Improving Wellbeing Is Good

At the Huffington Post Laura Paddison reports on the results of Finland’s experiment with a universal basic income (UBI):

Finland’s universal basic income test, which cost the government about $22.7 million, was designed and administered by the country’s social insurance agency, Kela. The experiment aimed to help the country assess how to respond to the changing nature of work and ― given its 8-percent unemployment rate at the time ― how to get people back into the labor market.

The trial ended in December. While final results won’t be available until 2020, preliminary results were revealed on Friday.

On employment, the country’s income register showed no significant effects for 2017, the first year of the trial.

The real benefits so far have come in terms of health and well being. The 2,000 participants were surveyed, along with a control group of 5,000. Compared with the control group, those taking part had “clearly fewer problems related to health, stress, mood and concentration,” said Minna Ylikännö, senior researcher at Kela. Results also showed people had more trust in their future and their ability to influence it.

“Constant stress and financial stress for the long term – it’s unbearable. And when we give money to people once a month they know what they are going to get,” said Ylikännö. “It was just €560 a month, but it gives you certainty, and certainty about the future is always a fundamental thing about well being.”

I would tentatively support a UBI experiment in the United States under certain conditions on the grounds that improving wellbeing is good. Among the conditions I would require are that it be closely modeled on the Finnish program. It should be a “carve out” program rather than a “pile on” meaning that it should replace other benefits rather than just adding to benefits. Individuals participating should be selected at random from the unemployed meaning that those unwilling to work would be excluded. Performance metrics should be defined in advance including measurements of the cost of administration and the program should be self-cancelling if it fails to achieve its pre-defined goals.

I also think that we should be prepared that the outcome of such a program would be quite different in the U. S. than in Finland. We also should take into account that the monthly stipend would need to be much higher here because of differences between our system and Finland’s. Finland is a tiny ethnically and culturally homogeneous country. The rate of alcohol abuse there is much higher than here but their rate of opiate abuse is enormously lower. I wouldn’t be surprised if a similar program here would end up being exponentially more expensive and result in an increased mortality rate among its beneficiaries.

But it might not. And that would be good to know.

0 comments

More Diet Opinion

In a piece at Bloomberg Faye Flam covers a lot of the same territory I did yesterday:

A team of 37 scientists has designed a diet for the long-term future, and the good news is that it doesn’t require anyone to eat insects or soylent green. There’s nothing dystopian about it, but some nutrition experts are still turning up their noses at the plan, which was designed to minimize environmental degradation while still feeding the 10 billion people expected to inhabit the planet by 2050.

The main complaint: The EAT diet, published in the Lancet last month, is padded with lots of corn and soy, and would ask Americans to make a drastic cut in our average consumption of meat, dairy and eggs. There’s a bitter aftertaste of the 20th-century government-recommended diets high in carbohydrates and low in fat, which are now considered a factor in skyrocketing obesity and Type 2 diabetes.

Critics quickly blasted the Lancet authors’ claims that meat is harmful to our health, or that vegan diets are better for the human body. They point out that scientific studies to date give mixed results, and are based on hard-to-interpret evidence rather than controlled experiments

She takes note of the historical record:

Historically, advances in food quantity went along with degradation of quality. By studying ancient skeletons, archaeologists have found that as grain farming expanded, people deteriorated — their skeletons became shorter, with more signs of disease, and their teeth went from healthy to rotten. Nobility remained tall and healthy — eating more varied diets, including meat. It was the peasants who suffered.

Scientists eventually figured out that it takes more than just adequate calories to feed humans. We evolved to need the right combination of amino acids and particular forms of fat, as well as vitamins and minerals. Science has made great strides in preventing vitamin deficiencies, but we still don’t know what’s optimal — just what’s good enough.

and finally arrives where I began:

It might look arrogant for anyone to claim to have designed a perfect diet. What’s perfect for weight-conscious Americans may not coincide with what’s necessary to ensure proper brain development of every child in Africa. It’s also smart to be looking ahead to our more crowded future — so we can keep eating food and never have to resort to dystopian mystery substances.

There are other issues. A significant amount of the data on which they rely has been derived from Chinese studies which have come into question and, even if true, may be more relevant for Chinese people than for Norwegians. And concurrent with the environmental warnings are other warnings that the population of humans is likely to peak around 2050. China’s population may already have peaked.

A more benign future may be realized by educating women, particularly in Africa and the Middle East. Those are the places where fertility rates are still sky-high and the available evidence suggests that fertility rates decline as women become better-educated. Rather than preparing for a Stand on Zanzibar or Soylent Green future we might want to start thinking about the implications of a stable or even declining human population.

