Vaping, Ideology, and the Will to Power

I think you might find anaesthesiologist Ronald Dworkin’s essay at The American Interest thought-provoking. It begins by making an argument against the public health establishment’s opposition to vaping:

Companies like JUUL Labs have created an e-cigarette substitute for smokers to “vape.” Although the substitute contains nicotine, it lacks the carcinogens and carbon monoxide found in “real” cigarette smoke. Despite improvement over traditional cigarettes, many public health experts oppose vaping, thinking it represents more of a gateway to cigarettes than a liberation from them. Nor does the FDA allow e-cigarette makers to advertise their products as being safer than traditional cigarettes. This has caused the public to mistakenly view both products as equally bad.

E-cigarettes are like the nicotine patches in my patient story: While it is best for people to abstain from all cigarettes, better that they use a less dangerous form. The public health activists are like the surgical team that denied the man his patches: In their quest to bring perfect health, they sometimes end up causing worse health. The average American is like my patient: resentful toward those who tell him or her how to live.

and then turns to how public health, despite its scientific foundations, is inevitably ideological:

Individuals, like all real things, have resistance; they do not reliably conform to abstract principles or universal categories. Every nurse, social worker, psychologist, and doctor knows this limits science’s applicability. Because public health experts deal with whole populations, they are less likely to see how abstract scientific principles can fail. A public health expert might say, “We must fight cigarette addiction to improve health.” The phrase can be taken for truth because it evokes no precise image, and because the expert who utters it does so in good faith. But the policies the phrase inspires do not necessarily end cigarette addiction. Why? Because there is a divergence between words and things, between the scientific principle and the reality of individual human behavior. A simple phrase does not represent with sufficient exactitude the complexity of addictive behavior expressed by any one person—as most social workers, psychologists, nurses, and doctors can attest.

These two historical tendencies in public health combine to make the field both arrogant and ideological, relatively speaking.

Arrogant because public health experts do not watch their science fail on a daily basis. Because they work with large populations rather than with individual cases, public health experts often think with words—for example, the American Public Health Association’s (APHA) goals to “reduce global childhood mortality” and “support global food security.” Goals like these are easy for the thinker with words; the delay between error and the serious consequences of error—a very short timespan for an anesthesiologist—is too long for the public health expert to learn humility or even responsibility. After articulating a principle, the public health expert sees nothing go right or wrong for years, if ever, and so the value of the words can only be judged by their good intentions. When the entire planet becomes a platform for action, and the desired goals verge on being utopian, the issues themselves start to lack physicality. The public health expert is thus tempted to believe that everything has been done when only words have been spoken.

Read the whole thing.

There are aspects of the story which Dr. Dworkin touches on but does not explore. One is the will to power. Nietzsche thought it was the main driving force in human beings. It would be incredible if it were completely absent among public health activists.

The other aspect is that constraints on government spending also place constraints on this will to power. Remove those constraints and there is a real danger of loosening the constraints on that urge to power as well. If there were no constraints on government spending it would be necessary to invent them.

4 comments

Economics B+, Civics D-

In her op-ed at Bloomberg economist Stephanie Kelton lost me at this paragraph:

Option B is your standard Robin Hood redistribution. Money is taxed away from those at the top, and money is invested in programs to lift everyone else (shown in blue). Again, the distance (or degree of disparity) between the top and the bottom is the same as under Option A, but this time the top lost and the bottom gained.

Name one federal program that does that. Overwhelmingly, federal government programs do one of two things

  1. They notionally at least help everyone. That’s the case with military spending, Department of Agriculture food inspections, the judiciary, and so on.
  2. People who already have income in the top 10% of income earners are paid to do things on behalf of “the bottom”. Whether the things they’re paid to do actually “lift” anyone is hard to say. At the very least it’s disputed.

If you’re going to just extend credit indefinitely, why not actually “lift” those at “the bottom” with direct cash grants? If you argue to do anything else, you’ve stopped being an economist and started being a politician. Or a commissar.

