What the Experts Have Wrought


In his column in the Washington Post Robert Samuelson muses about whether high asset prices are signalling an incipient recession:

To test his theory, Steuerle compared U.S. household net worth (what people own minus all they owe) to the economy’s annual output, gross domestic product (GDP). Since 1950, the ratio has mostly remained 4-to-1 or less. Americans’ assets, from homes to stocks, grew roughly in tandem with the overall economy.

But there were two glaring exceptions. In early 2000, the ratio jumped to 4.5-to-1, and at the beginning of 2007, it rose to 4.9-to-1. There are two possible explanations for these leaps: Americans had become permanently richer — their accumulated wealth was rising faster than their annual incomes (GDP); or for some reason, the value of their assets had temporarily increased.

With hindsight, we know that the second answer is correct, because in each case, the economy soon entered a recession that reduced the ratios. What worries Steuerle is that the same pattern is now unfolding. Toward the end of 2018, the ratio hit an all-time high of 5.3-to-1.

The implication is that asset prices — particularly for stocks and real estate — are artificially high and that, when the bubble inevitably pops, a serious recession will occur, Steuerle writes in the journal Business Economics. People will feel poorer; joblessness will rise; confidence will slacken; business investment will weaken.

It would be about damned time. Make no mistake: artificially inflating asset prices was the explicit objective of quantitative easing. Said another way, the academics at the Federal Reserve’s response to the Great Recession was to exacerbate income inequality in the hope that the newly-endowed ultra-rich would start investing in the United States. The strategy did make the ultra-rich even ultra-richer. It did not spur business investment in the United States.

I agree that Stephen Moore should not be appointed to the Federal Reserve Board of Governors and, if appointed, should not be confirmed. I also agree with the editors of the Washington Post that we need experts there.

However, the experts I’m interested in lean more towards practicum than prowess as a researcher or teacher. Only theoreticians would have given us an abomination like quantitative easing.

9 comments

Is a Party Realignment Happening?

I want to commend to your attention an article at The American Interest by Frank DiStefano on the history of party realignments in the United States. Here’s a snippet:

America throughout its history has had five distinct sets of parties, which scholars call party systems. Each underwent a similar cycle of birth and collapse. During each party-system era, America had two major parties competing on fairly equal terms for about half the national vote. Those parties ruled for decades, attracting consistent coalitions around stable ideologies that were nothing like the Democrats and the Republicans we know today. After decades of battles, however, America slowly changed. When the issues America designed those parties to debate were resolved or faded away, the parties turned into weak institutions coasting on old ideas. Eventually, they crumbled in what the scholars call a realignment. Realignments are the moments in which we tear an entire old order down and build a fresh new era with new coalitions, new ideologies, and new ideas. In the rubble of the old system’s collapse, the American people then create two new coalitions designed to debate new solutions to the nation’s new problems. Sometimes new people or ideas take over the husk of an old party. Sometimes a party simply dissolves and a new one takes its place. Either way, a new era begins with two new coalitions trumpeting new ideas ready to engage in the next era’s great debate.

I disagree with his interpretation of events to some degree. I don’t think that political developments in the United States have been so driven by charismatic individuals as he seems to or completely immune to exogenous factors. So, for example, I think that many party realignments through our history have been produced by people who hadn’t been here a generation before or their children trying to make sure that their voices were heard. That explains, specifically, the realignments at the turn of the 19th century and that during the Great Depression. I also think it’s a factor in the resurgence of support for socialism we’re seeing today.

3 comments

Far From Obsolete

At Bloomberg Leonid Bershidsky lends some support to the point I made a little while ago—that automobile ownership is not becoming obsolete:

Knittel and Murphy found, using U.S. government data, that millennials own 0.4 percent fewer vehicles per household than baby boomers did. But controlling for socio-demographic variables including income and the family life cycle explains away this entire difference. Doing the same for vehicle miles travel data reveals that millennials are more active travelers than older Americans.

Millennials, Knittel and Murphy wrote, “operate under many of the same constraints as prior generations, and they still have strong preferences for personal vehicles.” Most of the U.S. isn’t really built for any transportation solution other than private cars. In Europe, where public transportation and car-sharing networks are better developed, various studies show that millennials are less likely to own cars than previous generations, but robust studies such as Knittel and Murphy’s are lacking, so it’s unclear whether, as in the U.S., most of the difference is explained by socioeconomic factors rather than preferences.

I’ve heard many young people say they choose not to own cars because of environmental awareness or the convenience of sharing options. But do they actually mean what they say — or is it simply that they can’t afford to buy a car and would rather frame that reality as a choice?

He goes on to observe that particularly in the developing world vehicle ownership is driven by a desire for prestige, something that is likely to increase rather than decrease as those countries become more prosperous.

