Ruled By Misconceptions

I’ve stumbled across a paper you might find interesting. It’s a year old but it just came to my attention just now because it’s apparently just found a publisher. The paper was written by Douglas J. Ahler of Florida State University and Gaurav Sood and is titled “The Parties in Our Heads: Misperceptions about Party Composition and Their Consequences”. You can read the paper in full here. Here’s its abstract:

We document a large and consequential bias in how Americans perceive the major political parties: people tend to considerably overestimate the extent to which party supporters belong to party-stereotypical groups. For instance, people think that 32% of Democrats are LGBT (vs. 6% in reality) and 38% of Republicans earn over $250,000 per year (vs. 2% in reality). Experimental data suggest that these misperceptions are genuine and party specific, not artifacts of expressive responding, innumeracy, or ignorance of base rates. These misperceptions are widely shared, though bias in out-party perceptions is larger. Using observational and experimental data, we document the consequences of this perceptual bias. Misperceptions about out-party composition are associated with partisan affect, beliefs about out-party extremity, and allegiance to one’s own party. When provided information about the out-party’s actual composition, partisans come to see its supporters as less extreme and feel less socially distant from them.

The authors make a number of interesting observations. For example, Republicans greatly overestimate how many Democrats are union members (36.5% vs. actual 10.5%) while Democrats even more greatly overestimate how many Republicans earn more than $250,000 (31.5% vs. actual 2.2%). They also find something interesting: the more closely you follow the news the more likely you are to make these mistakes.

Here’s what to my eye is their most important observation:

Believing that opposing partisans hold more extreme policy preferences, and feeling more socially distant from them, are both liable to cause citizens to become less receptive to out-party communications and less likely to consider voting for that party. This may happen because people come to see opposing partisans as working on behalf of the interests of a few groups (at the expense of other groups or even the national interest) (e.g., Bawn et al. 2012), or because they think that the opposing party supports more extreme policies that it does, or potentially even because they distrust elites representing disliked groups.

Let that sink in for a bit. Lack of understanding of the people in the other party promotes the interests of the more extreme members of both parties at the expense of sympathy and moderation. No wonder we’re so screwed up.

6 comments

Kim’s Charm Offensive

Max Boot and the editors of the Wall Street Journal echo some of the caution I advised in my piece yesterday on the negotiations with North Korea.

Boot

Yes, it’s a good thing the two Korean leaders are meeting and talking. It is certainly better than the saber-rattling we saw last year, with North Korea testing nuclear weapons and missiles, and President Trump responding with threats to rain down “fire and fury.”

But let’s not imagine that Moon Jae-in and Kim Jong Un are making “historic” breakthroughs with their summit declaration. It is full of lofty but empty language promising “no more war on the Korean Peninsula.” The two leaders agreed to transform the demilitarized zone — actually the most heavily militarized area in the world — into a “peace zone,” and to conclude the Korean War with a “robust peace regime.” They even pledged a “nuclear-free Korean Peninsula.”

Yada, yada, yada. Upon closer examination, there is very little of substance here — certainly nothing to justify Trump’s hyperbolic tweet: “KOREAN WAR TO END! The United States, and all of its GREAT people, should be very proud of what is now taking place in Korea!”

Wall Street Journal

The hope is that Kim Jong Un has had a major change of heart, perhaps due to pressure from sanctions and China. But Kim has been even more aggressive than his forbears, making the pursuit of nuclear weapons a sacred duty of the state. Five years ago he declared the 1953 Armistice that suspended the Korean War null and void, and South Korean intelligence believes he was behind the 2010 attacks.

So why is President Moon offering the North diplomatic relief from the U.S. campaign of maximum pressure? He was chief of staff to left-wing former President Roh Moo-hyun, and like Roh he wants to play a “balancing role” between the U.S. and the North. His chief of staff, Im Jong-seok, was a follower of North Korean ideology and worked as an agent for the North as recently as 2005, collecting the regime’s intellectual property royalties in the South, according to his autobiography.

