What Patents Actually Do

There’s an article at ECN that echoes what I’ve been saying here for some time:

Lindsey and Teles argue that the main effect of patent laws is to empower already powerful corporations and groups to stifle startups and competition from less powerful inventors and small companies. In U. S. patent law, the first person to file a patent is the winner who takes all the rights. Even if the first to file wasn’t the first to invent, the first filer can, and often does, stop other inventors from using the fruits of their own inventiveness in the case of nearly simultaneous inventions, which often happens in rapidly advancing fields. So in this way, a law intended to let inventors benefit from their own inventions actually stops them from doing so.

Some years back I heard an interview with Dean Kamen, inventor of the Segway, an insulin pump, and many others in which he remarked that the secret to making a living as an inventor is not to invent anything important since, regardless of patents, your invention will be stolen by a big company capable of fighting you in court.

There are other reasons to abandon our current patent laws. One of them is that, since China’s enforcement of patent law is cursory at best, patents place Americans at a competitive disadvantage. That’s related to the point I’ve made previously about reciprocity.

0 comments

I Demand a Recount

In an article at US News ranking the 50 states in terms of health care, education, economy, opportunity, infrastructure, crime and corrections, fiscal stability, and quality of life, Illinois ranks 47th in terms of quality of life and 35th overall. Illinois ranks dead last in terms of fiscal stability which sounds about right.

Iowa placed #1 which does not surprise me. Louisiana ranked #50 which is equally unsurprising.

California ranks last in terms of quality of life which, honestly, strikes me as peculiar.

However, I find Illinois’s ranking as 35th overall is a gross injustice—to the other states. Its ranking in opportunity (24th) and crime and corrections are obviously overrated and its ranking of 13th in infrastructure is a free flight of fancy as anyone who’s ever driven on an Illinois road will testify.

In short, we wuz robbed. We should have ranked last.

8 comments

This Could Get Nasty

When I read this article I could only think of how nasty this could get. The white to black ratio in the population of Zimbabwe was never more than 1:20. In South Africa it’s more like 1:9. Also, the Afrikaners are very tough people and they arrived in South Africa at just about the same time as the Bantu-speaking people who make up 90% of blacks. Unless you think that blacks have some sort of inherent right to African land, a notion with troublesome implications, the Afrikaners have as much right to the land as the Bantu-speaking people do.

6 comments

It Is Time to Rethink the First Amendment

That was my reaction to Maria Cardona’s op-ed at The Hill, “It’s time to rethink the Second Amendment”. In it the basis of her argument is, echoing Earl Long, “the feds have the bomb” and think of all the benefits of repealing the Second Amendment.

A parallel argument could be made about the First Amendment and it would be no less incendiary than her suggestion. Just as there are First Amendment absolutists there are Second Amendment absolutists. I’m not one of them but I know some of them and their views are no less legitimate than those of First Amendment absolutists.

My view, as I’ve frequently repeated, is that guns and ammunition are too plentiful already and too easy to manufacture for attempts to eliminate the problems created by people with guns by restricting access to them to be as successful as their proponents like to assume they’ll be. A good start would be by enforcing the laws already on the books, something we apparently can’t manage to do.

20 comments

Bearing the Freight

In RealClearPolicy Robert Atkinson presents an interesting suggestion for changing how U. S. road and bridge infrastructure spending is funded:

Technology exists that could easily and relatively cheaply charge trucks by the mile traveled, varying the charge by the truck’s axle weight or the type of road the truck is traveling on. This vehicle-miles-traveled (VMT) is simple. The truck receives a one-way GPS signal to allow it to identify its location and an onboard computer loaded with price-per-mile data for all the roads across America. Additionally, trucks would be equipped with wireless axle-weight sensors, allowing the onboard computer to calculate an additional surcharge based on pavement damage (a formula that factors the type of road and the truck axle weight). The computer would then remit taxes monthly to the federal Highway Trust Fund and to every state the truck traveled through.

This sort of VMT system would have huge advantages over the current taxing system. First, taxes would be more carefully associated with true costs imposed on infrastructure. Trucks that do more damage to roadways would pay more. In turn, it would encourage trucks to drive more on roads that are properly engineered for heavy trucks, to drive fewer trips, and to use their hauling capacity more efficiently.