Any decline we’re seeing in automobile ownership is largely a run-on factor of our overemphasis on higher education. That has additional run-on effects as well, everything from delay of marriage, childrearing, and home ownership—factors in the acquisition of wealth—to an adolescence prolonged into their 30s and a lack of adult skills, including the ability to be a self-starter or shoulder responsibilities.

When the Constitution was signed the voting age was set at 21. At that time by age 21 most men had borne adult responsibilities for 5 years and, consequently, had more adult judgment. Nowadays that may be delayed until as late as 40.

But I digress. Don’t expect owning a car to become “quaint”. That isn’t going to happen for the foreseeable future.

5 comments

Skills, Jobs, and Wages

I wanted to draw your attention to this post at the Progressive Policy Institute by Ryan Craig on the “skills gap” which I found variously interesting, thought-provoking, and, occasionally, infuriating. I don’t think the “skills gap” is as real as he does but I do think it is important. Here’s an example of something I found infuriating:

Those who haven’t ever worked in the private might be forgiven for being skeptical about the existence of a skills shortage.

I have worked for 50 years in the private sector and I will affirm that the skills shortage is greatly exaggerated. During most of that period I have been a hirer—reading resumes, interviewing candidates, making offers, and so on. To the best of my ability to determine Mr. Craig’s actual private sector experience is pretty scanty. Instead his primary involvement is with education, rightly considered a “handmaiden sector”, either part of the government or intimately related to the government. The same can be said of finance, at least when what you’re financing is organizations heavily dependent on government grants.

The measurement he’s using, jobs on offer, is wrong. It is impossible to determine how many of the jobs that are being advertised actually exist or how many are merely stalking horses to justify bringing in somebody on an H1-B. The Minneapolis Fed, on the other hand, notes this:

Wages in STEM have been stagnant for 20 years, just as wages in most of the rest of the economy. If there were actually a shortage, you would expect wages to be rising.

Now there is an actual skills deficit but it’s not in skills taught by universities. It’s in the skilled trades and the skills needed by manufacturing workers. It’s in the basic skills that all employees need to be effective workers, things like showing up on time and having the right attitude.

2 comments

Four Claims

As I read this post from NPR, imagining a low carbon emissions future, I was impressed at what a thorough-going work of fantasy it was. It’s a pleasant fantasy but a fantasy nonetheless. You can read it if you care to. It’s very attractively presented.

In response I’m going to make four claims about carbon emissions. Rather than attempting to prove them, I’ll just suggest why I believe them to be true.

It doesn’t much matter what we do here.

There are many things we can do here. We can commute less. We can build less. We can use energy more efficiently. Unfortunately, none of those will actually solve the problem that people are complaining about. We can reduce U. S. carbon emissions to zero and, assuming that the models are correct, the effect on climate change will be negligible. This is the reason:

What does matter is what China, India, and, increasingly, the countries of Africa do.

It doesn’t much matter what ordinary people in the U. S. do.

I’ve posted on this extensively. Carbon emissions rise geometrically with income. Mark Zuckerberg’s 5,600 square foot home doesn’t require twice as many carbon emissions as the average home it requires a lot more than that. Add his flying around the country via jet and all of the other ways in which he causes carbon emissions and you’ll see what I mean. The implication of this is that the results of market-based strategies for reducing emissions will be disappointing.

We will need heavy industry for the foreseeable future.

Here’s just one example. Millions of people require insulin to live. Consider the industrial process by which artificial insulin is created. Here’s a production plant for the production of artificial insulin:

That’s heavy industry. It takes steel and power and people commuting to work. We won’t locate insulin-production plants in midtown Manhattan or in the Loop in Chicago. “Urbanization” is a fantasy. Moving insulin production to India won’t help. It will just be out of our sight and beyond our control. If India’s approach to heavy industry produces more carbon emissions than ours does, that will actually produce more emissions. Multiply insulin by the tens of thousands of other similar products on which our lives depend.

Too many of our policies over the last half century have been counter-productive.

We have subsidized road construction, home-building, and offshoring our manufacturing to places where it is safely out of sight and beyond our control. All of these things increase carbon emissions beyond what they otherwise would have been. These policies are popular which is why they’re likely to continue.

11 comments

Charges Against Smollett Dropped

What the heck just happened? The charges of disorderly conduct (in Illinois filing a false police report is disorderly conduct) against Jussie Smollett have been dropped. The Sun-Times reports:

Prosecutors on Tuesday dropped charges against “Empire” actor Jussie Smollett that accused him of staging a hate-crime attack against himself.

The actor was indicted March 8 with 16 counts of disorderly conduct for allegedly hiring two men to attack him near his Streeterville home in January. The $10,000 posted for Smollett’s bond will be turned over to the City of Chicago Law Department.

