His Valedictory

I want to commend John Dingell’s valedictory message to the American people, quoted at the Washingont Post, to your attention. Here’s a snippet:

My personal and political character was formed in a different era that was kinder, if not necessarily gentler. We observed modicums of respect even as we fought, often bitterly and savagely, over issues that were literally life and death to a degree that — fortunately – we see much less of today.

Think about it:

Impoverishment of the elderly because of medical expenses was a common and often accepted occurrence. Opponents of the Medicare program that saved the elderly from that cruel fate called it “socialized medicine.” Remember that slander if there’s a sustained revival of silly red-baiting today.

Not five decades ago, much of the largest group of freshwater lakes on Earth — our own Great Lakes — were closed to swimming and fishing and other recreational pursuits because of chemical and bacteriological contamination from untreated industrial and wastewater disposal. Today the Great Lakes are so hospitable to marine life that one of our biggest challenges is controlling the invasive species that have made them their new home.

Read the whole thing.

I have my issues with Mr. Dingell and more broadly with dynasties but his farewell message should be read and reflected on.

0 comments

Nurture Your Vice

This seems like an opportunity to remind people of some very good advice from Thornton Wilder’s play The Matchmaker:

There are some people who say you shouldn’t have any weakeness at all – no vices. But if a man has no vices, he’s in great danger of making vices out of virtues, and there’s a spectacle. We’ve all seen them; men who were monsters of philanthropy and women who were dragons of purity. We’ve seen people who told the truth, through the Heavens fall, and the Heavens fell. No, no nurse one vice in your bosom. Give it the attention it deserves and let your virtues spring up modestly around. Then you’ll have the miser who’s no liar; and the drunkard who’s the benefactor of a whole city.

That’s very Apollonian in its way and something sorely needed nowadays.

1 comment

Afghanistan Is Not Germany

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are outraged at the notion that we might actually remove our troops from Afghanistan:

History shows the great danger in failing to distinguish between fighting wars and deterring them. That’s especially true now that the authoritarian nations of Russia, Iran and China are seeking to dominate their regions and sometimes join forces against U.S. interests.

One lesson is that keeping troops abroad is often cheaper than bringing them home. An unwavering commitment to the defense of Western Europe under NATO prevented the Cold War from becoming a hot one. Some 300,000 U.S. troops across Europe deterred Moscow for decades until the Warsaw Pact imploded.

They can’t seem to get their heads around the idea that Afghanistan is not Germany. There has never been a cohesive modern state in Afghanistan. We aren’t detering the Russians or Chinese there. We’re trying to pacify the Afghans themselves. A bare handful of American soldiers were killed in Europe after the conclusion of World War II. More of our soldiers have been killed in Afghanistan practically every year since 2001. If we’d experienced the kind of resistance in Germany we’re experiencing in Afghanistan, we’d’ve left there, too.

Afghanistan is a country of zero strategic interest to the United States as long as they’re not hosting Al Qaeda bases. We can’t even supply a base in Afghanistan without paying off the Pakistanis. There are cheaper ways to prevent Afghanistan from hosting Al Qaeda bases than propping up a state there, the purpose of counter-insurgency operations.

9 comments

The Reason

The reason that we have more Javerts than Valjeans is that it’s more fun to be a Javert than a Valjean. Maybe temporarily but people should remember that Javert dies in despair while Valjean dies content.

We will all die. More of us should be able to say “I die content” at the end.

0 comments

The China 12 Step

Here’s the conclusion of Robert D. Atkinson’s Washington Post op-ed on the first step to the road to recovery in healing the U. S.’s relationship with China:

Rather than dismiss the threat Chinese innovation mercantilist practices pose to the U.S. economy, jobs and national security, the Washington establishment needs to publicly acknowledge that the threat is serious and that China needs to be confronted — not only to protect the U.S. economy and national security but also to save the very soul of the global trading system. Only then can we engage in a productive critique of the Trump administration’s tactics, including its over-reliance on tariffs and its unwillingness to assemble a global coalition of the willing to pressure China to reform. Denying that China’s actions pose a grave threat and placing the blame on ourselves will only fan the flames of protectionism and cause even greater harm.

I suspect hie recommendation will fall on deaf ears. Too many people are making too much money from things as they are.

0 comments

Explainer

I think that Dana Milbank doesn’t get it. Here’s a snippet from his latest Washington Post column:

Forgive me, but would anybody mind if we declared a moratorium on Democratic apologies?

I don’t doubt many public servants have done things worthy of regret. But it’s becoming difficult to keep up with the sorry spectacle.

Let me explain. Continually changing standards means you always have to say you’re sorry.

1 comment

Responsibility

Megan McArdle is unimpressed by the “Green New Deal” proposal to say the least. From her Washington Post column:

Progressives frequently argue that getting to “as much as possible” requires setting goals that are out of reach. They call it “shifting the Overton window,” or widening the spectrum of plausible policy options, an idea broached in the 1990s by policy analyst Joseph P. Overton. The folk version: Ask for the stars, you’ll get the moon.

