How Not to Run

My favorite television spot for a Chicago mayoral candidate has got to be one of the spots for Toni Preckwinkle, president of the Cook County Board. I’d embed it but it doesn’t appear to be available on Youtube which looks like an un-media savvy thing to me.

In the spot several earnest-sounding ordinary Chicago types make glowing statements about Board President Preckwinkle and she chimes in with modest support for their praise. One of them chortles “She was a CPS teacher!” and BP Preckwinkle adds “So I believe in more teachers rather than more jails.”

I guess that’s fine if you don’t examine it too closely but isn’t the more apt comparison between teachers and police officers rather than teachers and jails? I mean why do you need police officers to arrest people if you don’t plan on jailing them? If she’s actually running against adding police officers, it would certainly distinguish her campaign—everyone else is running on adding police officers. (Just for the record Chicago already has the highest number of police officers per 100K population of any major U. S. city and I know of no empirical evidence that more police officers reduces the incidence of crime. Indeed, the only pseudo-controlled study of which I’m aware found no correlation.)

So, what do you do if you lay off police officers, hire teachers, and you come home at night to find your apartment ransacked by burglars? Call a teacher? The entire thing is goofy.

0 comments

That’s Not Necessary to Liberal Democracy

My primary reaction to Farhad Manjoo’s latest New York Times column:

It’s the cuts at BuzzFeed that sting most. You may regard the site as a purveyor of silly listicles and inane quizzes. I think of it as a relentlessly experimental innovator: It’s the site that gave us The Dress and published The Dossier, a company that pushed the rest of the industry to regard the digital world with seriousness and rigor.

More than anyone else in media, BuzzFeed’s founder, Jonah Peretti, bet on symbioses with the tech platforms. He understood that the tech giants would keep getting bigger, but to him that was a feature, not a bug. By creating content that hooked into their algorithms, he imagined BuzzFeed getting bigger — and making money — along with them.

At the least, the layoffs suggest the tragic folly of Mr. Peretti’s thinking. Google and Facebook have no economic incentive for symbiosis; everything BuzzFeed can do for them can also be done by the online hordes who’ll make content without pay.

So where does that leave media? Bereft.

in which he leaps to the defense of Buzzfeed is that it shakes any confidence I might have had in our present naturalization process.

There is no right to earn a living as an opinion writer. If there is one thing that has been demonstrated over the period of the last 15 years it is that 99.999% of opinion writing isn’t worth the paper it isn’t printed on. I would go farther and suggest that paid opinion writing is an artifact of the giant media conglomerates he criticizes. Ben Franklin wrote a lot of opinion but he wasn’t paid for it. He was a professional printer and an amateur opinion writer. He did his opinion writing while waiting for a paying job to come in.

Vibrant, diverse, interesting, high quality opinion writing predates the major media outlets and will survive after they’re gone. The biggest threats to quality opinion writing aren’t layoffs at Buzzfeed. The larger threats are illiteracy and loss of attention span.

9 comments

State Your Plan

The connecting thread that I see uniting many of this morning’s opinion pieces and our politics more generally is a general reluctance for the authors to say what they actually mean. So, for example, in Max Boot’s Washington Post plea for the U. S. to continue its military activity in Afghanistan and Syria, here’s what he says:

Advocates of retreat will argue that an open-ended deployment is not sustainable. But that’s not true. U.S. troops are volunteers. As long as they aren’t taking many casualties, the public isn’t opposed to their deployment. U.S. forces have suffered six fatalities in Syria and 66 in Afghanistan since 2015 — an average of 18 a year. Those losses are tragic, but in 2017 the U.S. military lost 80 service personnel in training accidents. Training is now four times deadlier for U.S. forces than combat. Nor are these conflicts financially ruinous: The war in Afghanistan accounts for less than 10 percent of the defense budget. If Trump chooses to pull out, it will be his choice. Unlike Richard Nixon in Vietnam, he will not have been compelled to exit by public pressure. There are no antiwar protests in the streets.

These kinds of deployments are invariably lengthy and frustrating. Think of our Indian Wars, which lasted roughly 300 years (circa 1600-1890), or the British deployment on the North West Frontier (today’s Pakistan-Afghanistan border), which lasted 100 years (1840s-1940s). U.S. troops are not undertaking a conventional combat assignment. They are policing the frontiers of the Pax Americana. Just as the police aren’t trying to eliminate crime, so troops are not trying to eliminate terrorism but, instead, to keep it below a critical threshold that threatens the United States and our allies. This isn’t as satisfactory as pursuing unconditional surrender, but, as we may discover before long, it beats the alternative.

but what he rather clearly means is that withdrawal from Afghanistan and Syria threatens the American imperium that he wants. The European settlers believed they had a right to the land. That’s why the “Indian Wars” persisted. So did the British with respect to the North West Frontier. Conviction of a right to the land is a necessary component of such protracted campaigns.

