What Have We Learned?

What have we learned over 15 months of a Trump presidency? Precious little, I’m afraid.

We haven’t learned that Trump was a boor, an ignoramus, and a cad. Anyone who’d been paying attention already knew that.

We haven’t learned that Hillary Clinton is ungracious, self-pitying, and paranoiac. Anyone who’d been paying attention already knew that.

We haven’t learned that the Russians are engaging in espionage and disinformation campaigns against us. That was already common knowledge. I’ve always assumed it to be the case.

We haven’t learned that power is the primary motivating factor for the Republicans in Congress or that they’ll do anything including support Trump to hold onto it. That understanding is part of the very foundations of our republic so you would really need to be opposed to 200 years of the American experience not to recognize that. Or think that the Democrats don’t have precisely the same problem.

We haven’t learned that the Justice Department in general and the FBI in particular are corrupt and thoroughly politicized. Anyone who’d been paying attention already knew that.

We haven’t learned that the press hates Trump. Anyone who’d been paying attention already knew that.

Writing in the National Post Conrad Black observes:

The American media, joined by the fatuous imitative chirping of the Canadian media (not that Americans would be aware of or have the slightest interest in what the media or anyone else in Canada thought of anything), regularly imply or state that the U.S. government is being run autocratically by a thuggish individual unfit for his great office. Robert De Niro wants to send the president to prison in a comedy skit; Kathy Griffin, whose opening gambit was a still photograph of the president’s severed head, is now lampooning his entourage in predictable simulations. Desperately unoriginal and mouthy occupants of late-night purported comedy — Bill Maher, Stephen Colbert, Jimmy Kimmel, Chelsea Handler — imagine that shouting rehashed denigrations of the president and his family are amusing. It is a bore; it isn’t working, and history moves on.

Pew Research Center and Harvard Media Studies surveys both confirm that 90 per cent of the national media coverage of Donald Trump is hostile, but he is accomplishing his stated goals, slowly. The asinine Dodd-Frank financial strangulation law, which enacted the bipartisan dual-branch official American pretence that private greed rather than unspeakable governmental incompetence was responsible for the 2008 financial meltdown, is being repealed. The Secretary of State-designate has returned from a secret visit to North Korea that appears to presage the most ambitious American diplomatic activity since president Reagan’s arms-reduction talks with president Gorbachev (1988), or even president Nixon’s accord with Mao Tse-tung and Chou En-lai (1972).

The economy is flourishing, illegal immigration is sharply curtailed. Assad has been smacked down and Putin faced down, and the gigantic canard of Trump collusion with Russia has collapsed. That investigation, generated by a fired FBI director illegally taking a doubtfully accurate memo and leaking it to the press, has now degenerated into an absurd handoff to New York prosecutors to see if the president’s lawyer committed a campaign finance offence when he paid off a rather peppy porn star for silence about an alleged one-evening encounter with Trump when no abuse or even ungentlemanliness was alleged, 10 years before he ran for president. Truly is America, the greatest nation in history, with all its complexities and shortcomings, mocked by the shallow bias of its free press and the absurdity of public discourse.

The arrogant façade of the fascistic American criminal justice system that had been infiltrated by the Clinton-Obama Democratic party has been torn down and the director and deputy director of the FBI revealed as potential felons who will possibly have their own day in the kangaroo courts they so delighted in sending less deservedly accused to face. There are many vicissitudes but the American leviathan is, however awkwardly and inelegantly, reviving. But the most salient aspect of it is not the war on and travails of Trump, but the fact that the national media have shot their bolt every day for 34 months since he announced his candidacy for president. The media threw their obligation to retain some element of fairness and detachment aside, and gambled everything on poisoning the wells and polluting public opinion so badly (as they did with Richard Nixon, but he had no idea how to deal with it) that the people’s choice (by the narrowest of margins and in a stunning surprise) would be overturned. They gambled and they have lost.

My point is not to promote Trump; it is the colossal failure of the press, and the widespread extent of this phenomenon.

Is any of that news? Or did we already know that?

7 comments

Kara and Mamie, Happy and Thriving

Mamie, on the left, is now eight months old and she’s been part of our pack for six months. As you can see, she’s settled into the pack nicely and is a full-fledged member. Kara, our youngest Samoyed, is her buddy, companion, and sparring partner. They’re cuddling in this picture. It’s rare to see either of them sitting still long enough to take a nice picture, so relish it.

Kara is still mourning Nola’s loss but Mamie has done a good job of cheering her up.

