Read the Chart

I recommend looking at the charts that David Leonhardt presents in his latest New York Times column. I found them interesting and revealing. Take this one, for example, which illustrates the changes in the number of people with health care insurance since 2008:

about which he writes:

Since taking office, Trump has tried to undermined the Affordable Care Act, causing a rise in the number of Americans who do not have insurance.

I think he places a lot more stock in intentions than I do. A stronger message might be that quite a few people won’t purchase health care insurance unless compelled to do so. Or that a relentless advertising campaign (one of the things funded by the Affordable Care Act and which ended in June 2015) has an effect.

At any rate read the whole thing. I don’t think the charts are quite as damning of Trump as he seems to and a lot harder on Obama.

9 comments

Shoot the Messenger

My old business partner came up with a number of notable witticisms, one of which I think of as the “reverse Voltaire”: “I may agree with what you say but I deny to the death your right to say it”. That was largely the reaction of the editors of the New York Times to President Trump’s 2019 State of the Union message:

Mr. Trump’s soothing message, in short, was wholly at odds with the acrid reality of how he has governed. In that way, the entire spectacle — reflected in the vibrating hostility between the two sides trapped together in the House chamber — evinced the true state of the union: fractured, fractious, painfully dysfunctional.

The State of the Union address is one of those moments that allows Mr. Trump to play the role of president, with pomp, standing ovations and, sweeter still, a captive audience of his opponents. Even Mr. Trump grasps that, for this one night, he is called upon to rise above partisanship and address the entire nation rather than merely his rump political base.

Beyond the general theme, he nonetheless failed this challenge.

The president, facing several investigations and a Democratic House determined to hold him to account, called for an end to “ridiculous partisan investigations.”

“If there is going to be peace and legislation,” the president said, “there cannot be war and investigation. It just doesn’t work that way!”

[…]

If Mr. Trump’s words ring hollow, his actions still matter enormously. Given how bitterly divided the government is, how wounded and uneasy the nation is, it’s impossible not to cling to a hope that he might yet rise to the office and do something for his fellow Americans. But, rather than wait for that to happen, the wisest course for citizens interested in a stronger union is to focus on building it themselves.

Shorter: never Trump.

7 comments

What Goes Unmentioned

In his latest New York Times column Tom Friedman lurches uncontrollably into a good observation:

During the late 19th and the 20th centuries the world shifted from being governed by large empires in many regions to being governed by independent nation-states. And the 50 years after World II were a great time to be a weak little nation-state — for several reasons.

First, because there were two superpowers competing for your affection by throwing foreign aid at you, building your army, buying your cheap goods and educating your kids at their universities. Second, climate change was moderate. Third, populations were still under control in the developing world. Fourth, no one had a cellphone to easily organize movements against your government or even see what Paris or Phoenix looked like. Fifth, China was not in the World Trade Organization, so every poor country could be in textiles and other low-wage industries.

All of those advantages disappeared in the early 21st century. Climate-driven extreme weather — floods, droughts, record-setting heat and cold — on top of man-made deforestation began to hammer many countries, especially their small-scale farmers. Developing-world populations exploded thanks to improved health care. Africa went from 140 million people in 1900 to one billion in 2010 to a projected 2.5 billion by 2050. The same surge happened in Central America, in countries like Guatemala.

Meanwhile, the smartphone enabled citizens to easily compare their living standards with Paris or Phoenix — and find a human trafficker app to take them there. Also, China joined the W.T.O., gobbling up low-wage industries, and the end of the Cold War meant no superpower wanted to touch your country, because all it would win was a bill.

The result: It’s much harder to be a weak country today, and the weakest of them are starting to fail or fracture and hemorrhage their people. That’s Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador and Venezuela in our hemisphere and Sudan, Syria, Afghanistan, Libya and many countries in sub-Saharan Africa across the Atlantic.

