Merchants of Death

I very rarely cite The American Conservative and I don’t believe I’ve ever quoted Tucker Carlson before but his diatribe against the execrable Max Boot and Bill Kristol deserves your attention. Both are faithful advocates for American Empire, something that would only bring death and destruction, including the destruction of anything resembling America. Here’s a sample:

“The September 11 attack was a result of insufficient American involvement and ambition,” Boot wrote. “The solution is to be more expansive in our goals and more assertive in their implementation.” In order to prevent more terror attacks in American cities, Boot called for a series of U.S.-led revolutions around the world, beginning in Afghanistan and moving swiftly to Iraq.

“Once we have deposed Saddam, we can impose an American-led, international regency in Baghdad, to go along with the one in Kabul,” Boot wrote. “To turn Iraq into a beacon of hope for the oppressed peoples of the Middle East: Now that would be a historic war aim. Is this an ambitious agenda? Without a doubt. Does America have the resources to carry it out? Also without a doubt.”

In retrospect, Boot’s words are painful to read, like love letters from a marriage that ended in divorce. Iraq remains a smoldering mess. The Afghan war is still in progress close to 20 years in. For perspective, Napoleon Bonaparte seized control of France, crowned himself emperor, defeated four European coalitions against him, invaded Russia, lost, was defeated and exiled, returned, and was defeated and exiled a second time, all in less time than the United States has spent trying to turn Afghanistan into a stable country.

and

Under ordinary circumstances, Bill Kristol would be famous for being wrong. Kristol still goes on television regularly, but it’s not to apologize for the many demonstrably untrue things he’s said about the Middle East, or even to talk about foreign policy. Instead, Kristol goes on TV to attack Donald Trump.

a sure path to continued fame.

Afghanistan. Iraq. Libya. Syria. Each of these debacles has turned out very much as I said they would. The lessons are clear. There is no appetite in the United States for the sort of scorched earth policies that would be required to achieve the sorts of victories they long for and even less appetite for imperial occupation of these places that would be required to hold them.

2 comments

Hydroelectric Isn’t Green

My motivation in posting this is to remind people of something I think they should know. Electrical power produced by hydroelectric dams isn’t green. From Science Magazine a couple of years ago:

Using rivers and dams to make electricity is often touted as a win for the climate, a renewable source of electricity without the greenhouse gases that come from burning fossil fuels. But it turns out hydropower isn’t quite so squeaky clean—and with countries around the world poised to erect hundreds of new dams, that could have big implications for future emissions.

Reservoirs already contribute roughly 1.3% of the world’s annual human-caused greenhouse gas emissions, the study finds—about as much as the entire nation of Canada. It also suggests future reservoirs will have a bigger impact than expected, largely because they emit much more methane, a potent warming gas, than once believed. The methane is produced by underwater microbes that feast on the organic matter that piles up in the lake sediments trapped by dams.

There is plenty of research on methane emissions from hydroelectric dams, upstream behind the dam as well as downstream from the dam. Methane is significantly worse than carbon dioxide in terms of the greenhouse effect. From Scientific American:

While CO2 persists in the atmosphere for centuries, or even millennia, methane warms the planet on steroids for a decade or two before decaying to CO2.

In those short decades, methane warms the planet by 86 times as much as CO2, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

But policymakers typically ignore methane’s warming potential over 20 years (GWP20) when assembling a nation’s emissions inventory. Instead, they stretch out methane’s warming impacts over a century, which makes the gas appear more benign than it is, experts said. The 100-year warming potential (GWP100) of methane is 34, according to the IPCC.

The bottom line here is that if you’re trying to reduce climate change due to greenhouse gases in the atmosphere building hydroelectric dams is probably no solution and may even aggravate the problem you’re trying to solve.

8 comments

Westminster Kennel Club Show, 2019

I’ve spent the last two evenings watching the group judging for this year’s Westminster Kennel Club dog show and a good deal of the last several days watching the agility competitions or the breed competitions. If you’re not familiar with all-breed dog shows, the way conformation shows are organized is that judges choose among the entries for the various breeds to select a Best of Breed for each breed. The various breeds are organized into seven groups: the Sporting, Non-Sporting, Terrier, Working, Herding, Hounds, and Toy groups.

The BoBs are then judged to determine which is the best example of the breed for each of the several groups. These seven Best of Group winners then compete to determine which dog is Best in Show, the dog that conforms most closely to the written standard for his or her breed. This year the Wire Fox Terrier was picked as Best in Show, no particular surprise. WFTs have been tapped as BiS at Westminster 14 times over the show’s 143 year history—more than any other breed.

