Where Is the Hiring Taking Place?

One of the things that struck me about Danielle DiMartino Booth’s analysis at Bloomberg of the employment situation for February was this statement:

On a more fundamental level, what are the odds that the demand for labor is sustained? In February, the construction sector added 61,000 jobs, the biggest increase in 11 years. Over the last four months alone, it has added 185,000 new jobs.

A warming trend after a brutally cold January probably played a part.

If that were the case the strongest hiring would have taken place where the cold was most severe or at least where the cold was most extraordinary. Does she have evidence of that? If so, she should produce it—it’s not in the BLS’s Employment Situation Report.

If it’s not the case she may be obscuring by assumptions what is actually an even bigger story. Youth wants to know.

6 comments

Knowing One’s Place

I found Justin Stover’s essay on the role of the humanities in higher education at The Chronicle of Higher Education very interesting. Here’s a snippet:

The reality is that the humanities have always been about courtoisie, a constellation of interests, tastes, and prejudices that marks one as a member of a particular class. That class does not have to be imagined solely in economic terms. Indeed, the humanities have sometimes done a good job of producing a class with some socioeconomic diversity. But it is a class nonetheless. Roman boys (of a certain social background) labored under the rod of the grammaticus because their parents wanted to initiate them into the community of Virgil readers — a community that spanned much of the vast Roman world, and which gave the bureaucratic class a certain cohesion it otherwise lacked. In the Middle Ages, reading Virgil, commenting on Aristotle, participating in quaestiones disputatae, writing chansons de geste and romances — these set apart scholars — bachelors, masters, and doctors alike — as an international community.

In that context the humanities would be the method by which the “creative class” inculcates in its young the “interests, tastes, and prejudices” of its members. That evokes two questions.

First, what are those “interests, tastes, and prejudices”? Second, is that something that should be paid for out of the public purse?

My general reaction is that there’s an app for that. It sounds to me as though higher education is in desperate need of radical reconsideration.

0 comments

Why?

My reaction on reading Jack Detsch’s article at Al Monitor on U. S. arms sales to Saudi Arabia:

The United States sold more than $650 million in weapons to Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates as the Yemen war expanded last year, according to a study released Thursday.

The Washington-based Security Assistance Monitor said the weapons went to Saudi Arabia and the UAE through the State Department’s Direct Commercial Sales program, which allows American arms-makers to sell directly to foreign customers.

US weapons contractors reportedly sold $610 million in precision-guided bombs and small arms ammunition to the Saudis, and another $48.6 million in M-4 and M-16 automatic rifles and spare parts to the Emiratis. Congress receives detailed readouts of direct US commercial weapons sales, but only cursory data is made public.

Under the program, the UAE spent nearly $60 million for small arms in 2016, while Saudi Arabia purchased about $11 million worth of machine guns.

was why? Saudi Arabia’s illegal, immoral war against Yemen does not promote American interests in the region. Yemen does not pose a threat to us; it doesn’t pose a threat to Saudi Arabia. The only explanation I could come up with is for the money which in turn reminded me of Lenin’s wisecrack about capitalists and rope.

The Saudis are waging war against Yemen; they have fomented the civil war in Syria and continue to support it. They have funded madrassas all over the world that promote their vile, reactionary, anti-modern version of Islam. They are not our friends. Why do we keep supporting them?

3 comments

Meeting With Kim

I’m not sure where to start in reacting to Noah Rothman’s piece at Commentary on the announced meeting between Donald Trump and Kim Jong Un. How about here?

This meeting between the leader of the free world and the criminal proprietor of the world’s largest open-air prison might produce a breakthrough. Trump might convince Kim to agree to the permanent and verifiable dismantling of his nuclear program, thus surrendering the only leverage that got North Korea to the table in the first place. Kim’s long-range missile program might be on the table for the first time in 20 years. In exchange, Trump could offer diplomatic recognition, a peace treaty, or sanctions relief. A grand bargain is possible in theory.

Donald Trump isn’t “leader of the free world”. He isn’t even leader of the United States. The United States doesn’t have a leader in the sense that North Korea does and, God willing, it never will. He’s the president of the United States, penned in by politics, law, the Congress, and the Supreme Court.

The prospects for anything material coming from these talks are essentially zero. We’ve seen this movie before. See here for a chronology of U. S.-North Korean missile and nuclear diplomatic history. At every step the North Koreans have lied and cheated. Throughout the 90s the U. S. conducted a series of negotiations with North Korea under the present Kim’s father and grandfather. Basically, nothing came from the negotiations other than temporizing long enough for North Korea to produce nuclear weapons.

Threats have been tried. Negotiations have been tried. The one thing that hasn’t been tried, at least not for long enough, is strategic patience.

We need to distinguish between acts of war that are worth going to war over and those that aren’t. North Korea has provided the latter in plenty for more than a half century. Its possession of nuclear weapons if one of them. We’ve got learn to live with risks.

1 comment

Then What?

The editors of the Wall Street Journal succinctly characterize Illinois’s situation:

The only two restraints—at least for now—on public union governance in Illinois are GOP Gov. Bruce Rauner and the state’s flat income tax. Democrats hope to do away with both in November.

