In her weekly column at the Wall Street Journal Peggy Noonan succinctly summarizes Hillary Clinton’s persistent error and the quandary in which Democrats find themselves:
“If you look at the map of the United States,†she said, “there’s all that red in the middle where Trump won. I win the coasts. . . . But what the map doesn’t show you is that I won the places that represent two-thirds of America’s gross domestic product. So I won the places that are optimistic, diverse, dynamic, moving forward.†Mr. Trump’s campaign “was looking backwards. You know, you didn’t like black people getting rights, you don’t like women getting jobs, you don’t wanna see that Indian-American succeeding more than you are.â€
Why did 52% of white women support Mr. Trump? Because the Democratic Party doesn’t do well with white men and married white women. “Part of that is an identification with the Republican Party, and a sort of ongoing pressure to vote the way that your husband, your boss, your son, whoever, believes you should.†James Comey announced that he had reopened the investigation of her State Department emails, and “white women who were going to vote for me, and frankly standing up to the men in their lives and the men in their workplaces, were being told, ‘She’s going to jail. You don’t want to vote for her.’ â€
So, to recap: Trump supporters were racist, narrow and ignorant, and Trump women are not tough and modern but fearful, cowering and easily led. They live in a big mass of red in the middle (like an ugly wound, or an inflammation!) while we have the coasts—better real estate. And better people.
The point of her column is that Ms. Clinton and others who hold her views are clinging bitterly to a “Deliverance” view of America beyond the urban megalopolises. I think she’s got the wrong movie. More like The Hills Have Eyes. Or maybe Wrong Turn.
However, let me provide an alternative explanation to the one proposed by Ms. Clinton to why big cities are prospering. They’re being highly subsidized and the calculations of government subsidy generally don’t capture the actual value of those subsidies. The interstate highway system subsidizes major cities. Intellectual property law subsidizes big cities. Banking laws subsidize big cities. Uncontrolled imports of hard goods while controlling the provision of services subsidizes cities. Concentrating federal government offices in Washington, DC and its environs subsidizes the East Coast megalopolis.
Then there are the direct subsidies. In the wake of 9/11 New York City received between $20 billion and $50 billion in direct subsidies from government at various levels. Then there are the huge infusions of cash the big, mostly New York-located banks received during the financial crisis. That New York is prospering from all of these subsidies is not surprising what would be surprising is if it didn’t.
Not all major cities are flourishing. Chicago is not. Philadelphia is not. Baltimore is not. St. Louis is not. That effectively refutes the urban/rural dichotomy being proposed. What should be more closely examined is subsidized vs. unsubsidized. In today’s economy what is subsidized flourishes while what is not struggles.






