Medicaid Expansion and Opioid Abuse

I found the article at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities addressing the claim that Medicaid expansion caused the “opioid epidemic” interesting:

The latest data from the federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality highlight the importance of the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) Medicaid expansion in increasing insurance coverage among people with opioid-use disorders (OUD).[1] Our analysis of these data, which offer a comprehensive picture of opioid-related hospitalizations around the country, finds that the share of hospitalizations in which the patient was uninsured fell dramatically in states that expanded Medicaid: from 13.4 percent in 2013 (the year before expansion took effect) to just 2.9 percent two years later. This steep decline indicates that many uninsured people coping with OUDs have gained coverage through Medicaid expansion.

In addition, the data rebut claims that Medicaid expansion contributed to the opioid crisis. Opioid-related hospitalizations were higher in expansion than non-expansion states as early as 2011, three years before Medicaid expansion took effect, and have been growing at roughly the same rate in expansion and non-expansion states since expansion took effect. Medicaid is part of the solution to the opioid crisis, not a cause.

My only comment is not about the subject matter, whether Medicaid expansion did or did not contribute to the increased abuse of opioids, but on how you go about drawing conclusions. Their own data do not support their conclusion. They do support the conclusion that Medicaid expansion is not the only factor. They do not demonstrate that Medicaid expansion is not one of several factors.

It might be the case that other pathologies at work in the states in which Medicaid was expanded under the PPACA produced the abuse. It might be that states in which abuse was increasing rapidly were more likely to expand Medicaid. It might be the case that Medicaid expansion increased the likelihood of abuse. All of those might be the case or none of those might be the case or some combination, possibly with additional factors. What we do know is that abuse has increased and states in which Medicaid was expanded saw higher rates of increase. Full stop.

Someday researchers without axes to grind might get to the bottom of the question and that might help us formulate solutions. Clearly, we’re not at that point.

7 comments

About the White House Staff Turnover

I don’t comment on the various White House hirings and firings. No play-by-plays. I only have this to say. Trump is a lousy manager. Historically, over the period of the last 60 or 70 years, presidents have taken either a staff management or a micromanagement strategy.

Ike set the pattern for staff management. You hire a good staff, you support them, you establish the objectives, the staff executes them. Republicans have tended to use this approach.

Clinton and Carter were both micromanagers. They wanted to make every decision, write every memo, and administer every department themselves. Democrats have tended to be micromanagers.

Trump isn’t trusting enough to be a staff manager and he’s not assiduous enough to be a micromanager. One of the tells on his problems: he pits his underlings against each other. GWB did that, too, and IMO it’s a sign of a weak manager.

6 comments

The Watcher’s Council Forum

The Watcher’s Council Forum question this week is about the legalization of prostitution. Both the question itself and the discussion are interesting. As is not unusual I’m the outlier. I’m unconditionally against legalizing prostitution on social, psychological, legal, and moral grounds.

8 comments

Russian Meddling

With all of the stewing about “Russian meddling” in the U. S. electoral process, there’s been relatively little reflection on what we should do about it.

I oppose meddling in the political processes of other countries not merely by the Russians but by any other country and IMO our first action should be to stop our own meddling in the electoral processes of other countries. It’s a simple guideline but one which seems to have eluded most.

Then we need to change our voting processes. I’ve studied the systems used in the United States. I understand them and the organizational structures that support them. In the aftermath of the 2000 election I was the chief informant and part of the design team for an award-winning voting machine so I have at least a little authority in this area.

We can use electronic, electro-mechanical, or purely pen-and-ink voting systems but we cannot use systems that have any sort of network connectivity without opening ourselves up to unacceptable levels of risk, one of the most important of which is the risk of a loss of confidence in our systems. Online systems should be prohibited by law. They are inherently insecure and too easy to defraud.

The systems we use should be simple enough for the people who will be using them, easy to tabulate, and auditable. The system we designed had all of those characteristics.

Securing ourselves against psychological operations like those in which the Russians engaged is more difficult. We should treat them as seriously as we would throwing a hand grenade into a classroom.

We might want to adopt rules more like Germany’s and prohibit political advertising in the period immediately prior to the election. You could reduce the affront to the First Amendment by prohibiting taking money for political advertising or politicking in the month or six weeks prior to an election.

We should rely more on retail politics and much less on wholesale politics. Reliance on wholesale politics leaves us open to psy ops.

5 comments

Trade, Trump, and the National Interest

In his column at the Wall Street Journal Walter Russell Mead correctly characterizes President Trump’s views on trade and the national interest:

Mr. Trump’s record suggests that more trade shocks are coming, and that they may be more severe. His attacks on free trade emerge from one of the most deeply rooted beliefs of his presidency—that American foreign policy has lost sight of the national interest and reaches instead for a vague and unrealistic “globalist” agenda. By “America First,” Mr. Trump means restoring the primacy of the national interest. The president may spend a lot of time on the golf course, but he pursues his nationalist agenda with great persistence. He is willing to take risks and pay a high price to achieve it.