Democrats in Springfield have filed three constitutional amendments to establish a graduated income tax—the rates won’t be determined until after voters give their assent. The state’s flat 4.95% income tax, believe it or not, is lower than the rate in all its neighbors save Indiana (3.23%). But its property and corporate taxes are among the highest in the country.

I would like to ask a question of the two billionaires, J. B. Pritzker and Chris Kennedy, vying for the Democratic nomination for governor. Why don’t they pay their “fair share” in taxes as they demand others in their tax bracket do? There is no barrier to their doing so. Is it more likely that the ultra-rich like Pritzker and Kennedy will meekly surrender more of their earnings to the insatiable maw of the state government or it more likely that they will do as they have in the past—avoiding if not evading taxation including by moving out of state?

And if an amendment to the state’s constitution is adopted allowing a graduated personal income tax and if the subsequent tax increase does not realize enough revenue to fill the gap? Then what?

While they’re seeking constitutional amendments will they seek one that will allow the state to renegotiate its contracts with public employees? My assessment is that they’ll follow historic precedent and won’t.

0 comments

The Trump-Kim Talks

The editors of the Washington Post cautiously support President Trump’s offer of direct talks with North Korea:

The challenge for Mr. Trump is avoiding another repeat of that cycle. That means setting an achievable goal: A realistic one might be a long-term extension of the freezing of missile and nuclear tests in exchange for limited U.S. concessions. Unfortunately, by agreeing to a summit, Mr. Trump has already handed over one of the largest potential trade-offs free of charge. Mr. Kim will use the event to portray his murderous regime as a legitimate nuclear power able to parlay with the United States on equal terms. He will no doubt demand a U.S. withdrawal from South Korea and a formal peace treaty in exchange for denuclearization, in the hope that Mr. Trump, unlike every previous U.S. president, will swallow those terms.

Given the president’s decision, the administration’s best course would be to use the coming weeks to hold preliminary talks with the Kim regime that make clear U.S. expectations and place the summit on firmer ground. If it becomes evident that the North is unwilling to commit to a freeze on its nuclear and missile activities, or will make excessive demands in exchange, Mr. Trump can step back. What he should not do is walk blindly into an encounter with a dictator who, we can be sure, will be well-prepared to take advantage of this president’s well-known weaknesses — starting with his penchant for impulsive decisions.

I oppose the talks. Neither side can back away from their central demands. From the U. S. side it’s likely to be the next step towards an illegal, immoral preventive war fought under the banner “We Tried”. Such a war would be likely to draw in the Chinese and, possibly, the Russians and it’s one that nobody would win.

Until and unless the North Koreans attempt to make use of their puny nuclear arsenal against us, our best course of action is to do nothing. Maintain the status quo. Should the Norks be so foolhardy as to attack us we should respond in a way that will ensure that no other country would ever seek nuclear weapons as a deterrent. Presidential energies would be better directed to preparing the American people and the Chinese for such an eventuality.

9 comments

Are We There Yet?

In his Washington Post column George Will joins the chorus of pundits wondering why the heck we’re still in Afghanistan:

For 73 years, U.S. troops have been on the Rhine, where their presence helped win the Cold War — and now serves vital U.S. interests as Vladimir Putin ignites Cold War 2.0. Significant numbers of U.S. troops have been in South Korea for 68 years, and few people are foolish enough to doubt the usefulness of this deployment, or to think that it will or should end soon. It is conceivable, and concei­vably desirable, that U.S. forces will be in Afghanistan, lending intelligence, logistical and even lethal support to that nation’s military and security forces for another 1,000 — perhaps 6,000 — days.

It would, however, be helpful to have an explanation of U.S. interests and objectives beyond vice-presidential boilerplate about how “We will see it through to the end.” And (to U.S. troops) how “the road before you is promising.” And how the president has “unleashed the full range of American military might.” And how “reality and facts and a relentless pursuit of victory will guide us.” And how U.S. forces have “crushed the enemy in the field” (or at least “put the Taliban on the defensive”) in “this fight for freedom in Afghanistan,” where Bagram Airfield is “a beacon of freedom.” If the U.S. objective is freedom there rather than security here, or if the theory is that the latter somehow depends on the former, the administration should clearly say so, and defend those propositions, or liquidate this undertaking, which has, so far, cost about $1 trillion and more than 2,200 American lives.

I am one of the few who opposed our adventure in Afghanistan from the start. I agreed that we needed to do something in response to the terrorist attacks on 9/11. Why did “something” take the form of invading and occupying the country? I was right that we’d be unable to uproot the Taliban. I was right that we’d be unable to establish a strong central government in Afghanistan. I was right that the Afghan government would never be capable of defending the country against foreign incursions by terrorists.

Now I’m right that no president will have the political courage to exit Afghanistan. It will be up to Congress but cowardice is so entrenched in the Congress that the likelihood is that we’ll be there forever.

4 comments

How I Behave

The Predictive Index is a workplace behavior assessment tool, intended to help managers get the best results from their workers. Recently, my current employer had me take the assessment. I thought you might be amused at the results.