7 comments

‘Splain Me

Can someone explain the Monty Python-esque anti-corn syrup Budweiser ads to me? Doesn’t Anheuser-Busch InBev use rice syrup in Budweiser? That doesn’t belong in beer, either. In Germany that couldn’t even be sold as beer.

6 comments

We Want to Know the Plan

Judging by his tone the CEO of Gallup is pretty apparently shocked at the results of a poll taken by his own organization:

Here’s a good question about caravans: How many more are coming?

Gallup asked the whole population of Latin America. There are 33 countries in Latin America and the Caribbean. Roughly 450 million adults live in the region. Gallup asked them, “Would you like to move to another country permanently if you could?”

A whopping 27% said “yes.”

So this means roughly 120 million would like to migrate somewhere.

The next question Gallup asked was, “Where would you like to move?”

Of those who want to leave their Latin American country permanently, 35% said they want to go to the United States.

The Gallup analytics estimate is that 42 million want to come to the U.S.

Forty-two million seekers of citizenship or asylum are watching to determine exactly when and how is the best time to make the move. This suggests that open borders could potentially attract 42 million Latin Americans. A full 5 million who are planning to move in the next 12 months say they are moving to the U.S.

Rather than find a solution for the several thousand potential migrants currently at the border, let’s start by answering the bigger, harder question — what about the 42 million who would like to come? What is the message to those millions who will seek entrance either legally or illegally? What should we tell them?

Most U.S. citizens like me just want to know the plan. What is the 10-year plan? How many, exactly whom and what skills will they bring? What do we want? Answer these questions, and the current discussion can be resolved.

Keep in mind that it’s not only 330 million Americans who are wondering — so are 42 million seekers from Latin America.

I think it’s a question that demands an answer.

How are New York and Los Angeles going to house those migrants? How will Seattle and San Francisco? How will they be fed and clothed? How will their children be educated?

We are barely producing enough jobs for what used to be quaintly called the “natural increase”. It is fantastical to believe we will produce an additional 5 million jobs beyond that over the next year, two years, or 10 years let alone 42 million.

7 comments

Capitalism, Socialism, and Social Democracy

In his latest piece at Bloomberg legal scholar and Obama Administration appointee and advisor Cass Sunstein leaps to the defense of capitalism, cautioning Democrats of the hazards of embracing socialism:

Since 2010, most Democrats have had a favorable attitude toward socialism. Recently, 57 percent of Democrats reported such a favorable attitude, well above the 47 percent who said they have a positive attitude toward capitalism. (By contrast, 71 percent of Republicans are upbeat about capitalism, and only 16 percent feel positively about socialism.)

True, most of the Americans who approve of socialism are likely to be thinking of something like Scandinavian-style social democracy, rather than something out of Karl Marx. But words matter, especially when they refer to systems of governance. What, then, is socialism?

According to a standard definition, socialism calls for government ownership or control of the means of production. By contrast, capitalism calls for private ownership and control — for a robust system of property rights.

In capitalist systems, companies and firms, both large and small, are generally in private hands. In socialist systems, the state controls them. If they are given room to maneuver, their rights are conditional; they can be taken away at any time.

Many people have identified socialism with government planning. Socialist systems give public officials a great deal of authority over prices, levels of production and wages.

Friedrich Hayek, socialism’s greatest critic, showed that giving that authority to government is a recipe for disaster. The reason is that even if officials are well-motivated, they lack the necessary information.

Unlike planners, free markets and the price system are able to encode the knowledge, the preferences and the values of dispersed people. Hayek rightly described the process as “a marvel.”

Whether we are speaking of laptops or sneakers, coffee or candy bars, umbrellas or blankets, markets establish prices, levels of production and wages on the basis of the desires, the beliefs and the values of countless people. No planner can possibly do that.

So here’s the problem. Many Democrats say that they like socialism. But it is doubtful that they want the government to own and operate the nation’s airlines, hospitals, restaurants and department stores.

Nor is it likely that they would favor a political candidate who called for a National Planning Agency, establishing prices for goods, services and wages. Even if they want an increase in the minimum wage, socialist-style planning is surely a bridge too far.

In his own effort to explain what he meant by socialism, Sanders did not invoke Karl Marx. Instead he spoke of Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

In particular, Sanders pointed to Roosevelt’s great 1944 speech, in which he called for a Second Bill of Rights. As Roosevelt described it, the Second Bill includes a right to adequate medical care; a right to a good education; a right to protection against the fears of old age, sickness, accident and unemployment; a right to freedom from domination by monopolies; a right to earn enough to provide adequate food, clothing and recreation; and a right to a useful and remunerative job in the private sector.

