The Poll

You may see a few things written about the latest Quinnipiac poll from partisans of one side or another and I wanted to set the record straight on it. Here are a few of the major findings:

  • Trump maintains his low approval rating.
  • Congress maintains its low approval rating.
  • Congress’s approval rating is lower than Trump’s.
  • More people identify as Democrats than Republicans.
  • More people identify as independents than either Republicans or Democrats and nearly twice as many identify as independents than identify as Republicans.
  • More people have an unfavorable view of the Republican Party than of the Democratic Party but the difference is within the margin of error.
  • More people want the Democratic Party to take control of the Congress than want the Republicans to maintain control, presumably as a counterbalance to Trump.
  • Favorable/unfavorable views of the presidents of the post-war period break down along party lines.
  • A majority of Americans see the economy as being in good shape.
  • A super-majority of Americans see their own financial condition as good.

I’m a bit surprised at how persistent and pervasive propaganda is in the results. By any objective and balanced measure Harry Truman, John Kennedy, Jimmy Carter, and GWB were poor presidents; Gerald Ford, Bush Sr., and Bill Clinton were mediocre. Nixon and Johnson are controversial. IMO Barack Obama was a mediocre president; only soft bigotry or partisanship could award him a higher grade.

I think that overall the findings constitute a scathing indictment of the American political system. We’re all losers. The only winners are unpopular incumbents who are re-elected again and again.

Hat tip: RealClearPolitics which notes that the favorability of the Democrats is falling. As the late Mayor Daley once said, however it looks now, somebody will win the election.

5 comments

Another Precinct Heard From

And national security is precisely the argument made in favor of steel and aluminum tariffs by Secretary of Commerce Wilbur Ross in a Wall Street Journal op-ed:

One more point before I leave this subject. I get it. You don’t like “brown industries”. Propose an alternative to manufacturing, building, farming, mining, and so on that will provide decent livings for the majority of Americans who will never get a college degree and who don’t have the qualities of mind and temperament to be software developers. It’s not going to be driving for Uber or working in an Amazon warehouse. That’s especially incumbent on you if your own job is protected by trade restrictions.

0 comments

There Are Better Arguments

I found the arguments that Daniel McCarthy made in his New York Times op-ed in support of Trump’s tariffs weaker than the case that should be made. Consider:

  • The U. S. has the freest trade of any major economy.
  • All of the major economies with which we trade, e.g. China, Japan, Germany, have significant restrictions on imports and subsidize their own industries.
  • Japan and Germany both have levied tariffs against China for dumping steel and aluminum.
  • We don’t have free trade with any country.
  • We have carefully managed trade which necessarily fabricates winners and losers.
  • The winners need to be a much broader class of Americans than at present.
  • We’re going to have domestic, steel, aluminum, semiconductor, aerospace, communications, etc. industries for strategic reasons.
  • That means they can either be subsidized by trade restrictions or by direct subsidies.

and that’s just getting started.

Let’s have free trade; let’s not have managed trade that we call “free” that benefits about 3% of the American people.

1 comment

Do We Need Billionaires?

In most of John Tamny’s posts for RealClearMarkets I agree with some of his observations but disagree with many. His most recent offering, critiquing an article by Financial Times columnist Jenny Lee, is no exception. I agree with him that in many cases billionaires deserve their wealth:

Lee has a problem with the superrich. As she sees it, “We don’t need billionaires. We need their billions back. For the cities that already exist. For the people in them.” That’s why Lee supports Warren Buffett’s “Giving Pledge.” She believes that “it is moral to fix what is broken,” and that the billions given back by billionaires will help fix what she deems broken. Where does one begin?

Up front, it’s their wealth. So while the self-unaware Lee isn’t at all guilty about giving away that which she had no role in producing, it should be said that it’s not my place to tell the rich what to do with their billions.

There are cases where the very rich clearly do not deserve their wealth. For example, politicians like Mike Madigan who has amassed a fortune by cross-ruffing his law practice, challenging property tax assessments, with his post as Illinois House Speaker, increasing property taxes and further complicating them. That is de facto corruption and he doesn’t deserve whatever he’s derived from that corrupt practice. He’s no exception. Any number of congressmen and senators have entered public office as paupers and emerged after a lifetime of “public service”, have accumulated a fortune.

Did Bernie Madoff deserve his wealth?