I haven’t really considered what the implications of such a system would be. I wouldn’t be a bit surprised if its first effect was to change the composition of what sort of freight was being transported by truck.

The basic problem in our present system is that the federal government pays 90% of new interstate construction while state and local governments bear the cost of maintenance. That’s the cause of our problems. We keep building new interstates regardless of commercial merit which creates opportunities for developers while state and local governments are so busy paying for health care and public employee retiree pensions that they aren’t maintaining the existing infrastructure adequately.

5 comments

When Foreign Policy Is a Family Business

I’m glad that the major news media outlets are going after the problematic treatment of U. S. foreign policy as a family business hammer and tongs. The sort of implicit influence peddling that’s going on is repellent and counter to U. S. interests.

I only wish they’d had this consciousness years ago. The Clinton Foundation was no less troubling. These corrupt arrangements will poison our foreign policy for years to come, long after their principals have left the scene.

6 comments

What Do They Want?

I honestly don’t know what the editors of the Washington Post want. While running an op-ed in support of an end to U. S. aid for Saudi Arabia’s genocidal war in Yemen, they publish an editorial lamenting the carnage in Syria where the Russians support the Assad government:

After months of hesi­ta­tion, the Trump administration recently outlined a policy for Syria that supports the U.N. process and calls for eliminating terrorist groups; officials say U.S. troops will remain in the country, which provides Washington with some diplomatic leverage. But Mr. Putin eschews cooperation with Washington. Instead, he is doing his best to bluff and intimidate President Trump into ordering a withdrawal. In the absence of a firm U.S. response to its latest outrages — and so far there is no sign of one — the Kremlin is unlikely to change course.

There was a way to bring the Syrian civil war to a quick conclusion: we could have joined the Russians and Iranians in supporting the Assad government and discouraged the Saudis from arming and otherwise supporting the Islamists in Syria in no uncertain terms. If we couldn’t stomach supporting someone as heinous as Assad, at least we could have avoided supporting Al Qaeda there.

There are no “good guys” in the Syrian civil war. Our intervention there is no less illegal than in Yemen. The best we can do is butt out. The Saudis are promoting a genocidal war in Syria, too, in Syria’s case with proxies rather than on their own and they need to have their ears pinned back.

0 comments

Who Lost China?

Speaking of scales falling from somene’s eyes, in his column in the Washington Post Charles Lane expresses shock that buying consumer goods in massive quantities from China hasn’t resulted in China’s government becoming more liberal:

Remember how American engagement with China was going to make that communist backwater more like the democratic, capitalist West?

For years, both Republican and Democratic administrations argued that the gravitational pull of U.S.-dominated international institutions, trade flows, even pop culture, would gradually reshape the People’s Republic, resulting in a moderate new China with which the United States and its Asian allies could comfortably coexist.

Well, Chinese President Xi Jinping has just engineered his potential elevation to president for life. This is the latest proof — along with China’s rampant theft of U.S. intellectual property, its military buildup in the South China Sea and Xi’s touting of Chinese-style illiberal state capitalism as “a new option for other countries” — that the powers-that-be in Beijing have their own agenda, impervious to U.S. influence.

The notion is and always has been foolish and everyone with a lick of sense or who knew anything about China knew it. What our policies with respect to China have accomplished is undermining U. S. manufacturing employment (not to mention the environmental disaster of delegating our heavy manufacturing to China where problems become intractable). The statistics are very clear. U. S. manufacturing employment collapsed under the one-two punch of granting China Most Favored Nation trading status and the country’s admission to the WTO. China has maintained that membership without ever meeting the commitments it made for admission.

Again, better late than never. Reversing course in our trade policy with China is going to hurt but it’s something that desperately needs doing. I suggest reciprocity as the foundation for future trade policies.

4 comments

There Are No “Good Guys”

In an op-ed in the Washington Post Sens. Mike Lee, Bernie Saunders, and Chris Murphy reveal that the scales have fallen from their eyes and they’ve realized that the Obama Administration’s policy in Yemen, fecklessly continue by the Trump Administration, was foolish:

More than 10,000 civilians have died and over 40,000 have been wounded in this war. Fifteen million people can’t access clean water and sanitation. An estimated 17 million people – 60 percent of the total population – do not have reliable access to food and are at risk of starvation.