Roosevelt contended that “economic security and independence” are essential to individual freedom. Sanders endorsed that claim.

Sanders also spoke of economic inequality, emphasizing the extraordinary wealth of the top one-tenth of 1 percent, and the distress and difficulty faced by those at the bottom.

In his words, “Democratic socialism means that we must create an economy that works for all, not just the very wealthy.” That means better access to health care, higher taxes on the wealthiest, better educational opportunities for all, and an effort to “put millions of people back to work.”

Reasonable people are drawn to all of those ideas. But please, let’s not call them “socialist.”

Roosevelt’s own goal was to save capitalism, not to overthrow it. As he once put it, “One of my principal tasks is to prevent bankers and businessmen from committing suicide.” He believed in what Democratic Representative Joe Kennedy of Massachusetts is now calling “moral capitalism.”

I think that part of the problem is the sloppy use of language. How much of that is deliberate I have no way of knowing but I suspect that some of it is. “Socialism”, “state socialism”, and “social democracy” are not synonymous although far too many people use the terms as though they were. Indeed, history tells us that rather than their being allies state socialism is the implacable enemy of social democracy. The former has inevitably stamped out the latter whenever it encountered it.

My own view is more aligned with G. K. Chesterton’s—that the main problem with capitalism is that there are far too few capitalists. What is needed is less government power rather than more. Natural monopolies are the exception rather than the rule—most have been granted, nurtured, or supported by government. Very few billionaires have become billionaires or once acquired held on to their riches other than through rent-seeking.

In other words powerful, centralized governments far from being an effective tool for decentralizing wealth abet ,its concentration. It would help if people desired freedom more than they did what the wealthy can afford to buy.

6 comments

Wisdom, Tradition, and History

I think that Eric Alterman needs to be very careful about saying things like those in his recent New Yorker piece:

That’s what history does best. It locates us and helps us understand how we got here and why things are the way they are. “History instills a sense of citizenship, and reminds you of questions to ask, especially about evidence,” Willis told me. In a follow-up e-mail after our conversation, Mikhail wrote, “A study of the past shows us that the only way to understand the present is to embrace the messiness of politics, culture, and economics. There are never easy answers to pressing questions about the world and public life.” Bruce Springsteen famously developed a profound political consciousness after happening upon Allan Nevins and Henry Steele Commager’s “A Pocket History of the United States,” first published in 1942. In his recent Broadway show, Springsteen explained, “I wanted to know the whole American story. . . . I felt like I needed to understand as much of it as I could in order to understand myself.”

I realize that his primary purpose is to forge a club to beat over Donald Trump’s head but people might reach the logical conclusions from his remarks that people who have experienced more of history might have perspective that those who haven’t lack, that there may be wisdom in tradition, or that the headlong rush to overturn traditional norms to meet the preferences of those without historical perspective are misguided.

My own view of history is somewhat jaded. While I think that a knowledge of history and, even more importantly, historiography are important, I think that we know almost nothing of events that occurred prior to about 1400 and that most of what we think we know (before and since) is actually propaganda.

Is it history or propaganda that George Washington chopped down a cherry tree and never told a lie?

4 comments

Diet Talk

Spurred in part, first by a report from the United Nations Environment Programme and then by some of the stated goals of the “Green New Deal”, I wanted to point out that a lot of problematic things are being said about diet. I’m going to present my reactions in bullet form:

  • Some human beings are, for practical purposes, incapable of thriving on a purely vegetarian diet.
  • No one really knows how high a percentage of people that might be.
  • There is a genetic basis for this and it’s reasonable to think that people whose ancestors lived in Germany are different from people whose ancestors lived in China are different from people whose ancestors lived in Ghana.
  • Most people of European descent who are capable of thriving on a purely vegetarian diet require a significant amount of discipline and in all likelihood supplementation to thrive on a purely vegetarian diet.
  • On average Americans eat too much meat—more than 120kg/year by some reckonings. That’s excessive and not conducive to good health.

I consume less than 100g of protein from all sources daily. That includes meat, poultry, fish, seafood, eggs, dairy, and vegetable sources. How do I know? I weigh everything.

That’s probably about the same as the average person in China.

I am not killing the planet.

My ancestors on both sides in all likelihood survived on dairy (milk and cheese) and grain. My Swiss ancestors were milk brokers for as far back as we have records—800 years. There were a lot of Irish cowboys on my mom’s side. I would not be surprised at all if I were genetically incapable of surviving on a purely vegetarian diet.