The question I would ask is that, if the proponents of invading Afghanistan had stated the intention of staying and fighting there forever, would we have invaded at all? I do not think we would have and, in particular, I think that Sen. Obama would not have been bamboozled into thinking that if we just put a few more troops there the situation in Afghanistan could have been readily resolved and we would not have lost thousands of our young men and women and degraded our equipment as we have. That will result in our spending billions that would not otherwise have been spent to restore our military readiness.

I would add that, contrary to Mr. Boot’s implication, I do not believe that most American soldiers are soulless mercentaries. I think that many if not most believe that they’re defending their country and the people they love back home. I do not think they’re fighting for American empire. Good luck on your recruiting goals with that sales pitch.

California Sen. Kamala Harris is presently, apparently, backpedaling from her remarks about dumping the entire health care insurance industry, to be replaced by a single-payer system. I thought that was one of the major benefits of a single-payer system and its main source of funding. Was I wrong? She should be proud of it.

What’s the complete, unvarnished plan for reducing carbon emissions to the level you say is necessary for survival? How much of New York’s sea coast will be obscured by the offshore windmills that will be required to accomplish Gov. Cuomo’s objective of reducing carbon emissions via wind power? What’s your plan for improving the lives of the tens of millions of Americans who will never realize the benefit of higher education while bringing in tens of millions of unskilled workers to compete with them? How do you plan to raise the effective tax level on the highest income earners? Or tax their wealth?

The key point here is that the American people should be allowed to make their decisions based on information as complete as possible rather than on sugar-coated rosy scenarios. I think the people can handle the truth. It’s the politicians who can’t.

4 comments

Question

At what point does the Mueller investigation become a self-licking lollipop? I don’t doubt that the various Trump Administration and campaign officials lied to the FBI. I think they’re a bunch of creeps and lowlifes who are incapable of uttering a simple declarative sentence without lying. But based on my understanding every single crime with which they have been charged emerged from the investigation, i.e. would not have occurred but for the investigation.

I have been steadfast in my determination to let the Mueller investigation run its course and remain so but I find the nature of the crimes that are being prosecuted unsettling.

19 comments

Flight

Tribune editorial board member Kristen McQueary remarks on the departure of people with the means to do so from Illinois:

Pritzker and a Democrat-led House and Senate plan to introduce a graduated income tax proposal that would, at least initially, hit upper-income earners in Illinois. Candidates for Chicago mayor, including Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle, have proposed a new tax on million-dollar property transactions. Aldermanic candidates, including Ald. Pat Dowell, 3rd, have floated the idea of a separate city income tax for wealthy Chicagoans. And mayoral candidate Bill Daley is open to a tax on commuters who live outside the city but work in Chicago.

Reality check: The number of residents fleeing Illinois for other states jumped to 93,704 in 2014 from 68,204 the previous year. It increased in 2015 to 106,544, and in 2016 to 109,941. More exodus in 2017 of 114,779 and last year, another 114,154.

Who do you think is leaving Illinois? For the most part, it’s people who have the means to do so.

Which brings us to the broader problem: How did we get to a place where wealth, success and entrepreneurship are shame-worthy? And where giving back by these same individuals is largely ignored?

Cubs Chairman Tom Ricketts often becomes folly for the income-equality crowd. Yes, he’s a rich guy. Yet due to his generosity, thousands of kids on the South Side can enjoy a new indoor sports center in Pullman. Ald. Anthony Beale, 9th, who knows the value of kids playing sports, reached out to Ricketts to invest in the struggling Pullman neighborhood. Ricketts enlisted Cubs Charities to donate $500,000 to the Pullman Community Center, a state-of-the-art indoor recreational complex that opened in November in Beale’s ward. Other sponsors stepped up too.

This is just one of many, many examples of high-income earners giving back. You don’t hear about it enough, though.

“I am more interested in what’s in your heart than your wallet,” Beale said of his efforts to raise private money for the center. “I believe this was in (Ricketts’) heart. He wants the Cubs to be a Chicago team, not just a North Side team.”

Left-leaning politicians bash people like Ricketts and want to tax them more to solve budget problems. But remember: Ricketts didn’t vote on those unbalanced budgets, year after year. He didn’t accumulate mountains of debt. He didn’t vote to underfund worker pensions. He didn’t vote to borrow more money instead of cut spending.

