned about the power of these unions; one of those reasons is whether compulsory collective-bargaining fees amount to compelled speech by employees in favor of unions, contrary to the First Amendment. Yet the fact is that the court decided those issues in a similar case 41 years ago, ruling that there was no constitutional violation given governments’ compelling interest in stable labor relations. Opponents of mandatory fees are asking the justices to overrule that long-established precedent, something they are usually loath to do, for good reason.

While I agree with those who point out that public employees’ unions are different from private sector unions, a distinction the editors don’t seem to recognize, but I agree with the editors that a compromise solution is available. Justice Breyer’s suggestion probably shows the general contours of the compromise:

Perhaps sensitive to that reality, Justice Stephen G. Breyer repeatedly suggested at oral argument that the court adopt a compromise — one that would not upset precedent but would update it, to take account of genuine First Amendment concerns related to public-sector collective bargaining. Specifically, Mr. Breyer asked attorneys for the contending parties for their views on a solution under which employees could be required to pay, but only for a narrow range of collective-bargaining duties as defined in state law, rather than for tangentially related matters, such as union conventions, for which unions have heretofore been permitted to charge.

It’s not completely unreasonable for the unions to collect representation and related fees but not nearly as reasonable to demand money to be paid out as political contributions. The unions should also be required to maintain books that maintain that distinction.

7 comments

I Can’t Believe

Emma Chambers, the actress who portraryed Alice on the hysterically funny BBC sitcom, Vicar of Dibley, has died at the young age of 53. In her honor I’m posting one of her funniest bits from Vicar:

The ability to make people laugh is a great gift. What a loss.

0 comments

Urban Homesteading, Racial Politics, and Ducks in a Row

There’s an article at Jacobin about “urban homesteading” that I found interesting and largely agreed with. Here’s what I thought was its meat:

Speaking at a national housing convention shortly after his swearing in, Kemp, a former US representative and NFL quarterback, sung the praises of programs that allowed public housing tenants to purchase their buildings and become homeowners.

For Kemp, these “urban homesteaders,” mostly low-income black women, proved that “poor folks can become managers, producers, entrepreneurs . . . if only government helps clear obstacles.” Homeownership transformed welfare recipients into workers and taxpayers by harnessing “the greatest engine of growth ever devised — entrepreneurial free enterprise.” HUD’s small-scale experiments in resident ownership, Kemp insisted, represented “one of the most dynamic movements in America since Rosa Parks moved to the front of the bus and helped launch a crusade.” After all, “equal access to homeownership was what the American dream was all about.”

If Kemp was particularly rapturous in his praise, he wasn’t alone in imbuing homeownership with an alchemical power.

For more than forty years, supporters in both major parties have offered homeownership as a solution to the myriad problems facing low-income families. More individual private housing, not affordable public housing, has long been cast as the way to attack poverty.

There were some things in the article I took exception to. For example, I think the author is too hard on Jack Kemp. Kemp may have been wrong but he was genuine, sincere, hardworking, and not motivated by racial bias. I think she disses home ownership too much.

We’ve tried building public housing and that was a manifest failure. We’ve tried scattered-site housing and that hasn’t been much better. Dispersing inner city populations have had the adverse effects of breaking up communities and their support systems and meeting with enormous resistance from the previous residents.

If she has another solution to the challenges of inner city housing, she should propose it.

There’s a significant racial component to all of this. When other residents of majority black neighborhoods take derelict homes and rebuild and refurbish them, it’s “urban homesteading”. When whites do, it’s “gentrification”. I don’t know what the experience has been in other cities but I can tell you what happened in St. Louis and Chicago. In both places mostly gay white men moved into urban neighborhoods that were decaying rapidly, took advantage of the low prices, bought property, and turned homes that were in practically falling down condition into showplaces.

Finally, the condition of the inner cities of St. Louis, Baltimore, Detroit, and many other cities is such that anyone who’s willing to tackle the job of improvement should be encouraged. That can’t be accomplished if keeping neighborhoods segregated is a higher priority.