1 comment

Mayoral Update

Chicago Tribune columnist John Kass takes on the Chicago mayoral election in his latest column:

Boss Madigan is a careful, disciplined and cautious man. Yet now he’s on federal tape, and he’s heating up at just the right, or wrong, time in the mayor’s race.

And just the idea of Madigan on federal tape sent shock waves of fear through the state’s political establishment.

Madigan can thank Ald. Danny “Happy Ending” Solis, who was wired up by the FBI on Madigan’s friend Ald. Edward Burke, another prince of the property tax reduction business in Chicago.

The FBI videotaped Madigan pitching for tax appeals legal business in a Chinatown hotel deal, and it all went public in the Sun-Times.

Now the four “establishment” candidates in the mayoral race — I prefer to call them the Madigan-Burke Gang of Four because that is what they are — are trying to distance themselves from Madigan-Burke. They’re sending out their wizards to shake rattles so voters might not connect the dots.

The Madigan-Burke Four are Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle, Illinois Comptroller Susana Mendoza, lawyer Gery Chico and Bill Daley, son and brother of Chicago mayors.

Last night a pollster called me to get my opinion on the upcoming mayoral election. One of the questions was “If you had a choice among…for mayor, for whom would you vote?” I answered “None of the above” to the delighted laughter of the pollster and my wife.

There are presently 14 candidates running for mayor. I won’t vote for any of the “establishment” candidates. That leaves me with Jerry Joyce, the son of a former alderman, Garry McCarthy, formerly chief of the Chicago Police Department, Paul Vallas, formerly head of the Chicago Public Schools, and Willie Wilson, a businessman. I’m suspicious of Garry McCarthy and I have issues with all of the candidates’ stated positions. It’s not a happy time. I think that we need a candidate with a pre-built constituency who’s nonetheless willing to upset the status quo and I don’t think that characterizes any of the candidates.

0 comments

Explainer

I want to commend Cullen Roche’s post on the good, the bad, and the ugly of modern monetary theory to your attention. You will be hearing a lot more about MMT in the coming year or so, since it’s being espoused by people who want to spend a lot more than they can within present constraints, and you may find it informative. I suspect that most of them will ignore this key passage from his post:

Importantly, MMT does not say deficits don’t matter or that the government has NO constraint. While the government has no nominal budget constraint it does have a real budget constraint (ie, inflation).

and, importantly, real productive capacity. Our present problem is that we’re already issuing ourselves credit faster than inflation and faster than we’re increasing what we’re producing. Therefore, if you want to consume more you should want us to produce more. There are fundamentally two ways that more can be made available to consume:

  1. We can import less.
  2. We can produce more.

In theory we could also export more but other countries want to consume more, too, and are in a position to block that strategy.

In my view if we elect to do none of those things and instead issue ourselves credit so we can buy whatever we want, untethered to the underlying economy, it’s risky.

A few more things to keep in mind: very few Keynesians actually believe in what Keynes taught, very few free marketeers actually believe in free markets, and very few of those who claim to support MMT actually do. There will never, however, be a lack of people longing for perpetual motion.

Also I remember very clearly Paul Krugman’s curt assessment of MMT (“it’s just wrong”). As those espousing what could best be thought of us “folk MMT” gain more influence in the Democratic Party, I expect that to disappear into the memory hole.

Update

There’s another good explainer on MMT at The Macro Tourist.

6 comments

Waiting for Comment

So far I have searched in vain for informed, unbiased comment on the prudence of the United States’s suspension of the Intermediate Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, annnounced by Sec. of States Pompeo and remarked on by me yesterday. I will continue to look.

The best argument I have seen to date for remaining in the treaty has been that remaining in the treaty provides the United States with a legal basis for sanctions. That is untrue. No such sanctions are authorized in the treaty. It provides no legal basis. It might be argued that it provides a moral basis but I don’t think it does that any more than anything else offensive we might deem Russia to have done.

The full text of the treaty is here. I’m not an expert but my reading of the plain language of the treaty suggests to me that the Russians are not in compliance for reasons many others have mentioned. However, it also suggests that the Russians are right as well: our use of armed drones, something we have done for well over a decade, is a violation of the treaty as well.