Mr. Moon may care less about denuclearizing the North than using engagement and money to entice the two nations into a confederation without a change in governance. To that end, he could be attempting to draw Mr. Trump into a repeat of the mistakes that Presidents Clinton and George W. Bush made that rewarded the North for promises of denuclearization that never materialized.

Let me submit something for your consideration. There’s a parallel between what Kim Jong Un is doing and the recent visit to Washington by Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. Both are being portrayed as “liberalizers” when they’re really engaged in asymmetric warfare. They’re inserting themselves and trying to control our OODA loop.

5 comments

Prediction Is Hard

If you don’t already know of them, you might be amused by this list of wrong predictions about technology in Inc.. Here’s an example:

“The world potential market for copying machines is 5,000 at most.” — IBM, to the eventual founders of Xerox, 1959.

One of the things their list of predictions brought to mind is that we’ve seen the like of Elon Musk a century ago in the form of Lee de Forest. The main difference is that de Forest actually created an impressive string of significant inventions and founded a whole series of companies, some of which are still active in somewhat different forms to this day.

Here’s a question for you. Are the pessimistic predictions about technology more laughable or are the optimistic ones?

4 comments

Suspended in Mid-Air

This interview with Australian journalist Dinny McMahon at Knowledge@Wharton touches on a number of topics I’ve commented here on The Glittering Eye over the last 15 years including the sources of Chinese economic growth, the graying of China, and just how much of a house of cards everything is. For me here’s the kernel of the interview:

Knowledge@Wharton: Is the end of the Chinese Miracle in sight?

McMahon: In my mind, the miracle’s already over. The reason I say that is what has been allowing the Chinese economy to grow so quickly over the last six or seven years has been that the accumulation of debt has been faster than the economic growth. That is not sustainable, and that’s not a miracle. That’s just alchemy. The issue is what happens next in the economy. I don’t know exactly what will happen. Firstly, I think the reality is that China will become the global power we assume it will. But it’s certainly not a foregone conclusion.

When I wrote my series on “China’s time bombs” thirteen years ago, I was optimistic about the ability of the Chinese government to address its most pressing problems including demographics, environmental degradation, and its financial system. Over that period the Chinese authorities have done very little to come to terms with those problems and their potential impact on the rest of the world is much worse.

Now the questions are whether those problems fall on China with a bang or a whimper and how the rest of the world and the U. S. in particular deals with the changes that will inevitably come to China.

0 comments

If a Tree Falls…

If a tree falls in the forest and it isn’t reported on by the New York Times does it make a sound? That’s the bottom line of a post by Michael Shellenberger at Forbes. He opens by pointing out that although the cost of solar panels to consumers has gone down the cost of solar energy has risen:

Between 2009 and 2017, the price of solar panels per watt declined by 75 percent while the price of wind turbines per watt declined by 50 percent.

And yet — during the same period — the price of electricity in places that deployed significant quantities of renewables increased dramatically.

Electricity prices increased by:

  • 51 percent in Germany during its expansion of solar and wind energy from 2006 to 2016;
  • 24 percent in California during its solar energy build-out from 2011 to 2017;
  • over 100 percent in Denmark since 1995 when it began deploying renewables (mostly wind) in earnest.

I don’t think he’s being quite fair. What percentage of total electrical power is represented by wind and solar in those places? In California wind and solar combined furnish about 16% of California’s electricity while nearly two-thirds come from natural gas or hydro. In other words in all likelihood the cost of solar panels just isn’t that important in the big picture.

In addition the price per kwh of electricity in nuclear Illinois is 11.7 cents—that’s higher than the U. S. median price not lower. In California it’s 15.2 cents.

He continues by pointing out something that’s been noted here: as we deploy more solar and wind natural gas and hydro actually become more important not less.