10 comments

Inherently Corrupt

One of the hottish topics about which I haven’t written is Janus v. AFSCME, presently before the Supreme Court. In the case the plaintiff challenges the union’s right to charge him agency fees on grounds of free speech and association. In his Washington Post column, George Will, who has an insider’s view of the case, writes:

In private-sector collective bargaining, management and labor negotiate how to distribute companies’ profits. No comparably adversarial process exists in the public sector. There government, which acquires its “profits” (revenue) from a third party — taxpayers — “negotiates” with unions that have an interest in government doing what it wants to do anyway: expand. Because government is both employer and policymaker, collect­ive bargaining by the union is inherently political advocacy and indistinguishable from lobbying. Hence in 2012 the court acknowledged that compulsory fees are “compelled speech and association” implicating on First Amendment rights. President Franklin Roosevelt was right: “The process of collective bargaining, as usually understood, cannot be transplanted into the public service.”

I have no opinion of the legalities and I don’t know which side should prevail. I do know that I think the present situation with public employees’ unions is inherently corrupt. Dues and fees are being directed into political contributions which are recycled into higher wages.

My predisposition is to ban public employees’ unions from making political contributions, full stop. There are other ways of correcting the present situation without muzzling the public employees’ unions but I’m afraid that some of those measures would have serious adverse secondary effects while others would require a complete transformation in our form of government.

7 comments

The Middle Class Lifestyle

Following up on my post of yesterday (to which James Joyner has contributed his thoughts at OTB), I thought I’d describe my childhood a bit. For the first ten years of my life we lived in a small house in a blue collar neighborhood making the transition from being entirely white to entirely black, which is what the neighborhood has been for the last forty-five years. I’ve posted a picture of the house here.

It was a one bedroom house with kitchen, living room, dining room and bath. Shortly before I was born my dad and his pal, Jack, added a large room at the back of the house. That room served as bedroom and playroom for me and my siblings until my youngest siblings (twins) were born. Then it was our playroom and bedroom for me, my siblings, and my parents while the twins occupied the bedroom.

Prior to marriage had worked as a teacher in the St. Louis Public Schools. After marriage she taught in a school in St. Louis County. The St. Louis Public Schools did not allow their teachers to be married but the County schools did. My dad worked two jobs: building his practice as an attorney during the day and teaching law at St. Louis University at night. We were indubitably middle class.

The neighborhood in which we lived was a gritty, working class one. There was a bar on the corner. Above the bar was a brothel. The girls used to give me a nickel to get cigarettes for them at the grocery store across the street, a tiny one room affair with shelves that went up to the ceiling and a sort of trolley that enable the storeowners to get things from the upper shelves without climbing a ladder.

The woman who lived next door to us ran numbers. Down the street there was a guy who sold drugs out of his garage. He also had a very interesting comic book collection from before the reform of the comics industry in 1954.

My parents scrimped and saved as much as they possibly could. We had a comfortable life but we didn’t own a lot of stuff. If they couldn’t pay cash for it, they didn’t buy it. That’s one of the big secrets. The way to get rich and the way to stay poor are the same: buying things on credit and paying interest.

Here’s another big secret. Most young people don’t know what their parents’ lives were like before they were born or when they were very young. They imagine that their lives as young people should be what their parents’ lives were like when they were ten years older than they are.

In case you think that my experiences were out of the ordinary, my wife’s parents’ experience was very similar. Early in their marriage he was in the South Pacific fighting in World War II. She lived with his parents working at one of a succession of fairly menial jobs. When he got out of the service he went to college on the GI Bill. They lived frugal lives and saved like crazy, eventually buying a house.

My point here is that being middle class doesn’t mean big houses in leafy suburbs, private schools for the kids, multiple cars, and vacations. That’s upper middle class. Middle class means living not just within your means but below your means and saving for the future.

22 comments

I Don’t Tweet—Don’t Ask Me

I don’t have much more than what amount to tweets this morning.

  • The Schiff memo, like the Nunes memo before it, is a purely political document.
  • I’m still content to let the Mueller investigation work its way through.
  • My disinterest in the Winter Olympics, now concluded, is extreme. I didn’t watch a single event.
  • Why are we supporting Nazis in Ukraine and Al Qaeda in Syria? I think we’ve lost our way.
11 comments

All the Children Are Above Average

And as I read Mark Perry’s post at the Foundation for Economic Education, “Why Our Shrinking Middle Class Is a Good Thing”, I could only think, “Oh, for an educated class that understands statistics!” What the statistics he cites in the article really tell us is that in many places in the country a six figure salary barely provides a middle class lifestyle any more.