It is a rule of thumb in negotiation theory that when the parties to a treaty are unequal in strength and the weaker of the two parties is in violation, the treaty should be reconsidered.

International treaties are means not ends. I believe that we should conform faithfully to the terms of treaties to which we are party. That’s why I believe that we should enter into treaties much more deliberately and sparingly than we do.

I am not yet persuaded that the Trump Administration has acted prudently in suspending the INF. I will continue to consider the matter. The question I would ask of readers is, when both parties disregard a treaty, what good is it? To whatever extent is a signal of intentions it has become a signal of the wrong intentions.

5 comments

U. S. Suspends Participation in the Intermediate Range Nuclear Forces Treaty

This afternoon Secretary of State Mike Pompeo announced that the United States was suspending its participation in the Intermediate Range Nuclear Forces Treaty (INF). CNN reports:

Washington (CNN)Secretary of State Mike Pompeo announced Friday that the US is suspending the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, a key pact with Russia that has been a centerpiece of European security since the Cold War.

“For years, Russia has violated the terms of the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty without remorse,” Pompeo said, speaking from the State Department. “Russia’s violations put millions of Europeans and Americans at greater risk.”
“It is our duty to respond appropriately,” Pompeo said, adding that the US had provided “ample time” for Russia to return to compliance.
The long-expected suspension, which has raised concerns about a renewed arms race with Moscow and put European allies on edge, goes into effect on Saturday. Pompeo’s announcement starts a 180-day clock to complete withdrawal unless Russia returns to compliance with the 1987 agreement.
President Donald Trump and his senior officials had been signaling for months that they were ready to pull out of the INF treaty, which the US accuses Moscow of violating since 2014.

Background

According to this report prepared by the Congressional Research Service, the Obama Administration complained of Russian violations of the INF in 2013, officially in 2014. In September 2014 then-Secretary of State John Kerry met with Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov. The Russians responded with claims of their own, one of which was that American use of drones violated the INF. The U. S. position on this is that, since drones are piloted albeit remotely, they are not covered under the INF. The talks ended with assuaging U. S. concerns.

The U. S. has reiterated its concerns ever since in its annual compliance report.

The Trump Administration announced its intention of suspending its participation in the INF unless Russia came back into compliance back in October. The Russians have done nothing to assuage U. S. concerns.

Alternatives

I could create a decision matrix for this but the parameters of the alternatives include Russian compliance, U. S. compliance, and whether to suspend or not for a total of eight different alternatives including the Russians are not in compliance but the Americans are and the Americans suspend participation, the Russians are not in compliance but the Americans are and the Americans do not suspend, neither the Russians nor the Americans are in compliance and the U. S. suspends its participation, neither the Russians nor the Americans are in compliance and the U. S. does not suspend its partipation, and so on.

Conclusions

I have no way of determining whether the Russians are in compliance with INF or not or whether we are in compliance with the treaty or not. I will take it on faith that the Russians are not in compliance but we are. Making those assumptions is remaining in a treaty the Russians are violating better than suspending our participation in a treaty the Russians are violating?

I will reserve judgment in the hope of reading the views of an unbiased commentator. I despair of finding one.

4 comments

Did Columbus Cause the Little Ice Age?

I’m going to admit to a healthy skepticism about this conclusion from scholars at University College London reported by the BBC:

Colonisation of the Americas at the end of the 15th Century killed so many people, it disturbed Earth’s climate.

That’s the conclusion of scientists from University College London, UK.

The team says the disruption that followed European settlement led to a huge swathe of abandoned agricultural land being reclaimed by fast-growing trees and other vegetation.

This pulled down enough carbon dioxide (COâ‚‚) from the atmosphere to eventually chill the planet.

It’s a cooling period often referred to in the history books as the “Little Ice Age” – a time when winters in Europe would see the Thames in London regularly freeze over.

“The Great Dying of the Indigenous Peoples of the Americas led to the abandonment of enough cleared land that the resulting terrestrial carbon uptake had a detectable impact on both atmospheric COâ‚‚ and global surface air temperatures,” Alexander Koch and colleagues write in their paper published in Quaternary Science Reviews.

