I’ve stumbled across a paper you might find interesting. It’s a year old but it just came to my attention just now because it’s apparently just found a publisher. The paper was written by Douglas J. Ahler of Florida State University and Gaurav Sood and is titled “The Parties in Our Heads: Misperceptions about Party Composition and Their Consequences”. You can read the paper in full here. Here’s its abstract:
We document a large and consequential bias in how Americans perceive the major political parties: people tend to considerably overestimate the extent to which party supporters belong to party-stereotypical groups. For instance, people think that 32% of Democrats are LGBT (vs. 6% in reality) and 38% of Republicans earn over $250,000 per year (vs. 2% in reality). Experimental data suggest that these misperceptions are genuine and party specific, not artifacts of expressive responding, innumeracy, or ignorance of base rates. These misperceptions are widely shared, though bias in out-party perceptions is larger. Using observational and experimental data, we document the consequences of this perceptual bias. Misperceptions about out-party composition are associated with partisan affect, beliefs about out-party extremity, and allegiance to one’s own party. When provided information about the out-party’s actual composition, partisans come to see its supporters as less extreme and feel less socially distant from them.
The authors make a number of interesting observations. For example, Republicans greatly overestimate how many Democrats are union members (36.5% vs. actual 10.5%) while Democrats even more greatly overestimate how many Republicans earn more than $250,000 (31.5% vs. actual 2.2%). They also find something interesting: the more closely you follow the news the more likely you are to make these mistakes.
Here’s what to my eye is their most important observation:
Believing that opposing partisans hold more extreme policy preferences, and feeling more socially distant from them, are both liable to cause citizens to become less receptive to out-party communications and less likely to consider voting for that party. This may happen because people come to see opposing partisans as working on behalf of the interests of a few groups (at the expense of other groups or even the national interest) (e.g., Bawn et al. 2012), or because they think that the opposing party supports more extreme policies that it does, or potentially even because they distrust elites representing disliked groups.
Let that sink in for a bit. Lack of understanding of the people in the other party promotes the interests of the more extreme members of both parties at the expense of sympathy and moderation. No wonder we’re so screwed up.