3 comments

Faded Into History

The world’s oldest known person, Nabi Tajima, has died at the age of 117 in Japan:

An official in the southern Japanese town of Kikai said Nabi Tajima died in a hospital on Saturday night. She had been there since January.

Ms Tajima was born on August 4, 1900, and reportedly had more than 160 descendants, including great-great-great grandchildren.

Her town of Kikai is in Kagoshima prefecture on Kyushu, the southernmost of Japan’s four main islands.

She became the world’s oldest person seven months ago after the death of Violet Brown in Jamaica, also at the age of 117.

Guinness World Records certified 112-year-old Masazo Nonaka of northern Japan as the world’s oldest man earlier this month, and was planning to recognise Ms Tajima as the world’s oldest person.

The US-based Gerontology Research Group said another Japanese woman, Chiyo Yoshida, was now the world’s oldest person in its records. She is due to turn 117 in 10 days.

She was born just about the same time as my maternal grandmother. I’m sure she is mourned by her many descendants. 117 is an extraordinary lifespan and her death supports my suspicion that there is an upper limit on the human lifespan. What is that? Seven standard deviations, eight, above the median lifespan?

But there’s an even greater meaning to her death. She was the last person known to have been born in the 19th century (contrary to popular opinion the 19th century ended on December 31, 1900). The oldest living person now was born in 1901, the 20th century.

So from the human standpoint the 19th century has faded into history, not merely into memory.

4 comments

Ports and State-Owned Companies

Now here’s a question for you. Should the federal government allow U. S. port facilities to be taken over by companies owned by foreign governments? The Wall Street Journal reports:

A U.S. national-security review has raised concerns about Chinese state-run conglomerate Cosco Shipping Holdings Co. taking control of a large container terminal in Long Beach, Calif., according to people familiar with the matter.

The terminal is part of Cosco’s proposed $6.3 billion purchase of an Asian shipping rival, which holds a long-term concession to operate the facility at the Port of Long Beach, one of the biggest gateways for imports into the U.S.

Cosco’s takeover of Orient Overseas International Ltd. 0316 0.78% , announced in July 2017, is undergoing a review by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the U.S., a secretive federal panel that vets foreign purchases of American companies on national-security grounds.

Cosco executives met with CFIUS officials this week and proposed to divest or carve out the Long Beach terminal to satisfy U.S. concerns about the deal, the people said.

I know what my answer would be. I don’t think that companies owned by foreign governments should be allowed to do business in the United States full stop. And I realize how that would affect hundreds of banks and airlines.

The very notion raises a whole host of thorny issues of international law, regulation, and diplomacy. We shouldn’t allow it.

8 comments

WWAGD

At RealClearWorld Matthew Rooney has a cri de coeur, proclaiming himself a globalist:

The idea that America is the loser on the global marketplace is news to our competitors. The Europeans have been trying for years to reform their labor markets in an effort to reach our job creation rates. The Japanese are just now starting to see our growth rates for the first time in a generation. Our Mexican friends would give anything to have our productivity levels — not to mention our institutional stability. Our Canadian friends obviously covet our climate — more than one Canadian in ten owns real estate in the U.S. — but why does their Prime Minister visit San Francisco every time he comes south of the 49th Parallel? He is courting the technology industry on behalf of Toronto and Montreal in hopes of copying our ability to innovate.

At the Bush Institute, we have looked at globalization since NAFTA and its impacts on American growth, job creation, trade, and competitiveness. We have looked at the impact of immigrants on our economy. We see a largely positive picture of growing prosperity based on stable demographics, innovation, and rising productivity.

But what would a globalist do? Certainly not what we’ve been doing for the last 30 years. It seems to me that a genuine globalist would oppose occupational licensing in the U. S., the broad sort of intellectual property rights that have become the sine qua non for American trade negotiators, and American agricultural subsidies. They would also oppose China’s membership in the WTO or being given Most Favored Nation trading status but that is so counter-intuitive I presume it would make his head explode.

Being a phony globalist is easy; being a real one is hard.

1 comment

Check Your Assumptions

And contrary to Fatema Z. Sumar, expressed in her article in New Republic, I think the primary consequence of increased federal development aid to China’s neighbors would be to make rich people in those countries much richer. She assumes that development aid actually causes the recipients’ economies to grow. The evidence suggests something different. As H. L. Mencken put it, there is always a well-known solution to every human problem — neat, plausible, and wrong

What actually helps countries to grow is adopting economic reform. That’s what produced the remarkable growth of China, South Korea, and Japan. China’s mercantilist policies are now choking off that strategy.

