Does Populism Rise With a Declining Population?

And here’s another counter-intuitive suggestion. A decrease in population promotes an increase in population. From a New York Times op-ed by Philip Auerswald and Joon Yun:

Nicola Gatta, the mayor of Candela in southeastern Italy (population 2,700), is desperate to reverse two decades of population decline and literally keep his town on the map. If you accept his invitation to move there, he will pay you about $2,300.

It’s probably no coincidence that mayors in small Italian towns are making such offers at about the same time as a populist coalition is on the verge of taking over Italy’s government.

The last time that populism — what we broadly define as political movements that ostensibly set the interests of “ordinary people” against elites as well as an “other” — swept across Europe and the United States was marked by the same combination of slow economic and fertility growth that today prevails in advanced industrialized countries in the West and Asia.

I don’t know enough about Italian or Hungarian politics to comment about those countries so I’ll focus on the U. S. Populism is increasing in Texas, too, right along with the population. When you combine that with a casual observation that although population in Japan is actually declining, not just slowing in its rate of increase, it suggests an alternative interpretation. Japan has very low immigration. Is it possible that populism increases with immigration?

Or, more precisely, when people don’t think that their political leaders are paying enough attention to them, they tend to become more populist.

0 comments

Do Activist Shareholders Hurt Job Creation?

Here’s one of the least intuitive claims I’ve read recently. Activist shareholders who want to drive wider societal change through their proxy proposals reduce job creation. From a post at RealClearMarkets from Christopher Iacovella:

For one thing, shareholder proposals are not cheap. On average, responding to each resolution costs a company up to $150,000. To compound the problem, outdated SEC resubmission rules allow the same initiative to be reintroduced year after year, even when it consistently fails to gain support from a majority of shareholders.

While $150,000 is not insignificant, the reality is that most companies typically face 15 or more proposals a year. This diverts as much as $2 million worth of company resources from shareholders. Put another way, when dollars are being allocated to respond to the political proposals of the minority, they’re not being invested to maximize the value of the company for the majority.

This kind of activism also disproportionately impacts smaller companies who have fewer resources at their disposal. Instead of focusing on growing and staying competitive, companies are now devoting more resources to address these immaterial political issues; this directly impacts the bottom line. Public companies are engines of growth and innovation, not Trojan horses masquerading as elected politicians.

Of course, private companies have a way to circumvent the extra red-tape, added cost, and politics; they can decide not to go public. And that’s exactly what they’re doing in record numbers. The scale of the problem is hard to imagine; IPOs are down 84% over the last twelve years, and the percentage of American stocks owned by the average investor has decreased by 60% since 1950. Fewer public companies reduces investor choice and stifles job creation.

I’d like to see some actual data on this. This smells like a red herring to me. Doesn’t the opposite, stock buyers who pile onto value stocks, also “stifle job creation” through deadweight loss?

Shareholders have as much right to let their political or religious views inform their preferences in corporate management as somebody who is focused solely on maximizing financial returns. De gustibus, etc. If that’s what they want to do with their money, they have a right to do it.

8 comments

Older Industrial Cities

There’s an interesting article at Brookings on “older industrial cities”. It seems to me that how Democrats treat these OICs, overwhelmingly run by Democrats, is a pretty good litmus test for the party’s future.

1 comment

More On That Supreme Court Decision

I’ve been looking, largely in vain, for commentary on the recent Supreme Court decision effectively striking down an Obama Administration directive on class action suits by employees against employers. The thrust of every article I’ve found opposing the decision did so on policy grounds rather than legal grounds, a factor to which the Supreme Court’s majority tipped their collective hat in their opinion.

The best and fairest remarks I’ve found so far are from Noah Feldman at Bloomberg View:

Seen in terms of jurisprudence, the decision reflected a serious philosophical difference between the two wings of the court. The conservatives insisted on a literalist, original-intent reading of the relevant federal laws; the liberals focused on the laws’ purpose and the practical consequences of the decision.

The decision known as Epic Systems v. Lewis combines three cases, all of which grew out of fairly standard disputes between employers and employees over whether the workers were classified accurately and paid according to federal law. In such cases, it’s typical that no individual employee has enough money on the line to bother going to arbitration or to court. So lawyers fill the gap, bringing class actions on behalf of all employees similarly situated. Adding up their claims against a good-size company puts enough money on the table for the lawyers to make the case worthwhile.

What you think about this scenario pretty much tells you how you would’ve voted if you were one of the justices. Conservatives usually think this is just another instance of lawyers imposing unnecessary costs on business competitiveness. Liberals tend to think that without the lawyers to aggregate the claims and bring them, companies would get away with systematic illegal conduct.

On the legal level, the decision involved the relationship between two old statutes: the Federal Arbitration Act of 1925 and the National Labor Relations Act of 1935.