Let’s assume that their estimates of the pre-Columbian population of the Americas is correct. That’s by no means a given. Estimates have been everywhere from 10 million to 100 million or thereabouts. But let’s assume it anyway. That means that 55 million people died over the course of a century.

That’s just about how many people died from 1930 to 1960 due to the activities of Stalin, Hitler, and Mao. If the consequences of that many deaths had so great an impact on the climate, wouldn’t that throw all of the climate models off?

I would also think that we would find a lot more remains than have been found but that’s another story.

10 comments

Will Investors Accept Amazon’s Slowing Growth?

The second piece I want to remark on is Shira Ovide’s recent Bloomberg piece on developments at Amazon:

Investors haven’t paid a princely sum for Amazon stock all these years to have profits improve but revenue growth slow sharply. Investors waited for plumper profits for years. Now that the company has started to deliver, investors may be disappointed that some of that amazing growth has leeched away.

That Amazon would be able to produce the sort of growth that would justify its outlandish stock price has always been fantastical. Amazon began as an IPO looking around for a business model and prospered as that for longer than anyone can possibly have imagined. Now it has a business model, mostly based on retail services. We’ll see whether that satisfies its investors.

3 comments

Most Americans Don’t Hate the Wealthy

This morning I’m going to comment on two pieces at Bloomberg each of which is summed up handily in a single paragraph. The first is Tyler Cowen’s op-ed in which he expresses his skepticism about the Democratic presidential candidates’ plans to increase marginal tax rates on the wealthiest or impose a wealth tax:

Anyone promoting a wealth tax is in essence saying that there aren’t many ways of improving society within current resource constraints. That is a brand of pessimism which Americans voters have not often rewarded.

Let me summarize my views:

  1. An extremely unequal America in which the top 10% have much more and get better everything than the rest of the people does not comport with my idea of the U. S. I’d like to be living in.
  2. Failing to control immigration will inevitably promote greater inequality. People without educations, marketable skills, or a command of the English language will always be at a grave disadvantage. If you disagree with that assessment, please state what you plan to change to make it otherwise because that’s certainly the case now.
  3. The present emphasis on higher education is a flop. It only applies to a minority of the American people, we aren’t producing enough jobs that require a college education to make it worthwhile, and India produces a lot of people with bachelors and masters degrees, too.
  4. The only economy that will provide decent livings for most Americans is one that engages in more primary production and manufacturing.

It may be that the candidates are sincere in their views. I doubt it but it’s possible. I think it’s far more likely that the higher income taxes and wealth taxes they’re promising will die with the campaign or that they won’t accomplish the objectives they claim for them. But I’m willing to give them a chance. That’s why I say they should lay out their plans in detail. I think that these promises will follow the PPACA model: an enormous, complicated piece of legislation with lots of loopholes for specific groups whose shortcomings will be blamed on the compromises they needed to get Republican support that never materialized.

9 comments

How to Reduce Carbon Emissions

As I have tried, probably unsuccessfully, to explain from time to time I do believe that human action plays a role in global climate change and I think it’s possible even likely that greenhouses gases are implicated. I am, however, highly skeptical that the plans that have been put forward to deal with the situation will actually accomplish what their proponents think they will, largely due to assumptions of linearity which just won’t pan out.

However, for those of you who are interested I’d like to show you a couple of graphs that you may find eye-opening or at least interesting. The first illustrates U. S. manufacturing jobs:

and the second illustrates carbon emissions:

Look at the year 2001. That was the year that China was admitted to the World Trade Organization. If you have any doubts about the impact of that event not only on U. S. manufacturing but on carbon emissions, that should allay them.

Also, look at how little U. S. emissions changed.

I’m not going to go through the complicated analysis and number-crunching that would be required to prove it but to my eye it’s obvious that if we really wanted to reduce global carbon emissions we should be repatriating manufacturing jobs from China to the U. S. That would reduce carbon emissions more and faster than any foreseeable carbon tax or adoption of wind and solar power.

13 comments