Political reform is helpful, too, but that’s the subject of another post.

0 comments

What One Thing?

Francis Menton, the Manhattan Contrarian posts angrily about income inequality:

If you want to look at the world as providing the occasion for anger, resentment, and victimhood, then by all means declare income inequality to be a crisis. Are you not one of the 400 wealthiest people in the United States? Well boo-hoo! Let’s all sit around and feel sorry for ourselves and plot our revenge!

The other way of looking at the world is that it is a cornucopia of opportunity for those willing to go out and strive a little. Capitalism has just created a few hundred new billionaires! What are they going to do with all of that money — put it in a big pile and count it over and over again? If you want to be prosperous, and maybe extremely prosperous (if not a billionaire yourself), then get out there and find something to sell to these people! Believe me, this is the entire business model of the major law firms, and the lawyers at those places are definitely in the “extremely prosperous” category. Same goes for the people who run hedge funds, or who build and sell mansions, or yachts, or private jets, or luxury goods of every sort. With all that wealth waiting to be spent, there is no reason for anyone to be poor or idle. This is an economic engine ready to be ignited!

I’ll bet you can guess which one of these two ways of looking at the world has been adopted by the Washington Post. In the Post’s Wonkblog of April 6, Jeff Stein reports on “How 12 experts would end inequality if they ran America.” First, we must all agree that income inequality in the United States is a major problem. No, make that a “staggering” problem. And all the right progressive “experts” are hard at work figuring out the solution!

Imagine you had complete control of the U.S. government: What one thing would you do to reduce the country’s staggering economic inequality?

Contrary to the Contrarian I think that the increase in income inequality in the United States is a serious problem. In 1970 most of the income and wealth in the United States were held by the middle class; incomes of Fortune 500 CEOs were, perhaps, 15 times those of the median worker in their companies (and those were high by OECD standards). Now they’re hundreds of times the income of the median worker due to changes in the tax code. That’s a major change and it isn’t one that’s consistent with the sort of country I expected to be living in or want to live in.

There are so many things that have contributed to the problem it’s hard to come with just one but I’ll rise to the challenge: stop bringing in workers from other countries who’ll earn incomes below the poverty level. Most are already illegal and that would require a change in enforcement (my preference is for strict, serious workplace enforcement). Large numbers of low wage workers tend to push incomes down for everybody but the fortunate few.

1 comment

Sales Tax Revenues Are Not Declining

I found one thing in Chris Cox’s Wall Street Journal op-ed in opposition to the Supreme Court’s reversing its decisions from 1967 to 1992 and allowing states to collect sales taxes from Internet sales from companies that do not have physical “nexuses” in their states interesting:

‘Our states are losing massive sales-tax revenues that we need for education, health care, and infrastructure,” South Dakota’s Attorney General Marty Jackley told the U.S. Supreme Court Tuesday. His state’s Supreme Court opined that sales tax revenues have “declined.” The state Legislature, citing its own “finding” to this effect, enacted a law requiring out-of-state retailers to collect sales tax on purchases shipped to South Dakota.

But in addition to running counter to decades of precedent governing interstate commerce—which Mr. Jackley was in court asking the justices to overturn—the law is based on a false premise.

The state’s own data show that sales and use tax revenue grew from $787.7 million in 2013 to $974.7 in 2017—considerably faster than the state’s rate of economic growth. The governor’s budget for 2018 projects the state’s sales and use tax revenue will be more than $1 billion, 4% higher than last year, with no change in rate. That’s 29% higher than five years earlier. Sales-tax revenues have been booming in other states, too.

Intrigued, I decided to look at the experience in Illinois. Here’s the most recent data:

 Year Revenue (in billions)
2010 $11.14
2011 10.60
2012 12.27
2013 12.54
2014 13.03
2015 13.40
2016 14.05
2017 14.59

All figures are taken from the web site of the Illinois Department of Revenue which was built using DreamWeaver which surprised me since Central Management Services, which sets the governance rules, essentially mandates Microsoft. It does, however, support a point I’ve made in the past.

Those are increases that outstrip the rate of inflation, increases in the state’s GDP, and increases in personal income by far. Illinois doesn’t have a revenue problem. It has a spending problem.

