I think you might find anaesthesiologist Ronald Dworkin’s essay at The American Interest thought-provoking. It begins by making an argument against the public health establishment’s opposition to vaping:
Companies like JUUL Labs have created an e-cigarette substitute for smokers to “vape.†Although the substitute contains nicotine, it lacks the carcinogens and carbon monoxide found in “real†cigarette smoke. Despite improvement over traditional cigarettes, many public health experts oppose vaping, thinking it represents more of a gateway to cigarettes than a liberation from them. Nor does the FDA allow e-cigarette makers to advertise their products as being safer than traditional cigarettes. This has caused the public to mistakenly view both products as equally bad.
E-cigarettes are like the nicotine patches in my patient story: While it is best for people to abstain from all cigarettes, better that they use a less dangerous form. The public health activists are like the surgical team that denied the man his patches: In their quest to bring perfect health, they sometimes end up causing worse health. The average American is like my patient: resentful toward those who tell him or her how to live.
and then turns to how public health, despite its scientific foundations, is inevitably ideological:
Individuals, like all real things, have resistance; they do not reliably conform to abstract principles or universal categories. Every nurse, social worker, psychologist, and doctor knows this limits science’s applicability. Because public health experts deal with whole populations, they are less likely to see how abstract scientific principles can fail. A public health expert might say, “We must fight cigarette addiction to improve health.†The phrase can be taken for truth because it evokes no precise image, and because the expert who utters it does so in good faith. But the policies the phrase inspires do not necessarily end cigarette addiction. Why? Because there is a divergence between words and things, between the scientific principle and the reality of individual human behavior. A simple phrase does not represent with sufficient exactitude the complexity of addictive behavior expressed by any one person—as most social workers, psychologists, nurses, and doctors can attest.
These two historical tendencies in public health combine to make the field both arrogant and ideological, relatively speaking.
Arrogant because public health experts do not watch their science fail on a daily basis. Because they work with large populations rather than with individual cases, public health experts often think with words—for example, the American Public Health Association’s (APHA) goals to “reduce global childhood mortality†and “support global food security.†Goals like these are easy for the thinker with words; the delay between error and the serious consequences of error—a very short timespan for an anesthesiologist—is too long for the public health expert to learn humility or even responsibility. After articulating a principle, the public health expert sees nothing go right or wrong for years, if ever, and so the value of the words can only be judged by their good intentions. When the entire planet becomes a platform for action, and the desired goals verge on being utopian, the issues themselves start to lack physicality. The public health expert is thus tempted to believe that everything has been done when only words have been spoken.
Read the whole thing.
There are aspects of the story which Dr. Dworkin touches on but does not explore. One is the will to power. Nietzsche thought it was the main driving force in human beings. It would be incredible if it were completely absent among public health activists.
The other aspect is that constraints on government spending also place constraints on this will to power. Remove those constraints and there is a real danger of loosening the constraints on that urge to power as well. If there were no constraints on government spending it would be necessary to invent them.







