Questions About Obstruction of Justice

I realize that there are multiple views of the entire question of presidential obstruction of justice. I have some questions. We now know there was no underlying crime. Assume it in fact is possible for the president to obstruct justice without bribing someone or acting in some other way not within his constitutional powers. How likely is it that Trump obstructed justice?

Here’s the second question. If there was no underlying crime, is it even possible for the president to obstruct justice without bribing someone or acting in some other way not within his constitutional powers?

Those aren’t rhetorical questions. I really want to know.

15 comments

The Business Model

Speaking of the business model being the problem, the editors of the Washington Post also return to a subject about which they’ve written before—the treatment of Uighurs in China:

A sizable body of evidence, including statements from those who managed to flee, suggests the 1 million or more detainees are not free in any sense and are paying a dear price. By these accounts, the camps are a brazen attempt by China to commit cultural genocide against the Turkic Muslim minority in the region, including ethnic Uighurs, Kazakhs and others, stamping them into the mold of the majority Han Chinese.

Adrian Zenz, a lecturer in social research methods at the European School of Culture and Theology in Germany, who helped expose the camps and earlier estimated more than a million had been detained, said March 13 that he has updated the total internment figure to up to 1.5 million people. He said, “There is virtually no Uighur family without one or more members in such detention.”

In the best case China is run by the Han Chinese for the Han Chinese. In the more likely case it’s run by the ruling cadre for the ruling cadre. It’s an ethnic state like Finland or Hungary. 90% of its people are Han Chinese. In a country as huge as China that means that more than 100 million people are fundamentally impediments.

6 comments

Oops

The editors of the Washington Post helpfully point out that Facebook’s newly-discovered emphasis on privacy isn’t getting off to a very good start:

The company disclosed last week that it had exposed hundreds of millions of users’ passwords to its employees in plain text. The mishap, a question of carelessness rather than third-party sharing, is a reminder that the data debate is as much about protection as it is about privacy.

The KrebsOnSecurity blog first reported the flaw in Facebook’s system on Thursday. Facebook says no one outside the company could access the passwords, and there is no evidence its employees abused the vulnerability, which it detected in January during a security review. Still, the error is glaring: Storing passwords in an unreadable format is Security 101. It is standard practice for Facebook. And yet the company missed the problem for years. Facebook says the issue occurred not through its normal login system but through other mechanisms that unintentionally captured passwords, such as error logs.

Facebook’s lapse may not have violated any rules in the United States because the passwords were available only internally and no known harm has resulted from the mistake. But that is precisely the reason a privacy law must pay attention to data protection.

The only law that would really help is one that would outlaw Facebook’s business model. Its business model is to sell personal data. No amount of tinkering around the edges will change that.

Laws might induce Facebook to start observing ordinary and elementary security measures, however. Not retaining passwords online in plain text would be a good start.

3 comments

The Next Election

I wonder if it has occurred to Democrats that the 2020 presidential election and, in all likelihood, that in 2024 will be conducted under the rules that prevail now? In other words, even if there is a groundswell of public opinion supporting the abolition of the electoral college, something I find unlikely, it would take too long to come into effect in 2020.

The primary caucuses and elections start taking place in February. Between now and then isn’t a lot of time to amend the constitution.

2 comments

The Next Step

The president’s political opponents have, not unexpectedly, turned from collusion with Russia to obstruction of justice, in their arguments relying heavily on colloquial definitions of “obstruction of justice”. Under 18 U.S.C. § 1503 “obstruction of justice” is defined as an act that “corruptly or by threats or force, or by any threatening letter or communication, influences, obstructs, or impedes, or endeavors to influence, obstruct, or impede, the due administration of justice”. That only applies to judicial proceeding not to executive branch actions and, particularly, not to the president.

Can a president be indicted for obstruction of justice for exercising his constitutional authority? I do not believe he can or should. The first line of defense against abuse of presidential power should remain impeachment.

13 comments

TL;DR Version of Barr’s Summary of Mueller

Attorney General William Barr has released a four-page summary of the final report of the Mueller investigation. Lawfare has provided a copy here. Here’s a quick summary of Mr. Barr’s letter.

  1. The investigation did not find evidence that the Trump campaign “joined the Russian conspiracies to influence the election”.
  2. The Mueller investigation did not draw a conclusion on whether the president or his election campaign had obstructed justice, instead leaving that determination to the AG.
  3. Mssrs Barr and Rosenstein have concluded that there is not evidence to “establish that the President committed an obstruction-of-justice offense”.
  4. In light of the public interest in this matter, the AG and his office are determining how much of the report to release to the public.
  5. That process will be completed ASAP and will take relevant statutes governing grand jury testimony, etc. into account.

In this country we have no finding intermediary between guilty and innocent, no “not proven”. That is just about as close to an exoneration as we’re likely to get. That should be the end of the matter. It won’t be. This subject will continue to be up in the air for the duration of Trump’s term and beyond.

I look forward to additional informed commentary on Mr. Barr’s letter and, ultimately, the Mueller report itself.

9 comments

Quis Custodiet, Again

Since similar stories have been in the news recently, I have a question to pose. Who is the biggest goat in the story of the multiple crashes of Boeing 737 Max 8s? Boeing or the Federal Aeronautics Administration?