The hearing lasted less than 5 minutes. Cook County Circuit Judge Steven G. Watkins sealed the case file.

Here’s the telling quote in the piece:

First Assistant State’s Attorney Joseph Magats said the decision to drop the charges was not a statement that Smollett did not, as police and prosecutors said when the actor was charged, pay his assailants to fake the attack and then falsely report the incident to police and detectives.

Asked if the dropped charges meant the actor was, in fact, the victim of a crime, Magats was emphatic.

“Absolutely not. We stand behind the CPD investigation done in this case, we stand behind the approval of charges in this case,” Magats told the Sun-Times. “They did a fantastic job. The fact there was an alternative disposition in this case is not and should not be viewed as some kind of admission there was something wrong with the case, or something wrong with the investigation that the Chicago Police did.”

Before we conclude that Smollett’s case is, like Schrödinger’s cat, simultaneously dead and alive, I think there’s an interpretation that explains the decision to drop charges. Under Illinois statute the state’s ability to seek damages and penalties is quite limited, in all likelihood far less expensive than pursuing the case would be. Is it possible that the decision not to pursue the charges is actually a cost-saving measure?

20 comments

Four Baskets

At RealClearPolitics Charles Lipson declares that “a boatload of shoes is about to drop”. He divides that boatload into four “baskets”:

  • Basket No. 1: More information about the Mueller Report and the basis for its conclusions.
  • Basket No. 2: Will House Democrats push ahead with other investigations of Trump?
  • Basket No. 3: Expect serious backlash as voters ask, “Who led us down this rabbit hole?”
  • Basket No. 4: Did the FBI, Department of Justice, and intelligence agencies commit their own wrongdoing?

I think he’s overreacting. Baskets #1 and 2 are likely to happen. Basket #3 will almost certainly not happen—it’s more important to political junkies than it is to most people and try as they might neither party will gain much traction with it. They’d be better off sticking with bread and butter issues.

It is very difficult to believe that Basket #4 will take place. We have had a provable case of perjury on the part of the Director of Central Intelligence for a long time—nothing has come of it. Even if there are similar cases in the FBI and DoJ I it will take more than a mere scandal to bring those agencies to account for their malfeasance.

5 comments

The Problem Is Germany

I see that Walter Russell Mead has reached the same conclusion about NATO that I did long ago. From his latest Wall Street Journal column:

Is NATO dying? The idea was once unthinkable, but after the German cabinet decided to keep defense spending as low as 1.25% of gross domestic product for the next five years it has become unavoidable. This decision is not driven by any fiscal urgency. Germany is projected to have a balanced budget after last year’s surplus of €11.2 billion, its fifth annual surplus in a row.

What Berlin means by this decision is clear: The North Atlantic Treaty Organization and the U.S. are not as important to Germany as they used to be. While irritation with and contempt for President Trump influence German foreign policy, something more profound is at work. Democrats including President Obama, as well as Republicans like John McCain, have long called on Germany to demonstrate its commitment to NATO by spending 2% of GDP on defense. By refusing even to come close to meeting NATO’s spending targets, Berlin is thumbing its nose not only at Donald Trump but at the U.S.

It’s also blowing off its neighbors. Britain and France are seething over German restrictions on arms exports that limit their ability to sell weapons developed in association with German defense companies to third countries of which Berlin disapproves, like Saudi Arabia. Germany’s eastern neighbors, including Poland and the Baltic states, want a stronger, better-funded NATO. Germany’s refusal to honor its commitments, combined with its cooperation with Russia over the controversial Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, leaves these countries deeply fearful.

Germany isn’t alone in distancing itself from NATO. Turkey’s plans to buy S-400 missiles from Russia, and Italy’s recent decision to sign on to China’s Belt and Road Initiative, are also measures of the diminished value placed on the trans-Atlantic alliance.

If it were merely that Germany is not living up to its commitments, it would be bad enough. Germany has actually been undermining our collective security. It sold the equipment to Pakistan that enabled it to produce nuclear weapons. Then it turned around and did the same thing with Iran. Until 2009 North Korea’s only Internet connectivity ran through Germany. Germany has repeatedly violated the UN trade sanctions against North Korea.

Germany was the first major country to recognize Croatian independence and did so before Croatia was actually independent of Yugoslavia.

The Germans are not our friends and they have repeatedly demonstrated by their actions that they are not our allies.

3 comments

Harris’s Proposal on Teacher Pay

California Sen. Kamala Harris takes to the opinion section of the Washington Post with an op-ed proposing higher pay for teachers, paid by the federal government:

The United States is facing a teacher pay crisis. Public school teachers earn 11 percent less than professionals with similar educations. Teachers are more likely than non-teachers to work a second job. In 30 states, average teacher pay is less than the living wage for a family of four.