Fair enough. Sometimes people and causes do lose out by being too timid. What the progressive window-shoppers forget is that they can also lose out by being over-aggressive.

A pedestrian example: Many people could do better, salary-wise, if they simply negotiated harder with potential employers. But few of them could do better by opening with a pugnacious demand for $1 million a year. Wild demands, unmoored from reality, don’t increase what you ultimately take away from a negotiation; they are much more likely to end the negotiation abruptly when the other party concludes that you’re crazy.

Here’s a little received wisdom from negotiation theory. There is more than one price. There’s the asking price (the price the seller is asking) and there’s the selling price (the price the buy pays). There are any number of others but there’s also something called “the insult price”. Here’s how it works.

Seller: “I’m asking $5,000 for this rug.”

Buyer: “I’ll give $2,000.”

Seller: “How about $3,500.”

Buyer: “How about $2.”

In this case $2 is the insult price. It’s an offer so extreme that it ends negotiation.

I only have two other remarks. The first is that subsidizing those unwilling to work, a recommendation from the GND proposal, is foolishness. I’m with Paul of Tarsus (also favorably quoted by Lenin). “He who does not work neither shall he eat.” I respect the decision not to work. People should be free not to do so. We should also respect their decision enough to allow them to die as a consequence of that decision.

The other remark is that we should be very, very cautious of electing people who’ve never held any responsibilities to higher office. It’s hard for me to trust the judgment of anyone who’s never had responsibility for a child or a parent, or bought a home (with their own money), or paid off a loan, or knows how anything anything works.

9 comments

About That “Green New Deal”

I’m reading a lot both pro and con on the so-called “Green New Deal”. I am reserving judgment.

All I can say at this point is that I can support no plan that

  1. does not include regular empirical measurement based on outputs rather than inputs of its results and
  2. has annual goals based on those measurements and
  3. is not self-repealing if the plan fails to meet its goals in any year during which it is effective
15 comments

Practical Politics

I am so lacking in energy this morning I may not have it in me to do a great deal of posting today but I wanted to say this. I am reading a number of observations on socialism and capitalism, some pro some con. In my view like libertarianism socialism is a fine value with which to inform one’s political opinions but it makes for a lousy governmental organizing principle. Anarcho-capitalists cannot bring themselves to admit that their preferred system may produce intolerable social outcomes. Socialists can’t bring themselves to admit that culture and history are important and are not infinitely malleable.

The track record of state socialism is terrible. That cannot be denied. It is possible for small, wealthy, ethnically and culturally homogeneous countries to create expansive welfare systems for themselves only to pull back from them as they become less ethnically and culturally homogeneous and less wealthy. There is no experience to which to turn to consider such systems in large, wealthy, diverse countries. I think the results will more closely resemble the Soviet Union or China than they do Denmark, a tiny country of six million which, when it adopted its system, was 99% ethnically Danish and culturally Lutheran.

Something for those promoting the virtues of capitalism to consider: crony capitalism which is what we have now is not one whit better than soft socialism. If you’re going to defend capitalism, you need to condemn the aspects of our system which have led to it becoming crony capitalism.

What, then, is the solution? I think it lies in patient, constant stewardship. There is no broad, sweeping simple solution to our problems. As H. L. Mencken pointed out a century ago “there is always a well-known solution to every human problem — neat, plausible, and wrong.”

25 comments

Circling the Political Wagons

I have refrained from commenting on the ongoing political disaster proceeding in Virginia and I plan to continue my forebearance. It’s none of my business. I will, however, point out some good observations by David A. Graham at Atlantic:

Virginia has styled itself as a moderate, even at times progressive Upper South state—far away from the social conservatism of the Deep South—in part thanks to the Democratic tilt of Northern Virginia. Democrats have disavowed the white supremacy of Harry Byrd, once the dominant politician in the state. Yet race has been a central issue in Virginia’s recent elections. The white-supremacist march in Charlottesville in August 2017 is an obvious spark point, but the march also showed the strength of racism still within the state, and helped bring out other elements. Corey Stewart, a Republican who espouses a neo-Confederate platform, unsuccessfully ran for the gubernatorial nomination in 2017, losing to Ed Gillespie but driving Gillespie to defend Confederate monuments. Gillespie lost. Stewart won the U.S. Senate nomination in 2018, and was routed by Senator Tim Kaine.

If those elections showed that Virginia still has a very real race problem, the past week has shown that it is not confined to the Republican Party.

Then he goes off the rails. I attribute that to making sweeping generalizations based on limited and inadequate experience.

I will only add this. You cannot determine an individual’s character solely based on the letter that follows his or her name. That the Virginia Democratic Party did not exercise due diligence is incontrovertible. You determine the level of due diligence required in the same way that you decide whether there’s enough light in the reading room. When there’s enough light to read, it’s enough. When easily discovered but disqualifying facts are being discovered, you haven’t done enough.

6 comments