0 comments

Crafting a Party Consensus

It seems like just yesterday that “Jane Galt” was just a humble blogger. Now (her real name is Megan McArdle) she has a column in the Washington Post and in her most recent column she points to an issue that divides the Democratic consensus: housing. Her take on it is that it will be difficult because it’s a wedge issue for them:

Housing activists have had some success using state governments to override local opposition to building low-income housing. And a group in California decided to try to do something similar for market-rate development: A proposed law called SB-827 would have wrested control of zoning decisions near mass transit from local communities that often use ordinances to block denser development.

That bill just died in the California Senate, unable to even get out of committee.

It’s not really that surprising that it died. YIMBYism — yes-in-my-back-yard-ism — is always a tough fight against entrenched local interests. What’s remarkable is who killed it. It wasn’t just prosperous suburban homeowners, snug on their one-acre lots. The list of opponents reads like a who’s who of Democratic Party interest groups: the Sierra Club, the construction unions and, incredibly, even some affordable-housing activists, who think that encouraging market-rate development will encourage gentrification without helping lower-income families get access to housing. In the narrow areas where SB-827 would spur development, they may even be right — but city- or state-wide, the only way that California can hope to relieve the rent crisis among struggling families is to build enough new units that those families no longer have to compete with the affluent for the sharply limited housing stock.

YIMBYism is shaping up to be for the Democrats what free trade was for the Republicans — an issue where the policy elites are all singing from the same hymnal but a substantial portion of the base simply refuses to come in on the chorus. Hopefully Democrats can do better than Republicans have at finessing the divide between their base and their wonketariat. But if so, they’ll need to find a way to expand their activist coalitions.

What I find interesting about that is that it provides a rubric for creating policies that will gain broad support within the Democratic coalition. In essence such a policy must a) increase or maintain regulation; b) provide subsidies to blacks and Hispanics disproportionate to their numbers in the population; and c) leave the urban gentry alone.

A good case study is the Affordable Care Act. It increased the scope of government regulation in health care, gaining the support of the federal bureaucracy, it provides subsidies disproportionately to blacks and Hispanics, and, except for the lowest tier of the “creative class” who pay for it, it leaves the urban gentry alone.

I’ll leave how this same approach may be applied to other issues to the interested but I suspect we’ll see that as the model for the party going forward.

0 comments

Farewell, Carson’s

The Chicago Tribune reports that the venerable retail chain Carson Pirie Scott, long a fixture in Chicago, will close its doors:

Carson’s will shut down its department stores by late summer after more than 160 years in operation.

After parent company Bon-Ton Stores failed to find a bidder willing to keep the business going, a bankruptcy judge on Wednesday approved the sale of the company’s assets, including Carson’s and other retail chains, to a joint venture of two liquidation firms and a group of company bondholders.

The flagship of Carson Pirie Scott was once among a full lineup of showy department stores — including Marshall Field’s, Sears, Montgomery Ward, Henry C. Lytton & Co. and Wieboldt Stores — that called Chicago’s State Street home. None of those names can be found there today.

Carson’s was started in Peru, Illinois before the Civil War. It was acquired by Milwaukee-based Bon-Ton in 2006. As noted above it joins a long list of Chicago retail stalwarts in going under. I haven’t been in a Carson’s store in decades. I’m not their target customer. Indeed, I’ve never been able to figure out just who their target customer is.

Don’t blame Carson’s demise on Amazon. Online still only constitutes 8% of retail. Retail is enormously overbuilt in the United States and it’s been increasing at an unsustainable rate

out of proportion with the increases in population or income.

But retail’s real problem is large retail chains built through leveraged buyouts:

The reason isn’t as simple as Amazon.com Inc. taking market share or twenty-somethings spending more on experiences than things. The root cause is that many of these long-standing chains are overloaded with debt—often from leveraged buyouts led by private equity firms. There are billions in borrowings on the balance sheets of troubled retailers, and sustaining that load is only going to become harder—even for healthy chains.

The debt coming due, along with America’s over-stored suburbs and the continued gains of online shopping, has all the makings of a disaster. The spillover will likely flow far and wide across the U.S. economy. There will be displaced low-income workers, shrinking local tax bases and investor losses on stocks, bonds and real estate. If today is considered a retail apocalypse, then what’s coming next could truly be scary.

Those LBOs have saddled retailers with too much debt and for the last decade they’ve been chasing their next interest payment. Bon-Ton just reached the end of the road.

“Retailpocalypse” began a year or so ago and in 2018 it’s accelerating if anything. Rural counties, particularly in the West and South, where retailers are major employers, are likely to be hard-hit.

4 comments