What Went Wrong?

According to the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction the large sums of money spent by the U. S. government on stabilizing Afghanistan since 2009 have largely been wasted. USA Today reports:

The damning report finds that much of the $4.7 billion spent on programs to stabilize areas cleared of insurgents has been largely wasted — some of it siphoned off by corrupt officials, some of it paying for projects that did more harm than good. All told, the U.S. government has appropriated about $126 billion to rebuild the country, most of it to train and equip security forces.

“The large sums of stabilization dollars the United States devoted to Afghanistan in search of quick gains often exacerbated conflicts, enabled corruption, and bolstered support for insurgents,” the report states.

One of the big problems was that success was measured in terms of inputs rather than in terms of outputs. That problem isn’t isolated to our efforts in Afghanistan.

3 comments

Send In the Troops!

At The Hill DePaul philosophy prof Jason D. Hill pleads with President Trump to send troops into Chicago to create order:

President Trump, during your presidential campaign you made a promise to send federal troops to drain the swamp in Washington, D.C., and also one festering with feral thugs and gang-bangers who are committing genocide among black Americans right in the great city of Chicago.

I won’t quote you the homicide statistics, past and present, because by the time you read this they will have changed. Suffice it to say: They are horrific.

Something is terribly wrong when, in the most moral nation on earth, its third-largest city is ruled by gangs with a crime rate that is 35 percent higher than the national average.

and

I implore you to use your powers to suspend the dated Posse Comitatus Act, which unfairly limits your ability to use domestic militarization to respond to crises, and send in the resources necessary to stem the violence overrunning Chicago. Let me explain why this measure is necessary, starting with my story.

He follows with a litany of horrors. As the late Mayor Daley used to say, let’s look at the record. The homicide rate in Chicago is bad but it’s better than it was last year at this time and last year was better than the year before. Is the present rate acceptable? No! Does it merit bringing in the military? I don’t believe so.

The problem is as it has been gangs. Gun control won’t solve the problem. Most of the crimes are already perpetrated with weapons obtained illegally. More police officers won’t solve the problem. Chicago already has more cops per 100K population than other cities with much lower homicide rates. Legalizing drugs won’t solve the problem. The gangs will support themselves another way—through protection (as noted in the linked piece), gunrunning, or any of a thousand other illegal activities.

If you’re looking for collusion, look no farther than City Hall. The city government is in collusion with the gangs. In fact government at all levels has been paying them off for years under various pretexts.

If the situation warranted Gov. Rauner could send in the National Guard tomorrow without violating the Posse Comitatus Act. Why does’t he? Because it won’t help his re-election campaign and the worse that Chicago looks, the better. The cynicism of Democrats and Republicans alike is stunning. Don’t expect anything better from his Democratic opponent in November. If elected, J. B. Pritzker will treat Chicago with the same neglect his predecessors have.

What to do? Beats the heck out of me. I think that Chicago, like most Third World Countries, more than anything else needs better government. Sending in the troops won’t deliver that.

2 comments

Red, Blue, Purple, or Just Angry?

Read this article at Larry Sabato’s Crystall Ball on those who voted for Obama in 2012 who then voted for Trump in 2016 and then answer the following questions.

How good a predictor is a presidential election for the mid-terms? I would say they’re lousy.

How likely is it that those who cast a protect vote for Obama in 2008 and for Trump in 2016 will be satisfied with the changes that have occurred since his election?

How likely is it that they’ll vote?

10 comments

The American Promise

A lot of ink and electrons have been devoted to “the American dream”. Rather than talking about the dream, let’s instead talk about what might be called “the American promise” which I would characterize as if you work hard, follow the rules, and keep your nose clean, you’ll have a decent life.

What are the implications of that not being true? What if the only way you can have a decent life is by cutting every corner you can, breaking the law, and looking out for #1? What are the implications of that?

5 comments

Made in the U. S. A.

In my peregrinations through the wilds of the Internet yesterday I stumbled across an interesting statistic at the web site of the U. S. Department of Commerce. Gross product is equal to intermediate inputs plus value added. In the domestic automobile industry value added is just 22%. That’s extremely low. The intermediate inputs include everything from auto engines to door panels to tires to windshield wipers and an astonishing proportion of those intermediate inputs are made overseas.

Not only do we need to increase the value added in auto manufacturing we need to increase the proportion of intermediate inputs used in the production of autos that are made in the U. S. A. We need to capture a much larger proportion of the entire supply chain. We can’t do that just by imposing tariffs on finished autos.

0 comments

What Is “Full Employment”?

In his Washington Post column this morning Jared Bernstein writes about full employment:

A number of top-flight economists with whom I usually agree, most notably Paul Krugman, assure me that the U.S. job market is at full employment, meaning … actually, it’s not easy to describe what we mean by full employment. The easiest explanation is that that everyone who wants to work and is reasonably able to do so has a job that provides them the hours of work they want.

Let’s stop right there. The very first lesson I learned in economics and, I assume, the very first lesson learned by Drs. Krugman (an economist) and Bernstein (not an economist so I don’t honestly know whether he’s ever taken an economics course) was that supply, demand, and price cannot be discussed in isolation from one another.

What is the supply of labor available at $1/hour? What at $100/hour? There is no such thing as “full employment” in isolation from the entire potential pool of workers, wages, and business practices.

This generates a testable hypothesis. If the unemployment rate continues to fall, say to 3.5 percent or even lower, as some forecasters believe will occur, that’s when we’ll see wages for middle-class and low-income workers take off. Depending on the trajectory of unemployment, we’ll see if I’m right by later this year or next.