IMO it’s the FAA by a mile. Not that Boeing has covered itself with glory. But I think of Lennie Pike’s line in It’s a Mad Mad Mad Mad World: “Everybody pays taxes. Every businessmen who lie, and steal, and cheat from people every day, even they pay taxes”. We expect a certain amount of laxity, testing the boundaries from businesses. In the final analysis it will always be caveat emptor.

But the FAA has a heightened responsibility to promote flying safely. Its very purpose is to convince the public that it’s safe to fly. If it can’t do that, it shouldn’t exist at all.

But when unsafe aircraft are allowed to fly, unsafe drugs are prescribed to patients, unsafe food allowed to be sold to consumers, reckless banks become insolvent, yes, we should blame the companies but we really need to take the FAA, the the FDA, the DoA, and the OCC to task. They’re not there to be friends with the companies they’re supposed to regulate.

The biggest villain in the Deepwater Horizon story wasn’t BP; it was the Minerals Management Service, notoriously in the pocket of the companies it was supposed to be regulating.

Note that I’m not arguing against regulation or that we can always trust corporations. I’m just pointing out that it takes substantial vigilance to ensure that government agencies do their damned jobs. That doesn’t just happen automatically.

7 comments

The Country of the Future

I wanted to take note of some remarks made by President Trump on meeting with Brazil’s President Boldonaro this week:

Q Mr. President, will you grant Brazil NATO privileges? Will you grant Brazil NATO privileges? Are you —

PRESIDENT TRUMP: Well, we’re looking at it very strongly. We’re very inclined to do that. The relationship that we have right now with Brazil has never been better. I think there was a lot of hostility with other Presidents. There is zero hostility with me. And we were going — we’re going to look at that very, very strongly, in terms of whether it’s NATO or it’s something having to do with alliance. But we have a great alliance with Brazil — better than we’ve ever had before.

As I think I’ve made clear, I think expanding NATO beyond the original 12 members was an error and I think that further expanding it would compound the error. Additionally, Brazil is ineligible to become a member of NATO under the organization’s charter:

Article 10

The Parties may, by unanimous agreement, invite any other European State in a position to further the principles of this Treaty and to contribute to the security of the North Atlantic area to accede to this Treaty. Any State so invited may become a Party to the Treaty by depositing its instrument of accession with the Government of the United States of America. The Government of the United States of America will inform each of the Parties of the deposit of each such instrument of accession.

That’s not to say that I’m anti-Brazil. In the past I’ve expressed my opinion that Brazil should become a permanent veto-wielding member of the United Nations Security Council as should India.

Additionally, I think we have more in common with Brazil than we do with France or Sweden, countries with which we are incessantly compared.

Could we extend Section 5 protections to Brazil? Sure. As we could to Israel or South Korea. Indeed, I’d’ve preferred extending Section 5 protection to Latvia or Montengro over making them NATO members. I don’t think doing so would have been prudent but I’d’ve preferred it.

IMO Brazil would probably reject Section 5 protection if it was offered. Against whom would we be protecting them? Argentina? Venezuela?

3 comments

The Great Divorce

You might be interested in this post at Evergreen Gavekal on the tremendous gap between the financial markets and the economic data. Here’s a snippet:

It’s no doubt been one heck of a run this year for investment portfolios, and even more remarkable is the winning streak paired with deteriorating economic data. A logical question from here is what will give way first? I think going back to why this happened is critical to understanding the larger picture. For the Fed and its pause, they basically conceded that the economy cannot handle higher rates. This is rather dubious with short-term rates at a piddly 2.5%. We’d argue that past shifts like this are reminiscent of 2000 and 2007, and tend to telegraph an upcoming recession. For now, markets continue to embrace a looser Fed. But rates are still up over the last few years and the Fed will continue to pare back its balance sheet, which still means tighter conditions. As for China, the cyclical industries most tied to trade have recouped their losses from late 2018. This situation seems like a classic case of “buy the rumor, sell the news”, and the market is certainly not pricing in any risk of a deal failing.

The post is chockful of interesting charts and graphs.

2 comments

Who’s Qualified for the Federal Reserve?

I’m seeing quite a bit of kvetching about President Trump’s appointment of Stephen Moore to be a governor of the Federal Reserve. I carry no water for Mr. Moore. I find his writing a bit obnoxious and disagree with him as often as not.

I became a little curious when I read charges of his being unqualified. What do you think the qualifications for being a member of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors are? Basically, there are none.

I read the biographies of as many present and former governors going back right to the beginnings of the Fed as I could lay my hands on. I found three career paths academic, legal, and party apparatchik, sometimes all three. I found very few with practical banking experience other than having been a Rolodex hire. That’s pretty odd for an institution that’s tasked with regulating the banking industry. It’s almost as though it were constructed to facilitate regulatory capture.

Given our lousy experience with public-private hybrids like the Fed or FNMA and their enormous power I would think there would be more of a hue and cry for reform or at least some basic qualifications for the job. A PhD in economics qualifies you to teach at the college level. Full stop.

Or maybe we need to rethink what the function of the Federal Reserve should be.

In conclusion I have no idea whether Stephen Moore is qualified for the Federal Reserve or not or even how you’d make the determination.

6 comments