Fallen Idol

Stand-up comedy, television, and motion picture entertainer Bill Cosby has been found guilty of three counts of sexual assault. The New York Times reports:

NORRISTOWN, Pa. — A jury found Bill Cosby guilty Thursday of drugging and sexually assaulting a woman at his home near here 14 years ago, capping the downfall of one of the world’s best-known entertainers, and offering a measure of satisfaction to the dozens of women who for years have accused him of similar assaults against them.

On the second day of its deliberations at the Montgomery County Courthouse, the jury convicted Mr. Cosby of three counts of aggravated indecent assault against Andrea Constand, at the time a Temple University employee.

I doubt that this marks the end of the story. In all likelihood Mr. Cosby will spend the rest of his life either in jail or in court. Civil suits will strip him of the earnings of a lifetime.

It’s hard to overestimate how momentous this conviction is. Cosby was the first African American man to star in a television series, the first to have his own television series (he had three of them), and his role as Cliff Huxtable in the Cosby Show was held up as a role model, not just for young African Americans but for all young Americans. He joined with Sidney Poitier and other black actors in the 1970s to make movies that opposed the blaxploitation movies of the time in their portrayals of African Americans.

This is a genuinely tragic story.

12 comments

Voting With Your Butt

In their recent op-ed in the Wall Street Journal, Arthur Laffer and Stephen Moore, whose names are swear words in some circles and who are hallowed saints in others, point out something useful. One of the aspects of the recent federal tax reform legislation is that it’s certainly a shot across the bow of states who are depending on taxing the rich to support their ambitious state programs:

Since 2007 Texas and Florida (with no income tax) have gained 1.4 million and 850,000 residents, respectively, from other states. California and New York have jointly lost more than 2.2 million residents. Our analysis of IRS data on tax returns shows that in the past three years alone, Texas and Florida have gained a net $50 billion in income and purchasing power from other states, while California and New York have surrendered a net $23 billion.

Now that the SALT subsidy is gone, how bad will it get for high-tax blue states? Very bad. We estimate, based on the historical relationship between tax rates and migration patterns, that both California and New York will lose on net about 800,000 residents over the next three years—roughly twice the number that left from 2014-16. Our calculations suggest that Connecticut, New Jersey and Minnesota combined will hemorrhage another roughly 500,000 people in the same period.

It will also provide an opportunity for entrepeneurs in California and financiers in New York to demonstrate their commitment to their belief that the rich should pay their fair share. There’s an old wisecrack about “voting with your feet”, i.e. moving from one jurisdiction to another to avoid the effects of onerous legislation. Now they can vote with their butts, electing to sit where they are.

5 comments

Don’t Cry for Connecticut

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are eager to point out that income growth in Connecticut is slow:

The 50 American states have long competed for people and business, and the 2017 tax reform raises the stakes by limiting the state and local tax deduction on federal returns. The results of bad policy will be harder to disguise.

A case in point is Connecticut’s continuing economic decline, and now we have even more statistical evidence as a warning to other states. The federal Bureau of Economic Analysis recently rolled out its annual report on personal income growth in the 50 states, and for 2017 the Nutmeg State came in a miserable 44th.

The progressive paragon’s performance is even worse when you look at the details. The nearby chart shows that the state’s personal income grew at the slowest pace among all New England states, and not by a little. Governor Dannel Malloy’s eight-year experiment in public-union governance saw income grow by a meager 1.5% for the year, well below Vermont (2.1%). The state even trailed Maine (2.7%) and Rhode Island (2.4%), which are usually the New England laggards.

and they attribute the very slow growth to bad state government policies.

Maybe. But they really should provide some context. Connecticut’s median household income is $71,346—one of the highest in the nation. Rhode Island’s and Maine’s median household incomes are a third lower. If you’ve ever been to Connecticut, you’ll understand the reason why. The southern part of Connecticut is essentially a bedroom community for New York City, full of rich New Yorkers. A financial sector in which incomes aren’t rising as fast as during the boom period will mean that median household income in Connecticut will grow slowly, too.

To fill out the picture a bit, New Haven has areas that are urban slum while upstate Connecticut is largely rural, dotted with light manufacturing or, at least, it used to be before much of that sort of manufacturing moved to China. Then there’s Hartford which used to be a much greater insurance hub than it is now. A lot of that business has moved south.