I feel, however, required to point out a few of Dr. Mead’s misconceptions. First, we do not presently have and never have had a regime of “free trade” and virtually no one other than a few economists supports it. We have managed trade. The problem with the present regime of managed trade is that its foundations were laid when circumstances were very different than they are now, the U. S. maintained a trade surplus or rough balance, and the primacy of the U. S. economy was unquestioned.

It’s also worth mentioning, as a commenter here points out, that the very notion of free trade is problematic when you and your trading partners all have fiat currencies.

Dr. Mead writes:

Some neoconservatives in particular concluded that Mr. Trump’s contempt for promoting democracy and the rule of law abroad was a sign that he would destroy democracy in the U.S., and they went on to dedicate their polemical talents to persuading conservatives that President Trump is, at best, the second coming of Cataline.

As the later Mayor Daley used to say, let’s look at the record. Over the last 25 years what have the policies of the neoconservatives, particularly democracy from the barrel of a gun, accomplished? We’ve spent trillions of dollars and wasted more than ten thousand American lives and our repute and democracy’s repute in general is at the lowest ebb in decades. The most effective promoter of democracy is the soft power brought by a strong, vibrant U. S. economy. We’ve squandered that by following the advice of neoconservatives and neoliberals. While Trump has weakened our soft power, what he’s done is nothing by comparison with our being at war for the last nearly 30 years and China’s persistent assault on the global economy.

Dr. Mead concludes:

It is much too early to predict that the president’s assault on the liberal trade order will succeed. But it would be foolish to underestimate the determination he will bring to the fight. Investors, managers and political leaders around the world need to prepare.

There is no liberal trade order to defend. The present order is one in which our putative European allies and frenemies like China alike engage in mercantilist policies while billionaires in the U. S. reap profits. Over the period of the last half century the U. S. has transmogrified from an increasingly egalitarian economy and society to an incipient hereditary aristocracy.

I continue to believe in free trade but not the faux free trade of the present illiberal order. Let’s have free trade. The disruption will be enormous but when the dust has settled we’ll all be better off for it. Except the billionaires, autocrats, and oligarchs, of course.

6 comments

Oscar Ratings Drop

As I predicted the Academy Awards ceremony racked up its lowest viewership in years. From the Hollywood Reporter:

Last year’s Academy Awards, which earned a 22.4 overnight rating, ultimately fetched 32.9 million viewers for ABC, as well as a handsome 9.1 rating among adults 18-49. Still, those numbers reflected the second-lowest in Academy history. (ABC did not immediately report the adults 18-49 rating for Sunday’s Oscars, and Nielsen won’t widely distribute that information until Tuesday.)

The night was not as political as many recent award shows, with showings of partisanship few and far between. The fallout and response to the exposure of sexual harassment and assault in the entertainment industry was an obvious throughline, and honorees like best actress winner Frances McDormand made stands for inclusivity and representation in the industry. And host Jimmy Kimmel seems to have earned praise for another solid performance during his second consecutive year onstage.

But the writing was largely on the wall for lows, either way. All three marquee events of the U.S. TV calendar thus far — the Golden Globe Awards, the Grammys and the Super Bowl — were off significantly from 2017.

People want to be entertained by entertainers not lectured by them. Physician heal thyself. An industry divided among abusers, their enablers, and victims is only entertaining in the way a house on fire or a train wreck are.

1 comment

More Health Less Care

In an op-ed in USA Today physician Marty Makary makes the counter-intuitive assertion that there’s too much health care in the United States:

The study by Washington physicians is part of a broader movement of physicians. In fact, their findings are consistent with research my Johns Hopkins colleagues and I conducted. We asked over 2,000 physicians across the U.S., how prevalent is over-treatment (excluding the respondent’s own practice)? On average, the doctors said that 21% of medical care is unnecessary.

Breaking down the waste by type of medical care, they reported that 22% of prescription medications, 25% of medical tests and 11% of procedures are unnecessary. These findings validate previous estimates of the Institute of Medicine that suggest that nearly one-third of health care spending is wasted on clinical and administrative costs that do not result in better health for the American people.

Our present system pays for care not health. How big a surprise can it be that we’re getting more care including some that’s actually deleterious? Oft repeated: if you subsidize something you’ll get more of it.

Rather than considering the op-ed analytically, let me just make a few scattershot observations.