He concludes that the popular misconception can be explained by press bias:

This is a problem of bias, not just energy illiteracy. Normally skeptical journalists routinely give renewables a pass. The reason isn’t because they don’t know how to report critically on energy — they do regularly when it comes to non-renewable energy sources — but rather because they don’t want to.

That could — and should — change. Reporters have an obligation to report accurately and fairly on all issues they cover, especially ones as important as energy and the environment.

While I have little doubt that journalists are biased, I don’t think that’s what’s going on. I’d need to dig into the figures but I think that the cost of electricity to the consumer depends less on underlying production than on government subsidies in various different forms. That’s not just true of solar and wind; it’s true of all energy.

In the case of solar there are both producer subsidies and consumer subsidies. China is subsidizing the production of solar panels to a degree nearly impossible to imagine. That results in lower costs for U. S. consumers. The federal government subsidizes consumers for installing solar.

All of those subsidies don’t actually reduce the cost of energy. That’s misdirection. They increase it.

13 comments

Buy the Rumor, Korean Edition

If you’re wondering why I’m not hanging on every word exchanged among Korean and American diplomats, I don’t generally comment on press releases. Saying you’re going to do something is not the same as doing something. I don’t much care what they say they’re going to do. I’m much more interested in what they do.

I think that Kim Jong Un has learned a lot from the Chinese. The Chinese authorities can write a heckuva press release.

6 comments

How to Respond to Trump, Trumpism, and anti-Trumpism

In her Wall Street Journal column Peggy Noonan, no particular fan of Donald Trump, muses on how we should be reacting:

What is required of us at this point in history? What is required of those of us who aren’t making history but observing it, watching with concern or alarm? There’s a sense now of not getting the news but listening for what shoe just dropped.

Thursday morning there was the president’s latest unhingement, in a phone interview on “Fox & Friends.” He was agitated; he spoke of witch hunts, monsters, fakes, phonies and killers. They are “trying to destroy” his doctor, who withdrew his nomination as secretary of veterans affairs. James Comey is “a leaker and he is a liar.” “There is no collusion with me and the Russians.” “Fake news CNN actually gave the questions to the debate.” “They have a witch hunt against the president of the United States.” “It is a horrible thing that is going on, a horrible thing. Yet I have accomplished, with all of this going on, more than any president in the first year in our history. And everybody—even the enemies and haters admit that.” He’s disappointed in his Justice Department. The “corruption at the top of the FBI, it’s a disgrace.” Michael Cohen represented him “with this crazy Stormy Daniels deal.” “But I’m not involved, and I’m not involved—I’ve been told I’m not involved.” He gets along with Kanye West. “I get along with a lot of people frankly.” “CBS and NBC, ABC—they’re all fake news.” They tried to suppress the Trump vote, so that his supporters on Election Day would say, “So let’s go to a movie, darling, and we’ll come home and watch Donald lose.” “Let me tell you the nuclear war would have happened if you had weak people.” “I don’t watch NBC anymore; they’re as bad as CNN. I don’t—by the way I made them a fortune with ‘The Apprentice.’ ”

You could call the interview far-ranging or scattered, you could call it typically colorful or really nuts, but you couldn’t hear it without feeling more disquiet and unease. And that was just Thursday’s installment of “As the Trump Turns.”

So what is required of us at this roiling time? What are some behavioral rules for the road? The political turbulence we’re experiencing isn’t going to go away, and what’s important at such a time is to absorb the daily shocks, think long-term, speak your mind, share your heart, and do your best.

Beyond that, I think the great requirement of this moment, in the second year of the Trump era, is: Don’t lose your composure. Don’t let it rob you of your peace. Maintain your poise. Don’t let the history around you destabilize you. Don’t become sour. Keep on your game, maintain your own standards. There are people on television who level the gravest charges against the administration. But they don’t look sad, they have a look of cackling glee. History isn’t unfolding for your amusement. If it’s such a tragedy, you could now and then look stricken.