This is creating wide zones of “disorder” — and the biggest geopolitical trend in the world is all the people trying to get out of zones of disorder into the world of order. And that is what’s creating all the populist, nationalist, anti-immigrant backlashes in the world of order — particularly in America and Europe.

That is the real context for this immigration crisis. What’s the answer? Well, if you look at what slowed the flood of single Mexican men illegally and legally coming to America in the last decade, it was the combination of greater economic opportunity in Mexico, thanks in part to Nafta, plus slower population growth in Mexico, plus improved governance in Mexico, plus better border security along the Mexico-U.S. border.

That same formula has to be applied now to Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador.

demonstrating that even a stopped clock is right twice a day. There are some critical factors he leaves unmentioned in his analysis. The first is that there are poor people in the United States, too. As many as 20 million Americans live in “extreme poverty”—half of the poverty income. That’s about $6,000 for an individual and $24,000 for a family of four. 20 million is a number equivalent to the entire population of Guatemala, the largest Central American country.

It is not the 19th century or even the early 20th century. Our economy does not create entry level jobs the way it used to. Each person who comes into the United States seeking an entry level job either displaces another entry level employee or reduces the wages of all entry level workers, making things that much worse. I believe that our corporate responsibility to the people who are already here is greater than to the people of Guatemala, El Salvador, Costa Rica, Honduras, or Nicaragua.

The second thing is that of his answer the only thing we can actually control is border security. We can’t negotiate a NAFTA-equivalent with Guatemala, El Salvador, etc. solely on our own. Nor can we slow their population growth nor improve their governance.

That’s one of the ways in which I arrive at my conclusion: we have a moral responsibility to control migration into the United States. That will require a number of measures including physical barriers at the U. S.-Mexican border. As I have said before I would also increase the number of H2-B visas we issue, enforce our employment policies with a greatly enhanced eVerify program, and have an information program targeted at the countries of Central America with the message that they cannot improve their lives by entering the United States illegally.

3 comments

State of the Union 2019

Somewhat against my better judgment I watched the State of the Union message last night. It was President Trump at his best such as it was—he stayed largely on-script. It was overly long and in my view pointless, emphasizing more than anything else that these exercises should be dispensed with.

For their part I did not think the Democrats’ performance had the effect they were seeking. All of the female Democratic senators and representatives wore white, a poor choice. White shows every crease, fold, and wrinkle. It looks becoming on very few. As some non-Democratic commenters in the peanut gallery pointed out, it was reminiscent of a Klan rally, presumably not the effect they were seeking, especially under the circumstances.

The Democrats remained disciplined, largely following Speaker Pelosi’s lead in their reactions. When she applauded, they applauded. When she stood, they stood. Again, I do not think that evoked the reaction they were seeking. I thought they looked petulant and oppositional. For example they did not applaud when President Trump took note of record low black, Hispanic, and Asian unemployment. They rather clearly think they can be strictly oppositional and still take care of the people’s business. I’m not so sure.

I don’t care for the practice opposing party responses to begin with and I thought that Stacey Abrams was an odd choice of someone to deliver it. The unavoidable conclusion was that Democrats are promoting the line that they’ll win elections if Republicans just don’t rig them, darn it.

Bottom line: it was a wasted two hours for me.

2 comments

Story About the Banjo

I have an amusing story about the banjo I thought I’d share with you. One afternoon about 50 years ago I was in one of the concourses at O’Hare and saw a man and women in their thirties sitting waiting for a plane, completely surrounded by instrument cases. They must have had eight between them.

I walked up to the man and asked “Are you Mike Seeger?” (Mike Seeger was Pete’s younger brother.) He looked at me, startled. “Yes. No one ever recognizes me. How did you?” I responded “I play the banjo”. “That would explain it” he replied.

We had a pleasant, brief conversation about playing the banjo.