We actually liked the Sussex Spaniel and Dachshund better but it’s difficult to assess dogs, especially coated dogs, unless you actually put your hands on them. Even at that I’m not much of a judge of terriers.

0 comments

Reading the Tealeaves

I don’t think that William Galston is reading the tealeaves quite correctly in his recent Wall Street Journal column when it comes to “Medicare for All”. He says it’s a trap for Democrats:

A political party is asking for trouble when it embraces a position on a high-profile issue that most Americans oppose. But it isn’t easy to avoid this pitfall when a majority of the party’s own members endorse that position. As the campaign for the Democratic presidential nomination heats up, the Medicare for All plan first proposed by Sen. Bernie Sanders risks pushing candidates into this trap.

The stakes are very high: This unforced error could give President Trump his best chance to win re-election in 2020.

A recent Politico/Morning Consult poll found that endorsing Medicare for All rather than improvements to the Affordable Care Act did more than any other issue to increase enthusiasm for a prospective nominee among the Democratic rank and file. Fully 57% of Democrats said they would be more likely to support such a candidate compared with 22% who said they were less likely, and 37% said that they would be “much more likely” to do so.

So it was no surprise that in a town-hall meeting soon after announcing her candidacy, Sen. Kamala Harris vigorously backed Medicare for All. Yet many observers were taken aback when, citing excessive paperwork and delays in the approval process, she went on to say she wanted to get rid of private health insurance altogether. “Let’s eliminate all of that,” she said. “Let’s move on.”

Ms. Harris’s version of Medicare for All means private insurance for none. Even if you like your private plan, you can’t keep it. And many Americans do like their private plans, which is why they find proposals like Ms. Harris’s so troubling. A Kaiser Family Foundation survey last month found that, while 56% of Americans claimed to favor Medicare for All, support sank to 37% for versions of the proposal that would eliminate private insurance companies.

Some leading Democrats also have doubts about this approach. Minnesota Sen. Amy Klobuchar, who entered the presidential race last weekend, has declined to endorse Medicare for All. So has another potential Midwestern candidate, Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown. Former Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper, who seems likely to run, staked out his position last year, saying “I don’t think we can get to universal coverage as quickly if we try to fight that battle now. . . . The imperative now should be to make sure everyone’s covered.”

Colorado Sen. Michael Bennet, who reportedly is also considering a run, was even blunter on “Meet the Press” last Sunday: “What Democrats are saying is, ‘If you like your insurance, we’re going to take it away from you’—from 180 million people that get their insurance from their employer and like it, where 20 million Americans who are on Medicare Advantage and love it. That seems like a bad opening offer.”

How do you reconcile those apparently conflicting opinions? That 70% of people support “Medicare for All” but they also want to keep their present insurance? I think the answer is that most Americans don’t pay all of their health care expenses out of pocket, want to keep it that way, and see M4A as a way of maintaining that.

At least to me that suggests a framing of the issue that would lead to M4A being a net positive for Democrats at the polls.

1 comment

About That CaHSRA

I think that everyone is misinterpreting newly-elected California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s announcement yesterday that California would scale back its ambitious Los Angeles to San Francisco high-speed rail project. I don’t think they get it. He thinks that just waiting a bit will mean that the federal government, i.e. not Californians, will pay for it for them. The “Green New Deal” resolution and various infrastructure plans being pushed from both sides of the aisle tell him that’s a good strategy.

Meanwhile, in her WaPo column Megan McArdle explains why the United States doesn’t have high-speed rail and probably never will. To her reasons I will add two:

  • Corruption. The reality of life in these United States is that any high-speed rail program is viewed as a license to steal by everyone involved in the process. Cost overruns by orders of magnitude are par for the course. It’s viewed as a victimless crime.
  • Those who benefit most are not willing to pay. Why is the New York to Boston route so criminally slow? Because whatever its benefits the people of Boston and New York aren’t willing to pay for upgrading it. If they were we’d already have high-speed rail, particularly in the Eastern United States where they don’t have mountains and earthquakes to contend with.
6 comments

China and the Uighur Unpersons

The editors of the Washington Post take to their fainting couches over the unconscionable treatment of the Uighur population of China’s western provinces by the Chinese authorities:

China has sought for years to assimilate the Muslim Uighur population into the majority Han Chinese, partially by flooding Xinjiang province with migrants from elsewhere. But the effort to crush the population has picked up speed under President Xi Jinping, whose government set up an archipelago of bleak outposts for carrying out forced indoctrination, to eradicate the Uighur language, traditions and culture. At first, China denied these camps existed; then China admitted that they exist but claimed they are for “re-education” and vocational training. As eyewitnesses have verified, the real purpose is much darker, to coerce the detainees to give up their language and culture. Experts have said more than 1 million Uighurs are now detained, out of a population of more than 11 million. Dolkun Isa, president of the World Uighur Congress, told us there may be 2 million or more imprisoned, based on word leaking out to Uighur families and those who have been released.