The FAA says that courts should enforce arbitration agreements as written, unless judges find that the agreement falls within “such grounds as exist at law … for the revocation of any contract.”

The NLRA, for its part, says that workers may join unions and engage in collective bargaining or “other concerted activities for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid or protection.”

The conservative opinion written by Justice Neil Gorsuch — his first really important decision for the court — simply took the FAA as controlling law. The arbitration agreements exist, and they should be followed unless there’s a legal reason not to.

Gorsuch first dismissed the idea that there was anything unlawful about the individual arbitration agreements. Then, for good measure, he explained that there was no reason to think that the “other concerted activities” permitted by the NLRA were meant to include class-action lawsuits, which were rare in 1935, and unknown in their modern form.

Gorsuch’s opinion is neatly argued and clearly written. If you lived on the moon, with no knowledge of the realities of labor relations or the politics of class actions, you’d think it was obviously correct. The justice is almost certainly right when he says that the authors of the NLRA weren’t thinking about class actions when they allowed collective action by employees.

But as Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg pointed out in her stinging dissent, the reality of the NLRA is that it was enacted to overcome the long history of anti-union law and practice, including the notorious “yellow dog” contract, in which employees agreed not to join unions. The whole point of the NLRA, Ginsburg convincingly argued, was to reject the idea that employers could use their structural power in forming employment contracts to make employees give up their rights.

Seen from this perspective, the class-action suits look like exactly the sort of collective, “concerted” employee activity that the NLRA was designed to permit. If that is correct, then the NLRA, which was enacted after the FAA, should effectively modify the command that arbitration agreements should ordinarily be enforced.

To this argument Ginsburg added a further twist that under the NLRA, the individual arbitration agreements are in fact illegal. If so, then the agreements fall within the clause of the FAA that exempts arbitration agreements that would fail under ordinary contract law — because you can’t enforce a contract to do something illegal.

Ginsburg went further, implicitly accusing the conservative majority of reverting to the so-called Lochner era, when conservative justices struck down progressive legislation in the name of the liberty of contract. This was a clever rhetorical move, because the majority was in fact upholding the arbitration agreements as an exercise of the supposedly equal contracting rights of employers and employees.

But the accusation isn’t exactly correct, because today’s conservatives aren’t inventing constitutional rights out of whole cloth. They are simply relying on conservative interpretation of federal law passed by Congress.

Now perhaps I’m reading something that isn’t there but my reading of that is that the majority’s decision can be read purely in terms of the law while the minority’s view cannot be understood as other than making policy. In other words viewing this decision as a litmus test of conservative vs. liberal is a gross oversimplication.

I don’t want Supreme Court justices making policy. I don’t even want Supreme Court justices who want to make policy. I want judges who want to adjudicate on the basis of the law. If they want to set policy, they should run for Congress.

My preferred policy would be one in which the federal government isn’t subsidizing big companies and in fact has a certain level of hostility to them. They should be broken up when they get large enough to start exerting monopoly or monopsony power. But how we get to that policy matters to me, too.

0 comments

Unum

Can anyone identify for me a multi-cultural society in which one of the cultures does not dominate the others politically, socially, and economically? I can’t think of any.

3 comments

Shouldering Responsibility

In his post at City Journal Peter Cove underscores a point I’ve made here frequently:

Work is transformative, and not just in the values-based, spiritual sense that liberals like to mock, but also practically. People on welfare who are given a job—any job—gain a sense of possibility that enables them to start getting the rest of their lives in order. Just as nothing succeeds like success, dependency begets more dependency; long-term idleness can create psychological and physical impairments to finding employment. Instead of attacking work as a way to punish people dependent on government, it should be seen as a vehicle for becoming an adult member of society—a citizen in full.

Additionally, a job is a responsibility. Contrary to a view held by far too many, happiness comes from shouldering responsibilities not avoiding them.

1 comment

Be Careful What You Wish For

A couple of years ago during the Chicago teachers’ strike, I saw a neighbor sporting a sweatshirt emblazoned with the slogan “Teachers Should Be Paid As Much As Plumbers”. I turned to my wife and said “I wonder how she would react to learn that in Chicago teachers are paid more than plumbers.” My wife, with characteristic commonsense, suggested it would probably be better if I kept that fact to myself.

That’s what I thought of when I read Robert Maranto’s remarks on teacher pay in the Wall Street Journal:

Nationally, teachers make a median $58,000 a year, with great benefits. This is better than some activists claim, but it still puts teachers in the lower tier of professionals. While the proposed 20% raises in Arizona and Oklahoma are a good start, I would go further. A 40% raise would lift the median teacher’s pay far above that of accountants ($68,000) and into the same ballpark as civil engineers ($84,000). Surely educating the nation’s children is as important as balancing books or building bridges.