There is a slim, now more than 50 year old pamphlet titled “How to Lie With Statistics” that should be required reading for every educated person.

What is middle class? I would propose that for the entire country “middle class” should mean median income ±two standard deviations, upper middle class median income +three standard deviations, and “the rich” as median income +four standard deviations. Median income minus three standard deviations are “the working poor”. For individual localities the definitions would vary based on the local median income.

According to the Census ACS median income for a family of four in Chicago is around $66,000 (other reckonings say $47,000). The “middle class” would then be households earning between $45,000 and $85,000. Incomes in Chicago have basically been flat for a dozen years. Note that if you research this yourself you should distinguish carefully among Chicago, Chicago metro, and Illinois.

Using my method the middle class cannot by definition shrink but it can become poorer which is very much what has happened over the last 30 years.

8 comments

If You Ignore Enough

As I read Sarah Jones’s article at The New Republic, “Telling Rural People To Move Won’t Solve Poverty”:

It sounds easy enough: If you can’t find a job where you are, move. But experts tell me that this refrain is a gross oversimplification. The problems that plague rural America did not originate there, and their consequences do not end where cities begin. The roots of rural poverty in fact say quite a bit about the nature of poverty generally—both why it happens and what can be done to prevent it.

“Just like there’s not one urban America, there’s not one rural America either,” explained Kenneth Johnson, who teaches demography and sociology at the University of New Hampshire. Some rural areas shrink with disproportionate speed; others, however, are actually experiencing net in-migration. The differences frequently map onto differences in regional industries. “For example, the parts of rural America that tend to receive net in-migration most of the time are those that are just beyond the edges of the urban areas,” Johnson said. “And then the other ones that often will receive migration gains are recreational or retirement kind of amenity areas.”

it came to me that she’s ignoring the enormous subsidies that cities receive. Consider just one city: Washington, DC. Not only are the headquarters of every federal agency located there, the lobbyists, law firms, think tanks, and other organizations that are creatures of those federal agencies are, too, and they provide an enormous boost to the local economy. Housing prices aren’t high in the DC metro area because of the clement climate and beautiful scenery. It’s because there’s money there.

Every major city benefits from a vast array of federal, state, and local government agencies and the financial benefits they bring. It’s no accident that the first counties to recover after the Great Recession were those where seats of government were located.

It doesn’t have to be that way at least not any more and large private sector organizations increasingly tend not to operate that way. On a daily basis I meet with people on three continents and a dozen cities and it doesn’t matter whether I’m sitting in a cubicle in the office or at my dining room table. I’ve sometimes thought of setting up a blue screen in my dining room, projecting a palatial office onto it, and turning the video on for more meetings.

As more Americans become urban dwellers the temptation to design programs that work best in urban settings becomes irresistible and the whole thing becomes one enormous feedback loop.

Here’s my (modest) proposal for reducing rural poverty. Relocate federal agencies. Moving HHS’s headquarters from the Hubert Humphrey Building to Yazoo City would unquestionably boost the local economy there. And would probably be a lot cheaper to operate.

17 comments

The Sixth Fact

In addition to the five facts about President Trump’s infrastructure that the non-partisan group No Labels tells us about at RealClearPolicy I think there’s a sixth fact: the program is heavily skewed towards roads and bridges—big, showy projects that might not be what we need. That’s one of the problems with the ASCE’s annual status report. It tells us a lot about what could be done and absolutely nothing about what should be done. It evaluates the condition of roads and bridges used by hundreds of thousands of people on a daily basis right along with rural bridges that wouldn’t be used by a dozen people annually if it were in prime condition.

Rather than the amenities in airports that Tom Friedman incessantly squawks about, our greatest infrastructure needs are probably sewers and a power grid desperately in need of updating and a redundancy the private sector will never willingly provide.

I guess I shouldn’t stew about it. Given the 80-20 balance of state, local, and private funding vs. federal funding, few projects will probably end up being funded under the program. State and local governments are too busy paying the pensions of public employee retirees to do much of anything else.

That’s the problem with infrastructure plans. Everybody wants to fund their infrastructure needs with somebody else’s money rather than their own.

2 comments