I wanted to comment on James Fallows’s most recent article at Atlantic because to my eye it exemplifies something I see pretty commonly. When you find a house that doesn’t completely meet your expectations or needs you might say “it has potential” but you wouldn’t say “I love it; let’s tear it down.”
But that’s very much what Mr. Fallows says in his piece, “The Reinvention of America”:
My own form of American nationalism, intensified both by living outside the country and by travels within it, arises from love of the American idea: inclusion, expansiveness, opportunity, mobility, the open-ended struggle to make the nation a better version of itself. After living in Japan during its amaze-the-world era of the 1980s, I wrote a book arguing that the proper U.S. response was not to try to be more like Japan but instead to be “more like usâ€â€”which was the book’s title. (Its subtitle was Making America Great Again. Sigh.)
I believe that’s a trope used by people who don’t really care for America much but are very much taken by the idea of what it might become with the proper guidance. Their guidance, of course.
I think that’s fatuous and facile. They just don’t have the courage to say that they don’t like America. The problems with the construction are that it’s counter-experiential and it’s unrealistic.
That it is counter-experiential is practically self-evident. As a little experiment try it on your wife. “I love you because of what you might become.” Looking into my crystal ball, I see divorce in your future. At the very least marriage counseling. When you love your wife when she wakes up in the morning, when she’s getting ready for work, when she putters around the house, and when she comes home tired after a long day at work, that’s love. When you love her only when she’s all dolled up for a night on the town, you love yourself or, at the most, your idea of her. It would be just about as effective in speaking with your kids or your friends.
If you love broccoli, you love it raw, steamed, roasted or just about any other way. When you love it when it’s been braised in butter, cream, and cheese, doesn’t that really mean you love butter, cream, and cheese? Or maybe just good cooking?
It’s unrealistic because America will never live up to your expectations for a simple reason: not everyone shares your vision and everybody else is pulling in their own directions. The future will always fall short. For every part of the “American idea” of which you approve (“inclusion, expansiveness, etc.”), there is its opposite and they’re all just as much a part of the idea as those parts of which you approve. You can find those qualities in France, Germany, or Uganda, too. If he hasn’t found those qualities anywhere else in his travels, I don’t think he’s traveled nearly enough. There are limits to what you can learn of a country from the bar of the InterCon.
I prefer by far the formulation of the Armenian poet: I love my country because it is mine.