The median pay for a Chicago teacher is $71,000. The median pay for a civil engineer in Chicago is $70,000. The Chicago teacher is being paid for a nine or ten month position. The engineer for a twelve month position. Additionally, when the teacher retires he or she is eligible for a pension of 75% of pay to which she or he has not contributed a sou. Teachers do not pay Social Security. Mission accomplished. Next?

2 comments

When the Curve Failed

I found Paul Krugman’s New York Times column particularly good today. My observation has been that the more closely he hews to economics, “wonkish” as he puts it, the better. In this particular column he muses over why wages have been flat:

From the mid-1990s until the 2008 financial crisis, it looked as if there was a fairly stable Phillips curve – a relationship between unemployment and the rate of wage growth. This wasn’t the “accelerationist” Phillips curve that underlies the concept of the natural rate of unemployment – there was no sign that low unemployment led to accelerating inflation. It was, instead, a neo-paleo-Keynesian relationship between unemployment and wages. You can see how good the relationship looked in Figure 1, in which wage growth is measured on the left axis and the inverse of the unemployment rate on the right axis…

[…]

After the crisis, wage growth dropped – but only about as much as it dropped in the early 2000s slump, despite much higher unemployment. And it has increased only modestly since then, to levels well below pre-crisis growth, despite unemployment rates as low as we’ve seen in a very long time…

He proposes several possible explanations: despite the very low unemployment rate there’s also a lower rate of employment and monopsony for labor, particularly in local markets.

In the Wall Street Journal Federal Reserve Governor Neel Kashkari has an answer of sorts:

Today’s flat Phillips curve and low long-term interest rates are not mysteries. They are products of a bipartisan political consensus that allows the Fed to focus on achieving its inflation and employment objectives rather than short-term political goals. If Americans want to keep this economic expansion going, we all should recognize the important role Fed independence plays in keeping inflation in check.

That’s something of which we should never lose sight. Economics isn’t a “hard” science like physics or chemistry and the Phillips Curve isn’t like plotting the orbit of a planet. It’s an artifact. It’s the result of human behavior and human responses to change.

One more thing. The graph that Dr. Krugman presents in his Figure 1 of “average hourly earnings of production and non-supervisory employees” shows only wage income. It does not reflect total compensation. Although growth in total compensation has been slow relative to the period before 1980, it’s not as slow as you might conclude from his graph. Just as one example you would expect wage income to rise more slowly starting in 2014 and, indeed, the data more recent than Dr. Krugman’s graph suggest that was the case.

1 comment

Today’s Supreme Court Decision

I found the Supreme Court’s decision in three cases before them on employees’ right to sue an employer in a class action suit interesting on a number of grounds. See the analysis of the opinion at SCOTUSBlog here.

I’m uncomfortable with putting a thumb on the scales of justice in favor of large corporations as the decision would appear to do but that isn’t the only thing I found interesting in the decision. The decision highlight a schism within the court which IMO goes far beyond conservatives and liberals, strict and loose constructionists, or Democrats and Republicans but to the very nature of the U. S. courts and U. S. law. Congress has the power to restore the status quo ante; this decision wasn’t one of constitutional law.

The dissenting justices led by Ruth Bader Ginsburg rather clearly take the position that their role is to find the right policy and then figure out a way to make the law support it. It seems to me that’s a formula for long-lasting social problems. The concurring justices, however they’re castigated, equally clearly defined their position as following the law wherever it took them.

I’m not just worried about corporations having too much power. I’m also concerned about unanswerable judges having too much power. Our system by design grants much power to the Congress and gives the people power over Congress through the short terms granted to members of the House. For a variety of reasons our system is not functioning as designed. Rather than having the courts arrogate the power of the Congress to themselves, we should figure out why our system is not functioning as designed and correct that.

I wish someone better informed than I would comment on this. I’ll hunt around to see if I can find some good commentary on just this topic.

2 comments

Switzerland’s Greatest Contribution to Britain

At the Institute of Economic Affairs Kristian Niemietz asks “What Have the Swiss Ever Done for Us?”, the “us”, apparently, being Britons. The article serves as a good primer on Swiss civic organization. If you’re at all interested in Switzerland, by all means read it.

It omits some very, very important factors. Switzerland is a consensus-oriented society. Nearly every law of any significance is subject to a national referendum. And that consensus rejects involvement in the affairs of other countries. It has very few treaties. It does not participate in the euro. It is not a member of the European Union. It is not a member of NATO. It only recently and reluctantly became a member of the United Nations (2002). It is more prosperous than the United Kingdom or even the United States. It is more egalitarian than the United Kingdom and much more so than the U. S.

So, in answer to the question asked in the title of the article, the Swiss have done something of critical importance to Britons. It has left them alone.

0 comments