1 comment

Instincts

At The Nation Aaron Coleman is skeptical that black voters will rally ’round Kamala Harris as they did for Barack Obama:

In spite of his cultural competency, Obama’s tenure oversaw an economic recovery that left many black families behind, and a proliferation of highly visible police brutality. Today, after both a long honeymoon and hangover with a charismatic black candidate, the code-switching playbook may be played out.

When Kamala Harris held her first presidential press conference at the her alma mater, Howard University, she hugged black students sporting black-and-gold Alpha Phi Alpha fraternity jackets and pink-and-green Alpha Kappa Alpha sweatshirts. She posed for pictures with beaming black women in their box braids and Afro-puffs. She shook hands with little curly-haired kids in Bison hoodies. Standing behind a placard modeled after Shirley Chisholm’s presidential design and in front of a plaque bearing Howard’s logo, Kamala conjured the imagery and legacy of the historically black University—a lineage that includes Toni Morrison, Thurgood Marshall, Zora Neale Hurston, Donny Hathaway, and more.

Yet all the pageantry doesn’t seem to be enough to distract from her policy record.

I think that black voters expected President Obama to “bring home the bacon” and when he did not do that they were disappointed. I suspect they will not be as easily misled by another black presidential candidate.

I have a larger question. Which are the most atypical states in the Union? As should surprise no one, Hawaii is the least typical, followed by Alaska. California is the third least typical state.

Within California Northern California is very different from Southern or Central California and within the San Francisco area Oakland is extremely atypical—demographically it’s a lot like Chicago.

About 30% of present day Americans are either immigrants or their children. In other words that’s atypical, too.

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with having a background or experience different from those of most Americans. Indeed, I like it. But I do think that it affects your understanding of Americans. Your instincts are understandably skewed.

I think it’s about time that we had a president whose life experience was more like that of most Americans than our last several and by that I don’t mean white. I mean not plutocrats, not aristocrats, and with more typical life experiences. I would vote for Cory Booker before I’d vote for Kamala Harris. IMO he’s more likely to understand typical Americans than Kamala Harris is.

5 comments

A Brief History of Professional Blackface

Over at Outside the Beltway Stephen Taylor remarks on the pernicious history, particularly in the American South, of amateur blackface. I have no knowledge of that but I did want to make some observations about professional blackface.

When it comes to observations about professional blackface, I’m probably your man. My mother’s family was in vaudeville. My maternal grandmother’s uncle, a headliner in vaudeville (a “headliner” was someone whose name appeared at the top of the marquee), performed in blackface. I’ve posted pictures of him in blackface here. My grandfather was a member of Primrose & Dockstader’s Minstrel Men, the most prominent minstrel troupe of the turn of the 19th century. My grandfather claimed, proudly, that he had never done blackface. It’s possible since not all of the members of the company appeared in blackface but I have my doubts and my grandfather was known for, well, stretching the truth.

A good place to start in commenting on professional blackface performance in the United States is with Frederick Douglass’s comment in 1848. He characterized blackface performers as “the filthy scum of white society, who have stolen from us a complexion denied to them by nature, in which to make money, and pander to the corrupt taste of their white fellow-citizens”. I have no doubt that he was right. Note the date of his comment. The Irish were very heavily involved in professional blackface entertainment. They were Catholics. They spoke English but had few saleable skills other than the ability to clown around and entertain people. The white Anglo-Saxon Protestants, the real establishment, thought of them as not much more than animals, the better to justify the harsh treatment of the Irish by the English. Daniel Decatur Emmett, the most famous composer of minstrel songs and blackface performer of the 19th century, was of Irish descent. The phrase “Jim Crow” derives from blackface minstrelsy.

It wasn’t merely the Irish or whites who performed in blackface. Blacks did, too, lampooning, caricaturing, and maligning Southern black manners. Bert Williams, the only black to appear in the Ziegfeld Follies, performed in blackface. There is no record of what Mr. Douglass thought of them.