Not exactly. When the pool of workers can grow indefinitely—just off the books—the size of the pool can’t be measured. When you can’t measure the number of workers in the entire pool, what they’re being paid, or the conditions under which they’re working, the unemployment rate is meaningless.

For generations U. S. policy has been to maximize the number of minimum wage employees (the Germans call it “the American strategy”). That has been accompanied by loose enforcement of immigration laws, a large volume of legal immigration, and lowering or elimination of import duties. Businesses have become accustomed to those policies. Whole business models depend on them.

My view has long been that we need to change that. There are some businesses that shouldn’t be profitable in the U. S. Businesses shouldn’t be able to depend on a reliable stream of workers who’ll work for low wages.
Wages should be higher.

We need to decide what kind of country we’ll be and we need to change what we’re doing to match that. There will be pain. But I think most of us will be better off for it.

3 comments

Out in the Open

You might enjoy a fascinating article at the New Yorker on pre-Islamic texts found in the north of Arabia as much as I did:

In a small valley, an ancient grave was surrounded by a toppled cairn, with a desert meadow of nettles and tiny blue wildflowers below. Al-Jallad walked to a basalt slab shaped like a giant arrowhead, covered in etchings. As the field hand stood nearby, he squatted and read aloud, “Li ‘Addan bin Aws bin Adam bin Sa‘d, wa-ra‘aya ha-d-da’na bi-qasf kabir ‘ala akhihi sabiy fa-hal-Lat fasiyyat.” The writing said that the grandson of a man named Adam had once sat in this spot and pastured his sheep; he grieved for a brother who’d been captured by an enemy tribe, and prayed to the goddess Allat for his deliverance. As Al-Jallad read, the field hand stared, astonished that these markings encoded a language that he could, more or less, understand.

For three days, the members of Al-Jallad’s expedition walked across hilltops, logging a thousand new Safaitic inscriptions. Around the remains of cairns, there were texts carved everywhere, and rock art, too—drawings of lions leaping on horses, warriors with bows and spears, gazelles, ostriches, dancers with flutes. The inscriptions, Al-Jallad explained, were a form of monument-making. “The fact that they don’t appear monumental to our eyes is because our idea of monumentality comes from a Greco-Roman model, where things are neat and square,” he said.

They paint a picture of Arabia in the period just before the birth of Mohammed somewhat different than the prevailing one just as the earliest texts of the Qur’an do. They’d better scour them up quickly; challenging people’s religious beliefs can be a dangerous activity. Don’t be surprised if an active program to suppress them springs up.

0 comments

Who’s Qualified To Be President?

Among past presidents twelve had been generals:

George Washington
William H. Harrison
Andrew Jackson
Zachary Taylor
Franklin Pierce
Andrew Johnson
Ulysses S. Grant
Rutherford B. Hayes
James A. Garfield
Chester A. Arthur
Benjamin Harrison
Dwight D. Eisenhower

Seventeen had been governors:

Thomas Jefferson
James Monroe
Martin Van Buren
John Tyler
James K. Polk
Andrew Johnson
Rutherford B. Hayes
Grover Cleveland
William McKinley
Theodore Roosevelt
Woodrow Wilson
Calvin Coolidge
Franklin Roosevelt
Jimmy Carter
Ronald Reagan
Bill Clinton
George W. Bush

Sixteen had been senators:

James Monroe
John Quincy Adams
Martin Van Buren
William H. Harrison
John Tyler
James Buchanan
Andrew Johnson
Benjamin Harrison
Warren G. Harding
Harry S. Truman
John F. Kennedy
Lyndon B. Johnson
Richard M. Nixon
Barack Obama

None has been CEO of a large company (unless you count Trump). No president had previously been a Supreme Court justice (Taft served on the Supreme Court after being president).

Maybe it just reflects my own prejudices but I think that the record suggests that having been a senator is not a particularly good qualification for the presidency.

This post is in reaction to a comment on a post at OTB about qualifications for the presidency. If you’re going to impose additional qualifications for running for president please, please don’t require them to have held elective office.

4 comments

Dialogue in a Sandwich Shop

Me to cashier: Has anyone ever told you that you look like 11?

Cashier: Actually, I get that a lot. I think so, too.

Me to cashier: It’s a compliment.

Cashier: I know. I think she’s cute.

Me to cashier: Me, too. Her older sister maybe.

1 comment

Slouching Towards Middle East War

I think that this interpretation of Israel’s recent attacks on Iranian forces in Syria by Reva Goujon at RealClearWorld is about right:

Israel knows that in this age of emerging great power conflict, it cannot take for granted the United States’ long-term commitment to the Middle East. On the one hand, the U.S. administration has been vocal about trying to reduce its overseas commitments, demanding that regional players step up to the plate so it can remove its own forces. The last thing the White House wants is to get pulled into a confrontation with a major power such as Russia over a minor power such as Syria. On the other hand, the White House under President Donald Trump is bent on recasting Iran as an international pariah and is evidently willing to risk confrontation with Tehran, even if doing so ends up prolonging the United States’ presence in the region.

Israel’s objective is to steer the United States toward the latter course. If Israel is to seize its opportunity to weaken Iran, which also entails taking on more risk, then it needs to do so in a way that keeps the United States engaged.

The $50 trillion question is whether domestic political considerations will overwhelm common sense and foreign policy interests and propel us into a disastrous war in the Middle East. I’m betting on domestic political considerations.

8 comments