However, I think Mr. Tamny is overly rosy or maybe romantic about how billionaires become billionaries. Those born in a log cabin who pulled themselves up by their bootstraps, meeting “the needs of millions and millions in order to earn billions” are rare even among billionaires. I’ve been acquainted with a number of Fortune 500 CEOs over the years and those I’ve met have been of a particular stamp, skillful navigators of the currents of our society, government, and economy, politicians who exploit government policies to their own advantage.

Some, like Donald Trump, have parlayed inherited wealth into more wealth, or, in Mr. Trump’s case, about the same wealth he would have it if he’d put his inherited wealth into a mutual fund. Not dishonest but not particularly praiseworthy, either.

In the particular case of Warren Buffett, it would be much more virtuous if he were to give his wealth to the deserving poor while he was alive rather than after he’s dead. He reminds me of the young man in Matthew 19:20-22:

“All these I have kept,” said the young man. “What do I still lack?” 21 Jesus told him, “If you want to be perfect, go, sell your possessions and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow Me.” 22 When the young man heard this, he went away in sorrow, because he had great wealth.

IMO we’re going to have billionaires. There will always be the ultra-talented who fully deserve their wealth along with those who want enormous wealth and who are skilled navigators of the sort I’ve seen. Rather than confiscating their wealth we should be making the waterways easier to navigate and therefore less profitable.

5 comments

Everybody Talks About It

My planned business trip to New York City this week had to be rescheduled due to bad weather. My evening departing flight was cancelled early yesterday and there were simply no flights until afternoon today at which point the trip no longer made sense. I offered to work through the weekend with the folks I was going to see but they, prudently, demurred.

There’s something that seems to me would be worth studying. Is it my imagination or are the opinion pieces in the East Coast-centered news media less numerous or less interesting when the weather is bad? Or good? It sure looks that way to me. Maybe it’s just my glum attitude.

6 comments

Kendara’s Show Boat, 2006-2018

Kendara’s Show Boat, our Nola, has died. I, my wife, and our entire pack are bereft, beside ourselves with grief.

Three weeks ago a mass was discovered just above her hip. It continued to grow, she lost her appetite, lost weight, became increasingly weak and fatigued.

I am taking her death very hard. She was the sweetest, most loving, gentlest, and most dear dog we have ever had. We were especially close—she was licking my hand to the very end. In her last trip to our backyard yesterday morning she, my wife, and I played The Game. Now only Kara will play it with us.

Additionally, she represented a special sort of connection. She knew every dog we’ve ever had with the exception of Jenny. Of our present dogs Ziva knew only Nola; Kara knew Tally, Will, Smidge, and Nola; Mamie knew only Nola and our present dogs.

Ziva, Kara, and Mamie have been looking for her and scolding us for her absence. I feel the same way. Kara seems to understand what has happened and is taking it particularly hard. She’s seen a lot of her pack mates die in her short life.

8 comments

The Siren Song of Authenticity

Legitimacy means something that can be supported with logic and reason.

Authority means knowledge, qualities of character, or having authority delegated to you by some recognizable and accepted process.

Authenticity is derived from who you are and the experiences inherent in who you are.

In our post-postmodern world authenticity has transmogrified to its opposite and you can become authentic by an act of will.

The titanic irony of actors and actresses, authentic in exactly nothing, are now taken as authentic.

Discuss the aftermath of the Parkland school shooting in terms of legitimacy, authority, and authenticity.

2 comments

Euros, Dollars, and Selective Concern

One of the things that always strikes me about Lawrence Summers’s occasional Washington Post op-eds is how selective his concern is. In his most recent offering he’s concerned about the value of the dollar relative to the euro:

One of the many surprising aspects of financial market performance since the start of 2017 has been the weak performance of the dollar, which has fallen by close to 10 percent on a trade-weighted basis and by about 17 percent against the euro.

This has occurred despite a variety of factors that might have been expected to push the dollar up. These include upward revisions in economic forecasts, expectation of monetary tightening, rising real and nominal long-term interest rates, fiscal stimulus on a huge scale in a full-employment economy, rising protectionism that should choke off import flows and tax reform directed at reducing capital outflows and increasing capital inflows.

Here’s a graph of the exchange rate between the euro and the dollar for the period 1999 to 2017:

Okay, when did the exchange rate become a concern? The value of the euro was at a historic high in 2008 and has been trading higher in 2018. Is there some arbitrary number or set of conditions when it becomes a concern?