David is a very verbal, animated and stimulating communicator, poised, and capable of projecting enthusiasm and warmth. A fluent, lively, forceful talker, he is able to sell ideas with assurance and intensity. He has a strong sense of urgency, initiative and competitive drive to get things done, with emphasis on working with and through people in the process. He understands people well and uses that understanding effectively in persuading others to do willingly what he wants them to do.

Impatient for results, David is a confident and ambitious “doer” and decision-maker, a self-starter who can delegate responsibility and authority when necessary. Having a distinctly low level of interest in details which are not pertinent to his goals, he will delegate them whenever possible, relying on persuasion, rather than close follow-up, to assure completion of such work. Venturesome and rather freewheeling, David is uninhibited in expressing and acting on his own ideas, which he will do without very much concern for traditional, established policies. Skillful at “selling” his ideas to others, he is also determined and persistent in expressing and acting on them.

At ease and self-assured with groups or in making new contacts, David is gregarious and extraverted, has a compelling impact on people, and is always “selling” in a general sense. He learns and reacts quickly and functions at a faster-than-average pace. Able to adapt quickly to change and variety in his work, he will become impatient and less effective if required to work with repetitive routines and details or to do structured work under close supervision.

When asked what I thought of the assessment, I responded that I thought it was pretty accurate. I don’t really think I’m a great fit at my current job.

5 comments

Would a Radical Islamist Middle East Have Been Better?

At Foreign Policy Robert Kaplan points out something that I would hope were obvious. What Syria and Iraq have in common and the reason that there has been war and chaos in both is Ba’athism:

The United States intervened militarily in Iraq in 2003, 15 years ago this month, and the result was war and chaos. But the United States did not intervene in Syria in 2011 when the regime there was challenged, and the result was still war and chaos. Though the media has interpreted the past decade and a half of armed conflict in the Levant exclusively through the failure of U.S. policy, the fact that the policy in Syria was 180-degrees different from the one in Iraq and yet the result was the same indicates that there has to be a deeper, more fundamental force at work in both countries that journalists and historians must acknowledge.

That deeper force is the legacy of Baathism. A toxic mix of secular Arab nationalism and Eastern Bloc-style socialism that dominated Syria and Iraq for decades since the 1960s, it made the regimes of the al-Assad family in Syria and Saddam Hussein in Iraq completely unique in the Arab world. Baathism, more than George W. Bush or Barack Obama, is the father of the violent Hobbesian nightmare that has devastated the lands between the Mediterranean Sea and the Iranian plateau in the early 21st century.

Let me be a bit more explicit than Mr. Kaplan in characterizing Ba’athism. Ba’athism is secular, multi-ethnic, and multi-confessional. In essence it is fascism with Arab characteristics. Both Syria and Iraq were autocracies ruled by minorities, the Shi’ite-affiliated Alawites in Syria and Sunni Arabs in Iraq. In a post-Ba’athist Iraq Sunnis are subordinated just as in a post-Ba’athist Syria Alawites would be subordinated although in Syria subordination would take the form of pogroms and genocide as was the case before the French put the Alawites in charge.

The critical problem is that in the absence of Ba’athism in Syria and Iraq they wouldn’t have become liberal democracies. That’s a fantasy harbored by neoconservatives and liberal interventionists. In the wake of the failure of Arab nationalism they would have taken the same path as so many other countries in the region: they would have become Islamist and increasingly radical, as we can see happening in Turkey right now.

Now the $64 billion question. Would a radical Islamist Middle East have been better than a secular authoritarian one? I don’t think so. And that’s why invading Iraq was so stupid and why helping the anti-government rebels in Syria was foolish.

4 comments

You Call That Bank Reform?

Writing at the New Republic Alex Shephard bemoans Democrats’ reaction to the banking reform bill working its way through Congress:

The 17 Democrats who voted for the bill to proceed on Tuesday are either centrists or facing reelection in states that Donald Trump won in 2016. They have defended the bill on the merits, arguing that it will free up credit in rural areas and that it’s an overdue fix for Dodd-Frank’s flaws. There is also a sense among Democrats that this may very well be the best deal they can get on Dodd-Frank reform. But it’s also clear that they’re supporting the bill for performative reasons, hoping to show voters back home that Congress can do more than just bicker and that Democrats are willing to work with Republicans to get things done. “This is old-school legislating,” North Dakota Democrat Heidi Heitkamp told Politico.

But it’s not old-school legislating, not really. If it were, Democrats would participate in a give-and-take with Republicans. There would be parts of the bill that they could point to as significant Democratic wins. But as it stands, the bill is a giveaway to the banking industry in which consumers get very little. Even though it may be easier for some consumers to get loans, that comes with the tradeoff of a weakened financial regulatory system and fewer consumer protections.

Nothing in the bill bears any resemblance to my idea of the sort of reform that’s needed. If I were king I’d split up the big banks (including the investment banks), ban branch banking, and prohibit state-owned banks from doing business in the United States. But that’s just me.

I don’t think that fractional reserve lending is necessarily a problem. Size is the enemy not fractional reserve banking.

13 comments