When tragedies such as the war in Yemen occur, the American people’s instinct is to help. Americans have so far provided more than $768 million in humanitarian aid to that country.

What few Americans know, however, is that the U.S. military is making the crisis worse by helping one side in the conflict bomb innocent civilians. The millions we have spent in humanitarian aid were necessitated, in part, by a U.S. government failure.

In order to understand this failure, we need to understand how the United States got involved in Yemen to begin with. In March 2015, a coalition of Arab forces led by Saudi Arabia launched a military intervention into Yemen.

The goal of this intervention was to support the government of President Abed Rabbo Mansour Hadi against Houthi insurgents who had taken control of much of the country, including the capital city of Sanaa.

The Obama administration, without consulting Congress, quickly authorized U.S. military forces to provide “logistical and intelligence support” to the Saudi coalition. U.S. military support for this intervention continues to this day. U.S. forces are coordinating, refueling and targeting with the Saudi-led coalition, as confirmed last December by Defense Secretary Jim Mattis .

We believe that since Congress has not authorized military force for this conflict, the United States should play no role in it beyond providing desperately needed humanitarian aid.

I think they should start their history of U. S. involvement in Yemen a little earlier, all the way back in 2010 when the Obama Administration began its “drone war” in Yemen. Ostensibly, armed U. S. drones began attacking Al Qaeda in Yemen. Unfortunately, our human intelligence in the region is poor and we rely heavily on local authorities. Although in theory we were fighting Al Qaeda and the action was given a fig leaf by the Authorization to Use Military Force, in reality we had become the Yemeni government’s air force, attacking individuals of unknown affiliation to Al Qaeda but whom the Hadi government didn’t like.

Under the U. S. Constitution the Congress has the sole authority to declare war. We look the other in exigent circumstances, allowing the president as Commander-in-Chief to make war for a short period in emergency conditions. Going after enemies of the Hadi government does not fit that rubric and in 2010 the Congress should have shut down the Obama Administration’s illegal campaign immediately.

Well, better late than never, I guess. President Trump isn’t popular with anyone in the Congress and the likelihood of the Congress acting now is much better than it would be with a president of whom they approved. It’s high time that the Congress began shouldering its responsibilities rather than delegating them to the president.

I hope this occasions a realization that there are no “good guys” in the Gulf. None of them are our friends. They’re all “bad guys”. The best we can do is butt out and keep our noses clean. If the objective is to protect our shores, protect our shores. Don’t enter into the civil wars of other countries.

1 comment

Listen

I never anticipated that Katrina vanden Heuvel would be the voice of reason on U. S.-Russian relations but that’s what appears to be the case. From her Washington Post column:

Please. Bots are not bombs. Facebook ads are not the equivalent of planes flying into the World Trade Center. The casualties of Russian interference in our election are a far remove from the thousands lost during the terrorist attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, or at Pearl Harbor. The efforts detailed in the indictment — $100,000 in Facebook ads, more than one-half of which was spent after the election plus some scantly attended rallies — do not constitute a coup d’état. With Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania vital to Trump’s electoral college victory, a Senate hearing reported the total amount spent on Facebook targeting Wisconsin was “a mere $1,979; all but $54 was spent prior to the completion of the primary. . . . The spending in Michigan and Pennsylvania was even smaller.” According to the indictment, the supposedly sophisticated operation only learned in June 2016 that it should focus its activities “on purple states like Colorado, Virginia & Florida.”

There is no more important bilateral relationship in the world than that between the U. S. and Russia. Open conflict between our two countries could end the world. A good start in mending it would be for us to stop supporting Al Qaeda in Syria in our crusade to oust Assad. Of the available alternatives that is the worse. We could also stop creating and arming anti-Russian regimes on Russia’s borders, particularly when they are literally Nazis.

For their part the Russians might want to stop hacking into our election apparatus. I realize that we’ve interfered with scores of elections around the world including Russia’s. That’s no excuse for doing it to us.

But the hysteria that’s being fomented is dangerous.

5 comments