My point is that, while taxing income tends to produce less of it, in Connecticut that doesn’t present the whole picture and in the Nutmeg State slow income growth isn’t as bad as it may sound and certainly isn’t as damaging as in Maine. It’s the difference between a Mercedes and an Audi, (or, in some cases, the difference between a Ferrari and a Porsche) not the difference between paying the rent or not.

0 comments

Finland Steps Back from BI

The BBC reports that Finland is abandoning its experiment with a universal basic income:

The Finnish government has decided not to expand a limited trial in paying people a basic income, which has drawn much international interest.

Currently 2,000 unemployed Finns are receiving a flat monthly payment of €560 (£490; $685) as basic income.

“The eagerness of the government is evaporating. They rejected extra funding [for it],” said Olli Kangas, one of the experiment’s designers.

Some see basic income as a way to get unemployed people into temporary jobs.

The argument is that, if paid universally, basic income would provide a guaranteed safety net. That would help to address insecurities associated with the “gig” economy, where workers do not have staff contracts.

Supporters say basic income would boost mobility in the labour market as people would still have an income between jobs.

Finland’s two-year pilot scheme started in January 2017, making it the first European country to test an unconditional basic income. The 2,000 participants – all unemployed – were chosen randomly.

But it will not be extended after this year, as the government is now examining other schemes for reforming the Finnish social security system.

The article doesn’t really explain why Finland is dissatisfied with the plan but this may have something to do with it:

In February this year the influential OECD think tank said a universal credit system, like that being introduced in the UK, would work better than a basic income in Finland. Universal credit replaces several benefit payments with a single monthly sum.

The study by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development said income tax would have to increase by nearly 30% to fund a basic income. It also argued that basic income would increase income inequality and raise Finland’s poverty rate from 11.4% to 14.1%.

In U. S. parlance the OECD found that a “cut out” system would work better than an “add on” system. Finland is also considering such a system as well as a negative income tax.

The challenge is, as usual, that pesky human nature. If you provide incentives for idleness, people will be idle. Programs that were affordable for a small group become unaffordable as the original target population grows. How do you reduce poverty without creating a permanent underclass?

The best answer, also as usual, is a private sector job that pays a decent wage. Creating or maintaining the conditions for that remains elusive or unpalatable for some.

1 comment

I’d Say 2 For 2

The editors of the Wall Street Journal like one of the recent Supreme Court decisions but not the other:

The Court ruled in Jesner v. Arab Bank that foreign corporations cannot be sued under the 1789 Alien Tort Statute, which was originally intended to punish piracy and injuries to ambassadors under the common “law of nations.” But plaintiff attorneys have been using the law to haul foreign defendants into U.S. courts for human-rights violations that occur overseas.

In Jesner, foreign plaintiffs charged that the Jordanian Arab Bank should be liable for injuries perpetrated by terrorists in Israel since it had cleared automatic wire transfers via the U.S.-based CHIPS system for groups later placed on Treasury’s list of terrorist organizations. Writing for a 5-4 conservative majority, Justice Anthony Kennedy affirmed the Court’s Kiobel (2013) decision that liability under the 1789 law does not extend to suits against foreign corporations when “all the relevant conduct took place outside the United States.”

In sterling concurrences, Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch explained that allowing foreign corporations to be sued under the 1789 law would violate the separation of powers. “Creating new causes of action and navigating foreign policy disputes belongs to the political branches,” Justice Gorsuch noted. That was the good decision.

Article III of the Constitution grants independent judges the limited power to adjudicate disputes of common law between private parties. Yet the Court on Tuesday erred by relinquishing some of its authority to the executive branch in Oil States Energy v. Greene’s Energy decision, which upheld inter partes review for patents.

Inter partes review allows anyone to challenge a patent at any time before a special tribunal composed of administrative law judges selected by the Patent Office director who are vested by Congress with authority to nullify patents and even override contrary jury verdicts. The process was intended to discourage frivolous patent litigation but is susceptible to political bias. Apple joined a brief last fall supporting inter partes review, but then it complained in January that a plaintiff in a case that it had filed with the tribunal was lobbying administrative judges behind the scenes.