I can guess what the performers, white or black, thought of it. There were eking out a living under very trying circumstances with few other alternatives other than being mistreated as farm laborers. WASP employers wouldn’t hire them.

In the early 20th century blackface performance remained popular and many of our prominent composers of popular song composed minstrel-style numbers including Irving Berlin, George Gershwin, Schwartz & Dietz, and Harold Rome. By the 1930s it was becoming déclassé (hence my grandfather’s claim) although Judy Garland had a big hit with “Franklin D. Roosevelt Jones”, performed in blackface for the movie Babes on Broadway in 1941. The song had been introduced by Rex Ingram in 1938 and was covered by Cab Calloway and Ella Fitzgerald.

The list of prominent white actors who appeared in blackface in film is long including Bing Crosby, Bob Hope, Fred Astaire, Shirley Temple, Doris Day, and many, many others. Laurence Olivier’s Othello (1965) was done in blackface but by then it elicited critical comment as did his very broad performance.

My view of professional blackface performance is that it should not be excused but understood in context. It is more complex than a simple narrative of whites mocking and abusing blacks although that is surely a component. It should not be excised from our history. To do that would be to bowdlerize that history and remove an enormous and important part of our entertainment legacy.

8 comments

One Paragraph

There is one paragraph in Holman Jenkins’s Wall Street Journal column in defense of Howard Schultz of which I think note should be be taken:

This is the part that never will be explained in a campaign speech or op-ed. Scandinavian citizens exhibit an off-the-charts willingness to pay the necessary taxes because they have an off-the-charts confidence in government to deliver services in an honest, equitable and efficient fashion.

The reason that the Swedes and the Norse have more trust in their governments is that their governments are more trustworthy than ours. I do not entirely know why that is but I know that it is true. I do not know if it is due to our greater individualism, their greater (until recently) homogeneity, our lack of social cohesion, our two party system, just plain perversity or all of the above but American politicians using their offices to become rich is commonplace and crosses party lines and ideologies. Bill Clinton never earned a salary greater than $30,000 in his life before he became president. Now he’s a multi-millionaire. Rahm Emanuel pushed his way into investment banking without training or experience using the Rolodex he’d acquired via his political activities as a lever and was paid millions. Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan has been cross-ruffing his law practice with his power over property taxes in Springfield, an obviously corrupt arrangement, more than 30 years. These are not exceptions. They are the rule.

It will take more than a government program to change that. It will take a sea change in American government and if you want to see why that will not happen just look at the present Congressional leadership.

12 comments

The NYT’s About-Face

The editors of the New York Times, reversing their previous position, say that it’s time to withdraw our troops from Afghanistan:

This page has been supportive of the war in Afghanistan since it began. We criticized NATO countries in Europe for not sending enough soldiers. And we were critical of the Bush administration for its lack of postwar planning and for diverting resources to the war in Iraq.

Events have shown us to have been overly optimistic regarding the elected Afghan government, though we were rightly critical of its deep dysfunction. We have raised concerns about military tactics that cost civilians their lives and been skeptical of the Pentagon’s relentlessly rosy assessments of the progress made and the likelihood of success.

[…]

It is time to face the cruel truth that at best, the war is deadlocked, and at worst, it is hopeless. The initial American objective — bringing Bin Laden to justice — has been achieved. And subsequent objectives, to build an Afghan government that can stand on its own, protect the population and fight off its enemies, may not be achievable, and certainly aren’t achievable without resources the United States is unwilling to invest.

Walking away from a war is not a strategy. But an orderly withdrawal of NATO forces can be organized and executed before the year is out and more lives are lost to a lost cause. Two Americans have been killed in combat already in 2019. No American soldiers should be fighting and dying in Afghanistan in 2020.

President Trump should seize the opportunity. If he does not, we may be stuck in a futile stalemate for years, decades, spending money and wasting American lives.