The Democrats in Chicago and Springfield did that. So when you hear the wealth-bashing, make no mistake who’s really responsible for the budget mess we’re in. It isn’t the Ricketts family.

In fairness I don’t think that Gov. Pritzker, Board President Preckwinkle, or Ald. Dowell actually think that wealth, success, or entrepeneurship are shameworthy. They have big plans, they need money to realize them, and, well, they want to tax the rich for precisely the same reason that Willie Sutton is said to have robbed banks: it’s where the money is. That a declining population, particularly a declining population of the rich, means it will be that much more difficult for the hardy few or us who remain to fund their dreams or even service the debt they’re incurring does not seem to occur to them or, if it does occur to them, to matter.

5 comments

Chicago Film Festival

Here are my suggestions for a Chicago film festival:

Ice Station Zebra
Nanook of the North
The Big Chill
The Thing
2012
Snowpiercer
Chilly Dogs

For context: “Today’s about as cold as it gets in Chicago”.

5 comments

The Micawber Problem

There’s a memorable statement made by one of Dickens’s most memorable characters in the novel David Copperfield. Mr. Micawber (masterfully played by W. C. Fields in the 1935 movie adaptation) says “Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen pounds nineteen and six, result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds ought and six, result misery.” In his column in the Washington Post Jared Bernstein attributes the federal deficit unequivocally to not enough revenue:

Let’s begin by asking why the budget deficit of about -4 percent of GDP is unusually large. Historically, late in an expansion such as the current one, with unemployment this low, the budget deficit has been close to zero. This expansion, however, has seen both tax cuts and spending increases financed by borrowing. So, relative to what we’d expect, what’s driving the deficit: less revenue or more spending?

Congressional Budget Office data suggests it’s a revenue shortfall. In the summer of 2017, before the tax cuts and spending deal, the budget office predicted that we’d spend 20.5 percent of GDP in 2018, which turned out to be about right, as the actual spending-to-GDP rate last year was 20.3 percent. But CBO also thought — and remember, this was before the tax cut — that we’d collect 17.7 percent of GDP in revenue. The actual share came in well below that, at just 16.4 percent. By the way, that 20.3 percent spending share: It’s precisely equal to the 50-year average, i.e., it’s no outlier. What’s unusual is the low revenue number.

A look at longer-term CBO projections further underscores the revenue shortfall. The figure below shows CBO’s forecasts for spending other than interest payments and revenue from two different vintages of its long-term budget outlook, one from 2010 and its most recent, from last year. Spending net of interest is appropriate because our alleged spending problem refers to spending on government programs, not on servicing the debt (note, however, that the general finding is the same if I use total spending).

He continues by demonstrating that if present trends continue the budget deficit will only increase. Check his reasoning carefully. It’s a masterful piece of legerdemain. The key phrase is “relative to what we’d expect”.

There’s another way to look at it, expressed here at The Balance. Check the attractive infographic there. Federal revenues are increasing. So is federal spending. Federal spending is rising faster than revenues are increasing. I would submit that as long as that’s the case the deficit will only broaden. I would also observe that increasing taxes and spending will increase deadweight loss, i.e. less economic growth than would otherwise have been the case and, consequently, less revenue than would otherwise have been the case.

Let me make my views clear. I opposed both the GWB and the more recent Trump cuts in the personal income tax rate because to my eye the evidence was extremely clear. Personal consumption expenditures were increasing and, indeed, PCE comprised the largest percentage of the U. S. economy in history. Domestic business investment on the other hand was inadequate to produce enough growth for us to do all the things we want to do and that can’t be explained by inadequate consumption since PCE was so high.

I have also opposed all of the foreign adventurism in which we have engaged over the last 25 years. War is not only hell, it’s expensive hell. I’m under no illusion that we can balance our budget by cutting military spending but we could economize a bit by only spending money on things that are necessary.

Don’t blame the present situation on the Baby Boomers. That’s fatuous. When has the Congress been dominated by Baby Boomers? Answer: never. And we’ve known that the Baby Boom generation was large and would get old and retire for 70 years. It didn’t suddenly sneak up on us. The Congress, led by the Greatest Generation and now by the Silent Generation, just failed to prepare.

Simplifying things to the greatest degree possible there are three courses of action: more revenue, less spending, or it doesn’t matter. Mr. Bernstein is clearly in the “more revenue” camp. I think that would be the right answer but for history. When faced with increased revenue the Congress always increases spending not merely in proportion to the increase in revenue but to the universe and beyond.