A 7-2 majority led by Justice Clarence Thomas circumvented the knotty separation-of-powers questions by holding that patents are public rather than private rights. This ruling overturns 200 years of judicial precedent and means that the federal government can revoke patents as it can a public monopoly.

But the purpose of patents, which is to encourage innovation and reward investment, will be undermined if they can be nullified without due process and hearing before an Article III judge. As Justice Gorsuch noted in his dissent joined by Chief Justice John Roberts, “Ceding to the political branches ground they wish to take in the name of efficient government may seem like an act of judicial restraint,” but the decision “signals a retreat from Article III’s guarantees” and leaves people vulnerable to governmental intrusion.

U. S. intellectual property law has become excessively expansive over the last 20 years. That hasn’t led to more innovation but less as big companies use the power of the law to crowd out upstarts. The decision is a start but it’s just a start.

1 comment

The Cold Equations

It’s not enough for your heart to be in the right place. Your head has to be in the right place, too. It wasn’t lost on me that Bernie Sanders is working on a plan to give everyone who wants one a job paying $15 per hour. In her Washington Post column Megan McArdle crunches a few numbers

Sanders wants the government to provide guaranteed jobs at $15 an hour, plus benefits. His office did not, a representative demurely told Post reporter Jeff Stein, yet have cost estimates for this proposal.

Perhaps we can help the senator out. With two weeks of paid vacation, each worker would make roughly $31,000 a year. Adding, conservatively, about $10,000 for benefits, would bring the total cost to about $40,000.

The United States has between 25 million and 50 million workers making less than this total compensation package. Millions more are unemployed or fully out of the labor force. Assuming most of them did the rational thing and signed on, that would make for a $1 trillion to $2 trillion annual program — rivaling or exceeding our total expenditure on Social Security, with maybe Medicaid thrown in for good measure.

and concludes

The impulse behind this idea is noble, and correct: that all Americans should be able to earn a decent living for themselves. But nobility can’t take a back seat to practicality. This old socialist standby deserves to stay exactly where we left it — on the ash heap of history.

Let me put on my green eyeshades and do a little number crunching myself. Based on figures from the IRS, the total income of the top 1% of income earners is around $1.5 trillion. If Sen. Sanders’s plan is to pay for his program by taxing “the rich”, ceteris paribus he’ll need to realize an effective tax rate of 85% on them.

In 1960 the nominal tax rate on the very richest Americans (the top .02%) was 91%. But the effective rate has never been greater than around 25%. Simply stated we’ve never been able to figure out how to extract that much money from “the rich”.

Nearly a quarter of American workers earn less than the $31,000 plus benefit of the program. He’s talking about devoting around 9% of U. S. GDP to his program—more than defense and Medicare combined.

Grow our way into the amount necessary? Even the Trump Administration doesn’t believe that kind of growth can be coaxed from the economy.

Since we can’t fund the program by taxing “the rich”, why not just extend ourselves credit? I don’t believe that even the most committed Chartalist believes that we can extend credit to the tune of 9% of GDP into the indefinite future without inducing a catastrophic loss of confidence in the dollar.

Bottom line: there’s just no practical way to accomplish it.

And I’m not even starting on the run-on effects.

7 comments

Love the One You’re With

I wanted to comment on James Fallows’s most recent article at Atlantic because to my eye it exemplifies something I see pretty commonly. When you find a house that doesn’t completely meet your expectations or needs you might say “it has potential” but you wouldn’t say “I love it; let’s tear it down.”

But that’s very much what Mr. Fallows says in his piece, “The Reinvention of America”:

My own form of American nationalism, intensified both by living outside the country and by travels within it, arises from love of the American idea: inclusion, expansiveness, opportunity, mobility, the open-ended struggle to make the nation a better version of itself. After living in Japan during its amaze-the-world era of the 1980s, I wrote a book arguing that the proper U.S. response was not to try to be more like Japan but instead to be “more like us”—which was the book’s title. (Its subtitle was Making America Great Again. Sigh.)

I believe that’s a trope used by people who don’t really care for America much but are very much taken by the idea of what it might become with the proper guidance. Their guidance, of course.