That’s a terrible choice of words. The Chinese authorities are not trying to “assimilate” China’s Uighur population.
They are supplanting them, removing them, eradicating them, following the same playbook as used in Tibet. China is racist. Its authorities view it as an ethnic state as surely as Hungarians or Kosovars do theirs. If you’re not Han Chinese, you’re not Chinese.

There is some controversy over the history of the Uighurs but the question is whether they’ve comprised the major part of China’s Xinjiang province for the last millennium or the last 10,000 years. The Han Chinese tend to believe the former, the Uighurs themselves the latter. Whatever the case they are not newcomers, not invaders, not foreigners.

Here’s the remedy proposed by the editors:

China must be held to account for crimes against the Uighur population. Worthy legislation is pending in Congress to address this, and the time has come for the rest of the world to demand admission to the camps, in search of a lost Uighur musician and more than 1 million others.

There are only three avenues for meaningful responses: trade sanctions, diplomatic sanctions, or military sanctions. Since the editors have condemned each of those for China in the past it would be interesting to hear their views on what sort of response would be appropriate. On that, sadly, the editorial is silent.

6 comments

Krugman Versus Lerner

I’ve mentioned before that Paul Krugman’s reaction to MMT could be summarized as “it just doesn’t work that way”. He provides a more complete response in his New York Times column this morning. Here’s his conclusion:

The bottom line is that while functional finance has a lot going for it, it’s not the kind of axiomatically true doctrine that Lerner – and, I think, modern MMTers – imagined it to be. Deficits and debt can matter, and not just because of the effects of deficit spending on aggregate demand.

That said, I don’t think these objections are all that central to the budget issues facing progressives in the near future. You don’t have to be a deficit scold or debt-worrier to believe that really big progressive programs will require major new revenue sources.

and, consequently, major decreases in private saving and spending. I doubt his answer will mollify those promoting MMT as the solution to our fiscal problems because they’re what I think of as “folk MMTers”.

“Folk Keynesians”, a characterization that includes practically everybody in Congress, believe that government spending always stimulates the economy. They don’t believe there are ever any adverse consequences. They don’t believe that any “time-shifting” takes place. Similarly, “folk MMTers” believe that a monetary sovereign can always issue unlimited credit without adverse consequences.

What too many seem to ignore is that economics is not accounting. Accounting is just arithmetic and a few commonsense rules of thumb. Economics is a science of human behavior and, consequently, subject to the vagaries of human behavior. Human beings respond to incentives and adjust their behavior purposefully in response to them which is why any attempt at fine-tuning the economy by anyone for any reason will always be frustrated.

3 comments

The Voice of the Establishment

There are few better barometers (other than Larry Summers) of the conventional wisdom among establishment Democrats than Steve Rattner who, in his New York Times op-ed, warns about debt:

Medicare for All. The Green New Deal. Free college tuition.

With each new entrant into the Democratic presidential sweepstakes comes a fresh cascade of ambitious social programs to entice and excite would-be supporters.

The list of “payfors,” to use a bit of Washington jargon, grows more slowly. They’ll pay for this how, again? Tax the rich, tax the rich — or take cover behind a convenient bit of progressive dogma: Don’t worry about the fiscal impact because America’s rising budget deficits and debt levels don’t much matter.

That’s a scary drift of thought, and it should set off alarm bells for all Americans. Vast increases in debt will ultimately compromise Washington’s ability to maintain its current array of spending programs, let alone add new ones, and threaten our standard of living.

It would be nice if he were as concerned about debt during Democratic administrations as he is during Republican ones but, alas, that seems to be too much to ask for.

There’s more than one way of looking at debt. One way is that more debt today means less spending tomorrow and that’s the thinking he reflects in his piece.

Another way is that government spending doesn’t matter. We can just issue ourselves credit without let or hindrance.

My own view is that we should not issue ourselves credit to pay operating expenses, only for things that will pay real dividends. Some things pay dividends far beyond what is spent, e.g. the space program, some things have diminishing returns to scale, e.g. health care spending, other things actually have declining returns to scale, e.g. war. All spending, public or private, affects incentives. Bad incentives are like gunk in the engine. They reduce the power of the whole machine.