There is nothing the editors point out other than Bin Laden’s assassination that was not true in 2009 or in 2005 and every sign tells us that they will be true in 2020 and 2024 as well. What assurance do we have that, if a Democrat is elected in 2020, the NYT will not reconsider its editorial position again and decide that the stalemate in Afghanistan was a consequence of feckless Republican bungling of the war in Afghanistan rather than the intrinsic character of the conflict itself? Time to withdraw or, at the very least, change from the present counter-insurgency strategy to a strategy of counter-terrorism.

1 comment

How Do We Get a Responsible Government?

My reactions to the three policy proposals in Adam Garfinkle’s article at The American Interest vary from indignant disagreement to grudging agreement. His first proposal is about health care reform:

To take just one example, healthcare insurance premiums could be made affordable again for the vast majority of Americans if the three categories of the most expensive generic cases were carved away from the main insurance pool: the very ill elderly; trauma cases; and treatment for chronic and progressive diseases like diabetes. These cases could be handled by a secondary insurance market, just as secondary insurance markets operate in many niches of a modern economy. Even if some combination of state and Federal government were to heavily subsidize insurance premiums for these classes of cases, it would still be simpler and cheaper than the Affordable Care Act.

and exhibits a remarkable lack of understanding of insurance, health care, economics, or human nature. The total amount of insurable risk outside of his exclusions is extremely small—perhaps as little as 5% of health care spending. The ACA was a “Hail Mary” designed to preserve insurance companies and discourage the legislation being tarred as “socialized medicine”, a goal at which it did not succeed. I believe the question the Obama Administration was trying to answer was how do you insure more people, get the legislation through the Congress and past the various interest groups, and have the result be something you can reasonably claim is health care reform? The ACA was an answer to that question about as good as could have been expected. I happen to think it was the wrong question but that’s another issue.

Mr. Garfinkle’s proposal amounts to socializing 95% of spending. That would remove it from the hands of the insurance companies. When you add subsidies for the poor to the mix in the amount left there would be no health care insurance industry. How that results in lower prices eludes me. It would unquestionably be resisted to the last breath by the health care insurance industry and what the reaction of physicians would be is not clear.

His second proposal is for Social Security:

Second, let’s take a look at the Social Security trust fund. We’ve known for many years that our demography is leading to an insolvency train wreck—more healthy retirees and fewer workers to support them. Every expert who follows this problem agrees that at current rates of tax inflow and disbursements we have at most seven years before the entire system implodes. It’s hard to think of a clearer example of the irresponsibility of Congress—or perhaps we should be honest about calling it cowardice—that this can has been kicked so far down the road.

Of course something has been done in recent years to slow the train engines, but what has been done has been both band aid-like and prejudicial, again to people who work with their bodies for a living: The retirement age for both men and women has been kicked out several years. This is class prejudicial because the data clearly show that people who do physical labor for a living have shorter lives than those who do not. So extending the retirement age amounts to a reverse Robin Hood: taking from the poor to give to the rich.

None of this is necessary, because if Congress had any courage it would do the simple and honest thing: Simultaneously remove the cap from taxing income and means-test benefits.

My preference would be to abolish the payroll tax and the trust fund and to pay Social Security benefits from general revenues but I’d settle for his plan. Heck, I’d settle for raising FICA max to the lowest wage earned by the top 1% of income earners (presently about $389K), indexed. At that we could probably afford to lower both the employer and employee sides of FICA in a revenue neutral way, a consummation devoutly to be wished.

I think his final proposal, putting the budget on auto-pilot, is insanity:

The Westminster method is a bridge too far for us, but legislating an automatic continuing resolution isn’t. So why doesn’t any Senator or Congressman even suggest it? You tell me.

That illustrates my fundamental disagreement with Mr. Garfinkle. Representative government shouldn’t be easy. It should be hard. I’d like to make it even harder by mandating single-issue requirements for all laws. That would eliminate government shutdowns, too.

His proposal would do the opposite of making government more responsible. It would result in removing all responsibility from the Congress.

15 comments