That is a rapid fire series of half true or partly true statements. I think it may be true that some jurisdictions are facing a “teacher pay crisis”. There is no such crisis in Chicago. In Chicago the starting pay for a teacher is twice the median individual income and higher than the median family income. The average teacher pay is over $80,000 a year, significantly higher than the median family income. That’s for a nine or ten month school year, leaving time for a teacher to take a second job during the summer if desired.

Additionally, pay doesn’t tell the entire story. Here in Chicago teachers retire after 30 years (or less, depending) at three-quarters pay, something which people who are not public employees can only dream of.

The way you determine the market clearing price for anything, whether it’s a Chevy or a teacher, is by how many are left over at the asking price. Here in Chicago we do not have a problem attracting qualified applicants. Basically, there’s a waiting list. Draw your own conclusions.

She continues:

As president, I will make the largest federal investment in teacher pay in U.S. history. We will fully close the teacher pay gap during my first term, and provide the average teacher a $13,500 raise.

Here’s how it will work:

Under my plan, the federal government will immediately make an investment in every state to provide the first 10 percent of funding needed to close the teacher pay gap. Then we will support states to do their part: For every $1 a state contributes to increasing teacher pay, the federal government will invest $3, until we fully close the teacher pay gap. States will be required to maintain their investment over time, and increase that amount to cover their share of wage inflation.

Under prevailing pay rules in every school district I’ve ever heard of, the worst teacher at a given pay grade and step receives the same wage as the best. The teacher from the worst and least selective education school in the country receives the same pay as a teacher from the best education and most selective education school in the country in the same grade and step. Seniority is the primary determinant.

As far as I can tell the primary effects of her plan will be to reward states that underpay teachers while enormously increasing federal spending. That’s assuming Congress attaches no additional strings to the program. Short version: I’ll be paying for Los Angeles’s educational system.

Shorter version: the bidding war has begun!

10 comments

Moving On

In his column today in the New York Times David Brooks draws what I think is a reasonable conclusion:

Democrats might approach this moment with an attitude of humility and honest self-examination. It’s clear that many Democrats made grievous accusations against the president that are not supported by the evidence. It’s clear that people like Beto O’Rourke and John Brennan owe Donald Trump a public apology. If you call someone a traitor and it turns out you lacked the evidence for that charge, then the only decent thing to do is apologize.

I do not believe such apologies will be forthcoming. I don’t believe anyone will back down from their previous positions. That would require a certain degree of grace, something sadly lacking in our national discourse. Democrats will continue to proclaim Trump a traitor, albeit possibly less loudly. Republicans will declare victory and vindication.

Grace would require penitence commensurate with the exaggerated accusations. The major media outlets have devoted more than 2,200 hours to coverage of something that didn’t happen. It would also require grace in victory which would mean a quieter acceptance. I don’t think the parties are capable of either.

Mr. Brooks continues:

The sad fact is that Watergate introduced a poison into the American body politic. Richard Nixon’s downfall was just and important, but it opened up the mouthwatering possibility that you don’t need to do the hard work of persuading people to join your side. Instead, you can destroy your foes all at once through scandal.

Politics since Watergate has been defined by a long string of scandals and pseudo-scandals — Iran-contra, Whitewater, Valerie Plame, Benghazi, Solyndra, swift-boating. Politico last year compiled a list of 46 scandals that were at one time or another deemed “worse than Watergate.”

The nation’s underlying divides are still ideological, but we rarely fight them honestly as philosophical differences. We just accuse the other side of corruption. Politics is no longer a debate; it’s an attempt to destroy lives through accusation.

The political media, especially on TV, now has a template it can apply whenever a scandal looms into view, to hook viewers into the speculative story line. According to the Tyndall Report, the three main broadcast networks made the Russia collusion investigation the second-most-covered news event of 2018, trailing only the Kavanaugh hearings, another scandal.

All the players slip into their assigned roles. Straight reporters are doing good, hard work. But the flow of information is not fast enough to keep up with 24/7 programming, so you get this toxic deluge of raw speculation.

which is something I’ve been saying for decades but I think he’s being far too exculpatory of his peers. It isn’t “the American body politic”. It’s American journalism. A whole generation entered journalism for a chance at real power—taking down a president you despise, becoming a hero, and being portrayed by Robert Redford in the movie adaptation. Now it’s become a bad habit, still being pursued by journalists who are too young to remember Watergate (but who studied it in J-school).

The price is being paid in the form of loss of credibility, attendant viewership, and lost jobs but the rest of us are also paying. What can substitute for not being able to trust what’s being reported?

2 comments