We should choose wisely.

However, pay attention to what Mr. Rattner has to say. He’s telling us what the present Democratic leadership thinks.

9 comments

Darker Than You Think

Springfield’s State Journal-Register reports that Illinois’s budget is in significantly worse shape than had been thought:

With Gov. J.B. Pritzker’s first budget speech less than two weeks away, the Pritzker administration said the state’s financial problems are worse than expected.

In a report released Friday, former comptroller and now deputy governor Dan Hynes said the state’s budget deficit next year will hit $3.2 billion unless steps are taken to bring it under control.

The administration said the deficit is 16 percent higher than what former Gov. Bruce Rauner’s administration projected in a report it released in November.

“We’ve had several weeks now to work with the agencies to look through their financials and really do an assessment of the damage done by the previous administration,” Hynes said in an interview. “It’s worse than we thought both in terms of the scope and size of the deficit facing us (next year), but also the amount of unpaid bills left on our desk.”

Naturally enough, he lays the blame squarely on his predecessor:

The report placed most of the blame for the problem on Rauner and continued fallout from the budget impasse during his administration. The report said spending pressures became obvious as various state agencies submitted budget requests to the administration that were considered maintenance budgets.

For example, obligations for human services means those projects face an additional $275 million shortfall. State employee health insurance is facing an estimated $170 million deficit.

The report also said that simply looking at the bill backlog gives a misleading picture of the money owed in connection with unpaid bills. The backlog stood at $7.9 billion at the end of last year. However, the state also owes $5.5 billion on money borrowed to help pay down the backlog and save on interest payments. There is also $650 million to be repaid to special state funds and about $500 million owed to state workers for unpaid step increases.

“Adding all of that up was a stunning revelation,” Hynes said. “It really spells out how serious this problem is.”

Would-a, could-a, should-a. It’s Gov. Pritzker’s watch now and he will be tested. The question is will he preside over the state’s continuing decline or seek to expand Illinois’s population and economy? I know where I’d put my money. My advice: stop digging.

3 comments

The WSJ and the GND

The editors of the Wall Street Journal call for a rollcall floor vote on the proposed “Green New Deal” legislation forthwith:

President Obama’s Clean Power Plan looks modest by comparison. The 10-year Green New Deal calls for generating 100% of power from renewables and removing greenhouse gas emissions from manufacturing and transportation—to the extent these goals are “technologically feasible.” Hint: They’re not.

The plan also calls for “upgrading all existing buildings in the United States and building new buildings to achieve maximal energy efficiency, water efficiency, safety, affordability, comfort and durability, including through electrification.” That’s all existing buildings, comrade.

Millions of jobs would have to be destroyed en route to this brave new green world, but not to worry. The resolution says the government would also guarantee “a job with a family-sustaining wage, adequate family and medical leave, paid vacations, and retirement security to all people of the United States.” Good that they’re starting small.

Sorry to mention unhappy reality, but renewable sources currently make up only 17% of U.S. electric-power generation despite enormous federal and state subsidies. Wind and solar energy have become more competitive over the last decade as costs have plunged. But without subsidies, solar costs remain about 20% higher than natural gas while offshore wind is two-thirds more expensive. The bigger problem is solar and wind don’t provide reliable power, so backup plants that burn fossil fuels are required to run on stand-by.

I presume that the editors are counting on the GND being legislation to argue about rather than to pass. Don’t propose anything like that unless you already know the outcome.

My advice: be careful what you wish for. What will the dog do with the car if he catches it?

This is another case in which I think that mandatory performance metrics are of tremendous importance. If the program doesn’t result in a net decrease in carbon emissions, it’s a zero. Fun fact: after transportation and power generation the third largest source of carbon emissions in the U. S. is the production of cement. There are on the order of 150 million buildings in the United States. rehabbing and retrofitting all of them will end up producing a lot of greenhouse gases. If you accept the assumptions of the GND, unless we reduce net emissions there is no long term so arguing that the massive building project will ultimately result in decreases is moot. If you reject the assumptions of the GND, there is no need for a crash program.

Here’s another issue. We don’t have enough power engineers to replace the present power grid completely and it takes time to train new ones. You can’t just retrain computer designers or programmers to do the job. Power engineering is a specialty of its own. Over time they could be trained but, again, if the assumptions of the GND are correct there isn’t enough time.

4 comments