I think that’s fatuous and facile. They just don’t have the courage to say that they don’t like America. The problems with the construction are that it’s counter-experiential and it’s unrealistic.

That it is counter-experiential is practically self-evident. As a little experiment try it on your wife. “I love you because of what you might become.” Looking into my crystal ball, I see divorce in your future. At the very least marriage counseling. When you love your wife when she wakes up in the morning, when she’s getting ready for work, when she putters around the house, and when she comes home tired after a long day at work, that’s love. When you love her only when she’s all dolled up for a night on the town, you love yourself or, at the most, your idea of her. It would be just about as effective in speaking with your kids or your friends.

If you love broccoli, you love it raw, steamed, roasted or just about any other way. When you love it when it’s been braised in butter, cream, and cheese, doesn’t that really mean you love butter, cream, and cheese? Or maybe just good cooking?

It’s unrealistic because America will never live up to your expectations for a simple reason: not everyone shares your vision and everybody else is pulling in their own directions. The future will always fall short. For every part of the “American idea” of which you approve (“inclusion, expansiveness, etc.”), there is its opposite and they’re all just as much a part of the idea as those parts of which you approve. You can find those qualities in France, Germany, or Uganda, too. If he hasn’t found those qualities anywhere else in his travels, I don’t think he’s traveled nearly enough. There are limits to what you can learn of a country from the bar of the InterCon.

I prefer by far the formulation of the Armenian poet: I love my country because it is mine.

5 comments

Cool

I found this story amusing. The Local reports that Swiss archaeologists are trying to get ancient Roman refrigerators working again:

Archaeologists near the Swiss city of Basel are trying to definitively establish if mysterious shafts discovered at Switzerland’s extensive Augusta Raurica site in 2013 could have been ancient refrigerators.
The Romans used shafts like the four-metre deep examples at Augusta Raurica – some 20 kilometres from Basel – as cool stores during summer.

The shafts were filled with snow and ice during winter and then covered with straw to keep the space cool well into the summer months. This then allowed for everything from cheese to wine – and even oysters – to be preserved during warm weather.

Now a team lead by Peter-Andrew Schwarz from the University of Basel is attempting, for the third time, to demonstrate that the Augusta Raurica shafts were indeed used as fridges, Swiss news agency SDA/ATS reports.

A first attempt to recreate the ancient cool box failed after archaeologists at the dig filed the shaft with snow all in one go. But that experiment showed temperatures in the shaft were above freezing point even in winter.

The second try was more successful: the shaft was gradually filled with snow and ice blocks were placed inside as well. Using these methods, snow remained until June.

This time they’re using a technique still used on the island of Majorca for cooling. Good luck to them.

What amused me about this story is that, if they had been found in the UK, they’d still have been in use. If you’ve ever had to cope with British plumbing, you’ll get the joke.

2 comments

If You’re So Smart Why Ain’t You Rich?

In reading this post by Barry Brownstein at the Foundation for Economic Education on Chinese students’ reaction to reading Hayek’s essay, “The Use Of Knowledge in Society”, it caused me to reflect on the experience of our two countries over the last 20 years.

China’s economy has blossomed, by some accounts becoming the largest on the planet. Ours has seen cycles of boom and bust and a long decade of phlegmatic growth.

I continue to believe that however things appear now we have little to worry about and that the contradictions inherent in China’s system will prove disastrous for it.

If the contradictions inherent in our own system don’t get us first.

7 comments

Take Back Your Poor, Your Huddled Masses…

In the last few days I’ve read a number of very nasty things about America and Americans written by second generation Americans. If there is any proof of my contention that immigration in 2018 is considerably different from immigration in 1918, that would have to be it.

One of the things that distinguishes the Ellis Island (1892-1954) immigrants from more recent arrivals is that the children of the Ellis Island immigrants generally learned English as their first language, many not learning their parents’ language at all, and were, if anything, 110% Americans. Have you ever wondered about those super-patriotic movies made from the late silent era right up to the 1950s? Those were mostly made by first and second generation immigrants.

Criticism of America and Americans is a characteristically American practice. My experience has been that’s something that baffles Brits, the French, Germans, etc. Being that self-critical just isn’t part of their makeup. It doesn’t bother me. As long as it’s done with love.

Hating America and Americans is something else again.

1 comment