It would be good for people to dig deep. Everything in our national political life is in flux. Don’t just oppose. Take time to look at why you stand where you stand. Why are you a Democrat? What truths, goals, realities of that party deserve your loyalty? Republicans, the same.

That is very much what I have tried to do here. Present reasoned, logical, and substantiated arguments against those things with which you disagree; provide substantial arguments for the things you believe in; maintain an even disposition.

That’s how we preserve the republic.

3 comments

Net Outcome

Just for the record I don’t think that the consequences of the cap on deductibility of state and local taxes will be that the ultra-rich desert California, New York, Connecticut, New Jersey, etc. in droves. I think it will be that those states will increasingly come to resemble Mexico from a social and economic standpoint. The middle class and merely well-to-do will leave those high tax states, leaving a small cohesive upper class, a large cohesive lower class, and a much reduced and struggling middle class.

If that’s the sort of society you want to live in, rejoice! It’s on its way.

2 comments

How Globalism Failed

I think you might be interested in this article about “stereotypical” globalist Ian Bremmer’s critique of globalism at Washington Examiner:

In a nutshell, Bremmer argues that international trade and technological innovation drastically changed labor markets, and many people unable to adjust to the changing economy feel left behind, or fear they are at risk to be left behind by further mechanization of the means of production. The resulting inequality feeds populist tendencies as citizens begin to find scapegoats for their woes, such as immigrants, inevitably creating an “us vs. them” mentality as they implore their government to protect them from threats to their livelihood.

My own critique is that, at least in the form it has taken in the U. S., globalism has always been phony. Genuine globalism wouldn’t protect lawyers, physicians, architects, and bankers while exposing auto workers and computer programmers to international competition. It wouldn’t shield intellectual property, a major focus of U. S. trade policy, while making physical property vulnerable.

3 comments

Opposing Made in China 2025

If you’re not aware of it, “Made in China 2025” is the Chinese government’s plan to dominate the high technology industries of the 21st century and climb the value chain in manufacturing. In general I agree with the editors of Bloomberg‘s views:

To be clear, China isn’t wrong to harbor such ambitions. And, so far as the basic economics goes, its success needn’t disadvantage the U.S. or any other country. The U.S. didn’t get rich in the last century at Europe’s expense: Its innovations raised living standards everywhere. That’s what trade and commerce do. In a well-functioning global system, successful economies prosper together.

In many ways, this is still happening. Take just one instance of China’s emerging technological prowess: Its success as a manufacturer of solar panels has lowered the cost of clean energy worldwide.

But the U.S. and its partners have two pressing and legitimate concerns. First, China is seeking technological superiority in fields — artificial intelligence, robotics, autonomous vehicles, augmented reality — that will be crucial for military, not just civil, innovation. The U.S. and its allies need to maintain their edge on the battlefield.

Second, China isn’t playing by the rules. It wants access to other countries’ markets and technologies but is slow to grant access to its own. And its technological push has often relied on questionable or outright illegal methods — from rampant cyber-theft of commercial and military secrets, to subtler violations of the spirit if not always the letter of the country’s obligations as a member of the World Trade Organization.

If anything they understate the issue. Requiring companies that wish to trade in China to disclose trade secrets and share intellectual property isn’t the full extent of China’s predation. The Chinese government has an active program of hacking both government and private companies’ networks to steal whatever they can.

I have always believed that admitting China to the WTO was an error but that particular horse has already escaped the barn and the harm done by it cannot be undone. What harm? U. S. manufacturing employment collapsed following China’s WTO admission as its trade with the U. S. exploded.

What then is to be done? I have always believed that some form of reciprocity was the correct approach to dealing with China. For Chinese high tech products to be sold in the U. S., the underlying technology should be placed in the public domain. Tariffs should be imposed on Chinese goods in the amount of subsidies provided by the Chinese government. And so on.

I’ll be interested in seeing how thinking in the U. S. on this subject develops. I don’t know how the U. S. can continue to prosper by doing all the spadework while China reaps the benefits.

3 comments