  • I predicted that electronic medical recordkeeping would increase costs and that’s what has happened. Anyone who’d ever observed how a physician’s office actually functions could have told you that.
  • The biggest problem with EMR is and always has been physician non-compliance.
  • If you have to hire someone to follow a physician around and transcribe everything the physician does for entry into a computer, EMR can never save costs.
  • The idea that Jeff Bezos, Warren Buffett, and Jamie Dimon can “fix health care” is fatuous.
  • The best we can do is change the incentives and, unless you believe that everybody up and down the health care food chain is going to take a pay cut, even that won’t do much.
  • The entire health care delivery system needs an overhaul and that will be fought tooth and nail by everyone who’s a part of that delivery system.
9 comments

Underwear Is Down

After a long-winded anecdote about men’s underwear, Jeffrey Snider finally gets to the meat of his post at RealClearMarkets:

For the sake of brevity, I’ll highlight here just a few of the major series. The Bureau of Labor Statistics calculates that nominal hourly compensation, the metric right where wage acceleration due to a labor shortage would show up, expanded by a seasonally-adjusted annual rate of 1.8% in Q4 2017 (the latest estimates) over Q3. The less noisy 4-quarter average was 2.4%, compared to an average of 3.8% in Q2 2015 before all the “global turmoil” and 4.0% at the start of 2014.

The results in “real” terms, meaning those adjusted for inflation as it is now, are much worse. Real hourly compensation was down 1.8% (annual) rate Q/Q in Q4, after growing by just 0.6% in each of the two previous quarters.

The Bureau of Economic Analysis in its separate estimates on personal income and spending reports one version of the former called Real Personal Income excluding Transfer Receipts (RPIxTR). Transfer receipts refer to government payments like unemployment insurance and welfare, and their exclusion is an attempt to gain a purer sense of the private economy as it is without non-economic additions.

This is one of the major economic data points that the NBER uses in determining the business cycle (FWIW). Between December 2013 and October 2015, RPIxTR grew by a seasonally-adjusted total of 8.7%, or an annual rate of 4.7%. In historical context, that wasn’t very good at all, but better than the years before.

If the labor shortage was real, and the unemployment rate indicative of anything meaningful, we should have expected personal income particularly in this view of it to accelerate by more than a little. After all, if there is so much demand for workers that businesses are competing more intensely for them, then that would mean not just wage growth but also the more important related component of hourly growth – as a business, if things are picking up and you have to compete for new workers you are going to use your existing labor to the max, too.

There might be a shortage among certain specialties but there is no generalized labor shortage. If there is it’s an invisible one. Mostly, I think that somber statements about a labor shortage are a way of justifying importing more workers in order to push wages down.

The very idea is either a misunderstanding, a mistake, a myth, or a baldfaced lie.

4 comments

It’s a Lifestyle Choice

After reading Ken Fisher’s op-ed in USA Today, it should be crystal clear to you that homeownership is a lifestyle choice, not an investment. And he doesn’t even mention the implications of the recent changes in the deductibility of state and local taxes or that property taxes levied based on the present market value of your home are taxing income you haven’t even realized yet. Unless home prices are skyrocketing while the taxes remain fixed, real estate taxes will eat up any conceivable returns. That might be true in California but it certainly isn’t true in Chicago. Home prices here haven’t gone up in 15 years while property taxes have more than doubled over that period.

3 comments

Summarizing the Announced Tariffs

In an op-ed in the New York Times Josh Bivens does a pretty fair job of summarizing the tariffs on steel and aluminum that President Trump announced last week:

To be clear, there’s plenty to hate about the policy course charted by the Trump administration. His anti-trade stance is of a piece with an agenda rooted in xenophobia and bigotry that has favored the rich over low- and moderate-wage workers. But despite this record, and despite the near-dogma status of free trade among economic writers, the proposed tariffs won’t end the world, and may even do some good.

First, let’s take them for what they are: temporary relief for specific sectors (steel and aluminum) facing a specific problem (global excess production capacity, propped up by foreign governmental subsidies). America has taken steps like this before, and did not slide down any slippery slope to autarky. This means that big-picture principles — like, “Free trade is good,” or, “Globalization decimated the American working class” — aren’t very helpful in assessing them.

I’ve seen plenty of hand-wringing that it’s starting a trade war. By that logic during World War II the war in the Pacific was started by the U. S. responding to the attack on Pearl Harbor. Or the North started the American Civil War by not immediately surrendering Fort Sumter to the Confederates.

The United States continues to have the least restricted foreign trade of any major economy. Every EU country has trade restrictions and most have various forms of subsidies for domestic industries. Most have filed complaints with China about its steel and/or aluminum subsidies. Under the circumstances I think the agonistic reactions to the announcement are overblown.

8 comments