My recommendation is moderation in all things or, as Plautus put it modus omnibus rebus optimus est habitu. It was a good policy 2,000 years ago and it still is.

10 comments

Stating the Obvious

Since I’ve been telling people this for years, I find the sudden revelation that the batteries of electric cars drain more rapidly in cold weather pretty amusing. From the Tom Krisher at the Associated Press:

DETROIT (AP) — Cold temperatures can sap electric car batteries, temporarily reducing their range by more than 40 percent when interior heaters are used, a new study found.

The study of five electric vehicles by AAA also found that high temperatures can cut into battery range, but not nearly as much as the cold. The range returns to normal in more comfortable temperatures.

Many owners discovered the range limitations last week when much of the country was in the grips of a polar vortex. Owners of vehicles made by manufacturers including Tesla, the top-selling electric vehicle company in the U.S., complained on social media about reduced range and frozen door handles during the cold snap.

I think there are plenty of use cases for electric cars, particularly in eastern cities without strong public transportation systems, but the argument in their favor is a lot harder to make north of the Mason-Dixon line. Driving an electric vehicle in rural Minnesota, for example, would take a special kind of dedication.

3 comments

Seeking Asylum

There’s a pretty good backgrounder on the U. S. asylum system at RealClearPolicy from the organization No Labels:

Though the government shutdown has ended, the debate over immigration continues in Washington. Last week, the Trump administration enacted its new policy of sending asylum seekers back to Mexico while their immigration cases were being heard. And just hours before President Trump delivered his annual State of the Union address, a caravan of more than 2,000 migrants reached the southern border, according to Fox News; many of these people are expected to seek asylum once at a port of entry or in the United States.

They omit a few things. The first is that, although the U. S. statute on asylum extends asylum to people with “well-founded fear of persecution” the legitimate sources of the fear are for political or religious reasons. Women fleeing their husbands are not eligible for asylum, for example. That was a reform introduced unilaterally by the Obama Administration without Congressional approval. Also, fear of crime is not a cause for being granted asylum under the statute.

Another is that although it is true that after World War II we accepted significantly more refugees, circumstances were different than they are now. The U. S. population was 120 million rather than 330 million as it is now. Additionally, the percentage of immigrants in the U. S. in 1948 was about 8% rather than the 15% (or more) it is today.

At this point there doesn’t seem to be any reason to expand the cap on the number of asylum-seekers who are ultimately granted asylum. In 2016, the last year for which we have numbers, we accepted 20,455 asylum-seekers, about a quarter of those seeking asylum in that year. The maximum we will accept is 50,000.

If we were to reduce the number of economic migrants entering the country illegally, expanded the number of judges and other officials reviewing asylum petitions to eliminate the backlog of application, and the number of asylum petitions granted were to rise to 50,000, I would favor raising the ceiling. As it is the large number of economic migrants who enter the country illegally should be seen as crowding out legitimate asylum-seekers.

2 comments

What Should It Cost?

I agree in principle with this editorial in the New York Times. Excessive fees should not be charged to read public records:

One bright spot of the Trump era is a greater public understanding of the rule of law and the institutions and individuals who sustain it.

But concerned citizens who wish to keep up with court cases — not to mention journalists covering them — face a barrier: the byzantine and overly expensive Public Access to Court Electronic Records system, more commonly known as Pacer.

Pacer, a 30-year-old relic that remains unwieldy to use, is a collection of online portals run by the administrative arm of the federal court system. It was designed, at least in principle, to provide online access to the more than one billion court documents that have been docketed in federal courts across the country since the advent of electronic case filing.

But the public can gain access to these public documents online only by paying significant fees. Pacer charges 10 cents per page to view electronic court documents — or up to $3 for documents exceeding 30 pages, which are common. It’s easy to burn up $10 just by looking up rudimentary information about a single case.

But I think this is a bridge too far:

here’s also an admirable bill that was introduced last year in Congress, the Electronic Court Records Reform Act, that goes a step further than what is being sought in the class-action suit. It would make all documents filed with the federal courts available free to the public. (In 2017, the Supreme Court, often a late adopter of new technologies, made virtually all of its new court filings freely available online.) The legislation also would mandate needed updates to Pacer, including making documents text-searchable and linkable from external websites.

The federal government shouldn’t be in the business of financing commercial news organizations. Web sites, particularly web sites that can support significant numbers of concurrent users while maintaining reasonable page load times, are expensive to build, maintain, and host. They aren’t “free”.

The Times is rent-seeking here. Fees should be whatever are necessary to keep the site going rather than being set at a level that defrays the costs of companies that turn around and charge for their papers or access to their web sites.

8 comments