If you’re in the “less spending” camp there are some realities you need to confront: most people rely on Social Security as their primary income after they’re too old to work, health care costs (not just spending) need to be reduced, and we’ve got to stop wasting money on foreign wars that can’t be won. Today most of those in the “less spending” camp are Republicans and they have steadfastly refused to come to terms with any of those realities.

There is also a growing “it doesn’t matter” camp. If you hold that view, you believe that we can simply issue ourselves credit for whatever we choose to spend without adverse repercussions. They may be right but in my view that’s risky and there is no way to mitigate the risks. If they materialize they will be catastrophic.

Where I come down in all of this is that we need to raise taxes a bit (pick your preferred strategy) while holding the line on spending which will require a drastically different Congress and sharply different politics, we need to restrain defense spending to actual defense and cut health care costs which will also require a drastically different Congress and sharply different politics, and continue issuing ourselves credit which we can do with impunity as long as we a) do it more slowly than the economy is growing and b) don’t spend it on operating expenses. Health care, education, defense, interest on the debt, and Social Security spending are all operating expenses.

13 comments

Don’t Read Your Own Press Releases

In an article on the situation in Venezuela in the Washington Post that I was otherwise predisposed to quote this sentence pulled me up short and caused me to change my mind:

The authoritarian nature of the current leadership in Venezuela and the United States militates against that solution, however.

That is so stupid, fatuous, destructive, and vile I can hardly express it. The last time I checked Nancy Pelosi was not in jail, Jim Acosta had not been assassinated, and Robert Mueller’s investigation of whether Donald Trump and the Trump campaign had “colluded with Russia” was still proceeding in its methodical, plodding way as it has for two years. Were the Trump Administration authoritarian things would be very different. By comparison the Chavez and now the Maduro government have murdered hundreds of their own citizens, engaged in arbitrary arrests and prosecutions, and imprisoned and tortured its political opponents.

Just because you disagree with someone’s actions, opinions or rhetoric does not make them an authoritarian. To be an authoritarian you’ve got to, you know, do authoritarian stuff and to date the Trump Administration has not.

The editors and publisher of the Washington Post should be ashamed of themselves for publishing such tripe.

2 comments

The Call

Yesterday evening I had an unexpected telephone call. One of the candidates running for 39th Ward alderman called me to answer a question I had asked on his campaign web site. I had asked about the mayoral election. His response was both encouraging and disheartening—he said that he was in as much a quandary as I was.

He did say something that I liked—that he wanted the City Council to be more than a rubberstamp for City Hall. There’s an old proverb, possibly millennia-old that covers this: there’s many a slip ‘twixt the cup and the lip.

0 comments

Crumbling Infrastructure

The syllogism goes something like this:

  1. State and local governments have the primary responsibility for roads, bridges, sewers, and all of the other public works lumped together as “infrastructure”.
  2. State and local governments are not devoting enough attention or money to infrastructure.
  3. Infrastructure is deteriorating.

Why? The answer presented in this article at Governing is public pensions:

These states have little flexibility to ask their taxpayers for more money. They are taxed to the max. But more federal money alone won’t solve the problem. Consider the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, New York City’s state-run subway and bus entity. The MTA already expects $7.6 billion in federal funds for its current five-year, $32.5 billion capital assets program, a number that is expected to balloon to at least $60 billion for the next five-year plan, which starts in 2020. Even doubling the federal contribution to $15 billion or so would leave the MTA with a massive funding gap, one traditionally filled with borrowing. But with its debt already at $41 billion — 16 percent of its annual costs — the MTA will have a hard time returning to the borrowing well.

And no matter where its funding comes from, the MTA will remain overwhelmed by its mushrooming operating costs. Its pension and retiree health-care expenses, for example, have more than doubled in just over a decade, now constituting a full 21 percent of its budget.

Connecticut and New Jersey are worse off. While New York largely funds its pension plans, Connecticut owes nearly 19 percent of its residents’ annual income in pension liabilities, totaling $48.5 billion. New Jersey owes nearly 20 percent, or $115 billion. Each state also owes roughly $36 billion for retiree health care. Without cost reform, any tax, toll or fare hikes will largely go toward these costs, not better infrastructure.

The federal government has infrastructure responsibilities of its own to address. A sound currency, a military in a sufficient state of readiness, and confidence in the government are all important components of our civic infrastructure which have been sadly neglected and I don’t think that public pensions are the main culprits there.

All I can add to this piece is that here in Illinois the pensions being paid to workers (especially high-ranking workers) for the state’s Tollway Authority were eating up most of the revenue being derived from Illinois’s toll roads, leaving little for maintenance or improvement. Open road tolling which allowed the state to reduce the number of human toll-takers and, presumably, their management was one of the smartest things we’ve done in recent years.

4 comments