Also, the purchasing power of the dollar has been declining longer than any of us have been alive. In 1900 it was 100 times what it is now. When graphed along a long enough timeline a 17% drop is barely discernible.

2 comments

M. B. S.

There are a few things about Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, a.k.a. M.B.S., that Tom Friedman fails to mention in his profile of him in his New York Times column. Here’s the meat of Mr. Friedman’s column:

It’s only a matter of time before King Salman turns over the reins of power to M.B.S., who’s already the effective ruler. M.B.S. is not a democrat, nor is he interested in promoting democracy. He’s a modernizing autocrat. The most we can expect from him is the modernization of Saudi Arabia’s economy and religious/social structure, but given how badly the country has stagnated from years of tentative reforms, this is deeply significant.

M.B.S. is definitely bold. I can think of no one else in the ruling family who would have put in place the profound social, religious and economic reforms that he’s dared to do — and all at once. But I can also think of no one in that family who’d have undertaken the bullying foreign policy initiatives, domestic power plays and excessive personal buying sprees he’s dared to do, all at once. They are two halves of the same M.B.S. package. Our job: help curb his bad impulses and nurture his good ones.

and here

If Saudi women are empowered (which will be fully true only when the rules of “male guardianship” over them are lifted), and the kingdom becomes a more normal, connected and productive society, Saudi Islam will naturally become more moderate and inclusive. Given how Saudi Arabia sets the tone for Islam globally, this will isolate extremists and empower moderates everywhere. Again, huge.

This will take time to play out, though, and reverse the supply chain of extremist books, madrasas and clerics Saudi Arabia exported across the globe — but the whole world will be better for it.

I wish someone with more knowledge of Saudi Arabia than I were painting a more realistic picture of the country, the situation, and the individual. All I can do is tell you how I see it.

First and foremost M. B. S. is not a liberal. He’s a cruel bungler who’s trying to consolidate power. He’s the architect of KSA’s war with Yemen which should have been over in a week but which has really confirmed just how hollow the Saudi military is.

The second is that historically Saudi Arabia has not been an autocracy, at least not an autocracy as it would be imagined in the West. It teeters between being a theocracy (like Iran) and being a monarchy in tenuous balance between the monarch and the great lords, something like England of the 13th century. Basically a big family squabble with dynamics that I can’t possibly understand.

All the Saudi princes who are no longer billionaires this year compared to last are a mark of the consolidation that’s going on. I’m concerned that it can only lead to a spreading war.

I don’t quite understand the modest liberalization in the treatment of women. Is he trying to be more like the cool kids? Is he trying to seize power from the clerics to wield it himself? Clearly, it obsesses Tom Friedman but I can’t help but think there’s more to it and more to the man than Mr. Friedman is leading us to believe.

0 comments

The Italian Elections

I think that I can say what Roger Cohen took 845 words to say in his New York Times column about the results of the Italian elections in one short sentence. The “world is flat” globe that transnational progressives like Mr. Cohen strove to build is collapsing around their ears and it’s our fault.

It’s not our fault. The Europeans take their lead from the United States much less than Mr. Cohen supposes. What is actually happening is that people in Europe and at least some people in the United States are reacting in similar ways to similar challenges. For the last two centuries at least the countries of Europe have tried to mold themselves ever more completely into ethnic states. Each country with its own language. Each country with its own culture. Largely defined by historical affinities. Mass immigration poses a challenge to the ethnic states of Europe that is more grave than anything the U. S. has ever faced. If the immigrants have no intention of adopting the languages or cultures of their new homes, the situation is that much more precarious.

Second, the reaction reflected in the Italian elections were inevitable as soon as Germany was reunified in 1990. Germany’s wealth and size meant that it would dominate Europe. When Angela Merkel issued her invitation to immigration, although the other Europeans had no say in it, it had implications for all of Europe not just for Germany.

If Italy is not Italian what is it? European? What if the Italians or the French or the Swedes aren’t Europeans? What if they’re Africans? Or Asians? What if they’re Muslims?

These are questions the ethnic states of Europe must address. If being Italian means speaking Italian and having an Italian culture and being able to trace your ancestry back to Italy for a dozen or a hundred generations, what role can these new immigrants possibly play?

3 comments